Real communism has never been tried. Prove me wrong. Pro tip: You can't

Real communism has never been tried. Prove me wrong. Pro tip: You can't

Other urls found in this thread:

de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pariser_Kommune

It was tried and was ruthlessly crushed by French soldiers.

WRONG

Low quality bait. Stalingrad/10.

Commies had plenty of years to try their ''real communism'' it's most Fascists that were killed in ww2 too fast to establish full Fascism.

de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pariser_Kommune

Real communism has been tried plenty of times, but it never works because of the human nature. In theory it is a great idea, but in practice it "fails" every time.
Also what the fuck is wrong with captcha? I have to solve 10 of them before i can post.

socialism had been tried countless times communism had never been tried because its literally a post scarcity fantasy land with no state. Even the soviet qualified their own regime as socialist.

1. rare flag
2. WRONG

WRONG

Give an argument fat boy

taxation is theft

It was fake news

WRONG

sage and get on a copper commie
>praise kek

there is no such thing as real communism

Let's keep it that way you red rocket loving prick

It hasn't been tried because it cannot be tried.

In common usage, theft is the illegal taking of another person's property or services without that person's permission or consent with the intent to deprive the rightful owner of it. - wikipedia

taxation is not illegal.

>Fantasy (never been implemented) cult that solves all the worlds problems and evils if you read Marx' gospel.

>Actual in-practice system meant to rely on mankind's organic markets and spontaneous orders.

Paris Commune

Again he didnt even do that it was fake news about from the government to scare people.

OP: "WRONG"

If there are steps beyond even that I don't want to see them.

The real redpill is that communism in the Eastern Bloc only failed because it suppressed nationalism. Quality of life in Czechoslovakia, Eastern Germany and Hungary was higher than in the west. Homelessness didn't exist and education was significantly better than the west. Places like Poland and Russia sucked, but that's only because Polish and Russians are literal niggers.

If real communism is never implemented and leads to dystopia whenever people try to implement it, maybe it's time to admit the ideology is unfeasible

WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG

see

Pol Pot did nothing wrong!

Still one might argue that communism was not implemented as intented by Marx/Lenin. In addition almost all soviet sattelite states had a better standard of living because their needs were tiny compared to the soviet union which was a homeland of many nationalities.

Because it cant be tried

real communism looks like this

>never been tried
>aside from the people that said they were trying it

Burden of proof is on you

Are you measuring in decades, years, months, what? It's not so great to have a decent quality of life if it turns into hell a few years later in my opinion.

The amount of information aggregated and conveyed by markets, prices, values, wages, etc. is simply stupendous. No mind or group of minds is capable of aggregating that information into efficient outcomes. It is simply beyond the objective capacity of the human mind to analyze that many data points spontaneously in real time.

It's like popping the hood of a car and instead of 300 parts, you see 10,000,000,000 parts which are all changing shape and size in real time. You can't tinker with it and have any meaningful success.

ANY system which replaces our spanteous market orders with some planner is simply, over time, incapable of good or efficient outcomes. Any form of dirigisme will fail, which is not to say some limited government is never acceptable, but it should not be relied on as the determinative factor. That's the line you can't cross, lest you aggrandize the finite capabilities of the human mind into some boundless godlike ability to plan our world to our liking.

It cannot be tried
We are not in a post scarcity society yet.

Real national socialism has never been tried either

...

More than 30 countries tried it. It failed