Tell me

Tell me exactly why communism doesn't work.

with love
leftypol.

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
youtube.com/watch?v=rq8y-ejapjE
connexions.org/RedMenace/Docs/RM4-BakuninonMarxRothschild.htm
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Not sustainable in the long run. You will eventually run out of money and resources to take from other people.

first you tell me of a time when it did work

It punishes successfulness and strength in general, this leads to a growing dysgenic effect on the population ultimately degenerating the people in a permanent and genetic fashion.

It requires 100% of the population to be willing to do so and technically requires them to be machine-like. It goes against every aspects of the Human nature, which is rise above the rest for the best and losers stay below. People like to own things and rewards, what communism cannot ever bring.
>inb4 "Property is theft"
It can't be if every families own a parcel of territory and a home, the planet is big enough

Goes against reality to the point that Soviets had to literally deny all of biology and make their own autistic version of it
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism

Are you still up, man? Jesus Christ! Do you smoke meth or something? LMAO

lack of proper incentives

open a history book.
with love
everyone else.

kys commie

Because humans are innately individualistic

People will never hold hands and sing Kumbaya. There will always be some people who'll want to be king, and anybody who dissents to their power is put into a work camp or killed.

Communism will NEVER work because it makes the assinine assumption that humans will forget their nature in a fortnight.

this

Pardon my ignorance but isn't The Ramones?

Friendly reminder to all non-shills that you should report slide & bait threads and threads that are off-topic.

Some examples of off-topic threads:
>Red pill me on X. (with no extra content or input of your own)
>Are X white?
>Is X degeneracy?
>How come X girls love Y guys so much?
>If X is true, then how come Y? Checkmate Z.
>X BTFO.
>How will X ever recover?
>/leftypol/
>(1 post by this ID)

Hasn't history proven that Marx's vision of an egalitarian utopia is unattainable, inevitably creating an Oligarchy more oppressive to the Proletariat than the Bourgeois it vilifies?

>/leftypol/
of course

>>>
> Anonymous (ID: zfLEpRmC) 01/10/18(Wed)19:07:49 No.156260771▶
>
>Pardon my ignorance but isn't The Ramones?
The thread barely started, OP is reading

You're not buying animal medicine yet

It's Nihilism dressed up. It promises a utopia from the ashes of society, so go burn it down like the useful idiot you truly are.

History.
>but muh not real communism

Ok. The fact that pure ideology cannot be directly applied to reality. This is true with any, not just Marxism. Henceforth why when the revolution occurred under Lenin it was slightly modified from what Marx predicted. Mao did the same thing in China, because an urban proletariat uprising was impossible in China given the standard of living of the average Chinese person living on the coast. Mao literally taught peasants to read using propaganda, that's how he floated it. Immediately after he died the party reformed into the economy you see today because Mao was an absolute retard.

Communism can only exist inside of a vacuum because if outside pressure is applied by competing states 9/10 the communists will collapse. Command and collective economies are also absolute shit because they are too lethargic to react to market forces. Either the big cheese complelty fucks up the determination on what to do or the collective can't come to a consensus fast enough.

Thinking that everyone is equal and should have a say in what is going on without any hierarchies is also a stupid idea, which is what Lenin somewhat realized when he created the revolutionary vanguard. Man has always had some kind of hierarchical structure since we were pursuing plains game on foot. It allows the best to take charge in the appropriate situations and allows for an easy delegation of duties.

Because people won't just give up their shit.
Therefore you have to kill them.
Therefore you have to kill anyone who opposes you.
Totalitarian society achieved.

it defies natural law

let his hips do the talking. his gay trap fucking hips.
youtube.com/watch?v=rq8y-ejapjE

Replacing rich cultures with coca-cola and mcdonalds is not nihilism?

No, it hasn't. Elites in communist countries were flawed, but at least they weren't outright trying to replace the people they were leading with foreigners.

People aren't machines, or at least things that fit in nice tidy spaces and always do what they're told. Faggitty ass Marx read about functionalist methods of control and production orientated industries. He's a tard and communism is bases upon broken assumptions that don't translate to reality.
>communism is an outdated theory

If you try to implement gommunism in the Sahara desert you would have an abundance of gulags and a shortage of sand

because you have to kill the smart as well as the rich

>Tell me exactly why communism doesn't work.
It's Jewish.

Jews are inherently anti-White

Therefore, their creation (Communism) is inherently anti-White.

>Replacing rich cultures
With Jewish cultures?

>with coca-cola and mcdonalds is not nihilism?
Capitalism is just as Jewish as Communism is.

>da joos
Marx wrote a fucking book called "on the jewish question"

>nihilism
No one said it isn't you cretin.

So you're a national socialist?
National socialism doesn't work

Dont make me dig up the webm of /leftypol/'s admin choking on a literal Jewish cock. Know your place faggots.

Well making everyone equality will lower quality. And anyone who tries to think or be different is condemned by that group which pushes equality. Look up the Ukraine farmers in Soviet Russia. Stalin’s men rounded them up and shot them because they had more money then the standard Russian “workers”. Then it lead to 6 million people dying of starvation because they put the farmers out of work by killing them. Seize the means of production ey? The success ratio in humans is only like 10% of the population (if that, so if you get rid of that 10% of people the other 90% are out of work or food.
Not only all of that but putting governments in charge of anything will only enforce an ideology of that nations which leads to violence, because anyone that isn’t like that is the enemy. and to say “well that isn’t real communism” is so stupid it’s unreal. It basically means if someone like you was in Stalin’s position you would rush in the utopian dream because you have the right moral judgement upon millions of people without understanding your own capacity for evil.
Start with yourself first, then judge the world, it’s better then getting in a mob with more people as dumb as you hell bent on killing the rich.

>Marx wrote a fucking book called "on the jewish question"
Marx was a Jew.
Trotsky was a Jew.
Lenin was a Jew.
Stalin was fucking a Jew and was surrounded by Jews.
The first Soviet government was Jewish.
Antisemitism was crime punishable by death in the USSR.
The Bolshevik revolution was Jewish.
The Jews were behind Mao's Communist Revolution.
Communism's beliefs are Jewish.

>So you're a national socialist?
Correct.

>National socialism doesn't work
Of course it does. That's why the Jews had to unite the entire world to destroy National Socialism. The Jews vilify it to this day because they're deathly afraid of it.

Because it requires you to sacrifice your success against your own will, and requires this of people who are not communist as well. In essence, it makes everyone equal which benefits those below the average and impedes those above. But here’s the flaw: the average is a measure set on the total production divided by the total number of people. If someone who is ingenious knows he will not get his reward and would instead have to sacrafice his earnings for equality, why would he work? The result is that he does not, nor do any of the other industrious people. This effect of removing competition lowers the average ever lower, impoverishing the population to no end.

All of the above is of course the theoretical application of communism. The real application of communism does the exact opposite of equality: all wealth is redistributed to the state, and therefore to the owners of the state, which are not the people but instead the communist party. The results is that youproduce a microscopic super elite in a sea of miserable poor people. Only an absolute fool who believe Stalin, or any member of the communist party, to be the equal of the average Ivan.
> plus you get no food
0/10 doctrine, worst even than sharia law.

>Marx wrote a fucking book called "on the jewish question"
Baukunin called Marx out on his bullshit too, want to talk about that?

connexions.org/RedMenace/Docs/RM4-BakuninonMarxRothschild.htm

>“Himself a Jew, Marx has around him, in London and France, but especially in Germany, a multitude of more or less clever, intriguing, mobile, speculating Jews, such as Jews are every where: commercial or banking agents, writers, politicians, correspondents for newspapers of all shades, with one foot in the bank, the other in the socialist movement, and with their behinds sitting on the German daily press — they have taken possession of all the newspapers — and you can imagine what kind of sickening literature they produce. Now, this entire Jewish world, which forms a single profiteering sect, a people of blooksuckers, a single gluttonnous parasite, closely and intimately united not only across national borders but across all differences of political opinion — this Jewish world today stands for the most part at the disposal of Marx and at the same time at the disposal of Rothschild. I am certain that Rothschild for his part greatly values the merits of Marx, and that Marx for his part feels instinctive attraction and great respect for Rothschild.

Yes, Consumerism is thinly veilled socialism, with globalist producers ruling over consumers indefinitely. It's Brave New World as opposed to classic 1984 commie bullshit.

>implying the union was left wing in any way

Because people like to own things, those will then lie to have things, which makes them elitary then, which disturbs the oh-so equal system, then someone points said inequality out and gets sent to a gulag, which then makes more people angry, then the commies are too dumb to plant food so the half country starves to death and you shoot some dissidence and at long last you are replaced by a system that can survive without killing eachother.

You're welcome, mate.
But hey, i don't imagine that someone who knows fuck-all about economy or basic human desires that you'd know why communism is shit.

Communism is when you tell the hobo on the streets that if he adopts your system all will be just as wealthy, but to his shock to find out that everyone is as rich as he was, which might fancy him if he's a schadenfreudiges piece of shit.

Now get the fuck out of here, /leftpyol/ enough countries have suffered your self-absorbed bullshit.

google the economic calculation problem

>Consumerism is thinly veilled socialism
Consumerism is the competitor rising to the top and haing such power over the people that they can brainwash them into thinking they need any of their garbage products

Because people like having things

Wasnt the leftypol board owner caught sucking dick? Im sure there was pictures and everything Lel what giant faggots.

Planet is not big enough. Population reduction is needed.

From, the always overlooked environmentalist.

Capitalism rapes earthchan every day

Communism in practice is the people and the economy existing to serve the State.

Capitalism in practice is the people and the state existing to serve the Economy.

National Socialism is the state and the economy existing to serve the People.

Both Communism and Capitalism are materialist and soulless. National Socialism is not.

>Capitalism rapes earthchan every day
Communism rapes/would rape the White race every day.

>replying to threads like this
the absolute state of Sup Forums
sage

>Communism rapes/would rape the White race every day.
Fuck off, idpol.

>the state has never contributed to pollution

baka

>amerimutt
>celebrity worship
of course

Nobody wants to work for free, fag

>Fuck off, idpol.
That's why your ideology is Jewish and anti-White.

Judeo Communism (and Judeo Capitalism for that matter) claims that race has nothing to do with being the basis of civilization and does everything in its power to destroy the White race.

You'd have us all be turned into niggers while the Jews sit behind their walls as our masters.

You're actually posting a picture of your beloved kike overlord oppressing a White person whose desire is to ensure the survival of his race and be separated from the Jews who are destroying his race.

>Judeo Communist
>kike worship
Of course.

>oppressing
I guess the horseshoe theory is real

...

>>oppressing
Yes, you Judeo Communists want nothing more than to oppress the White race into extinction.


>Keeps posting a picture of an anti-White kike

You Judeo Communists keep acting like there's nothing wrong with the Jews but then you freak out when we truthfully link Jews to Communism. One would think you'd embrace the Jewish connection to Communism. But oh wait, then you couldn't shill your Judeo Communism here now, could you?

Next you're going to tell us that we should support the Jews and support Communism because of the evil Holocaust that killed six gajillion Jews.

>Be me, an environmentalist
>Knows capitalism is bad for the earth
>knows people's diets are unsustainable
>Knows the Earth's population needs to be reduced.
>Thinks communism is only good for causing famine and killing millions of people.
>Becomes communist
>Creates communist revolution
>No more freedom of press
>Therefore no way to change production methods
>Society keeps polluting
>My friends get killed off by the government
>Now I'm really hungry
>mfw

...

>wants to send Whites to the gulag for opposing Judeo Communism and fighting for their racial survival.
>Communism totally is pro-White goyim!
Pick one.

im not sure you even understand a thing you're saying let alone everyone else
is this what a brain that runs on coca cola and mcdonalds sounds like?

Jews are actually the ultimate whites. THEY were the ones to first form a covenant with G-d. THEY are the chosen people. It's a Jew world and you're just livin' in it, baby. Why do you think THEY allow no converts? Christians will take any barbarian and look where it's led you.

piss poor attempt at arguing, mostly with fallacies
/thread

What is your percentage of what someone else has worked for?

Not an argument.

>Jews are actually the ultimate whites.
How can Jews be Whites when the Jewish race isn't White?

>THEY were the ones to first form a covenant with G-d.
The Jews of today are not the Judeans/Hebrews of biblical times. Also, God formed a covenant with them.

>THEY are the chosen people.
Then they killed God's only Son and rejected God's message. Christians are God's Chosen People. All Jews go to hell.

>It's a Jew world and you're just livin' in it, baby.
Just because evil controls the world does not mean evil is good.

>Why do you think THEY allow no converts?
Because Jews are supremacist and racist.

>Christians will take any barbarian and look where it's led you.
Jews hate Christianity and Christian beliefs. That's why the Jews are trying to destroy it.

Equality amongst the unequal breeds sedition, as no man wants to be subject to his inferior. Consequently, Communism isn't the correct solution to inequality amongst equals.
This is more pronounced when the organisation of all is decided only by some, as has occurred under most real world attempts at Communism.

According to Marx, the most 'ideal' structure of society (government/economy) reflects the motive power of society, or something like that. We haven't reached the necessary motive power (full automation) for communism to work. Capitalism is the way, for now, maybe for a long while to come.

All of these show woeful ignorance. And yes the Jews are supremicists as they are supreme that's why they don't make missionaries in the armpits of the world like you goys.

Troll
>Troll
Troll

>le leftey pole rade face
t. r/fullcommunism
just give it a rest with this shit

>All of these show woeful ignorance.
Of what? The fact that the Jews are behind everything negative happening to the White race?

>And yes the Jews are supremicists as they are supreme
If they're so supreme why are they so inherently destructive?

>that's why they don't make missionaries in the armpits of the world
Which is funny because the only reason White countries are declining is because of Jewish influence.

>like you goys.
Because Judaism is racial and not for the goyim. Pic related.

Communism is a natural extension of Judaism.

user is trolling you ffs

We've already told you countless times. The answer never changes. Go be cancer somewhere else.

SPLC ON SUICIDE WATCH
>SPLC ON SUICIDE WATCH
SPLC ON SUICIDE WATCH
>SPLC ON SUICIDE WATCH
GET IN HERE FAGGOTS:

Ugh, pol is larping again...

>Jews control the banks
>Jews want Communism

Doiiii god you fucking Goyim are so dumb. You think just because you got a leg up on the blacks that you're the "superior" race LOL

It completely ignores human nature
Which could be eventually circumvented, but you fags act like eugenics is the worst crime against humanity