Why not get rid of Sup Forums and Sup Forums and instead replace it with /ac/ (anime and cartoons) and /mc/ (manga and...

Why not get rid of Sup Forums and Sup Forums and instead replace it with /ac/ (anime and cartoons) and /mc/ (manga and comics). That way we have a board for animation and a board for illustrated novels!

we can't have nice things

That would be fucking awful and you God damned well know it.

>why not split up anime and manga and just delete Sup Forums?
Brilliant idea OP, now you NEVER have to read comics!

>comicfags in a nutshell
>cartoonfags in a nutshell

No because weeaboos hates anything Sup Forums related for some reason.

Adaptation fags would fuck it up.
>b-b-but old Sup Forums allowed live action adaptation of comics so this should too
>this cartoon is all comic characters and from comics so allow it
>adaptations are allowed and this anime is a manga adaptation so it is ok
And then you have

Oh, great, then instead of listening to a bunch of waifu manchildren who don't know anything about western comics or static visual storytelling whining about how much better "their side of the board" is, we can have a bunch of waifu manchildren who don't know anything about western comics or the American comics process whining about how much better "their side of the board" is.
You really fucking nailed it, champ, that's great.

Why doesn't this shit board just get deleted so we can improve the overall quality of the site instantaneously?

This post is so stupid that I'm going to actually announce a report. Holy shit. Take three days to kill yourself you retarded nigger.

Which board would get which mods?

What mods?

mods are global newfriend

Why can't retards like OP commit suicide en masse?
Oh, right

Sounds like a good 2018 april fools prank.

Then which board gets neglected by mods?

But then why do some boards have better mods than others?

Yes, because Sup Forums affects the ENTIRE website. Who can forget the legendary Sup Forums raids on Sup Forums and Sup Forums?
You fucking retard.

To be fair, we raided Sup Forums so hard and brought back so many PoWs they ended up gaining citizenship in the board.

>Sup Forums has to deal with people who want to talk about legitimately good anime like Studio Ghibli films and the moeshit gets drowned out
>underground comics like American Splendor and Love and Rockets get a space where their threads can actually live without getting drowned by capeshit

sounds good to me

>Sup Forums hates everything western
Where does this meme comes from?

And you think Sup Forums knows anything about japanese animation or its comics?

People who apply in mod applications are usually more interested in other boards and janitors on Sup Forumsmblr are usually Sup Forumsmblrites themselves and no one with a decent understand of actual board topics regularly browses threads here to keep discussion on-topic, delete troll threads, or enforce any sort of posting standard beyond "your post is getting deleted because I, a faggot janitor disagreed with it"

Also, compare the rules of Sup Forums
>Images and discussion should pertain to media of Western origin.
>Spoiler tag use is enforced. Don't know how to use spoiler tags? Read this.

To the rules of Sup Forums
>All images and resulting discussion should pertain to anime or manga.
>The use of spoiler tags is highly recommended. To spoilerize text, enclose it like so: spoiled text. In addition, images may be spoilerized by checking the "[Spoiler Image?]" box on the submission form.
>Purposeful spoiling of a series may result in post deletion and temporary ban.
>The discussion of "live action" television shows is permitted so long as they are distinctly rooted in, or based off of an anime or manga series.
>Japanese visual novels should be posted in /jp/, and Western on /vg/.
>Threads should be created with substantial OP text containing a meaningful topic of discussion. Please refrain from posting catch-phrase or template threads.

This is not to mention unspoken rules on Sup Forums such as against request to be spoonfed, and Sup Forums's generally hostile attitude to outsiders that help to maintain a consistent board culture.

(And the content and userbase of that board is less attractive to people from certain websites that will remain unnamed).

What the there is to talk about chibli films that hasn't said already?

Don't be dishonest. The Sup Forums is love mentality attracted many people from certain websites and they've largely been crossboarders who lower the quality of discussion wherever they go.

Sup Forums is not a website, it's a board.

>Ghibli garbage
>American Splendor
>good

Sure, let's pretend Sup Forums is not filled to the brim with tumblr users, let's pretend this problem hasn't been known to everyone who visits this website for years,

>manchildren who don't know anything about western comics
Being fair, this also describes Sup Forums.

Let's pretend it isn't a shitty meme.

There goes the tumblr user.

>The discussion of "live action" television shows is permitted so long as they are distinctly rooted in, or based off of an anime or manga series.
>every live-action thread on Sup Forums is just shitty Sup Forums memes thrown around
Works out so well for Sup Forums.

>"But Sup Forums, you NEED Sup Forums! Tumblr is lurking behind every corner, even though they're totally not!"

t. too new to remember redwood

Keep on memeing, faggot.
A retarded nigger everyone hated?

It working any better here?

Yep, what I thought. Too new to remember him.

I'll take the bait.
1. Anime inherently has more in common with manga than it does with cartoons, both in terms of culture and as mediums. The same applies for cartoons and western comics. The clashing of two fundamentally different cultures would just be a clusterfuck, given how autistic Sup Forums is.
2. That would be completely unnecessary. We don't need two separate boards dedicated specifically to animation and "illustrated novels." The main purpose of Sup Forums and Sup Forums are the talk about shows, films and comics within the medium, not the mediums itself. If you want to do the latter, you can just do it on the boards respectively.

No. That's the point. Live-action shit is cancer that attracts fags from one of the worst boards on the whole site.

>The clashing of two fundamentally different cultures would just be a clusterfuck,
Works fine on other boards.

What's with all the faggots who are pushing this meme opinion recently?

Sup Forums in that regard is in a fundamentally different state than Sup Forums, that specific rule wasn't the point. What I'm saying is Sup Forums in general does a better job of moderating/self-moderating.

>every live-action thread on Sup Forums is just shitty Sup Forums memes thrown around
At least they stay on the live actions threads for the most, and just occupy a small part of the catalog, unlike here.

Like?

Best idea I heard all day.

I think /jp/

OP here, I'm going to be honest, I just remembered a thread like this from a whileago and decided to remake to see what everyone thinks now. It's pretty different from before but if I remember correctly it was because the other one was on Sup Forums

What like Sup Forums?

qst

To supplement this, yes, it was a bait thread but it's pretty interesting to see people like don't even bother pretending not to be newfags

/vr/,/vg/,/m/ all allow both and do fine in that regard.

We don't have to pretend, as long as you stop taking average Sup Forumsmrade behavior and ascribing it to tumblr as a way to demonize it.

God comics and cartoons need to be two separate boards.

We have enough shitcrossposting as is.

All boards with flags really.

Fuck weeaboos. Anime and manga arract a specific type of sperging mongoloid. I like Blackcat and I like Zantana but I don't need a full size body pillow and endless merchandise and porn oh god the anime porn.. Fuckers need counseling. And the tumblrinas, (the extreme RARE breed of females that can't get laid) are MORE fucked up and depraved then the males.

Holocaust them all.

I would have zero problem discussing live action or animated adaptations, as long as I wasn't dealing with shit like Steven Universe or Winx Club. I would actually prefer discussing it with comics fans than cartoon fans, by far.

Or maybe it would lead to two of the best boards?

>be Sup Forums
>be elitist
>stay relatively the same for a decade

>be Sup Forums
>be inclusive
>get infested by all manner of horrible influences
>cry about board being a racist shithole and pine about the "good old days"

Sage

>/vr/,/vg/,/m/ all allow both
Allow both what?

Fuck you. Asshats like you are why there is no market for Zatanna body pillows.

>rare
Keep telling yourself that. Women are human waste who are far more resembling primates than males do, including the stupidity.

>the good parts of both boards would drown out the bad for the first time in any online community ever
Yeah sure bud

>Anime and manga arract a specific type of sperging mongoloid. I like Blackcat and I like Zantana but I don't need a full size body pillow and endless merchandise and porn oh god the anime porn
And yet there is body-pillows thread on Sup Forums right now , while there is none on Sup Forums.

No? That wasn't my point at all, you blithering retard.

Do you realize how much anime is based off manga? Splitting anime and manga and then allowing anime adaptation on the manga board was the bad end for that slope.

no thanks i don't want my japanese cartoon safe space getting invaded by normalfag reddit trash like that only wants to talk about generic shounenshit

Quit trolling cunt. It would endless flamewars about any and all west vs east.

Today I will remind them

>MUH Ghibli
i know, right man? Fags won't even talking about Cowbey Beepboop or Feely Cooly. Bunch of fucking pathetic moeblob virgins.
UGH

Discussion of both Western and Japanese cultural subject matters you dumb shit.

Not nearly even close to approaching how many cartoons are based off of comics? Call me uninformed, because I won't pretend like I absorb Japanese media almost at all, but I don't see why anime and manga would be split into separate boards in the first place.

I'm glad you brought that up.
Gas chamber all Steven universe fans as well.

>Sup Forums and Sup Forums still using the tumblr boogeyman to justify shitting up Sup Forums with off-topic bait whining REEE LIBERALS threads

Please God.

>Call me uninformed
Ok, you're an uninformed idiot spouting off stupid and inaccurate statements.

Nobody uses the word boogie man other than you, retard. It's half your posts. Stop it, it's not catching on.

It's worse than shounenfags. It's fags who pretend that kiddy shit like Ghibli stuff is good.

Are you fucking retarded? Nearly every anime is a manga adaption

>Nobody uses the word boogie man other than you, retard.
How new are you? It's a certain board's go to defense when they're called out on their shit.

Wow can’t wait for my Sup Forums posting “hurr does this d-list character written by a notoriously bad and gimmicky author need to be a black transexual” bait threads next to a thread about jizzing on figurines smile :))))))))

I'm glad we have these amazing mods.

>Not nearly even close to approaching how many cartoons are based off of comics?
user, there are probably more anime works based off manga that have aired on toonami than all cartoons ever based off a comic.

That... Yeah, exactly. That's what I'm saying.

Roll

Heil Hitler

I guess I phrased it awkwardly, I was trying to imply an inverse to what y'all inferred.

None of speak english. They just wait till some janitor flags them, or they spot porn.

I'd merge with Sup Forums just to have mods that actually pay attention to the board.

Why do I get a warning for bringing a shitty meme from Sup Forums but Sup Forums gets a pass with their shitty memes every time I report them?
I did that as an experiment to see what mods would do.

Where do you retards keep coming from? Seriously we need to make the word "weeaboo" and other variations of the word an instant bannable offense and hopefully it'll flush out some normalfags in the process

Because over half the mods on Sup Forums are in the pocket of a few boards and let said boards run wild across the entire site.

It literally exist because we couldn't say wapanese

I suggest putting on a word filter that changes it to waponese.

Because Sup Forums has more than triple the activity of Sup Forums and nearly all western media would be drowned out or spammed with dubs and loli porn in protest of those absolutely retarded merges

>newfag goes on rant about something
i don't think i could care less about your opinion if i tried, post-2013fag

>this is a bad thing

Sup Forums is actually the 10th fasted board. Sup Forums is what? 4th after Sup Forums Sup Forums then Sup Forums?

Why won't we merge Sup Forums and /mlp/ so Barneyfag could shit himself in rage?

There is far more overlap with Japanese and western video games than there is with Japanese and western animation, you fucking retard. I wasn't referring to culture in terms of the region. I'm talking about the fanbases behind it. Anime has a larger and more distinct culture than Japanese video games. Also, /m/ talks about mecha, which is a specific genre. It doesn't include an entire medium.