Ask a communist anything

Let's go.

Other urls found in this thread:

marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1931/01/12.htm
myredditnudes.com/
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Why are you using a Capitalist made computer or phone when there are people who don't have either one?

is this thread?

Using the inventions of my enemies to subvert them. ;)

Yes, this thread is fully communist.

>Using the inventions of my enemies to subvert them
Are you Chinese

How does it feel to know that you are one of the useful idiots actual communists refered to?

What is your share of what someone else has worked for?

What are your thoughts on Jews?

Capitalism didn't create the phone. Labor created the phone. There is no ethical consumption under capitalism.

I like to quote Chomsky when he was asked about his life.

"If I gave away my car, I would feel even more guilty. When I go to visit peasants in southern Colombia, they don't want me to give up my car. They want me to help them. Suppose I gave up material things -- my computer, my car and so on -- and went to live on a hill in Montana where I grew my own food. Would that help anyone? No."

Do you think you will be alive after the revolution? 65% of WILLING participants in the Bol revolution were executed by their own 'comrades.' Do you know what a useful idiot is user?

How'd the dreidel spinning go this year, Schlomo?

Bol revolution wasn't communist you dip.

Where is the food you've promised?

What do you do for a living?

Are you a REAL communist? Or just a Stalinist?

There's a huge difference.

mosin is good gun

>Inb4 "REAL communism hasn't been tried yet"

Why does every communist regime ultimately crash and burn? Surely it's not because your ideology is completely fucked and doesn't take basic human nature into account. SURELY the mad ramblings of a 1900's lunatic apply perfectly to the economic situation in 2018.

What's your opinion on concentration camps or mass murder?

No, i'm white

I am the actual communist

Why force others to toil in misery for your own gain?

People like everyone else. Admittedly have a lot of influence in hollywood.

>shill thread

SAGE & IGNORE

How would it not help? Chomsky should be shot for refusing to share.
What is division of Labour? Why don't you make your own Company, and thus seize the means of Production?

When is your mom microwaving your tendies?

>How would it not help? Chomsky should be shot for refusing to share.

? are you retarded. what are you talking about

How can you separete the good from the bad,
the smart from the dumb without a form of hierarchy and authoritarianism?

When will you grow up and get a job?

Communism implements a new party elite to replace the old capitalist elite.

The primary differences are that this new elite is not bound by checks and balances, and that it is criminalized to assert the existence of this new elite.

Following a communist revolution, the people invariably end up with the exact opposite of what they were sold.

The party leadership have been and will be an unchecked totalitarian ruling class.

Explain to me how this is not the case.

Where did you get that statistic from?

Not Jewish

Dumb pollock

Programmer

I'm more of a trotskyist

Whens the last time you got your breadcrumb ration?

According to the communist manafesto, socialism considered the proletariat takeover of bourgeoisie businesses or the government takeover of bourgeoisie businesses?

what do you understand by property?

That wasn't communism. That's why it doesn't seem like communism.

>not jewish
>still a communist

Have fun dying for your kike masters in the gulag, faggot

what is communism?

Can you really say that you have any thoughts when there is no private ownership? How can you own something as a communist? Stop sharing the people's thoughts.

Communism is a stateless, classless, moneyless socialist society.

Making my own company won't make capitalism ethical.

lol

People are different, doesn't mean we can't live together ethically without someone killing or raping someone else.

Lol, communists are the dumbest faggots on earth. Communism, within the basic framework of basic human biology, will never work. It’s literally impossible.

Keep trying to shove your square peg into a round hole.

Go sell your computer and give the Money to poor peasants right now, or get shot. Otherwise you are an enemy of the people

(OP)
According to the communist manafesto, socialism considered the proletariat takeover of bourgeoisie businesses or the government takeover of bourgeoisie businesses?

why are you a delusional tranny who after failing to make anything of themself thru the first 25 years of their life decided to start dressing like a girl and preaching marxism?

No you are not, unless you can provide proof of your wealth. If you can, that means you are actually an evil person.

> (You)
>Why force others to toil in misery for your own gain?

That is not really an answer. The communal system is the basis of communism. All is shared. No one owns anything.

So, one more time.
What is your share of what someone else has worked for?

Actually made me kek, thanks user

Have you read Das Kapital?

These might seem insulting but they're actually legit questions:

How old are you?
Since when are you a communist?
What is your craft?
Do you believe that your intelligence is above average?
Why should a gardener earn as much as his employer?

How can communism be achieved if there is no incentive for the party leadership to surrender power?

Why risk a communist revolution when all previous case studies indicate that totalitarianism and economic inequality will sharply increase, not be eliminated?

Is a system that cannot be implemented fundamentally flawed?

"In the U.S.S.R. anti-semitism is punishable with the utmost severity of the law as a phenomenon deeply hostile to the Soviet system. Under U.S.S.R. law active anti-semites are liable to the death penalty."
marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1931/01/12.htm

>It’s literally impossible.

Nice. Can i get that in writing?

Why am i an evil person chileanon?

People own things, just not the means of production

22
14
Programmer
Probably a bit above average
>earn
>money

If making your own capital isn't ethical, how is stealing my capital ethical? Because it's unfair that you and yours don't already have it? What happens if I refuse to let you steal my capital?

I'm not making a statement I am asking him a question. If he says proletariat and not government, then according to the Communist Manifesto communism is not against capitalism. But if he says government and not proletariat then he's going against the Communist Manifesto.

why are all the communists i know trannies who got bad grades, dropped out of pretty much everything, have a history of drug use, and now consider themselves to be 'successful' people despite having a shitty job, if any, and bitching about how communism is really good

like i don't actually care about the estrogen addict in the OP answering, this is a question to anyone

why do i not know any male or female communists, just trannies?

The only way to make sure people "live ethically" together is to make sure they're all one ethnicity or to brutally enforce peace via totalitarianism.

There is no party leadership. Read Marx my dude.

>Why risk a communist revolution when all previous case studies indicate that totalitarianism and economic inequality will sharply increase, not be eliminated?

They aren't communism. They never tried to be communism.

How’s highschool

Bol revolution wasn't communist you dip.

——————-

Jesus tap-dancing Christ, I can’t believe you’re this stupid.

Go back and retake your Critical Theory course.

how jewish are you?

strasvichen kokjala crasivoya

How come there are so many accidents and everyone is drunk or smoking in russia?

That's because you only talk to trannies.

Because your ideology aims at equity, if you gain from that, that means that you actually don't believe in that, and you are just using it for your own selfish desires.

So, evil.

Nice argument.

Then you will be removed.

No, that's not true

Know any good Communist jokes?

no the 3 trannies i know are commies

why are tranny failures so attracted to communism?

1. How did you embrace Communism as the most effective political system to improve quality of life compared to non-Communist ones?
2. Have you lived in a Communist country without bringing your capitalist wealth? They would gladly accept a Capitalist refugee. Four US servicemen did this during the Korean war. Only one of them had something positive to say - likely because he hasn't been able to escape.
3. Has Communism ever really been tried?

KEK
voluntary help + private ownership = capitalism

RETARD

I'm not making a statement I am asking him a question. If he says proletariat and not government, then according to the Communist Manifesto, communism is not against capitalism. But if he says government and not proletariat, then he's going against the Communist Manifesto.

Ok op, I rarely ever post on this hellhole but you seem genuine in your views so I will learn u something. Capitalism and communism are simply techniques for the distribution of resources. Capitalism relies on the selfishness of individuals and communism relies on the selflessness of individuals in order to fairly distribute and keep track of resources. Both have flaws. However in the future technology will automatically distribute and account for resources. how will it do this? By using the selfishness of consumers such as yourself to program and control society much like capitalism. Really you are just a techno capitalist but lack the vocabulary and understanding to define yourself as such. Also u r a faggot.

Noting to ask. Chinese are Nazies, If you haven't realized by now, you are completely retarded.

Here are you

Do you aknowledge that jews came up with and propogate communism?

SLIDE THREAD. SAGE & IGNORE
SLIDE THREAD. SAGE & IGNORE
SLIDE THREAD. SAGE & IGNORE

Happening here
and here

I've noticed the same thing. I think it's because trannies are so isolated and alone. They turn to communism because it's the one place they can be accepted and not ridiculed. Communism fights for them.

>Then you will be removed.
Sounds ethical

WHY....WONT.....YOU......DIE!!!!!!?!!!?!?!?!!!!!

How do you think communism could be achieved? I mean, you guys got all the way to the dictatorship of the proletariat over and over, but you never made the final step. How do you think that would work?

>VOLUNTARY
KEK

>People own things, just not the means of production

That is not correct. In communism all property is publicly owned. Not just means of production.

So what is your share of what someone else has worked for?

How can a 'real' communist revolution prevent itself from being subverted by the totalitarian elements previously discussed?

The majority of the workers are not and will not be politically motivated.

Previous examples began as 'real' communist movements and were invariably subverted by charismatic individuals.

Given that this has happened without exception, is it realistic to expect this would not happen again? Is this a fundamental flaw? Why can real communism not be implemented without subversion by a party elite?

i think its cuz theyre so delusional that they think shooting themselves full of estrogen will make them a girl

and that very same delusion makes them good commies

Are you a communist economically, ideologically, or both? I believe that economic communism could work somewhat properly if it was ideologically national and not infested with Jews. I think that the USSR fell due to being ideologically torn between Marxism and some form of nationalism while also getting economically sabotaged by the US and economically depleted by the Chernobyl disaster.

> dictatorship of the proletariat
Marx meant the entire class not 3 dudes.

Would you agree that materialism alone, without a backbone of strong transcendent values is useless in creating a functioning society?

Would you agree that anarchism is the true enemy of communism?

Would you agree that political orientations can easily divided into the left-right dichotomy or would you say that since the french revolution politics have gotten more complicated?

Is capitalism a left-wing ideology?

Which is preferable: The nation state or the federation state?

Is a centralised political power structure preferable to decentralised political power structures?

Should communists and fascists unite against capitalism?

Would you agree that communism and capitalism have with united powers smashed fascism?

Would you say that communism and capitalism are two sides of the same, the materialist, coin?

Sure they are user, its not like Marxism is mandatory as study subject in China.

Karl Marx wasn't even a religious Jew. I thought Jews owned the banks. Why would they want communism?

Exploiting other isn't ethical. Removed doesn't mean killed.

That's actually not true. Only the means of production are distributed.

*workers politically educated not motivated

They will be motivated, but not understand economic and political theory in depth. Vulnerable to charismatic individuals.

Like you don't want to fuck this.

>People are different, doesn't mean we can't live together ethically without someone killing or raping someone else.

user i'm gonna make the same question differently: How do you Know what workers are better then the others? And how do you reward them accordingly.

How does it feel to believe in something that has historically always resulted in death, starvation, misery, and failure?

Fair enough.
How would you get to that point then?

Comrade, I hardly see how that is related to the fact that they will never be girls. Sure you can fuck them all you want, but its still homosexual.

Bullshit, in socialism the means of production are owned. In communism, all is publicly owned.

So you have no idea what what the fuck you are talking about.

Please, let's keep up:

Are you specialized in some cutting edge technology like Vue or are you more like a Java type?
Are you earning above average or below average?
Do you believe that everyone in your workplace should earn the same no matter how experienced or good they are at their job?

I don't want to work for your centrally planned government operation.
What are you going to do about it?

Sage

What do you think of niggers?

>Would you agree that anarchism is the true enemy of communism?
Communism is anarchist. The only difference between Anarchists and Communists is how we get to it.

>Would you agree that political orientations can easily divided into the left-right dichotomy or would you say that since the french revolution politics have gotten more complicated?

More complicated. Think about something like Georgism. Henry George being a right wingter and his ideas spouted off as great by both Marx and Milton Friedman.

>Is capitalism a left-wing ideology?
No. It's center left at most. Left wing is socialism.

>Is a centralised political power structure preferable to decentralised political power structures?

No

>Should communists and fascists unite against capitalism?

Yeah but then we send fascists to the gulag after.

>Would you agree that communism and capitalism have with united powers smashed fascism?

Communism hasn't existed.

...

They are rewarded by having their needs provided and not exploited.

Not true.

I wish you wouldn't use that term.

If it's homosexual why dont homos fuck them. Gays aren't interested in trannies.

The working class as a whole has a revolution.

hehe ;) ask me questions Sup Forums i am not some caricature heeeheeehoo being a communist is such an important statement today!