This thread is for the discussion of Aikatsu, PriPara, Cocotama, and all of your favorite little girl shows

This thread is for the discussion of Aikatsu, PriPara, Cocotama, and all of your favorite little girl shows.

Who is your favorite girl from OG Aikatsu?

Reminder that Akari is LITERALLY the best and would make the greatest wife.

Ichigo is infinitely better than Akari in every possible way. What is wrong with you?

Ichigo is great but Akari is way better.

Wasted

And Yume is better than both.

How do a clown and a vampire fall in love?

Don't be ridiculous. Akari is great too but nowhere near as cute and amazing and pretty and talented and hard-working as Ichigo

Those first few are subjective, but not as hard working? What? Akari's entire character was written around working hard. Ichigo had some innate talent that let her learn things super quickly while Akari struggled to even do things like special appeals, which Ichigo did during her first performance. Akari had to bust her butt to do the same things that Ichigo was able to do without a sweat.

Just because Ichigo is more innately talented than Akari doesn't make her less hard-working. She put her all into everything she did always. It's like saying Mizuki is all talent and no hard work

The point I'm trying to make is that Akari had to work harder than Ichigo to get any success. Ichigo did her best everyday, but she also didn't have to go out of her way to practice certain things for weeks like Akari did. Ichigo could just do stuff.

Ichigo did strenuous training and aikatsu all day.
Akari did strenuous training and aikatsu all day.
Just because Akari's raw ability was worse doesn't make her more hard-working, it just makes her a worse idol.

>doesn't make her more hardworking
>Except she had to work harder to attain the same success

Remember how two literally who potatoes who had only ever done karaoke in front of their families somehow got into Starlight on their first try after deciding to audition basically on a whim, completely negating all of Akari's initial struggle to get in

She never reached the level Ichigo was. Maybe her competition was weaker, Ichigo is and always has been the better idol

We don't know how far Akari would have gone because the show ended when Akari become Starlight Queen.
>Maybe her competition was weaker
Luminas beat PowaPowaPururin and Tristar in popularity.

But they never beat Soleil. I rest my case

Let's work this out once and for all. This is still draft one, I put question marks next to everyone I'm unsure about the placement of, let me know why you think I'm wrong or if there's anyone I forgot. I think it's still too early to say for sure about any stars idles but I'd put S4 all in top.

Whoops, I forgot Rin

Hinaki and Juri are dating!

Move Ran up
Ran is like the 3rd best idol

She's clearly not better than Otome though or she would've been starlight queen. And both 2wings and WM are above her, so I'd say that putting Ran above Akari would make Ran sixth at best, and even then I'm not so sure that Ran's better than Yurika, because Ran had to drop out of Tristar, after all. So that's, like, seventh? Maybe it would be better to just move Akari down rather than move Ran up.

Ran got picked over Otome and even Ichigo in Mizuki's little audition. And Ran dropping out of Tristar was because of her feelings, not because of her talent. She was fully capable of it, she just wanted to be with her friends instead. It doesn't mean anything about how good she is.

Did we ever even see Otome winning?

No, we're told that Otome is supposed to be fantastic but she was constantly shit on by the actual plot and lost basically every single idol battle she got into on screen.

Threadly reminder that we got Stars instead of Noellekatsu.