Not really. It's just a bunch of autistic spergrage, to be honest.
>THE STORY ISN'T UNIQUE AND NEW
NO plotline is "unique." There's only about seven basic plots and storytellers have been using them in one permutation or another since before the written word was invented. Anyone who fails to grasp this isn't qualified to bitch about writing.
>H-HE USED CHARACTER ARCHETYPES BAAAWWWWW
This is like bitching about a car having wheels. If they were just cardboard cutouts meant to serve their archetypal roles, we wouldn't have shit like Mami flipping her shit and trying to whack everyone.
And then there's his fucking autismo "plot holes" list, all of which was explained by anyone who actually watched the show. It's not the show's fault that he's too fucking stupid to, you know, watch the show.
>How did Kyuubey survive that attack baaaw
He's effectively immortal and his bodies are disposable, dipshit, that's coverd.
>How did mami lose to a plebwitch
She was busy showing off for her new sempais and was high on the whole YAY I HAVE FRIENDS NOW. As is shown later the girl's apparent mental stability was the result of carefully balanced high pressure. She called kyuubey a *friend,* if that fuckin illustrates anything for you.
>Episode four, Madoka is captured by a witch after she foolishly went out, strangely no Homura rescue in sight. It is Sayaka who comes and helps her, question is, how did Sayaka know where she was?
They literally showed Mami hunting down a witch the prior fucking episode, you fucking numbnuts
>Why did Kyouko want to become friends with the girls she just tried to kill the episode earlier? It is never explained.
Completely ignoring several scenes, most potently the conversation in the church where they come to understand one another better. Jesus. I could keep going, but what the fuck.
So as far as we're concerned, he's evil.
Yes!