Is it true?

Dylan Peterson
Dylan Peterson

Is it true?

Nicholas Allen
Nicholas Allen

One has good looking artstyle, nice characters and top tier waifu, you tell me.

Cameron Perez
Cameron Perez

Gainax is the Seth Macfarlane of anime. Creates only meme shows for the lowest common denominator

Camden Myers
Camden Myers

I hate both, but Family Guy mixes its animation with its crude humor and references poorly, while Panty and Stocking does that extremely well. It's why FG is a dull animated show to watch, while P&S is enjoyable on a superficial level, just to see the next piece of animation.

James Hall
James Hall

This has some merit to it honestly.

If PSG was American, Sup Forums would trash it to hell and back.

Colton Cruz
Colton Cruz

Agreed. Meg is best girl.

Easton Hernandez
Easton Hernandez

If it was American it would probably be on /co/

Ian Wood
Ian Wood

This.

Oliver Adams
Oliver Adams

there are plenty of english language cartoons that I like
gravity falls for instance I liked a lot.

Henry Gutierrez
Henry Gutierrez

like?

Isaiah Miller
Isaiah Miller

both are shit

Easton Jones
Easton Jones

All of them.

Wings of Honneamise
Literally the greatest anime film of all time. A truly beautiful and ambitious film, tastefully done and with a good message.

Gunbuster
Nadia
Evangelion
FLCL
Gurren Lagann
All bullshit that panders to waifufags with no standards.

Xavier Long
Xavier Long

le ebin /tv/ copypasta
Neck yourself

Noah Scott
Noah Scott

I can't speak for all of those, but Eva is legit well made and FLCL tries to be a very surreal experience over waifufaggotry,

Nathan Lee
Nathan Lee

get this hothead out of here immediately

Austin Gomez
Austin Gomez

while using a squid girl reaction image

Camden Morgan
Camden Morgan

One's more appealing to watch. Family Guy designs are just the same eyes and same neutral pose, and the referential humor tends to simply just be a joke that the writers wanted to shoehorn in.

Jason Lee
Jason Lee

one is continues infinitely and gets stale and annoying pretty fast
other was actually funny, interesting, had likable characters, ended with a big twist and can't get a second season six years later
Even a cure if taken too much becomes a deadly poison, and a poison at right dosage can be a cure.

Jackson Scott
Jackson Scott

They're both shit but PSG actually understands that you cant drag the same jokes on for over a decade. Family Guy relies on people hitting each other, "remember that one time" gags, and referencing something for no reason and that alone is supposed to be funny. While humor is subjective though Family Guys is objectively trash at least PSG has actual animation, a pretty good soundtrack and an art style that hasnt been replicated over and over again.

Benjamin Perez
Benjamin Perez

funny
literally most of it is swearing
interesting
what about it is interesting? their pantsu?
likeable characters
no character in the show has any redeeming qualities whatsoever
big twist
stocking being evil? that was an asspull for the sake of a dumb joke to finish off the show

Levi Green
Levi Green

100x100 4kb

Jacob Jackson
Jacob Jackson

FLCL tries to be a very surreal experience over waifufaggotry,

you don't actually believe this, do you?

James Garcia
James Garcia

What a stupid post, it wouldn't be an anime if it wasn't Japanese.

Michael Fisher
Michael Fisher

it's like a david lynch experimental film

but with waifus

Jason Watson
Jason Watson

That's his point, that Sup Forums is just a bunch of weebs.

Blake Gutierrez
Blake Gutierrez

Wings of Honneamise
tastefully done

okay.

Luke Jones
Luke Jones

truly the david lynch of anime

Robert Hernandez
Robert Hernandez

We wouldn't be here discussing if it wasn't in the first place, now would we?

Tyler Miller
Tyler Miller

Liking anime doesn't mean hating Western things or thinking they're necessarily inferior. This thread is about a supposed hypocrisy on the part of anime fans.

Levi Brooks
Levi Brooks

notice the tone, the dialogue and the pacing. it's all very surreal

too bad it's kinda shit

Joshua Diaz
Joshua Diaz

There wouldn't be any comparison, let alone discussion on Sup Forums, if it wasn't an anime.

Parker Carter
Parker Carter

PSG was complete trash.

Memeing retards only care about it because muh ruined Christmas.

Adrian Thompson
Adrian Thompson

Duh, you'd keep to hating something that's essentially the same though.

Lincoln Nguyen
Lincoln Nguyen

That because family guy references 3DPD

Elijah Morgan
Elijah Morgan

Is that so? I don't think they're comparable at all. They're completely different in my view since they follow different formulas.

Jose Watson
Jose Watson

Eragon: fantasy bullshit
LOTR: fantasy bullshit
See how it means literally nothing

Christopher Sanders
Christopher Sanders

The four episodes of plot that PSG has is are better than what FG will ever hope to be.
Also, in PSG, at least the jokes fit into the flow of the episode and aren't random "just like the time when..." interjections.

Tyler Peterson
Tyler Peterson

Being a Japanese take on Western cartoons, as well as a celebration of animation is general, is what P&S has going for it.

FG is just an animated family sitcom that is thirty minutes of stupid. Macfarlane has made better with American Dad. But what's really sad is shows like Simpsons and SP that used to shit on it are less watchable than Family Guy. Bob's Burgers is actually funny though.

Landon Brown
Landon Brown

Eragon
I almost forgot about it, user. Why would you remind me?

Angel James
Angel James

Family Guy is shit on because classic Simpsons is the granddaddy standard, that it never reached. (as seen by the first cancellation of FG).

Anthony Perry
Anthony Perry

it's like a david lynch experimental film
lol

Jonathan Campbell
Jonathan Campbell

If it was American it would be animated entirely in garbage 3DCG and the tone would be entirely different.

Liam Green
Liam Green

B-b-but... mai waifu...

Luke Turner
Luke Turner

P&S always remainded me of Invader Sim's artsyle

maybe a little more "shapy"

David Sullivan
David Sullivan

Not really, seeing how family guy is a long running series and PSG is meant to be a quick 1 cour laugh.

Lucas Ortiz
Lucas Ortiz

South Park has really lost it the past two seasons. It needs to cut the continuity crap.

Cameron Rogers
Cameron Rogers

Wasn't there an announcement from Gainax West about PSG. What happened?

Joseph Hughes
Joseph Hughes

Bob's Burgers
More inane than King of the Hill with none of the character chemistry.

Logan Rivera
Logan Rivera

The other one is Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt.

Nicholas Reyes
Nicholas Reyes

none of the character chemistry
Not him, but what? That's its biggest strength if anything.

Justin Martinez
Justin Martinez

American Dad > Family Guy

Alexander Williams
Alexander Williams

Family Guy is fucking boring and the "humor" is not even dated with 1980s pop culture references, is just FG style is universally cringy

Cameron Gonzalez
Cameron Gonzalez

/thread

Hudson Garcia
Hudson Garcia

comparing PSG to family guy
not drawn together

Grayson Phillips
Grayson Phillips

pachinko

Noah Gray
Noah Gray

Sp become shit when they started current events

Asher Torres
Asher Torres

Bobs burgers characters are all basically inhuman.

Asher Wright
Asher Wright

Both are fucking trash to be honest.

Levi Richardson
Levi Richardson

Who were the gay elf and yellow guy supposed to be based off? The others are pretty clear cut.

Nolan Morris
Nolan Morris

Link and spongebob.

Dylan Taylor
Dylan Taylor

I get Spongebob but not Link. Is there more to it than him just being a green bishie? They already have not-Pikachu

Cameron Thompson
Cameron Thompson

I dont remember it much but the elf didnt know he was gay until someone pointed it out to him. He thought he was straight cause he had to save a princess all the time. And also I read it somewhere.

Is there more to it than him just being a green bishie
No. All the characters in that show just had their one quirk.

John Anderson
John Anderson

PSG didn't overstay it's welcome, wich makes it comfy and memmorable, unlike FG wich is at this point just beating a dead horse.

Josiah Phillips
Josiah Phillips

It always did current events though.
It became shit when it got all preachy about it

Gabriel Hernandez
Gabriel Hernandez

If your humor is on the dumb side, the best course of action is to not give your audience time to dwell on it. That's primarily where Family Guy fails.

Leo Harris
Leo Harris

The biggest difference between Panty and Stocking and Family Guy is that Panty and Stocking actually makes me laugh.

Recent Family Guy is shit, the comedic timing is horrible. They'll tell a joke and just drag it out for far too long, or just leave it sitting there, it's excruciating.

Hunter Russell
Hunter Russell

Why does Sup Forums know what Family Guy is? Not the name or that it exists, but know enough information to even argue about this.

Who the fuck are you people? Fuck off normalfags or go to /co/. Don't talk about your shitty western fuck here.

Adam Morris
Adam Morris

Sup Forums trashed it to hell and back when it was airing like some sort of reverse TTGL

but Gainax's charm shown through

David Allen
David Allen

I dare you to find anyone who doesn't think billy and mandy is good. American shows can be done well too regards to comedy

Adrian Perez
Adrian Perez

Tbh it is better than american dad or that black guy show.

It isn't like Simpsons is good anymore so if you want some fresh air, family guy is there for you.

mfw Futurama deserved better

Wyatt Rodriguez
Wyatt Rodriguez

This

Hunter Mitchell
Hunter Mitchell

it's a "people think CG is inherently bad" episode

Jace Collins
Jace Collins

You got it wrong, OP. No one here thinks every Chinese cartoon is good, we think no western cartoon has ever been good.

Chase Wilson
Chase Wilson

yeah it's not like we grew up watching Cartoon Network or anything.

Josiah Cooper
Josiah Cooper

I don't give fuck, I'm just mad that Grand Tour is shit. Give me back old Top Gear!

Ryan Davis
Ryan Davis

hehehoho
why do you have knowledge on things Sup Forums?
why aren't your reveling in your ignorance like me?
g-get out, you only belong if you're ignorant and proud!

Wyatt Gray
Wyatt Gray

jesus i want to die

Tyler Evans
Tyler Evans

Not Stewie
Fuck off

Julian Torres
Julian Torres

user, you should try watching more than anime. You might even have fun at it. I recommend Archer. Also second Top Gear is great.

Lincoln Gomez
Lincoln Gomez

I'm not sure if I'd personally describe it as "surreal experience" but it's true that FLCL isn't really about waifufaggotry.
The girls are far from being just waifus anyway as they're pretty much selfish bitches and the series is much more about Naota's development than idealizing girls.

Owen Lee
Owen Lee

No

Kevin Torres
Kevin Torres

That show was fucking awful. Should've stayed dead after that pilot episode.

Jaxon Hughes
Jaxon Hughes

Billy and Mandy is mostly hit and miss, you want good comedy you go watch Courage.

Noah Long
Noah Long

Do elaborate.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Confirm your age

This website may contain content of an adult nature. If you are under the age of 18, if such content offends you or if it is illegal to view such content in your community, please EXIT.

Enter Exit

About Privacy

We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners.

Accept Exit