Spring 2017

...

>in order of enjoyment
Uchouten 2
Natsume 6
Alice to Zouroku
BnHA2
Warau Salesman

Bahamut looks good too, probably going to pick that up.
Plan to watch Saekano in one or two sittings. That's how I watched season 1 and it was pleasant. The threads are shitty anyway so no loss there.

Watching:
Uchouten, Bahamut, Haine, Kado, Starmyu, Rokudenshi, Atom, Sakura Quest, Shoujo Machiavellianism, King's Avatar, Sukasuka, Gin, Re-Creators, Hero Academia, Tiger Mask, Alice, Shingeki, Berserk, Renai Boukun, Banchou Otome


Dropped:
Clockwork, Noise, Eromanga, Sagrada, Hinako Note (great OP and ED though), Yami Zukan (fuck off with alienshit), Zero

There's others I've watched but not sure if I'm continuing later.

>Great
Alice to Zouroku
Busou Shoujo Machiavellianism
Eromanga Sensei
Hinako Note
Nobunaga no Shinobi: Ise Kanegasaki Hen
Sakura Quest
Sin Nanatsu no Taizai
Tsuki ga Kirei

>Good
Clockwork Planet
Frame Arms Girl
Granblue Fantasy
iDOLM@STER Cinderella Girls Gekijou
Renai Boukun
Rokudenashi Majutsu Koushi to Kinki Kyouten
Shuumatsu Nani Shitemasu ka? Isogashii desu ka? Sukutte Moratte Ii desu ka?
Tsugumomo
Twin Angel BREAK

>Meh
Kenka Banchou Otome ~Girl Beats Boys~
Puripuri Chii-chan!
Zero kara Hajimeru Mahou no Sho

>Dropped
Fukumenkei Noise
Sagrada Reset
Sekai no Yami Zukan
Souryo to Majiwaru Shikiyoku no Yoru ni

I haven't checked out ID-0 yet. I also haven't dropped this many series in as long as I can remember, so I can actually say with authority this time: this season sucks.

Some of your greats invalidate your claims.

I saw a thread for episode 3 that died after like 10 posts. It seems nobody is watching the show and the few people that started at episode 1 dropped it after episode 2. Frankly I'm kinda disappointed with it so far. The aesthetic style and tone of the series seems really comfy and well-made, but the pacing of the plot is just boring. I'm gonna stick with it though.

AOTS:
Kings Avatar

God tier:
Seikaisuru Kado
Tsuki ga Kirei
Shingeki no Bahamut - Virgin Soul
Eromanga-sensei

Great tier:
Kabukibu!
Rokudenashi Majutsu Koushi to Akashic Records
Fukumenkei Noise
Sakura Quest

Good thing is that King`s Avatar is 60 episodes long, so its not just this season having good show to watch, but whole year.

Hero Academia is shaping up good, though everything is expected the Deku vs Todo and Stain fights will be pretty exciting.
Shingeki is decently animated and the music is very good again, so that's nice. Nothing exciting and no one knows why the fuck they decided to do 1 cour.
Laughing Salesman remake is hit or miss. When it's good though it's very entertaining and thought provoking.
Boruto is decent nostalgia for early pre Chuunin exams Naruto and I'm enjoying it so far.
Sakura Quest is cute.
Kado is intriguing so far. It could either become a very thought provoking (though poorly animated due to CG) anime, or a complete trainwreck. Should be fun to see which.
We'll see on Vrains, that's all I can say.
Granblue is alright albeit generic
Eromanga is funny but a complete copy paste of Oreimo, so I'm not expecting much more than a couple laughs here and there.
Alice is very entertaining so far, I love the characters so far. One of the top 3 of the season.
Re: Creators is a very attractive concept and so far has nailed the characters down very well. The director is known for hitting the mark about 20% of the time and otherwise causing massive train wrecks, so this will either be a cult classic or a code geass type situation, either way it'll be fun.
Akashic records is entertaining with fun characters and has the uniform of the year. Otherwise generic, but fun.
Hinako Note is decently entertaining but needs to drop some of the fucking quirks, because their repetitiveness is getting annoying and if they keep relying on them so heavily I'll drop it.
Little witch academia is cute as hell, has great lore, excellent music, and some of the most charming characters I've seen in years. I think it has a good shot at AOTY and a solid lead for AOTS with how cour 2 is going so far (only exception being them most recent episode). Either way, and no matter the sales, a very good showing for Trigger and shows they're not just a one hit wonder for TV anime.

Except fall, falls are always good
every other season is a race to the bottom