It's out

It's out

Other urls found in this thread:

ddreamzone.wordpress.com/2017/04/22/the-two-ciel-theory-masterpost-kuroshitsuji/
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

...

Why did Sebastian look so surprised when he saw the other Ciel?

you are barking to the wrong tree

Theory around is that Real Ciel was the sacrifice used when Summoning Sebastian, so in theory he should not be alive. Sebastian took his soul

Now we can have Cielcest.

No


Most likely because as he told Ciel he ate his soul

Is this the last arc?

>Ciel means blue
The whole blue star shit was stupidly obvious

>Finny is the only one to notice something is different despite the fact that realCiel doesn't wear an eyepatch
Why are his servants so fucking stupid?

>>Finny is the only one to notice something is different despite the fact that realCiel doesn't wear an eyepatch
>Why are his servants so fucking stupid?
one is literally stupic muscle head and maido is blind

You'd think one of Snake's snakes would be intelligent enough

Endgame right here brothers

they are snakes

It's been a while since I read this, but hasn't it been years since the series started? Why does Ciel still look like a shota? Doesn't he age?

The Ciel you know is an impostor (a twin or a body double), this is the real one, most likely a really convincing undead.

what if Ciel were twins but cause Aristocrats 1 was kept hidden??

Yeah but they're human, right? Why doesn't he age?

he dead bro

Ciel means sky, not blue.

>Hate "there was a twin all along!!11" developments
>Despise mistaken identity drama, and the addition of Curry's personal vendetta isn't helping
>Loathe the predicable general development of Ciel breaking yet again > all is lost > wait no he's stronger than he looks > everything is k... for now


And yet this chapter and the reveal were fucking amazing. How does this manga do it? It has everything I hate in the medium but I fucking love it.

Why is the Viscount th ebest part of this manga?


I agree it has nothing that really interested me yet I enjoy it for some reason

I don't get why it was revealed NOW of all times.

Everything has taken place over around a year so far. And maybe other reasons

Is he going to cuck Ciel and take Sebastian?

Love this smug shit already

No.

>eat soul of sacrifice
>literally comes back and even remembers our Ciel's weak constitution
>as if nothing had happened

Original Ciel is going to drag sebby down with him

Undertaker must be stole real ciel soul during Voyage Arc

...

Currently LAMOing @ your life my dude.

Hopefully not

Because he was dead, and it was implied his soul was the price for summoning Sebastian.

The plot has only been like a year or something.

There's been hints for like 10 years now. I'm not bothered that it's finally been shown.

He's far more likely to cuck Sebastian and take Ciel.

The movie just came out

So theres alot of hype for the series at the moment

can someone dumb this down A LOT for me? is there some twin/doppelganger nonsense, and did the undertaken manage to find the original's body and slip his soul back in?

Impossible, the contract was made to the living one.

tl;dr: There's been subtle hints that Ciel had a twin brother who was the heir for a long time. This ranges from noted inconsistencies in Ciel's behavior (present vs the past, and past vs past), some dialogue, and flashbacks (some of which were assumed to be hallucinations). The Undertaker was really close to their family, and all the zombie/blood transfusion stuff seems to have led up to his reviving the brother or something.

Here's a good master list of all the hints: ddreamzone.wordpress.com/2017/04/22/the-two-ciel-theory-masterpost-kuroshitsuji/

I like these two.

What's even their point in the story?

How likely is Soma x Sieglinde pairing?

Side characters that support the MC in their respective roles as well as expanding the plot and building the world outside of Britain. Having a personal doctor opens up a lot of opportunities such as having medical insight, being able to save other characters and providing more character interaction so we can learn more about them. I think Sullivan and Wolfram are excellent additions to the cast.

So, a healslut?

>No
Yes and now neither will be virgins

Can /ourCiel/ be counted as a virgin if he had his penis touched by a girl?

They need a wacky scientist to match wits with the Undertakers crazy stolen future tech and revival abilities. It was she after all who discovered that the Undertaker was performing blood transfusions.

All healers are sluts so saying "healslut" is unnecessary.

Men can't be sluts

>Men can't be sluts
Oh, my sweet summer child.

Boys and traps can be sluts, but not men.

so lizzy doesn't want to return because she has found out that our ciel is actually not the real one?

So in this scene one of the Great stars calls himself a "Butler" and due his attachment to the Sirius Star which is most likely Ciel, do you think its a fake body version of Sebastion?

Why are there two speech clouds coming from the right door and then unite into one? Someone with personality disorder? Siamese twins?

i have always wanted to see orgy doujins involving shota.

>the inevitable shota twincest doujins

>the inevitable shota twin rape doujins

Or the old butler or even another demon. It would be a good excuse to bring Ciel's father back. I guess undertaker is trying to bring their mom from the dead tho

At least one of them got raped by faceless old men.

Shit finally hits the fan. Next chapter Undertaker removes the mask revealing that he's actually Aizen.

What if new Ciel is actually Vincent?

Saw a distressingly convincing theory that it's Tanaka.

Why would Tanaka suck the real Ciel's dick too? For the same reason Lizzie does?

Because he's very loyal to the Phantomhive family and real Ciel = real heir, apart from just being part of the family in the first place.

Then Lizzie is being brainwashed so she can be the next Rachel.

This is highly unlikely. The new Ciel knows that the ring was cut out of his stomach (the whole candy from the tummy thing). Nobody other than "Ciel" or Sebastian knows about that. Even if it was Vincent's soul, somehow, he wouldn't know about that.

Ring out of stomach is still just a theory, right now.
That said, I'd like to think him being Vincent is unlikely.

Just to be sure, does everyone agree that new Ciel is the one who own the gun that was pointed at Soma?

Not sure. Was he the gunman or the one with the knife? Gunman seems more likely, but the message carved into the wall begs this question.

But fake Ciel is part of the family too.
I mean, I can see it happen.

It's a pretty solid theory though, with the soul record fragment of Sebastian asking about "getting the ring out" and how bloody "Ciel's" arm and the ring is in the flashback (meaning he probably did it himself).

It seems very likely, based on Soma's reaction to him and Ciel afterwards.
For the same reason as above, I doubt he was the knife user - and even as a zombie or whatever I doubt he could take out Agni. He could of just borrowed a knife or ordered the other to do it.
I get the feeling that whatever is going on, Ciel himself is probably not at risk of harm. We know that Undertaker wants to save him from Sebastian, and his brother was very protective of him and likely wants the same. I don't see any evidence for Tanaka being involved, but I could see why he'd get in on it.

Right, but it would make sense for Tanaka not to want to abandon the heir.
I'm not saying the theory is true by any means, but it's surprisingly plausible when everything is put together.

I agree it's solid, I'm just saying it's still only a theory for now.

MC harem expansion
additional shipperbait
the german reich arc wasn't too bad

Do you have any ideas on whom the knife user might be?

For me, new Ciel is the gunman cause when Soma saw him he hit him.
The man with the knife might be a guy from the music hall, in which case if Vincent is the new Ciel then he'd know about the carved message.

Honestly? Nope. I've seen people say it was Elizabeth, but she got her ass whooped by Sebastian. I doubt she could beat Agni, even with him taking a bullet for Soma, as he's someone Sebastian believes would be troublesome to fight. Agni commented on how abnormally strong/fast the knife user was, and he's superhumanly strong himself, and she never displayed that - just crazy sword skills.

>For me, new Ciel is the gunman cause when Soma saw him he hit him.
Probably, it just seems sketchy to me until I know the whole picture.

>in which case if Vincent is the new Ciel then he'd know about the carved message.
If neither the knife user nor Vincent-in-Ciel's-body are real Ciel, how would the message have been carved in the first place?
Vincent being in real Ciel is just plausible enough to worry me, but overall I don't think it will happen.

A new character, likely one of Stars or whatever, presumably a demon or some other supernatural being.

I agree it's unlikely to be her. I don't think it's Bravat, either, although I guess it could be possible. I don't know whether to expect that the knife user is some new faggot or what.

You'd think Souma would recognize his so called friend. Or at least notice that the new guy doesn't wear a fucking eye-patch.

When this became monthly it killed the interest

The hell do you mean no?

This is a monthly manga.

At its current rate we'll all be dead before it's finished if this isn't.

It was always monthly. It's been monthly for over ten years.

user, we know that there is 4 Stars. One of them is (real) Ciel, that leaves three more. Do you really think all of them are characters we already know?

I just want to know why, if he really is "Ciel's" brother, did they go after Agni/Soma? Or where they just unlucky collateral in the wrong place/wrong time? I've seen some people argue that he might be a bit of a wonky yandere due to his undead status, and that even as a kid real!Ciel was apparently get a creepy stare (the thing about fags).

Also, people are claiming "Ciel's" name is probably Astre, since it was the author's second favorite name for the character.

They seem to have been described as quite frail beforehand so there's not really much to go off of. It probably is some literally who, yes, but personally I think it's bad writing to gather a well-known cast together, introduce a character who has been hinted at basically since the beginning, and then alongside all that, drop a completely new rando in the middle of an attack personally directed at the main character.
Of course, Kuroshitsuji has never been known for its good writing, so I'm not disappointed so much as resigned to it. I was just mulling over possibilities.

Try Berserk sometime, then you'll get it.

>since it was the author's second favorite name for the character.
Is there a source on this? I've seen the "Astre" fan name but didn't know there was any actual basis for it.

It'd be pretty easy to slap on a fake eyepatch and just take it off later. The lack of Sebastian should of been more sketchy.

The Official Character Guide, has a initial sketch and a bunch of names of the character.

Nice, thanks.

And a bunch of previously known characters suddenly being revealed to be leaders of some weird cult would be a better writing to you?

Where are people getting the idea it's Vincent? Just from the line about "the Earth" that Undertaker drops?

No. As I said, I was mulling over possibilities. Such an innocuous thing to make you be defensive.

To be fair, the weird star cult thing seems like it was all set up by Undertaker to bring back the Phantomhives, since he's obsessed with them. There's plenty of characters who'd be interested in that.

The desperation of people who hated the 2 Ciel theory.

the Earl*

Yeah I've seen a lot of butthurt over the reveal, despite how relatively fleshed out 2CT has been

Where has Tanaka been these last few chapters? Last I checked he has been in full health. Cold be a body double of Tanaka with some stolen memories.

I'm still freaking out. The theory had been around for over 2 years or so? FUCK YES!

Do you think Soma will try to kill /ourCiel/ or will the misunderstanding be cleared before it?

realCiel and ourCiel will bond and reconcile at the end of this arc, but then Soma will appear and kill realCiel at the last moment.