Was killing her off that horrifically REALLY that necessary? What stupid edgelord wrote this scene?

Was killing her off that horrifically REALLY that necessary? What stupid edgelord wrote this scene?

Other urls found in this thread:

fgostory.blogspot.com.br/2016/03/en0100001111.html
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

I felt the same way about that death. They make a point to say she'll suffer infinite death and then promptly forget about her. Fuck FGO.

I know! It's like they came up with the most horrific way imaginable to kill someone off who we barely got to know for no reason other than to show that the bad guy is not a nice person.
And the worst part is that the main characters who saw it happen in front of them don't even really care and move on like it never happened!
Even if they weren't that close to her they should at least have some form of PTSD from that shit.
That was the most pointless and stupid death scene I've ever seen.

Isn't she freed in the Melty Blood manga?

I don't think so.

She was already dead anyway

Well, what else do you expect from FGO?

About that: how the fuck did her spirit materialize like a Servant, and what was the point of that twist if they were just gonna kill her off again like that anyway?
They could've made her fuse with another servant and become a Demi-Servant like Mashu, but they completely wasted her character.

How can she experience an infinite number of deaths if she was already dead to begin with?

Yeah, she died in Fateverse and she's part of Tsukihime now

Well seeing she was a carbon copy of Tohsaka rin was anything of value really lost?

It could have made sense somewhat had they made this into a big turning point in the story and used it to develop and flesh out the characters affected by it, but it just ended up being disconnected and gratuitous instead.

They should have either killed her for good instead of subjecting her to eternal agony, or, if they really had to torture her, made her predicament an integral part of the story and source of distress/purpose for the rest of the cast.

As it is, it just looks like a significant oversight and bad writing.

Basically her soul is obliterated and her very existence is gone.

This seems to be what actually happened, she is eternally dead (whereas normal deaths do not destroy the soul) rather than actually experiencing some kind of eternal torture.

>She will experience an eternal death akin to be absorbed by a blackhole or the sun, where she is disassemble on the molecular level. She disappeared, leaving no trace of her behind. The girl called Olgamally, is no more

My question is why they would waste such a horrific death scene on a character that we barely got to know and execute it in such a contrived matter.

What that was from her point of view in reality Lev just shift back to Chaldea erasing her for good.

Fucking this. Everything about this scene singlehandedly ruined Fate/Grand Order. If Nasu actually wrote this scene, then he is officially a hack.
The worst part about this shit that happened to her is that neither the audience or the characters even care.
The story never even gave us or them a reason to care.
And it will have no effect on the story whatsoever. It's a complete fucking waste.

Does she die this early in the game too?

To make the situation seem hopeless. The only humans left are Gudao, Mashu, Roman, and a bunch of unamed staff, they're completly cut off from any outside help, and their leader just died a horrible death.

Yes. In the fucking prologue.

I get that, but there's a much better way they could've handled that.

>people acting surprised that Fate/shit has awful writing

He did actually the only ones that are complaining are tryhards who want to make sense of everything just don't think.

>HURR DURR I POSTED IT AGAIN LOL
Fuck off.

>it's another "secondaries complain their waifu died" thread

Hey, the original Fate/stay night and Fate/Zero were legitimately well written. If Nasu actually wrote Grand Order according to , then it just means that Nasu is officially a has-been.

Well they needed some way to show the antagonist of this shit means business, because his character design is too god fucking awful to take seriously.

Nasu didn't write Zero just accept people die for no reason

Who's the best servant and why is it Tamamo?

I assume the director of the studio really hated her, because her death didn't had these touches of cruelty in the game.

That only works if the story and character behaviours change to reflect that. If you're going have horrible things happen to induce an overall sense of dread, that's perfectly fine, but it can't be accomplished by simply shocking the viewer with a one-off scene. You need to show that the characters feel the same way as well, and show how this affects their actions. Here, the supposedly relatable and human cast immediatly forgets about something that would give anyone a bad case of PTSD, which goes against any kind of emotional connection to the story and breaks any sort of credibility it could have had.

Do these look like hopeless people who just witnessed the gruesome death of their companion? Not really.

The antagonist literally could've killed the main character and Mashu right there.
But instead he kills waifubait and then skiddadles.
If that's what they call showing he means business, I'm not impressed.

He co-wrote it with Urobuchi, numbnuts.

The whole time it happened I wondered why the flying fuck were they just WATCHING. They don't even give enough of a shit about her to try and save her.
I feel like she just had more of a character arc in that one episode and her breakdown as she was going to die than MC and Mashu are going to have in all the seasons too.

I don't think anyone was impressed, its a shitty villain with shitty motives in a poorly written show.

To top it all off his character design screams mad hatter wannabe, the only way the assholes writing this apparently could think to give him any tension at all was to have him do the most edgy mustache twirling thing he could have possibly done.

She was something like teenage Ilya.
So long overdue to be killed.

Really now? That's fucked.

How was it in the game? Same thing but withouth the eternal suffering part?

>secondaries
>implying Grand Order's story is related to the original visual novel's story in any way

>Urobuchi
he isn't called "the butcher" for nothing after all.

Exactly. And that's what pisses me off about this shit so much.

everyone should be proud to be a F/GO secondary, because if you fall for fucking gatcha mobileshit you only have yourself to blame

Wow, I didn't know there was so many kids on Sup Forums complaining about a literal who's death.

For me it's mostly about how she died rather than the fact itself since i wasn't caring about any character at all prior to that scene
Also she was cute, nice uniform too

Porco Rosso is for bullying only

Fucking this. The scene singlehandedly ruined what could've been an otherwise mediocre show, and turned it into a steaming pile of Komodo dragon shit.

Truly, what a horrible fate/grand order!

Nasu.

No, only idiots who can't read think that. There are two Olgas in that manga, neither is from FGO. One is from Case Files and the other from an Extra timeline where she died earlier (she's a child). It's not FGO Olga.

I don't know why idiots repeat this bullshit. There's even two different Levs there who aren't from FGO because they aren't full demon yet.

Meh, not really. She suffered just as much in the game. You can read the translation here:
fgostory.blogspot.com.br/2016/03/en0100001111.html

>Lev: Yes. It's no different to a blackhole. Or perhaps the Sun. Well, regardless.
>Lev: It's the incarnation of hell that'd disassemble any person who touches it on the molecular level. Please, feel free to savour living death for an eternity.
>Olga Marie: No---No, no, help, somebody help! I……I, I don't want to die in a place like this!
>Olga Marie: I haven't been praised yet……! No one, no one has acknowledged me yet……!

>They could've made her fuse with another servant and become a Demi-Servant like Mashu, but they completely wasted her character.
They can't, Mashu isn't human, that's why she is a demi Servant.

The story was adapted from a mobile game, so it won't translate that well into a proper medium.

Yes except Urobuchi's death scenes for the most part carry weight on the story and the characters, and actually emotionally affect his audience.
When Mami died early in Madoka Magica, Madoka and Sayaka were horrified and emotionally scarred by her death, and it shocked the audience since we generally weren't expecting something like that in a show about Magical girls.
When Rider died in Fate/Zero, the audience was crying just as hard as Waver.

But then how can Waver turn into a demiservant?
Or Rin?

If you have watched or read enough typemoon, death by being incinerated isn't a big deal for a magi, it's simply that Olga wasn't suited to be one.

Still had more personality than that cardboard cut-out called Mashu

Gudako saves the director in the manga. This manga is canon, right?

>Pseudo-servant =/= demi-servant

>Dr. Roman: So the reason why we could not contact the outside world wasn't because of a transmission fault, But that anyone who could have received our calls have been erased.
>Lev: Heh, smart as always. It's regrettable that I didn't kill you first.

How did anyone overlook Roman figure it out but was trying to keep hopeful?

I mean if the intention was to show how high the stakes were and add weight to the bad guy, then why didn't the remaining characters seem that affected by her death? It was kinda just like they shrugged it off.

And Gudako doesn't fuck around like Gudao.

He's a Pseudo Servant. See Shirou and Angra Mainyu, same example.

>kills useless dumb bitch
>but not the guy who can stop him

Goetia should have fired this retard.

The worst part is that this was a one off OVA to promote a few smartphone game. So we're not gonna get any depth for MC-kun and Mashu.

Manga Gudao is kind of an asshole

The characters were a bit busy surviving and noticing everyone is dead besides the few fuckers in Chaldea.

Might be a little too occupied to give a shit about a stranger. Roman did bring her up a few times later, so he cared, but he had to become the leader and not fuck around anymore.

type moon stuff bad writing as always.

A stranger? They've all known each other for the same amount of time. If anything, Mashu has known the director longer than bland insert-kun.

We're complaining about the death scene itself for being fucking stupid and pointless. We couldn't give two shits about the character when we were never given a reason to care about her.

Because they didn't have any strong connection with a literal who like her? To (you) and Mashu, she was simply "the director of Chaldea", to Roman, "the daughter of Marysbilly". Also Olga didn't have the right mindset to be a magi in the first place.

>saves
If anything she's been damned to a life with Gudako.

They go as far as sending her the stone age to get of her.

The director avoided Mashu because she felt guilty about how her father treated her. She doesn't know her all that well. Lev had more interaction with Mashu than Olga.

Seriously. Lamest fucking villain since Exdeath from Final Fantasy V.

They had a very interesting setup though with her being dead, except of course for the complete lack of foreshadowing.

They could use the 3 minutes of screaming about not getting praised and father issues for some emotional "passing on the mission" for the MC/Mash instead. That would work much better in all aspects for what you're saying.

It may as well be. This is far more enjoyable and well written than Grand Order.

To be fair, Roman did care about what happened, but many people died and the world is on fire. He couldn't believe Lev would do that to Olga either, he brings it up in the last Singularity which confirms the Lev who was their friend wasn't the same Lev who betrayed them.

I like his design and Sugita voice though.

>killing her off that horrifically
>edgelord
>no spiked, edged or sharp objects colored with dark and red colors were used to kill her

it wasn't edgy.

Even if (you) weren't around to keep him busy, Flauros miscalculated in believing that Roman was in his office and not hidden eating cake in a room which would make him arrive late to their explosive appointment anyway.

Skirting out your responsibilities save lives kids.

Who are the Servants besides Mashu that do security duty for the Master to protect them from unwanted mana transfers?

Yeah but MC kun they knew for like 5 minutes.

Doesn't matter. They should at least feel traumatized with PTSD or have at least some form of human emotion after seeing someone get horrifically killed right in front of their eyes.

Sugita's voice is literally all Flauros has going for him. His design looks like some generic mustache twirling mad hatter shit.

Of course not, it was Flauros by then, in other worlds Lev killed himself before becoming a demon god.

Yes? And MC kun ran into the fire and stayed to die by her side. Which was more than Olga did to her by avoiding her for years. He touched her hand and treated her like a person, something only Roman did.

annoying bitch dies a horrific death, how are you upset over this?

Lev design is great, so no. And he was a really good person. ;_;

Are they both gay in the comics?

I love this meme.

Ads don't have human emotions

That's an impressive character design for post-Zero/Melty Blood Type-Moon.

They are gag comics, but yes.

They should have had RomanxGudao instead of Astolfo though.

Yes

Ghost aren't people

>Kiyohime
>unwanted

user pls

>yfw you realize the FV suffers the same fate
Pure pottery.

But protagonist reacts strongly after Roman dies. They even hallucinate him in their room and is unable to join the celebrations, holding up the tears and shit.

>Villain put a bomb right below her for no reason except raising the chance of the actualmasters being alive.
>Reveals she is already dead
>Regadless of that creates a wormhole through another space and time just to slowly throw her soul that had a few minutes of "life" left in a black hole for "eternal death"
>Then just leave the only left master that already realized a contract and his servant alone
>No one cared about the character anyway, but they still made it the climax of the OVA.

It was not only edgy, but also really stupid.

GO is a shitty mobage I really don't know what you all expected.

Or better yet, they could've merged her soul with a Servant and made her become a Demi-Servant/Pseudo-Servant like Mashu.

What if Cu-ster was still there when shit was going down? She could've made a pact with him and got powers like Mashu.

It could've been a good setup for a transition of her character, and they wasted it on a fucking edgy death scene.

Waifufags and pussies, you don't need to think too much about that.