Tanya versus Itami

ITT: Discuss how the Japanese military fight against the Empire military if the Empire in GATE were advanced like "Saga of Tanya the Evil".

...

Aoi Yuuki vs Risa Taneda
No dicks will be left standing.

Itami has Ruari which can tank everything.

The Elf can fuck with the elements and blue wizard can EXPLOSION

Itami can call in modern day air support also their AA guns are much stronger today than WW1

Itami wins.

Tanya is just a civilian salaryman. He is not a soldier.

You're assuming the 'empire' would let the JSDF have a beachhead.
Not to mention, this setting means that the NotGermany empire did an incursion into modern Japan.

I have no clue how things would have gone. But it's not notRome vs JSDF anymore.

>Tanya is just a civilian salaryman
>Major in the Empire's armed forces
>veteran of multiple battles, ace with silver assault wings
>not a soldier

in a 1 vs 1, Tanya wins: she is basically a plane
In a battalion fight 48 mages will still win against Itami company, even with inferior tech if they keep spamming magic
In a Empire vs JPDF, japan would probably win thanks to air superiority, better weapons and training

This, Itami forces have far better AA and complete modern training while Tanya's forces in the anime are basically in training.

Also magic in gate is more OP, its just that for some reason they never use it.

Tanya would just switch sides at the first opportunity and the Empire would lose fast.

modern military weapons can easily fuck the WW1 mages of Youjo Senki any day.

Magic is irrelevant to the equation.
20th century weaponry has nothing on the 21st.

Tanya.
JDSF greenhorn vs veteran of world war, tactic and magician.
She can diguise herself as innocent lil girl and Allahu Akbar Itami.
The same way she can kill every person in GATE universe, except Ruri, but Tanya can easily kite her or shot from the over 9999 altitude.
No chance Itami no chance.

that's some weird shit

>greenhorn

Let's be honest, wasn't Itami in the special forces or some shit? I mean despise being an otaku he actually has the skills.

You have the greenhorn and veteran switched around there, buddy.

A modern tank isn't going to be penetrated by anything WW1 can throw at it, and mages are basically bait for attack choppers, AA guns, and (depending on how much heat their boots are giving off) SAMs.

exactly, itami is not greenhorn

he has lots opf combat experience and has been through the ranks

tanya is greenhorn
she is an 8 year old edge lord


besides, itami is smart,
so he would run away

Itami's Krew would reck Tanyas blob krew

user, just wondering, you aren't underaged right? The way you write its painful to read, and this is coming from an ESLfag.

>Let's be honest, wasn't Itami in the special forces or some shit?
In how much operations does Itami participates except massmurder of middle ages people?
Zero=0
All he can do is shoot and run.
No real combat experience, his team could not kill the single dragon.
Tanya destroyed 7 bombers solo how can Itami compete?
Tanya knows amunition, weapons of present army she have the power of howitzer in her hands.
No chance Itami, no chance.

The fight was never Itami vs Tanya alone.

Doesn't matter.
In one month this monster creates a battalion of killers, meanwhile Itami hanging out with cute girls.

What if we're talking mage battalion vs an actual modern mechanized infantry battalion?

If the orbs mages use are "modern" maybe, just maybe, mages have superior shielding and can withstand fire from modern AA guns.

>No real combat experience, his team could not kill the single dragon.

>Tanya knows amunition, weapons of present army she have the power of howitzer in her hands.
>salaryman edge fag who is 8 in this world in ww1
>itami, career solider

so, aside from itami, most definatly knowing more about the weapons of the time, and having access to better than an old howitzer

>7 bombers
7 ww1 bombers do not equal a dragon
no maneuverability, or AA weapons basically just big flying targets
Itami is cool and collected. he is an adult
Tanya's body is a reflection of her body, childish and immature

I don't think they would hold against the fire density even one modern SPAAG can provide tbqh family

Being X is on Tanya side. God always wins.

>be japanese
>die
>reincarnate
>become soldier
>invade japan

>God always wins

If God will lose, the universe will be crushed.

>implying

In a fight with only their respective armies, Tanya wins.
But if it's allowed to have a god on a army, Sonzai X would be at JSDF side and it would a massive advantage

Sonzai X would help only Tanya because it' her personal toy. Check and mate.

Sonzai X would kill her Tanya if she doesn't have faith in him again

>godlike magic vs. modern military
Gee, I wonder what'd happen.

Ignore the "her"

Maybe we will see, but this is her trial of the faith anyway.

Well, considering how GATE worked Tanya would join Itami.

Because every fucking single powerful magic being on the fantasy side joined the Japanese.

>guise who would win, a WW1 army with a magic loli, or a modern army with a magic loli, a wizard and an elf?

If you put things on the table, it becomes much more clear. Tanya would get ripped apart by AAA that she can't see, and then her WW1 tier troops would be rolled on by tanks supported by radar artillery and jets dropping laser guided bombs.

Japanese millitary wins because NIPPON STRONK.

Itami has his harem

He wins

>Tanya's body is a reflection of her body
Hurrdurr
>and having access to better than an old howitzer
10000 altitude
>Detection of radio interceptions
>Killing objects when they can't even see you.
>gain the trust of high-ranking officials at age of 8
Tanya is a person who would do anything to win, to live, to became successful.
>Itami is cool and collected. he is an adult
Itami is a image of carefree adult who can't get a promotion.
>WW1 tier troops would be rolled on by tanks supported
How tanks can kill flying people, pls explain.

>WROOM WROOM

I found gate a disappointing show and tanya is a genuine killer who wouldn't, let assassins go because they failed, or willingly go into a suicide mission against a dragon.
So i bet tanya.

nothing can pierce magic.

My dick can.

What about those bombers ripping up mages?

They were average soldiers.
Tanya can hold and explosion.

>an explosion
>singular

Itami is better

You mean the mages who were explicitly so low on mana from fighting other mages that they couldn't produce shields anymore?

Did you forget Tanya went through military training?
She's not a mayor only for being cute.

Wrong, his whole country arsenal is better.

Who want to fight Tanya in 1 vs 1 combat anyway with that magic and shit.
That is like episode 5 all over again.

>Being X
>God

>Being X is on Tanya side. God always wins.

Itami befriend multiple gods and goddesses.