What style is better?

Would comics be better if written like manga? I've noticed that DC and Marvel have character arcs, but don't really plan on stopping a characters story permanently. Example, Captain America will never stop getting new stories, whereas Manga authors have a point where they know the story will end, and they'll stop writing the comics. And there's usually only one writer and artist in manga, but writers and artists come and go for comics all the time. Also, fights get extremely detailed in manga, some going on for multiple chapters, but the most detailed 1v1 battle in comics in the last couple of years has been the Reverse Flash/Batman fight in the button. The best example I can think of for a more manga styled story is Invincible. One author, pretty much one artist as well. Or maybe multiple artists with similar styles, idk. The fights are detailed as well. What do you gaylords think?

It's basically a case of Company Owned IP's vs. Creator owned IP's. Stuff like Mage and Hellboy and like you said, Invincible, are able to be what they are, and are being made like you would say "like mangas", because they're not owned by companies. The original creators have full control over the characters. If Kirkman or Mignola were to decide to turn their respective universes of Invincible and Hellboy into full-on shared universe superhero stuff, and they were successful enough to last more than a decade or so, they would turn to doing the Marvel/DC formula too.

in the past comic book fights used to be better. Compare this to what we saw in the recent Secret Empire event, or think of Avengers vs X-Men. Now we get splash pages of crowds of characters fighting nonsensically.
short storytime from New Mutants, when they meet the Hellions

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

...

What the fuck is "written like manga"? You mean shonen? If so, no, they're two different genres. If you write shonen like a cape comic, then it's just a Japanese cape comic. If you write a cape comic like a shonen, then it's just an American shonen. It's like saying "should fantasy books be written like sci-fi books?". You're either one or the other.

>Shonen is a genre

Then whatever the term for DBZ/Naruto/One Piece/My Hero Academia/Bleach like manga is.

>Would comics be better if written like manga?
Ask Bendis.

>Example, Captain America will never stop getting new stories, whereas Manga authors have a point where they know the story will end, and they'll stop writing the comics
How's Dragon Ball or One Piece.....Or fucking Jojo.

Jojo will last longer than us
When we are dead JoJo will still be going
Whenever the author gets old he'll just clone himself or something to make sure it keeps going
JoJo will live and we will die

Tbf, Toriyama didn't want to do jack shit with Dragonball for like fifteen years and didn't plan on ever doing anything with it again.

yeah, but there are multiple JoJo's, each one with their own story, when one's story ends, Araki starts a new part with a new JoJo. Captain America is generally only one character, from generally only one continuity, written by multiple authors for almost a century. Manga isn't comparable to capeshit.

Stealth Jojo Thread!

jojo translates well into cape comics.
Araki is such a westaboo

...

Berserk would like to have a word with you about ever finishing.

It will finish.
It will just be stick figures and text boxes, but it will finish.

>It will finish.

Abandon all hope.

Flash Volume 2 plays out nearly like a shonen.

>Whenever the author gets old he'll just clone himself or something to make sure it keeps going
Araki's a reverse aging vampire so he wont even have to bother

It's not about "style", it's just about money. Some mangas have the same issue you describe, most notably Dragon Ball.
Goku's arc finished before Z was even a thing, and then finished again when he beat Frieza, and again when he passed the baton to Gohan vs Cell, and again when he retired at the end of Z. Gohan's arc was done at the end of Cell, done again at the start of Buu and the start of Super when he retired and became a family man.
Let's not even talk about the rest of the Z fighters who for most of them haven't had an narrative reason to even be around since the fucking Sayian saga. Only exception to that is Vegeta because his endgame is just erasing his sayian-ness and they never really get to that point, so he still has room to grow.
But creatives are greedy and fans are faggy so they revive the corpses of those characters (kind of ironic for Dragon Ball) and sell more of it.

From what I understand it's the same for Hajime no Ippo although I dropped that years ago.
For all the "it was all planned" shit Oda says, he recycles tons of shit in One Piece and it's become stale a long ass time ago.

Also what this nigga said , although creator owned IPs can also get bloated and uncreative if the creator is a Jim Davis type.

Nekketsu.

...and then he did anyway.

>but the most detailed 1v1 battle in comics in the last couple of years has been the Reverse Flash/Batman fight in the button.


Wrong, that is not Deadpool vs The Punisher (sometimes Taskmaster too)

>Also, fights get extremely detailed in manga, some going on for multiple chapters,
Manga is written on a weekly basis and are far cheaper than comic books both to produce and to buy. Coming out far more often means their stories can afford to be more decompressed, to say nothing of the gulf in interests between Big 2 comics, where action is rarely a focus over character work, and battle manga, where fighting is the main draw. In the most competitive magazine like Shounen Jump where series get dropped like flies even the shittiest get 12 chapters at least

Can she control her powers, or is it 50-50 chance?

Too much talking. No one talks this much in a fight. They use exposition to cover for their inability to show. Even when manga explains the attack, it's after it happened and a villain is gloating or something.

They make capeshit manga. There's this and that avengers zombie thing

>Je suis le meilleur qu'il y a à ce que je fais... mais ce que je fais n'est pas très gentil.