Shirou would have SAVED EVERYONE

Shirou would have SAVED EVERYONE.

Who's name he could remember

Maybe she was just not worth saving.

Not everyone is Shirou.

Will she have a route in the remake?

...

Shiki should have learned COOKING.

Shiki would kick Shirou's ass.

Eh, it's ok. That guy couldn't live up to Tohno-kun's greatness anyways.

...

She was a street alley whore vampire, she didn't deserve it.

>saved everyone
Did you even READ Fate Stay Night or Hollow Ataraxia? It's a series of failures to save everyone.

Why would she get a route I can't even remember her name.

>saving everyone
>everyone

To save his you would have to kill him at birth.

>read right to left
>first page is on the left

I read that Nasu said that if Shiki and Shirou were to fight, it would be a stalemate. Shiki would keep destroying Shirou's swords, and Shirou would keep projecting swords until the side effects of using their powers killed them both.

No, he said that Shiki would kill every sword and win every fight unless someone overloads first.

As we know, Shiki is capable of killing Arcueid, Nero and so on, Shirou's knockoffs that have a very limited lifespan would get easily "killed" because that's simply how MEoDP works

Not to mention that overloading has never killed Shiki, it just basically makes him sleep for a day.

Hard to kill = Things with weird lifespans or no death concept

Easy to kill = Timed stuff

...

>Shirou
>saving anyone

Maybe. Someday.

Of course Shiki can easily kill Shirou's projections, thats not the point. The point is that the sword spam would prevent Shiki from getting within striking distance of Shirou. If he's too busy killing projections nonstop, he can't reach Shirou. On the other hand, Shirou's projections will never hit Shiki, because he can easily kill them.

Both of you miss out on things said so far.

>Shiki vs. Shirou
>"If powers are at max and we ignore the point of self-destruction caused from overflow then Shiki will win. >No matter how much Shirou makes swords, Shiki will keep 'killing' them. It's a different story if it's possible to use a 'Mana Burst' like Excalibur."

Couple factors here; overflow and self-destruction have to be removed as factors otherwise the fight will end with one of them imploding first, its not revealed which one maybe both, powers are counted as max, and if a sword with mana burst becomes a factor then its a game changer.

Shiki never said he was a hero, and rarely did he try to be.

Often he was even rather villainous.

...

I never particularly got that no one mentions that Shirou can just sit there snipe his ass from a couple kilometers out.

Would shirou have won the holy grail war in Fate/Zero if he participated?

Sure why not.

Considering the competition, he probably would have a decent shot barring Kerry, and that's if he's edgy enough to kill his own son

Also figure Kotomine might let him go for finally finding someone like himself (for real, not the misunderstanding with Kerry)

He wouldn't have met EMIYA. He'd be a weak-ass teapot counterfeiter.

>tuskihime had a shitty anime mixing up routes
>fate has had several for each route, prequal and tons of spinoffs

I think know who won in shiki vs shirou.

in b4 "tsukihime had no anime" damage control