Be honest, would you have made the sacrifice?

Be honest, would you have made the sacrifice?

Would have been killed long ago in my first battle

But yea I totally would have

If i was as fucked as he, i think i would.

But before he puts himself in that deplorable state, i think i would give up the idea of the sacrifice.

Anyone would if they were tortured like he was.

No, but I would try to ask guts for a mercy kill.

I would at least think about what the fuck I'm sacrificing. My maybe is close to a yes.

I would've done it just for a normal body after all that torture, getting to become a God would just make me not question it.

I would never have gotten into that situation in the first place. I have zero ambition so I wouldn't have been chosen by the behelit. I'm not strong or brave so I wouldn't have become a mercenary. I'm not a charismatic leaderly type so I wouldn't have a band of followers to sacrifice. I'm not obsessively controlling so I wouldn't sperg out and get myself tortured. If you changed me to the point that I could find myself in that situation then obviously I would, because I'd basically be Griffith and we already know what he did.

No.

And for those answering yes, most of you on Sup Forums have 2d waifus.

Ask yourself if you could sacrifice your waifu for yourself. The sacrifices literally go to Hell.

I would not have been in the right state of mind so it's hard to predict how I'd act in that situation. After all of my dreams fucked up, my body stripped any usefulness, forced to become a dependent vegetable my entire life after being tortureraped in a dungeon for two years by a sadist, isolated from everything and everyone, while overhearing people talk about how much they pity me and what a burden I am, I really cannot say how my brain would process a choice like that.

>The sacrifices literally go to Hell.
when did it say that?

Beginning of the manga.

Griffith could technically qualify for insanity plea, or even a crime of passion in this instance. But I think the point is that he was out of his mind by then. It doesn't mean that everyone who would be in that position would do the same, but causality has it that Griffith's propensity for ambition made it that he'd be the perfect candidate to say yes. He didn't have much of a choice in the matter. Not only was he willing to whore himself off to old men for victory, but he had to justify it in his mind as it being a way of honoring all of those who died for his dream, like that little boy.

If he didn't truly give a shit, he wouldn't have even had to do that. He had to feel weak, useless, insane, hallucinating, suicidal, and desperate to rationalize.

I don't know. It's still wrong though.

No. Because Im not a cunt

I'd kill myself long before that point, if possible.

Then again, I'm not ambitious enough for a behelit. I don't want to be a burden on others.

If I put myself in Griffith's place, I think I'd probably say yes.

Life isn't looking too bright, not to mention I would also be coerced into agreeing by demon lords.

If it was me sitting at my computer right now however, I'd say no.

If I were Griffith, I'd just murder myself, not to enable the behelit, but just to fucking end my potato life.

I'm depressed now, they didn't deserve that

>I just got tortured for 2 years straight.
>Instead of asking for a swift death, I'll instead damn the entire Band of Hawks, my loyal comrades in arms, to an eternity in actual hell, which probably makes my 2 years of torture look like fucking nothing because hey, I'm a selfish fuckboy.

If Griffith were an iota of a good person, which he wasn't even pre-Tower of Rebirth, he would've found a way to just die.

The point is he feels that all those who have already fallen would have died for nothing if he didn't go the distance.

He also feels that those alive are already willing to die in order for him to achieve his dream, so what difference does it make for them to all die now.

Also he wasn't in the best state of mind after years of torture and demons chatting to him.

The choice is actually fighting and dying for something or someone who believe in as opposed to having something or someone you believe in sacrificing your soul to Hell for eternity randomly.

I'm not arguing or anything - I'm p sure everyone can agree that Griffith is/was a sociopath before becoming Femto.

>The 2 years of torture probably didn't help either.
>Nor did constantly thinking about Guts beating him and leaving the Hawks.

How the hell did Guts survive the eclipse? The anime just ends with Casca getting raped while Griffith makes Guts watch.

I'd read the manga but I'm dyslexic and the manga is really cluttered and difficult to read

I'd ask Guts to kill me. I wouldn't want to kill all my friends.

Keep in mind despite any good in his heart Griffith had 1 friend. In his place I might actually have bonded with the rest of the band too.

>How the hell did Guts survive the eclipse?

Skelly knight came in and saved Casca and Guts.

Shame he couldn't have come in before the demon rape.

Skull Knight appears and saves him and Casca.


As an aside we can all agree that
Skull Knight = King Gaeseric = Pekoko or whoever that boy infused with elf magic from the legends was

Blame that on Zodd (who Skully doesn't kill for whatever reason)
Zodd is like 2nd most responsible for all the bad shit, 3rd is Guts himself.

>your best friend who you trusted everything with just whales on you and goes "smell ya later" without ever actually taking FIVE MINUTES to explain he wants to go on a soul-searching journey and expects you to magically understand his feelings like a damn woman
>not getting upset about that

My roommate just recently showed me Berserk. I love Griffith's character and I'm glad he did what he did. That being said, I'd probably pussy out of sacrificing my current platoon (marinefag). The funny thing is, there's a native American girl in my platoon who looks just like Casca...if she smiled more. 8/10 would rape to retardation

>friend leaves
>act like a little bitch and ruin everything for everyone
Aw, poor baby. Not to mention it's his own fault Guts left because of his tryhard philosophy about 'true' friendship. If you expect Guts to explain himself to Griffith, then Griffith should have explained his feelings instead of challenging Guts and getting his ass handed to him.

He was pretty fucked.
He couldn't even kill himself or tell others to kill him.

Honestly I would've.
Wouldn't have raped Casca and I would've spent eternity to atone for it all, but I wouldve.

No because I am not a narcissistic homosexual from an overrated series.

You know a villain is great when people can sympathize with him/her and justify/defend/whitewash their actions. Evil isn't something alien or people just doing things they wouldn't normally do. Evil is very human. It can be very rational. It can feel right. But it's still evil.

What Griffith did was inhuman but any person is capable of it.

No, I'm not a weakling like Griffith.

>You know a villain is great when people can sympathize with him/her and justify/defend/whitewash their actions.
That has nothing to do with how well written of a villain he is. It's really just
>anyone who had the highest highs then went to their lowest would give up their humanity for power

You have a gross misunderstanding of evil.

I disagree. But give me a non-gross understanding of evil.

You also omitted the "sacrifice your companions" part as well, but it's worded like a typical apology so no surprises here. Griffith isn't Dio Brando.

>overrated series
I still don't understand how people can think Berzerk is good.
Did they start reading as kids or something? Are they the same edgy fedoras who like the Preacher comic?

>Are they the same edgy fedoras who like the Preacher comic?
Probably this.

That's the old boring Berserk. New Berserk has cute mermaids and witches and stuff.

Probably

I like the new Berserk

I don't know, being tortured like that would really suck. Maybe at that point I'd rather just have my comrades kill me.

yes, wouldn't have hated guts or raped Cosca either

The real reason why Griffith fucked up is because he got his ideals and confidence shattered, exposed, and he couldn't handle that. (Man, I remember when Berserk was good.)

peekaf? i could see it

No because I wouldn't have raped a princess.

Nooope. That's an opportunity to both kill myself without guilt and make a service to mankind and the planet.
Evil can just go eat an entire dick and fuck off to the vibration it came from.

I'd have sacrificed the whole world to rid them of the suffering of life.

AYE BUT WHAT COST

Would I not be in the current of causality too if everything was the same leading up to that moment anyways

So why the FUCK did berserk spoil itself by revealing Griffith as a villain, THEN flash back to the golden age and spend forever showing him off like a good guy who eventually betrays them when we already know that'll happen? What kind of idiotic idea is that.

watch the movies it shows how man

After a year of torture and being mentally fucked? Probably. Either that or suicide. But I don't see myself ever raping Casca.

It was primarily Skull Knight, but Griffith also lets them leave, you can see him lowering his hand instead of using another gravity attack. Griffith spares Guts and Casca again later on the HIll of Swords. He still has a boner for Guts imo.

So why the FUCK did Star Wars spoil itself by revealing Vader as a villain, THEN flash back to the Republic and spend forever showing him off like a good guy who eventually betrays them when we already know that'll happen?

because the prequels were a mistake

Fuck you, I love the original anime.

You picked probably the worst possible example for arguing in favor of prequel stories.

You know it's funny, I actually was thinking about including an example of an existing work with a spoiler using berserks stupid "reveal villain first, tell dramatic story of their betrayal later" and star wars darth vader was the exact example I thought of.

But I ultimately didn't type it out because I got distracted by something else. And in this case, I'm not quite sure if you're being serious about star wars because the prequels didn't come out until before the originals, and shouldn't be watched before them (or even at all)

And the pain he was in, don't blame him at all

Zodd is immortal

In media res. We knew diddly shit about neither Guts nor Griffith at the beginning. We got this big guy with a bigger sword who wants to kill this evil bird looking guy. But why is that? Welllllll

What sacrifice?

That's the point.
Also, is there even "heaven" in berserk?

Yeah I know what it is. That doesn't make it less stupid and a waste of what could have been a massive impactful shock to the reader.

Like he may as well have written it like
>I've finally found you Griffith you bastard!
>Haha fuck you Guts.
>*record scratch*
>Yep, that's me. Bet you're wondering how I wound up in this crazy mess. Well it all started a few years ago...

Humans cling to life with all they have. Even Guts knows this, wonder if he thought about it in regards to Griffith.

What do you mean "could have been"? It WAS a massively impactful shock. It's one of the main things the series is famous for. This very thread is one of the countless threads made concerning what happened. Knowing early that Griffith is the antagonist didn't dampen anything.

Well it could have been massivelyer and impactfuler if the very first thing we knew when we saw Griffith wasn't "oh he becomes an evil reality warping god and Guts will eventually fucking hate him".

There's no "heaven" or "hell". They could be said to be the same thing, as its merely a description of a reality created by these cosmic entities.

All we knew at the start was that Griffith did something to Guts and it made him extremely mad. It was still a shock seeing just how far Griffith went to send Guts that far over the edge in anger though. Besides, by the time you're halfway through Golden Age you've probably forgotten all about it as you're too engrossed in Mercenary Wars: Thirty Years War Fantasy Edition.

In answer to your question though, it's because Miura was making it up as he went along and didn't initially create Femto with the thought that he was gonna be Guts' bestie who stabs him in the back and Casca in the vagina.

That's just a nickname he got because of his infinite lifespan. He won't die of old age but I'm sure someone could stab him through the heart and have him die.

Yeah but I'm a sociopath. I won't pretend like it's for any higher good or that I dindu nuffin.

Yeah you can still enjoy and be shocked by something like this, all I'm saying is that it COULD have been even better.

And I'm not the kind of person to just forget a spoiler because I'm engrossed in the story.

>reality created by Idea of Evil or God Hand
Yup, there is only hell

I don't see what difference it would have made. I didn't even think like that; just sounds like the impact of the event has worn off on you now that you're able to look back at the story.

Also structured the way it is, we started right in the middle of some action. Where should it have started, Guts' birth?

The lucky trips don't lie

It could have started at the start of the golden age.

But really you don't even need to really start at a different point, just don't show Femto or reveal anything about Griffith. Or hell, he could have shown Femto, but then not made Griffith still have the exact same helmet so we didn't know Griffith would eventually become him (or at the very least not know for certain).

No, Golden Age has more impact when you already know what it's going towards.

You can still know everythings going to get dark and fucked up just based on the difference in Guts appearance and attitude before and after the golden age flashback starts even without Griffith being the villain being preemptively revealed.

That's too vague to impart the same anticipation. The knowledge of Griffith's future, and the uncertainty of EXACTLY what happened, gives the entire Golden Age a lowkey sense of dread that's worth far more than a cheap WOW MIND=BLOWN surprise.

I guess you like to look up character deaths before starting series too because the sense of dread and wondering "EXACTLY" how they die is more exciting than being shocked, which you characterize anyone who values as stupid with all caps insults.

Having thin skin should be banned.

I think resorting to petty insults when you're no longer able to argue legitimately should be banned.

I actually don't think that should result in bans because I actually believe in freedom of speech and discussion, but I just parodied you for the joke. But as you have ironically missed, wanting other people banned just because they say something you don't like only shows you're actually the thin skinned one.

My waifu is dead anyways ;_;

>all caps insults.
wot?

yes, you are just an autistic, childish shitposter wasting your life in a shithole

I bet
is at least 5 years less experienced than
Reading for 'twists' is like watching horror for the 'thing jumps at camera and screeches' jump scares.

What are you blistered about? The first arc was an introduction. We're introduced the the main characters and conflict of the story. It didn't ruin anything.

His implication that anyone who values surprises in stories must just be an idiot who types mainstream memes like "WOW MIND = BLOWN".

And now he's fellating himself acting like "yeah my opinion makes me older and also automatically correct I win this" mentality.


You know there's a reason most stories have followed this basic structure of not starting in the middle with all the important points pre-revealed and then being explained later for thousands of years.

nah, you do sound like an idiot. that wasn't an insult in any shape or form
>mainstream memes
don't talk to me if your least dank meme is under at least 6 layers of irony, amirite?

That's not me, no. I didn't see a point in continuing when you were seeing attacks on you that weren't there but other people just had to bite.
As far as the actual topic, someone already pointed out in media res to you and that's where the conversation should've ended.

Rather than forced being sacrifice, I rather do it by myself.

Insult, meme, call it whatever you want it's still a childish way of trying to de-legitimize a viewpoint by trying to characterize it being said by a stupid person just because it's a viewpoint different from your own.


But in the end I can't deny this was a very interesting experience. I never would have thought there were actually people out there who think all well written surprises, twists and reveals in stories are the same as cheap jumpscares in bad horror movies and anyone who enjoys either of them is stupid, yet here I see it before me. Hell I guess Miura should just tweet how berserk ends and we can spend the next 30 years just wondering how Guts gets there (assuming he doesn't reveal Guts will actually die, not like anyone would care though since as we all know because only stupid people who like jump scares would be care about a major twist like the main character dying).

>You know there's a reason most stories have followed this basic structure of not starting in the middle with all the important points pre-revealed and then being explained later for thousands of years.
If you can't handle a common writing convention then why do you read anything at all?

>your own.
>all who disagree with me are one person

Miura's already said he doesn't want to give Berserk a bad ending considering how much time he's put into it.

>to an eternity in actual hell
I always assumed that it wasn't Christian hell though, its simply a place where all souls merge and lose consciousness

People can shitpost all they want but anime stills with 3frame battle scenes are far better than the disgusting CGI we've got now. I still can't believe they're making a 2nd season

Sounds a lot worse than Christian Hell.

You mean better. How is a loss of individual conciousness worse than a place which has a lake of burning sulfur and which is described with "weeping and gnashing of teeth"?

You still exist in the lake of burning sulfur.