The man in the high castle

does pol think this show is accurate?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall
imfdb.org/wiki/Man_in_the_High_Castle,_The_-_Season_1#Howa_Type_64
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_K._Dick
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silbervogel
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amerika_Bomber
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

Yes, anything (((they))) make is accurate and true. Now be a good goy and watch this show about how evil the nazis are

yes it's a documentary

No because even if the US lost against Germany and Japan in WWII it would be impossible for them to occupy a country the size of he US where most of it's citizenry are most likely armed. Concessions would be made to be sure to occupation would not have been possible

Gone off the book completely so meh

the american nazis are likable hans

This. Japan considered a mainland invasion and realized the futility of it.
If anything Germany and the US would undergo a very long cold war.

Also, strangely enough, it would mean the US and the Soviet Union would be besties.

Clearly. Didn't you know that the Japanese Empire executed everyone they caught making necklaces in the shape of hearts because they considered this "art" to be "degenerate"?

The real reason of the occupation is that they get the atomic bomb first and nuke Washington, with that menace I think they can get US easily.

Have you even seen it?
They don't shit on Nazis.

The difference on this universe though is the Germans somehow build atomic bombs and Hitler can predict the future by visiting alternative realities.

Is the show banned there, Hans?
The nazis are good people and the resistance are just butthurt jews and negros.

>Germans somehow build atomic bombs
So did we. Again, very long cold war.

>Hitler can predict the future by visiting alternative realities.
Well that's just silly.

>Hitler can predict the future by visiting alternative realities

what a fantastic movie it would make
Hitler and the time machine

Fascism would only be possible in America through elections. The Soviet Union and German Armed forces combined couldn't occupy the continental United States.

If the Germans had won on the Eastern front and we remained neutral than we probably would see a cold war of sorts between us and Germany with similar divisions across the world.
Doubt Germany could win because China would also remain nationalistic instead of turn to communism.

>US and Soviet Union would be besties

No, people have forgotten just how long the US has hated communism and it was long before the Stalin and the USSR even happened. The first red scare in 1919 was almost what most US politicians wanted because it gave them all the excuse they needed to purge the country of the troublesome anarchists and leftist leaders in recent populist movements.

MAYBE enemy of my enemy is my friend but most certainly not "besties"

Is an alternative universe in wich u don't get the atomic nukes and the nazis get them, is called dystopian fiction

this is why i couldnt enjoy it. i cant feel with the (((good guys))).

>Muh one gun behind every grass

Inbred dumbfucks with guns are not a real threat to an actual military. Had they beaten the army and landed their own forces they'd advance to the Missississiisssisippi in no time.

fucking retarded burger

>fantasy show about an alternate timeline

It's not accurate at all

This, If anything it seems kinda nice in the Reich for white people.

>Inbred dumbfucks with guns are not a real threat to an actual military.
Lol
That's why Japan decided not to attack mainland USA, right?

Behind
Every
Blade
Of
Grass

The armed militia strategy works. Sorry it doesn't meld with your noguns ideology.

Right, fair enough.

go shill your shit elsewhere

Even with the threat of atomic war, it's still an impossibly difficult task to occupy the US in 1945, with large swaths of landmass and only a few major cities, you would have to have literally millions of troops in the area. That's a great military cost just to occupy a beaten country.

>Americans Nuke Japan.
>Japan surrenders.
>Results in long cold war with former allies, the Soviet Union.

Compare to

>Germans nuke America
>America surrenders
>Results in long cold war with former allies, the Japanese Empire.

It's basically a play-for-play of what actually happened, with the actors switched. That's where the entirety of the realism comes from.

then what happens when the Nazis wipe out the members of the Manhattan protect before they develop Trinity?

You spelled Mississisipsispi wrong

Himmlers speech at the end of season 2 made my dick hard

with the menace of blow entire cities with 1 nuke....

>Europeans think guns don't work when in the hands of the military

germany struggled to contain armed resistances in france and poland, its laughable to think how they'd fare against a pissed off population on the other side of the planet who have more hunters than germany had manpower.

Germans never win anything and they are the reason we have a nose poking in every single place of the world, including my neighborhood

They also mixed so much with jews that you can't tell the difference anymore

No such thing as removing one without removing the another, they are now part of the same problem

Fucking incompetent faggots

>then what happens when the Nazis wipe out the members of the Manhattan protect before they develop Trinity?
Wouldn't have happened. Because they wouldn't have taken mainland USA within a reasonable timeframe to prevented its development.

They may have prevented it from being used, but not developed.

But that said, this is also a story where apparently there's timetraveling hitler, so who really cares?

Are you done being retarded yet? Fucking retarded proto-spic.

I don't watch nazi propaganda shit

>trump is ebil noozi
>is this show true???
dunno

You clearly have no idea what you're talking about. Guerilla warfare is a conventional army's worst nightmare, especially when you have no idea who's armed and who isn't and especially when you're most certainly outnumbered even if you have better weapons.

This.

It seems people forget how much of a thorn the French Resistance was in the side of Nazi Germany. Now picture trying to hold mainland USA in a place with much more population and much more guns.

>Even with the threat of atomic war, it's still an impossibly difficult task to occupy the US in 1945

You do realize thats exactly what the US thought about Japan BEFORE we nuked them right? We expected 500,000 dead if we attempted an invasion.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall

>In a letter to General Curtis LeMay when LeMay assumed command of the B-29 force on Guam, General Lauris Norstad told LeMay that if an invasion took place, it would cost the US "half a million" dead

watever u iliterate nigger. is a fiction book, u can write whatever, u can kill the Pope or get Kennedy alive I don't see what's soo hard to understand in a fiction book

Except that Japan didn't have nukes up until the 60s and they were still trying to get nukes even as the show progressed. For one reason or another Hitler is a weaboo in the show and wanted peace with Japan, despite Japan not having the bomb and did not have jet aircrafts, and still used bolt action rifles.

Isn't the premise of the show that many Americans willingly end up co vetting to nazi ideology?

That plane has to travel over miles of country to get to that city. Even in the US, interstate travel can sometimes take several plane trips depending on which state you're leaving and which state you're headed too and Anti Aircraft guns exist

>ree I'm such a dumb spaniard ree pay my debts

>watever
>u
>illiterate

Heh.
Like I'd bother with dumb "WHAT IF HITLER WAS THE WINNER?" fiction. It sounds like that really stupid book made some years back about Hitler going back in time to team up with the Confederacy to make the shitlord alliance. Eurofags in Sup Forums were buzzing about it a few years ago, and no one but them cared.

I've never watched the show actually, I just know the premise. I've been meaning to watch it but haven't found the time. Inaccuracies aside, I like the idea of a timeline where Hitler won

The fact that they deviated from the real cold war into "our nukes are small and real timeline's nukes are scary" fucks it up, yes. It was a shitty way to introduce the real world as a plot device.

Honestly the whole Time-Travel Hitler part of the show can go fuck itself.

k and then imagine if Germany was also a lot bigger via taking eastern land and growing into a super power

how did a nation of 80 million with little land and no colonies somehow almost win again

imfdb.org/wiki/Man_in_the_High_Castle,_The_-_Season_1#Howa_Type_64

They seem to only use it on their occupation police forces with captured Russian/American shit like dshks and M2s while their military uses the Type 64.

If the Jews think that they can slip an Apocalypse Angel LSD and keep alternative reality from manifesting into this timeline, they are sore-ass mistaken.

Good 'Christians' follow the Cross, Haken, or otherwise. Now they do, at least. Merry Christmas, and job well done Wall Street Jews. And yes, thanks for bringing the suppression Financial System into existence. That Evil system which marks people as Damned if they accept all the associated marks and degradations, rendering them incurably evil and proud in the soul... left only for the Beast to punish and harm into a state of perfect intimidation so they do not make additional trouble.

Jews always think that they have things figured out, not this time. Sieg Heil!

>k and then imagine if Germany was also a lot bigger via taking eastern land and growing into a super power

Then Germany would have to deal with an armed resistance in Europe AND in North America.

Oh fuck off with your time cube shit.

time *bubble

>It sounds like that really stupid book
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_K._Dick
just one of the biggest American writer of science fiction in the XX century. whatever I'm done with u

It shows the pacific states as an abused hellhole and the Greater Reich as 60's america with slightly more conservative values, with Stepfordian Nazism mixed in heavy-handedly to remind you dey wus da bad guy.

Something something but facism did win democratically something something

In the case of Japan, people seem to forget that they were already getting ready to sue for peace due to the naval blockade that was making it harder for the people to eat and obtain daily necessities. The atom bombings were done to ensure an unconditional surrender and as a show of force.

The New Japanese government at that time wanted to ensure that never again could Japan fall prey to war or a military government so they willingly asked the US to occupy them and to ensure the transition of their government into a non military power. Believe me, it would have been almost impossible to occupy the country otherwise, even with the atom bomb, which killed less than the firebombings

What would Sup Forums do if they had a kid with muscular dystrophy in a Nazi world?

Is it wrong that it makes me angry that (((they're))) trying to portray this as bad?

I read somewhere one of the reason we dropped the bomb was to force Japan to surrender before the Soviets got involved

The moment the channels of propaganda are broken down the " armed resistance " would end. There is no reason to fight national socialism as it is the only ideal that would keep race alive and prevent racial degeneracy.

The European north american would come around just as quickly as it did to come to the aid of the globalists cause.
Even the natives could see past the propaganda as they were immune to it. If only the European could see through it as well.

Did they actually get rid of all the swastikas?

I watched about half of season 1 and there were swastikas everywhere.

Is there a plot-based reason for this or is it just them being monumental cucks?

Volkshalle looks comfy.

Ridley Scott knew the Author of Man in the High Castle and is really trying his best to not make it a cookie cutter nazis bad resistance good story and not get his funding cut for the show. As you already know the Resistance characters are assholes and unlikable while always getting their comeuppance. Then you have characters like John Smith who are loved by even the blue pill audiences.

Read the novel. Actually, read lots of novels by Philip K. Dick. It's pretty good, albeit trippy towards the end.

Read Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, A Scanner Darkly, Ubik and Minority Report too.

a lot of us have former military experience, assbag.

i enjoyed both seasons very much

Best character is still best character
RIP Hitler

Himmiler became Kissinger

According to the show usa had a large nazi movement that suppoted the occupation forces

Even with the a bomb they would have to find a way to to get it over the Atlantic Ocean without being noticed. In 1945 this would be impossible to do especially since the Nazi's had no allies in this portion of the globe.

Surprises me how much they changed the map for the show.

Well, the most likeable character is the most powerful nazi in america on the show.

>But that said, this is also a story where apparently there's timetraveling hitler, so who really cares?

You did not watch the show, did you?

It's implied that all the wunderwaffen worked in this timeline, including super long range jet bombers and fighters.

The books was a let down for me, I read it long before the show ever came out, never saw the show. I liked the idea but he fell flat with the story, could have been much better.

>The moment the channels of propaganda are broken down the " armed resistance " would end
It didn't end in France.
It didn't end in Finland
It didn't end in Poland

That's where this breaks down. The real-world examples of where it should have ended didn't make it end.

The book being written by someone who wrote other good books doesn't make that book good.
I just hate the premise, is all.

>Canada
>just Canada

No, why would I watch something I'm not interested in?

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silbervogel

This. The show has a better story than the book.

>getting assfucked into being a cuck state by both the GNR and Japs

makes sense to me

It came true the moment the real-world examples that the french and british empires should easily win against national socialist Germany with their massive resource advantage and more men advantage also didn't come true.

Make a doctor do it instead.

The show also implied that FDR was shot and that the USA stayed out of the war. Which even if everything worked perfectly for the Reich they still wouldn't be able to conquer USA. It's too far away and there is way too many people/guns. It's a fun show to watch though.

Also
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amerika_Bomber

That seems to be a trend with Phillip K. Dick's stories.

Blade Runner is far superior to Androids Dream of Electric Sheep. Minority Report is a very dry book, but the movie is arguably better.

My son. Australias situation would be beyond cucked. Whatever fate awaited the slavs would likely have awaited the aus

>Germans not just bulldozing the italians and "other"

...

dude they make the nazis based as fuck
>1950s
>nazis building sweet monorails everywhere
>dam the Mediterranean to generate buttloads of power to desalinate water and turn the sahara into farmland

honestly, would take the japs over the current Chinese occupation

>In the end, it was considered too complex and expensive to produce. The design never went beyond mock up test.

>Hans is waking up

Throughout World War II, submarines managed to enter US waters. Considering how the Japanese managed to pull off pearl harbor and Germany's rocket capabilities, it's not unimaginable.

but Do Androids...? was so much better than the movie

Except for the "Like tears in the rain", that was godly

I disagree.

>they were all eventually abandoned as too expensive, and potentially consuming far too much of Germany's rapidly diminishing aviation production capacity after 1942.

>implying they adhere to Natsoc in the show

>implying you couldnt just occupy the major cities

i think no tears would be shed if they didnt control butte montana

No it's bluepill good goy as fuck
You want to know what it would be like just look up the Nazi supporting communities in the US before Pearl Harbor

They do lot of research and is what take the writer as base

Why are you posting in a thread about something you're not interested in?