Hey Sup Forums prove to me that illegal immigrants hurt the economy instead of helping it. Oh wait you cant. I'm about to make Obama-Leaf look like a bitch. You ready? Here we go.
Hey Sup Forums prove to me that illegal immigrants hurt the economy instead of helping it. Oh wait you cant...
Jace Torres
Other urls found in this thread:
gregmankiw.blogspot.ca
cbo.gov
economics.cornell.edu
nber.org
nber.org
npr.org
nap.edu
nber.org
voxeu.org
hbs.edu
wannalol.com
foreignpolicy.com
independent.co.uk
reuters.com
dailywire.com
louderwithcrowder.com
reddit.com
youtu.be
cis.org
twitter.com
Cooper Sullivan
Benjamin Gomez
Levi Watson
Wyatt Baker
Sebastian Adams
Here's an ACTUAL red pill guys: losers remain losers, winners win.
Hudson Smith
The fact that illegal immigrants can claim welfare based on a US born child
Austin Adams
Not an argument, immigrants on the whole are a productive force. Could/should/would.
Jacob Roberts
What's that the sound of crickets? Sup Forums is so easily BTFO
Luis Cooper
Let the leaf float away
don't waste your effort
Carter Lopez
Jacob Lewis
So why aren't they so productive in their own countries? Why in the world would poor countries allow their wealth creators to leave? They should WANT to pay for the wall.
Elijah Hughes
yea of course, because you have NO argument. It's easier for you to call me a leaf than face the very real fact that you're wrong!
Henry Morgan
A nonsense reply from a nonsense country
Gavin Myers
Are you going to start calling people right wing retards and posting a bunch of charts? Because that would be cool.
Aiden Edwards
What's the sound of a 150 mph leaf blower?
Cameron Jones
Over 100 billion in government theft annually. Spics pay less than half the tax dollars they use, if they even pay taxes.
Justin Thompson
Because the majority of them are victims of circumstance, Western countries are economically free, have high confidence and trust amongst people and have plenty of space for extras to thrive.
But that's besides the point, my point is they are an economic plus and not a minus
Eli Foster
remember to sage and hide obamaleaf threads
Jason Lopez
>implying you aren't the same autismo
how do you live so far on the spectrum?
Adam Roberts
Cool, some more nothing points. Thanks for validating my claim.
Brandon Nguyen
Still a net positive to the country's economy, the government is a scam to begin with. Next!
Jackson Rivera
...
John Cruz
No, I genuinely want you to start doing that.
Isaiah Sanders
Im not him but something even greater. You sage and I'll bump REAL knowledge.
Christopher Howard
>18 posts by this ID
gsus
calm down and fuck your dogo leaf
Nathan Robinson
tldr
fucking leaf
Justin Phillips
No thanks, now step aside kid. Your ideology just got shattered into a million pieces and thrown into the wind.
Adrian Martinez
More like do something about it. Oh wait, I forgot, Germans literally can't do anything besides fuck up Europe. No culture besides work!
Robert Taylor
It depends on your definition of "help the economy." More people by definition grows the GDP, that's just how it works. A country with a higher population will almost always have a higher GDP, unless it's a third world shithole. More people, and especially more poor people can hurt the GDP per capita, however which is a better representative of the quality of life of a nation than simply the GDP.
Eli Cruz
from a globalist perspective they do help the economy. their new heads to create debt from those who already have too much in your country....but like i give a fuck about that, don't need shitskins, give OUR ppl jobs and money first
Carter Torres
>unironically using a JFK quote
its still a culture
we can't all be known for fucking our pets
Cameron Cox
Why do I have to prove anything to a fucking leaf???
Oh how I long for the DAY OF THE RAKE!
Jose Cox
Not for long lol
Ryder Turner
illegal immigrants already cost the taxpayers of los angeles $10 million in attorney's fees to prevent them from being legally deported
Carter Parker
>tell me why immigrants are bad
No. I'll let your own government tell you.
foreignpolicy.com
reuters.com
dailywire.com
louderwithcrowder.com
If you actually read the news, your government doesn't want them either.
Thomas Parker
They don't hurt it.
But they should come here legally because it sucks for the people who come spend time and effort coming here legally.
Jackson Allen
But they don't hurt you in any measurable way. It's up to you to stay competitive in the market, its up to you to continue the white race and it's up to you to remain financially and physically in balance.
John Taylor
They don't harm YOU is the point.
Gavin Nelson
If they ain't white...you know the rest
Daniel Rivera
There is only one true obamaleaf. Fuck off leaf
Gavin Hall
> reddit.com
No you just fuck your own children Hans.
Jacob Rodriguez
>illegals help
dropped
Camden Davis
Hey idiot how about prove illegal helping economy instead of hurting it?
Anthony Cook
Also GDP per capita is consistently increasing.
Henry Perry
(((economy)))
Camden Russell
I just showed you through 10 links that it does, just because you French degenerates have a fetish for darker skin and uncontrolled immigration doesn't mean it's a bad thing. Sad, depressed little frog.
Nolan Powell
Look at CA's healthcare system
Camden Bell
I do not care. I want my country to remain for European people as it was enshrined in the constitution and explicitly created for. Even it made us economically worse to remove all non-Europeans I would not care. Not everything is about the economy you fucking kike.
Luis Barnes
Why is it always a leafm
Joshua Rogers
ya they do by taking jobs. they don't help in any measurable way except ppl at top....sigh. Make 125k/y+ in monopoly Canadian dollars, competition ha they can do that in their country. nigs gonna nig
James Ortiz
They do. More people = more problems, especially when automation starts picking up in the next decade. It's not a coincidence that all the best countries to live in in the world have a low population relative to their land/resources. Jobs and wages do not scale linearly with population.
Andrew Carter
>leddit
i know i have should've posted this earlier
Josiah Davis
>victims of circumstances
Yeah I'm sure they are.
Zachary Carter
what fucking side are you on leaf?
jesus christ youre the reason canadians get some much shit here.
Carson Gomez
I'm on the side for FACTS and TRUTH and KNOWLEDGE
Xavier Lopez
I saw that image posted on here, Germans are so pathetic.
Carson Reyes
i dont even think you know leaf.
Colton Ward
also sage
Thomas Bennett
its why it's called a imageboard faggot
Aiden Parker
Here is a fact. United States was formed with the explicit purpose of being a European majority country. Why do you want to disregard the will of my forefathers and ancestors.
Nicholas Allen
WAHHHHHHHHH WAHHHHHHHHH, Germans, could you find a more fucked and useless group of cannon fodder? No wonder your rulers chimp out every once in a while and thin the herd. Move on Hans, you have some Syrians to please!
I don't care who forms the majority, demographics are irrelevant to economics prosperity.
Landon Baker
Nathaniel Campbell
>Demographics are irrelevant to economic prosperity
>Ignores the direct correlation between economic prosperity and White population throughout the world.
Wow I thought you liked facts.
good shit go౦ԁ sHit thats some goodshit rightthere rightthere if i do ƽaү so my self i say so thats what im talking about right there right there (chorus: ʳᶦᵍʰᵗ ᵗʰᵉʳᵉ) mMMMMᎷM HO0OଠOOOOOOଠଠOoooᵒᵒᵒᵒᵒᵒᵒᵒᵒ Good shit
Aaron Rodriguez
>prove to me that illegal immigration hurts
>you have some Syrians to please
you just btfo yourself leaf
never btfo yourself
especially not in your own thread
Dylan Foster
If they were white europeans instead of shitskins the benefits would increase 100 times over. Prove me wrong.
Lincoln Diaz
>he blows himself out again
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HOW CAN ONE LEAF BE SO WRONG
Jordan Nguyen
>demographics are irrelevant to economics prosperity
>except productivity and earnings are higher amongst white in all western nations without a sungle exception
Well then, you just shut yourself in the foot.
Blake Parker
>what is envrionmental kill condition
>what is hitting the industrial age first because of environmental factors that select for planning and foresight
its like you guys didnt even read the part where I said VICTIMS OF CIRCUMSTANCE! I mean ya bro some apes decided to go north and some decided to stay near the warmer parts, good for you!!!
Luke Harris
Ya no I didn't, you're just too autistic to get it and also you didnt read my last post
dont you have a continent to ruin?? I dont mind anyone else but Germans are just the worst form of European, theyre the reason for how fucked the US is now
Alexander Long
They lower wages.
Now fuck off.
Ethan Diaz
MMMMM, did you even click the links I posted that show they dont? HMMMMMMM, for some reason I dont think you did
Jacob Nelson
how about we move all the illegal immigrants to israel so they can grow thier economy? or africa or mexico? those places need economic growth!!!
importing people with no money and no skill who get on welfare and steal and reproduce more of same is not a contribution to economic growth
Isaac Martin
i dont think you did either dumb nigger
reposting to reinforce that youve been thoroughly BTFO
cis.org
Carter Martin
>Everything is environmental
Yea man, populations who are isolated and in different environments for 100's of thousands of years will definitely not develop distinct genetically determined behavioral and intellectual traits.
Alexander Williams
they're breaking the law and they cost the u.s billions.
Easton Bell
study doesnt disprove that they are STILL an overall net benefit to the economy, just that the cost of a wall is less than the cost of illegal immigration but the benefit they bring>cost of illegal immigration
its like the point flew over your head didnt it?
Michael Sanchez
LIKE I SAID, VICTIMS OF CIRCUMSTANCE YET THEY STILL PROVIDE MORE BENEFIT THAN COST
are you serious right now?
Logan Adams
lol the moment you use alan krueger in an argument
anyone using the clinton's fucking economist is the stupidest fuck this side of anywhere
everything krueger has ever said has been disproven, even by himself, because they were all paid lies
Benjamin Cruz
>Hey Sup Forums prove to me that illegal immigrants hurt the economy instead of helping it.
My sister gets about 780$ a month for her five kids and sells the use of that card half the time to buy expensive shit for herself and buys the kids ramen and chips. Youre a fucking retard that doesnt know jack shit about what happens here in the states. Rural south especially bad.
Way to be a fuckin shill.
Grayson Richardson
Can't refute the point that shuts down his argument.
How fucking pathetic. Even for a leaf
Jackson Sanders
>They are not the same kind of humans
>The reason their countries are shit is because of the people in them.
Sometimes the most simple reason is the correct one, don't overthink it user.
Jaxon Collins
Your point is ridiculous, and downright delusional. The circumstances are that Mexico and the third world is poor because it is full of Mexicans and third worlders. The unskilled laborers are not involved in work which has high value. You see, the value of goods is based upon the value of the raw materials, and the high skill levels required to produce them. No getting around reality. Wealthy nations are wealthy because their people are intelligent enough to perform highly skilled tasks. Poor nations are poor because their people are only able to perform very low level labor. The cost of schooling a shitskin's kid or kids, alone is several times greater than his contribution to the economy. Unbelievable as it seems, becoming a chemical engineer is a much more difficult to acquire skill than picking tomatoes.
Julian Reyes
This boils down to a question: is it better to let the immigrants pay taxes or not? There's your solution.
Alexander Lee
yeah, you didnt read it.
get lynched.
Oliver Rodriguez
people in africa not using the wheel and being unable to farm by 1900 was all circumstance and enviroment right?
Kevin Rivera
>not factoring iq in
Ian Lee
>VICTIMS OF CIRCUMSTANCE
so its ok we become victims of their circumstances
>2:00am
>drunk and tired
>can still defeat a leaf at shitposting
get on my level
Austin Adams
cool, another 9 links for you to disprove now
they produce wealth >100$ billion, is that enough for your monkey brain?
so you're a spic?
Blake Thomas
i get my economics from a guy thats willing to shill for the RIAA
durr durr durr
It is exceedingly rare for a White House chief economist to give a speech on rock-and-roll. But Alan Krueger is scheduled to do just that Wednesday evening at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland. His talk there (a text was made available in advance) is a terrific window into how the music business explains the forces shaping our collective economic fortunes.
"The music industry is a microcosm of what is happening in the U.S. economy at large," Krueger, chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, says. "We are increasingly becoming a 'winner-take-all economy,' a phenomenon that the music industry has long experienced. Over recent decades, technological change, globalization and an erosion of the institutions and practices that support shared prosperity in the U.S. have put the middle class under increasing stress. The lucky and the talented – and it is often hard to tell the difference – have been doing better and better, while the vast majority has struggled to keep up."
we went from Henry Carey and the American School of Economics to these fuckwits
you noob econ students are like groupies for an indie band.
you use a bunch terms you thank makes you look smart to virtue signal but anyone that actually does what you talk about knows youre massive faggots
Jason Carter
>Leaf
Hudson Stewart
Sup Forums utterly BTFO, this is why no one takes you guys seriously! back to /r/marchagainstdrumpf for me!
Charles Clark
got fucking damn it
the eyes always get me
like looking into a abyss
Oliver Williams
who cares, they are deliberately breaking the law to get what they want. There used to be a time western society frowned upon such things.