Magical battles, wishes and dark twists.
WHO DID IT BETTER?
Joseph Mitchell
Adrian Rivera
Utena
Ethan Fisher
Madoka every time
Angel Bell
Utena. And that's not anywhere close to even being debatable.
Ayden Hall
Personally:
Utena > F/0 > WIXOSS > Madoka
Angel Hill
Yuri
Wyatt Nguyen
Madoka = Utena >> Wixoss >>>>>>>>>> Fate
Colton Brooks
>magical battles
Utena characters were just good at fencing.
Liam Martin
Madoka>utena>wix>zero
Landon Baker
F/Z was trash only retards like. Wixoss was okay but nothing amazing. Utena was great but it was also too long and had some weak episodes. Madoka was a perfect one cour show where every episode was better than the last one until 10 happened.
Camden Watson
>They were fighting for a magical goal.
>The prince gave Utena a magical power up in every fight.
>Touga's sword could shoot energy.
>Transforming clothes and swords coming out of people.
Nothing magical here, i see this shit every time i watch fencing.
Nolan Sanders
Madoka is garbage. Even worse than F/Z. The other two are great, with Utena being the best one.
Cameron Reyes
Those were just the delusions of some high schoolers.
Camden Hall
If we're rating which of these is best based on those restrictions, then it's a hands down Madoka.
Now if we're asking which of these are our favorite, then I have to say F/Z
Ethan Phillips
Uthena is terrible
Camden Thomas
Utena
Noah Kelly
Holograms.
Jackson Allen
Utena. How is that even a question?
Caleb Hughes
Madoka is the greatest anime in existence. And that's not anywhere close to even being debatable.
Camden Johnson
This. It's been 5 years and nothing has come close.
Lincoln Mitchell
/thread
Thomas Murphy
Samefag.
Jaxon Morgan
fpbp
James Hernandez
all of them
Isaiah Sullivan
You got me.
Connor Gutierrez
faggot
Jackson Morgan
Luis Walker
I might be a mobilefag but never a samefag
Owen James
Luis Anderson
Fate easily
Lincoln Bell
Utena>>>>>Madoka=Wixoss>Fate
WIXOSS is literally Madoka but with cards.
Jeremiah Thompson
I thought WIXOSS is Yugioh with Madoka suffering.
Landon Sanchez
This
Zachary Butler
Plot: Madoka
Story: Utena
Themes: Utena & FZ (tied)
Pacing: Madoka
Characterization: Utena
Directing & Cinematography: Utena
Writing: FZ
Music: FZ
Choreography: FZ
Overall: Utena > FZ > Madoka > Wixoss
Connor Sullivan
>Plot: Madoka
>Story: Utena
>Writing: FZ
Logan Cruz
> Themes: Utena & FZ (tied)
> Music: FZ
Luke Bell
>Pacing: Madoka
Jeremiah Bell
>Plot: Madoka
>Story: Utena
>Themes: Utena & FZ (tied)
>Writing: FZ
Gavin Young
Please. Urobuchi was exploring all of Madoka's themes and plenty others in Fate Zero long before he sold out to Aniplex. And there are literally thousands of bands in the world that would murder to be able to have Zero's breadth in terms of sound and originality.
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
Joshua Bailey
People placing any of these over Utena the greatest achievement of anime
Jaxson Jones
how is this wrong?
Logan Myers
Madoka barely has a plot and FZ isn't well written
Benjamin Nelson
Umm... U should also watch WIXOSS, before comparing these shows.
Jacob Brown
Care to substantiate either of those claims, big guy?
Colton Ramirez
WIXOSS is the worst on the list and it can be ignored.
Alexander Sanchez
Actually, the worst one on that list would have to be Madoka.
Juan Sanders
Really? A failed clone better than the original?
Chase White
Sailor Moon S
Caleb Kelly
Well yeah, WIXOSS took some poorly handled concepts from madoka, expanded them and made them better. Honestly, madoka is a really bad anime in general.
Lucas Parker
Just sailor moon.
Jace Barnes
>Madoka
>winning any category
Dylan Powell
Out of my way, inferior species.
Julian Lee
Plot: Utena
Story: Utena
Themes: Utena
Pacing: Utena
Characterization: Utena
Directing & Cinematography: Utena
Writing: Utena
Music: Utena
Choreography: FZ
Isaiah Perry
Get ready for some friendship puuuunch
Hunter Young
Utena. There is not an argument to be had here.
Isaac Bailey
>Yuusha Tuna
>Battles
If you are going to be a faggot about the show then at least do it right. A better bait would be Raising Project.
Jordan Torres
But i-it's not flagrantly mahou shoujo
B-b-but it's a school battle show
Jack Roberts
Please tell me how that sounds from the millions of other Kajiura OST's. Even when talking about TM, her work on Kara no Kyoukai far outshines Zero.
Kevin Diaz
Did you listen to the tracks I posted? Four pieces with completely distinct themes, at least three different cultural influences, two different time signatures, and featuring four wholly dissimilar arrangements of instruments.
Ryder Butler
Im not gonna argue about writing and shit like that but
>Music: FZ
Adrian Evans
Remember when faggots said Murata's cooking manga won't affect the OPM updates.
HAHA fucking idiots update was delayed for 3 weeks straight.
Jose Miller
Flip Flappers
Samuel Russell
Plot: Utena
Story: Utena
Themes: Utena
Pacing: Utena
Characterization: Utena
Directing & Cinematography: Utena
Writing: Utena
Music: Utena
Choreography: Utena
FIFY
Brandon Barnes
I couldn't take you seriously if I was paid to.
Leo Johnson
Madoka >>>> Utena > F/Z > Wixoss
Chase Jackson
Uthena is the worst out of those
Colton Bailey
>Plot: Madoka
>Story: Utena
Jose Murphy
I haven't even seen Utena and I'm sure it's the answer. The other three are various degrees of garbage.
Jayden Edwards
The one with the most sales :^)
Daniel Rivera
this
Jacob Hill
Mahou Shoujo Ikusei Keikaku is already better than Madoka ever was
Eli Mitchell
Madoka was good until the ending shit on itself. Ikusei was shit from the very first minute.
William Wilson
>Utena was ruined by the movie
>Madoka is a mixed bag but the reception to the TVA ending was definitely better than Rebellion
>Wixoss actually got better with destructed