What's the right thing to do in this situation?

What's the right thing to do in this situation?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=vhSHXGM7kgE
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

multi track drifting

Fpbp
/thread

i bring out my trusty 10ft pole

...

...

Are those people convicted criminals? Is this capital punishment

To not save the five persons is to violate their NAP. Since you will be violating the NAP anyways, might as well save lives.

I feed people who have violated the NAP on my property to my trolley. Watch yourself.

walk away and call 911

What that web series Mind field, they did an episode about it with "real people".

Grab a cooler and ice so you can harvest the organs.

THIS IS NOW A TROLLEY THERAD

Can't you pull it partially and cause it to flip over?

wtf, that doesn't even make sense

It's C3.

C3 isn't it

what race are the people on the tracks?

Their skin is white, according to the image. But could be Slavs

C3. Albert didnt know which pad it wasbut he knows for a fact Bernard doesn’t know either: bernard would know the pad if it was A6 and B5 (only 5 and 6 have only 1 option so that would be the only way Bernard would know the pad just by knowing the number) so Albert’s letter is either C or D since A and B are now excluded.

So now that Bernard can exclude A and B he realizes which one is the pad: that means we can exclude number 1 since there are no A1 or B1 pads so if it was on line 1 he still wouldn’t be able to tell the exact pad.

Albert knows now as well, he realized Bernard excluded line 1 so it can only be C3, since he got the letter C. We know it’s C3 as well since it can’t be D2 or D4 or otherwise Albert wouldn’t yet be able to know the exact pad (still 2 options in D but only C3 left in C, after excluding line 1).

kys

Well?

...

I dont see why this is a problem?

i never understood the track switching 'dilemma' thing , seems obvious to me , if you wanna maximize people dead you keep it and otherwise you switch .

It's deontological vs utilitarian ethics.

Yes, but they will say this is against the rules, but that violates the NAP so then you can shoot them.

That is beautiful.

Personally, I view if you insert yourself into the situation then you create a murder.
>leave the switch
>5 people die, it's an accident with nothing to do with you
>flip the switch
>1 person dies, you murdered them

Pull up a chair.

I would kill a max. ammount of people as we have to get rid of worthless consumer idiots worldwide.

nature Bernd not addicted to masonic-kike-Hegelbullshit

...

If those commies want you to violate the NAP to the detriment of all property owners for their own personal gain then they are commies who need to be eliminated anyway. This may even by why they've been tied to the tracks in the first place.

The situation solves itself.

Ask Bernard and Albert which pad it is.

this is my favorite trolley meme

what difference does it make ?, what matters is the outcome and both turning the switch and not turning it are choices you make .
the idea that people 'murder' people is absurd , theres no algorithm that can attribute the death of one person to another person . like does the fact that im not running to some place where a car accident is about to happen and warning people make me their 'murderer'. why are politicians not trialed for every death 'resulting' from their actions ?.

theres no point in accusing someone of 'murder' because that murder was the ultimate and inevitable consequence of every single thing that ever happened up to it . its the same as accusing the laws of physics of murder.

youtube.com/watch?v=vhSHXGM7kgE

>Hello, user.
>If you are hearing this, then you have pulled the lever, resulting in the deaths of your five friends.
>The sign was clear. You were warned.
>They would have lived. But your utilitarian philosophy would not allow you to stand by.
>Instead of saving these five people, your moral flexibility has cost them their lives.
>You have failed your final test.
>GAME OVER.

Trust a jew not to understand morals.

A fuckin jew.

This is why everyone hates Jews, even a simple problem get convoluted when they apply their "logic"