Which design do you prefer?

Which design do you prefer?

Other urls found in this thread:

twitter.com/inanakisiki/media
i.imgur.com/984gGoM.jpg
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

S1 > S2
S2 > S1
S2 > S1
Everything aside from designs: S1 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> S2

...

S1 is easily superior

S1 Saika is godness

ponkan8 > all other official artwork
sometimes ponpon > ponkan8

Novel.

all s2 except yuigahama she needs s1 tits

Of course 1st. Hand drawn are always superior than digital images

Reminder to accept no less than a threesome end.

I like both. Can't decide.

I like both, but ultimately prefer season 2. Season 1 feels a little simplistic and the animation quality/design is often very mediocre. Season 2 has a difficult time pulling off Yukino's typical facial expression shown in the s1 picture, which may in part be due to character development, it's nice that we see her smile far more often now though.
This guy knows what's up, we haven't really seen Yui's rack up close in season 2 as far as I can recall, but they seem smaller.

Yeah, I'm not sure why she got downgraded.

Yukinon's are perfect as always: modest, but not flat.

I don't like the facial close-ups in S2 at all, like a kid's drawing

the main series ending is clear. Yukino is conflicted on her lesbian love of Yui and straight love of Hachiman. She really wants to be the girlfriend of both. Hachiman also has a certain amount of the bi going on with Totsuka. Clearly the four-way Yui-Yukino-Hachiman-Totsuka path is the correct one

Novels is best

i like the girl that says senpai

S2 by far. Brain's Base's looks so cheap it's not even funny

S2 are too samefacey

...

Girls that says senpai or death!

The worst part is that the only scenes that resembled S1 were the ones without Yui or Yukino, so I started dreading their presence Pavlov style.

Yuki is a Lesbian? Hello? Say what? I am pretty sure 8mans attraction to Totsuka is just a gag.. you know that right?

Good choice.
Yukino and Yui designs from S1 were superior.

...

best girl

>Everything aside from designs: S1 > S2
NOPE
Irohasu is love

>My Landmine Kouhai is Dangerous as Expected

S2 Yukino is utter shit. You must be blind and retarded if you think S2 is better.

Yukinon 1 and 2's designs are basically the same. Why is the latter so bad?

S2 8man is too handsome

I'm going to say S1 simply because of bias. S2 took a scene I cried at in the light novel and made it solely awkward. Not to mention S2 has weird adaptation decisions where some books only got a small portion of time compared to the others. The Hayato Science/Arts fiasco in particular got, what, a single episode? Where as it was an entire novel to begin with. S1 just had better decisions and impact all around.

>Hayamin character quadruple-album
>bonus disk: her talking in character for an hour
Soon.

Okay, never.

Hikki looks better (or at least more believable as a loser) in Season 1. When it comes to the other characters, both designs are fine.
In terms of plot, the first season shits all over the second though. The only good thing that happened in the second season was Iroha.

Post Accelerator

S1 Hachiman actually looks like an unfriendly faggot. S1 Hachiman wins no contest.

>unfriendly
So, an accurate representation.

Granted, season 2 made him look somewhat attractive but creepy, which is how he is described.

why did I like this anime

Because it takes generic high school rom com situations and adds biting cynicism in place of where the idealism is supposed to be. However it manages to do that without being moody and unbearable to sit through.

>moody and unbearable to sit through
The sequel had a lot of great character interaction, but the whole GENUINE bit is exactly as you describe.

Komachi looked better in season 1

Not really, it's the same school life "teenagers learning to stop being antisocial spergs" with the usual trope of everyone falling for the MC as most other shows of this type. Yahari's nothing particularly special.

...

Hachiman has commented several times on their "slightly unhealthy Yuru-Yuri relationship"

And that's why I FUCKING HATE it in the anime. The light novel made me tear up, legit. After Hikki tries his best to save his club and gets kicked in the balls at the end when he find out that even if they were in the council they still would have been the same club in spirit, and finds his club slowly drifting apart as Iroha drags him around like a dog, the pent up frustration and anguish going in there, as well as the fact he has trouble finding the words and everyone is sobbing even before he finishes that thing he can't describe, is really touching in the novels.
In the anime it's a cringe scene.
imo and all that.

Saika-chan in the lower right?

Nah, it's Sagami, as the Hair is too dark for Totsuka

>no Saika
It's shit.

Source? I've found the image but can't find the artist.

Yui won the Hikki bowl already. Yukino helped her do it too, willingly.

S2 8man looks more like you'd expect a guy with at least four attractive girls interested in him to look like.

He looks hot to me. Way too much so.

> He doesn't realize all of ANOTHER is a fevered fantasy that runs through Yui's mind just before the rope breaks her neck so that she can die with a smile on her face

>four attractive girls
Wait. Who? I count 3 at most. Yui, Yukino, and Iroha if you count him as being second choice being "interested".

It's clear that Saki is at least interested, even if she's not pursuing him very hard.

no the two loners already have friends and acquaintances now. Guess again what the prime issue is. OreGairu NOT typical

Saki, orimoto, sensei, yuimom, yukimom, everyone wants the 8inch

I see. I'm not sure I completely agree but I can see where you're coming from there. She seems like the type who would tell herself she was "too busy" for anything like that though.

I thought it was pretty clear during the chocolate making scene and afterwards.

It's been a while since I've seen/read it admittedly. After S2 ended I stepped back from it, so I could easily be forgetting all her signs and flags as she isn't exactly a major character.

Nice try Yukinocuck. Yui won and Yukino helped her proving that she doesn't like him to begin with. She got her happy friendship end. Yui will win again in the main series.

Why does 8man get so fucking handsome in between s1 and s2?

> She got her happy friendship end
Comical

> Yui will win again in the main series
Don't stop believin'

S1 >*

because
>Love Comedy

S1 for everything, why did this even get a second season

>Comical
???

She helped Yui and is much better friends with her now. Hikki can become her friend too.

It's highly likely Yuipollfag. Don't respond to him.

I probably co't help but think about this webm when I eventually watch the Mad Max movies.

Yuifag here. I am very worried that WW is taking so long with vol 12 and that Yui won the AU. I am still pissed that he made Yui seem like a Hikki hungry girl that would step on her friend's throat.

I like both

I'm out of the loop. What is this AU that's being mentioned?

ANOTHER. Yui wins and Yukino helps her but swallows her feelings while doing so.

it's a bone Watari threw the Yuifags where all of a sudden Hachiman doesn't care about Yukino any more and other characters start acting weird in freaky unnatural way. Under those conditions Yui can win apparently. Has nothing to do with OreGairu other than same names so don't bother with it

That's the natural pain of two friends loving and going for same guy. It's a part of life, deal with it. Yukino will step on Yui's feelings and heart in the main series, watch for it

Yukino wasn't even going for 8man. She just ran away and decided to hide herself and her feelings.

>responding to bait

No. Sadly, it wasn't bait. I'm really that clueless.

after the ending of vol 11/S2 that is going to change. Yukino will go for what she wants in life and that includes Hachiman. Yui will make a noble attempt too but will be crushed it is clear

...

HIRATSUKA-SENSEI ON THE FRONT PAGE!!!

>Yukino is conflicted on her lesbian love of Yui
>source: my delusional yurifag headcanon
Kill yourself.

I quoted the main series canon

You're the one ignoring all the canon evidence in the main series. Your head is superfluous, best get rid of it

Yes, I had to go through a few hoops myself, but the full resolution was worth it.

twitter.com/inanakisiki/media
i.sli.mg/Mpfjnk.png

It's seems to be neither on the danbooru, nor on his pixiv.

Speaking as a nonwatcher, S2 Yukino looks terrible in almost every picture I've seen. The others look okay either way.

In retrospect, both fit for what they are. S1 is more comedic and lighthearted, while S2 is where all the heavy stuff happens.

I wouldn't want Hachiman's famous line from S2 with the season 1 character designs and art design, it just wouldn't hit as hard.

it didn't really hit hard in the first place anyway, honestly the character animation in S2 looks more fluid but very awkward some times.

...

>When you bust a mut inside Sensei

...

"Senpaiii~, I'm lying on your bed, what are you going to do about it?"

Ignore you and go for someone that isn't a slut.

Grab my gun and shoot the hussy for home invading.

I learned my lesson the last time you cut a hole in the condom. Now I lose 1/4 of every paycheck.

i.imgur.com/984gGoM.jpg

It's Yui that is Yurigahama not Yukinon

...

In spite of everything else, Light Novel Hikigaya is definitely the worst. He's 18 in some illustrations and other times he's 10.

So say Hachiman rejects Yui, friendzones Iroha, then goes all in for Yukino. Yukino overcomes all her issues, is completely better, but then rejects Hachiman because she's leaving and can't be with him, leaving him devastated, will Haruno feel a tiny shred of sympathy for him?

Does she care about the tool in her hand to fix Yukino after the job is done? Or does she just callously cast the tool aside?

Haruno doesn't care about Hachiman. She only cares about him as long as he interacts with Yukino.

I like pity-sex as this is the only way i can fuck other than criminal acts

She wouldn't give a fuck.But that's fine because Hachiman would do something ridiculous and potentially self-destructive to out-plan her if it came to that.

S1 is self-insert tier.
Middle is superior.