Why is communism so bad?

Why is communism so bad?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/NdGMehMANxc?t=20s
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

Read The Gulag Archipelago.

because you're on a american website

Because it is not biblical

Because people are not equal, no matter how much you force them to be.

muh toothbrushes

Because no matter how you slice it at the end of the day all communism means is that all power and all decisions are handed to a small group of people who aren't qualified to make decisions.

In a communistic society what people do is decided by central planners who have no experience in medicine, farming, engineering etc.
In a capitalist society there is no centralization, so every expert in their own field can make decisions for themselves.
When capitalism ''fails'' an individual misjudges a market and fails to make any money. When communism fails the entire country falls apart and people starve to death.

tell me one example where it worked.

bump.

Do you want to pay for all the sick/hungry humans on earth? Imagine we did and the economy became strained until the government said there is only one solution to this problem. There are 2 steps both of which are horrible.

Communism is antithetical to human nature.

Small scale communism is actually natural. A mother works to feed her children. Communism gets out of hand though when you try to scale it up. The genetic forces just don't hold after a certain point. Do you really care about some brown dude who's starving in africa? No! I only care about my children. So how do you expect me to not lash out when the times gets tough. I would die for my kids but I would barely lift a finger to save some stranger's life.

>I would die for my kids but I would barely lift a finger to save some stranger's life.

humans usually have what you lack however It's more about equal share of wealth than anything else and what you lack is likely the result of your indoctrination.

You are underage and deserve the ban.

Only children think communism is viable

Then why aren't you lifting your fingers to help strangers? Oh wait, you're just completely bullshitting.

>A mother works to feed her children.
you have absolutely no idea what communism is

it's not good or bad. It just doesn't work, nigga.

I'll just leave this here

It has some nice ideals that would work fot a post-scarcity society but the people who are into communism are the most sickening douchebags to ever come across
>haha gomrade rite in da gulab :DDDDDD

I dunno - repeated mass starvations?

You don't understand the prevailing idea underneath it. I don't need to know what communism is in certain scenarios I just need to know what laws it rests upon and I can attack those laws.
For ex: You're trying to say how the 17in MSI laptops are problematic and I tell you that all MSI laptops are problematic.

From the perspective of someone who has actually read all of Marx's work on political economy:

Because if you actually understand Marx's analytical framework and look at human historical development you realize that new modes of production have historically always been born as the accidental and unintended byproducts of people trying to reproduce their economic circumstances as they were.

The idea that humans can choose to impose a mode of production on the real underlying historical conditions of their existence is actually a utopian notion fundamentally incompatible with Marx's analytical approach to political economy.

The practical upshot is that it will probably require capitalism to produce the technical innovations to automate away the overwhelming majority of socially necessary labour time in order for communism to become something that could be feasibly imposed on reality.

Because it's by default authoritarian and you're trying to achieve it by subverting "free" nations. If you want to go practice communism so bad, go to one of the existing communist states; stop trying to convert every nation's system into a singular system. Besides, why do you have diversity so much? Shouldn't we be celebrating all types of nation states operating in their own autonomous ways so that we have the freedom of choice of which system to be apart of by having the freedom of movement to go there and experience how it is?

Jackboot faggot thug.

based Lett

Why is this bitch posted all the time?

incentive

that's the key word

after that, freedom/liberty

Because very nation that tried it went to the absolute shitter

communism is bad for the current owners of the means of production.

Communists seek to seize the means of production and give it to the worker.

>incentive
>that's the key word

in a communist society people have an amazing incentive to do well. The worker owns the means of production so if the factory fails he has no job.

Capitalist societies have no incentive. If you are a worker you will do as little as possible for the most pay. This creates negative productivity.

this man knows

this is fairy tale communism, which you can actually do in a capitalist society ironically enough. Start a company with your friends, there enjoy.

In reality communism is private enterprise made illegal and instead the government owns the means of production.

>In reality communism is private enterprise made illegal and instead the government owns the means of production.

you cant fool me I've read the communist manifesto.

Communists do not seek to have the government own everything. That would be nationalism. Communists seek to hand the means of production to the workers.

Read "200 Years together by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn"
It'll describe what happened

You're probably a shariablue shill though

bump

Not sure, she is getting old now and is nowhere as cute as she was a couple years ago.

wrong

It's tends to fuck up everything about the countries that practice it, especially the lives of the people who live there.

But she is and it´s painful to look at.

>hurr durr I red it
So have many people here.

We just don't take it to heart like a retard, such as you

>In a capitalist society there is no centralization
This is definitely not true.

Good post

Reading this book to make your mind about Communism is like reading memories of concentration-camp survivors to make your mind about NatSoc.

Doesn't work

What's wrong with reading about the effects of an ideology?

So, ready about the end results of an ideology is bad?

It's not so much that it's bad - it just doesn't scale. A tribal village can practice it just fine but on the scale of nations it just results in collapse and famine.

Ronerts >>>>> Stone >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Watson

It is in a purely capitalist society.
Protip, there are none of these. Even America is not purely capitalist.
Not that i am against all centralization. I don't see how a civilization would work without at least some centralization.

Thanks. I tend to think that a huge overabundance of productivity--as would be implied by truly widescale automation--would be really useful for a transition to a post-capitalist mode of production to be possible without requiring a large drop in perceived living standards for most people and the political resistance that would generate.

Who said it's wrong? I'm saying it is not enough. Just an example question - is this was immanent outcome or it was just a pereversion? You cannot answer that reading prisoner's book only. There are other interesting Russian authors who wrote about life in USSR, like Dovlatov and Polyakov, not to mention that there are work of soviet economists and philisophers. There are also interviews with Gaydar and Chernomirdin that tells much more accurate information about problems encountered in USSR.

>never actually worked
>responsible of many conflicts and civil wars
>literally the reason of hundreds of millions of deaths despite what commiefags say
>made more millions starve
>for all those reasons it should be hated more than nazism
>yet it gets praised and the academia shills for it everyday

And the worst of it all:
>loved and shilled everyday by kikes


Fuck communism, bunch of jew shit

No. What makes you think that? Reading about end resilt of attempts of ideology implication is very good, for both parties. Ideology followres can learn from mistakes and create more efficient plan of action. Enemies can learn more about weaknesses of ideology.

...

Why do these people ask retarded questions they can find the answer to in a 2 minute Google search?

Good post

no one cares about Roberts

Sup Forums cares

why should anyone give a rats ass about what Sup Forums thinks

You can say the same about Sup Forums

Say no to redpills. They only hurt you.

Sup Forums is more knowledgeable in it's field than Sup Forums is at anything

Not in actresses/ waifus field.

i repeat, Sup Forums knows nothing.

They know that Emma Roberts is best Emma.

no food.

Small scale communism works. Large scale does not.

Wrong

Because it requires slaves. It requires workers to serve the commune. People don't like to be slaves. Never have.

Technology will one day make human labor unnecessary. Under this environment a sort of communism or socialism would naturally arise, without activism. As slaves are built, and society, being free from human labor, would likely applaud attempts at social or communist states. Yet in the current times, with the current available technology, communist states fail. For people are not emotionless cogs of the machine, and they can not survive in this way.

no u

This bitch looks like Brian peppers

because it's just a scam for robbing the wealthy and educated of a society of their wealth and influence.
your indoctrination is showing

Only literal cuckolds who enjoy getting beaten up by women prefer Roberts over best Emma

>Why is communism so bad?
If i built a car that broke down 100% of the time i used it would you consider it a good car?

I-it just is! The big corporations said so! They would never lie to me!

Femdom is patrician fetish, fuck off.

Gentle Femdom, role reversal and foot worship are patrician fetishes
Full femdom is degenerate

The shit don't fucking work, lel

>not wanting Emma Roberts to beat you up with her puny weak arms and hands

> foot worship are patrician fetishes
I fucking knew you're one of these creeps. Opinion Discarded.

>preferring to get stuck with a hospital bill over massaging Best Emma's soles after she comes home from a long day of work

>Sup Forums is knowledgeable
Sup Forums is the opposite of knowledge. at least Sup Forums is well informed in their subject matter, people on Sup Forums will brag about their misinformation.

>being gay

>Sup Forums is well informed in their subject matter
entirely wrong. hate both boards

As a basic premise it assumes that people are not assholes. Which is not true. And when your base completely fucked there is no way to build something stable.

Listen here, vlad, every time someone has come promising true socialism, they've ended up killing a lot of the people who believed in them. Who cares if it was really true socialism or not, everything that claims to be true socialism kills you, why should anyone believe your version?

It doesn't work

> being frog

>T. Virgin loser who will never make anything of himself

Because it doesn't bloody work.

Because it never existed, and prolly never will. Unlike God.

>I'm going to completely ignore all context and nuance in history to push a neoliberal corporate whore narrative

Why though? Theu don't pay you to do this.

Since you people can't think outside of what media tells you watch this.

youtu.be/NdGMehMANxc?t=20s

delet

ERECT

What educated and well thought-out arguments
>$0.05 have been deposited into your account.

my entire family came from russia/ cccp. grandma told me how EVERONE was poor and how the daycare put down her sisters during the war because they couldnt feed them. It doesnt fucking work, its against human nature. Maybe a communism could work if you have a small group of people, but not an entire country!

If you're a christian and NOT a commie you're doing it wrong

muh erection

why do commies always concentrate on factories?

I suspect it is because it's the only kind of workplace where you can make this argument. The tradesman can choose to buy his own tools and suddenly he owns the means of production. Many choose to do this, and others choose not to.

>implying catholicism is christianity