Instead of repeating timeline only to suffer defeat why didn't Homu evacuate the city...

Instead of repeating timeline only to suffer defeat why didn't Homu evacuate the city? There could have been no casualties and she could have saved Madoka from making a contract with kyuubey.

Kyoko is best meguca.

Think of anything. Homura tried it and failed.

FPBP

That would be very hard for her to convince the other megucas, let alone an entire city. She couldn't even convince Mami to stay back and not fight the witch.

How? How is that possible?

How would a 13 year old girl convince an entire city to evacuate their homes in such a short amount of time?

Do I need to watch movies 1 and 2, or is it ok to skip and go straight to 3? Are 1+2 pure recaps or do they add anything substantial (I consider Evangelion Death a pure recap)

I just never got around to them before.

>he thinks Homu could've evacuated the city as a middle-schooler

Have you seen Hollywood movies? Anything is possible.

Did she try to kidnap madoka and abuse her day and night until her mind broke and she went full Stockholm syndrome?

Sabotage a nuclear reactor so it melts down and risks spreading radiation on the population.

She could stop time and tie up everyone and put them on buses

watch 1 and 2 if you are bored, you don't need them for rebellion

>short amount of time
she can travel back before making her contract, so what's stopping her from traveling years back?

Madoka would have still wished to fix her city after Walpurgis wrecked it anyway.

More importantly: Homura is socially retarded and cannot convince anyone of anything.

She is limited to that month

Is there literally any reason why the megucas couldnt go public?
If you start asking questions like that, the story falls apart.

Her wish was dumb, if she just wished to go back in time to whenever she wanted she wouldn't have to deal with all this bullshit.

I wonder.

1 and 2 are recaps, but some scenes are reanimated to look better. There are some other changes but they are all very minor and don't affect the story at all. I'd suggest watching the OP, though (it's the same in both movies). It's new and Rebellion uses some imagery from it. Also after the equivalent of ep. 10 in movie 2 it shows the TV OP, but this is altered as well. You might find that interesting but it's not too significant. In short you don't need to watch the first two movies but I'd say watch their OP at least.

Maybe there's a kind of filter in which people try to justify what they see via rational means? Everyone thought Walpurgis was just a really powerful thunderstorm, for one.

Why would they want to?

Some probably did.

She wouldn't do that because she actually loves Madoka and wouldn't want her to leave her family and friends. Even at the end of Rebellion she puts Madoka back with her family.

So she didn't try it then.

Why didnt your mom evacuate her womb?

To convince the people to evacuate in this case.
It's not like it would be hard to convince people you're telling the truth considering the things you could show them.

Just because you can prove you're magic doesn't necessarily mean you'll be able to convince like a million people to evacuate a city. Especially given how bad Homura is at convincing anyone of anything.

Because that requires her to think and she is canonically stupid.
she only ever appears to be smart because she has done the same shit over and over.

She could just keep trying until she figures out the right things to say.
Even the retard from Re Zero could resolve a similar situation.

She probably felt her effort was better spent on more direct solutions

Thank you user, you helped a lot.

She can't even figure out how to that with a small group of people, with or without magic

It would be a total waste of time

She repeated time 100 times i am sure if it was that easy it would have been tried.
Every time homu repeated time, she added to madoka's potential destiny ultimately making things potently worse for everyone if she ever failed completely. There was even a scene where she realizes this.

also homu is best girl

Just transform in front of everyone.

The one thing we can draw from the series is that Homura is a socially incapable and doesn't think things through.

That didn't work with Madoka or Sayaka. She's probably not capable of pulling that off, and more importantly, she doesn't think she is, so she'd never try.

It's a good question, what would happen if they tried to show off their powers. You only ever see them do it in front of a normal person if it's someone who has been targeted to become a magical girl. It's possible that normal people would not be able to perceive it properly, like how they can't perceive witches. The only people other than magical girls that can perceive witches are also those targeted to become magical girls.

just realized homura is over 21 mentally with all the repeats. makes it worse she literally cant give up even for a little bit or else. time travel is a bitch.

She can also get Mami and Kyoko to teansform. Anyone would be convinced.

>hey guys I'm a 13 year old girl from the future, there's going to be an enormous storm that's actually a supernatural being and it will kill us all, I politely request that everyone evacuates this major metropolitan area for 24 hours

She can only travel back to the hospital bed, and she can only do it when she's failed to save Madoka.

Proving to the public that magic muskets and rope exist (even if believed) still wouldn't prove the existence of time travel or future sight

The whole idea was to preserve Madoka's way of life
Not to rip her away from it

>Okabe: ??? (primer tier shit)
>Watashi: 5 years (10 semesters, no memory)
>Homura: 8 years
>Bill Murray: 33 years
>Rika: 100 years
>Nagato: 594 years

All Homura has to do is "predict" something that will happen.

In TDS Kamijou learns that Sayaka is a meguca.

I don't think the public knowing about magical girls would matter, at any rate. They could see the girls transform and see their magic and such, but they still can't see witches or QB or anything else having to do with the meguca business. And even if you managed to convince the entire public of megucas' existence, what of it? They've still made their wishes. They still have to hunt witches. They'd just have a media storm on top of that, assuming the media even cared to get on it.

>In TDS Kamijou learns that Sayaka is a meguca.

thank you Seyiku

Now that'd actually make for an interesting anime.

12 episodes of Homura trying to figure out how to evacuate the city without having to show magic to keep her freedom after that.

Mfw I realize that those 594 years were (mostly) the reason of why she ended up erasing Haruhi from everyone memories

She had a lot of good reasons. Remember Someday in the Rain? Yeah, that episode where everyone do their shit while Yuki is left alone and completely ignored, the whole world passing by her. Even Kyon is too focused on Haruhi to notice she put the cardigan on him.

that's like the whole premise of the movie dude

she was getting glitchy from having so many memories stored

Is Madoka a degenerate lesbian like Homura?

>why didn't Homu evacuate the city?
>hello mister mayor, i might look like a teenage girl but actually i'm a time traveling magic user in contact with aliens
>please evacuate Mitakihara because big bad magical being that normal people can't perceive will appear and do bad things
>and she could have saved Madoka from making a contract with kyuubey.
For how long?
Are you suggesting that single WN appearance is the only reason that could make Madoka agree to a contract?

I'm going to be that guy and ask if even Ramiel's Hyper Mega Angel Death Laser could take down Waluigi Night.

No, she's just a normal lesbian.

I feel like the witches are the kind of enemies that transcend normal brute force power boundaries, they're above normal creatures. Then again, so are the angels, so who knows.

Yeah she tried that already. It was pretty hot.

Source please? Couldn't find it through normal methods.

(Maitake) Debikano. It's non-h.

Thanks

...

Incubators are assholes.

depends on your point of view

no bully Coobie...!

...

mami is perfection
precisely because she's far from perfect

...

>spoiler
Come on man, she's not horrible.

she's just a little lonely user

This. Kyubey is only good for BBQB.

Yeah, I remember that episode you're talking about but I think that that It's nothing when you compare with the 594 years she had to repeat the same month

Fire up the grill

Because that wouldn't stop Walpurgis. It'd just move from once place to the next, fucking shit up.

Better to stop it then and there than risk pointless collateral.

Realistically, yes, 600 years of summer would break a person more than anything else you could inflict on them. But the point of the movie was more along the lines of "we neglected Nagato so much she never developed a sense of self" than "loops gave our robot feelings".

How is a teenage girl going to get a city evacuated?

Kyouko is the grill. Kyouko is best grill.

Homura is mentally 21, can she consent?

Didn't read whole thread, but Walpurgis is a witch. Witches are basically just predators, they're mobile and they seek out and affect humans. If all the people moved from the city, the witches would just go with them.

>Walpurgis is a witch
who is she exactly? was that ever covered?

I mean who was she prior to being a witch?

What we can all agree is Kyoko is a necrophilia, isn't it?

>Sayaka is on the bed
What do you want to do next?

It wasn't covered in the anime. There does seem to be a bunch of extra Madoka lore in stuff like spinoff manga and art/production books, but I haven't really looked into it myself. You might find something out if you do.

Don't you think Kyoko tried inserting her soul gem into Sayaka's womb for resurrection or other reasons?

She wouldn't give consent to us mere mortals anyway

Prepare a bath and change of clothes for her so she can get ready for a good night's rest.

Am I the only one who thinks dat Sayaka's arms are funny?

...

...

Is there someone who can make the WebM?

Lol, went back and watched that scene. Never noticed the way her arms are moving

That's fucking hilarious in a morbid kind of way.

It looks fine on mine. Maybe it got fixed for the movies? This clip is from the fancutfags version.

>"I can't take this anymore. I'm just going to fuck her senseless forever."

Why does she look so fucking smug all the time?

Reminder

I got a lot of (You)s!

Thanks!

Did she learn to become a master of robotics, Engineer, propulsion/electronics/laser technology and then extrapolate on those skills to build a power suit?
No. No she fucking didn't.

Pretty sure he meant funny as in haha.