The cast of Madoka was more enjoyable and better written than Evangelion's. Each had a better build up and pay off than the trio in Eva who are mostly static characters (Shinji stays the same redundant character throughout the whole thing until the very end) While Madoka is much shorter, the characters all had more varied motives and satisfying conclusions. Shinji strangling Asuka with the crucified units is "artsy" but it's not interesting or entertaining.
Anno is mediocre at writing and pretentious at times. (he admitted the symbolism in Eva were just for show. For fucks sake this guy literally named a character Jung Freud) Sure, Urobuchi is also not a perfect writer, his writing is more straightforward and honest. Madoka is not as edgy or artsy as Eva, but it's actually better that way. Yeah, we're not gonna see a cool Third Impact scene, Homura's story is more compelling than Shinji's or Asuka's or Rei's.
In conclusion, Madoka > Evangelion.
Colton Rodriguez
I think Madoka was much darker compared to Eva for its own good.
No way I could care less about the reasoning behind symbolism in Evangelion as long as it makes the imagery.
Accusing anyone of being pretentious is just bad manners at this point.
All in all, opinions.
Blake Ramirez
Sure, ok.
Charles Turner
Madoka is shit therefore I won't read your post
Cooper Long
"Magical girls but this time its edgy" woah....thats deep bro...
Wyatt Phillips
No (You) s for you
Michael Price
>Madoka fanboy reacts to reality
Owen Perry
Anno stated they werent good people
Justin Morgan
I think both are masterpieces, but NGE is better because OP is a faggot.
Nathaniel Fisher
i respect this opinion but it's not a fact
Austin Taylor
The truth is They are both pretentious garbage
Anthony Myers
Madoka was a weak crybaby until last ep. Sayaka was a dumb hoe. Kyoko was a crazy bitch. The only redeeming characters are Mami and Homura. Homura saved this animu from being shit
Logan Williams
Literally Magical Girl Ryuki lacking fun characters like Asakura and Kitaoka.
Ryder Thompson
Shinji was a weak crybaby until last ep. Rei was a dumb hoe. Asuka was a crazy bitch. The only redeeming characters are Misato and Pen Pen. Misato saved this animu from being shit
Ian Ramirez
Youre summoning up the two worst fanbases on Sup Forums into a flamewar. This is really next level shitpoting.
Joseph Clark
>Implying realistically flawed characters isn't a sign of great writing for both shows.
Aiden Russell
"Robots but this time it's edgy"
Ryder Williams
>worst fanbases >Not k-on, claddad, or fate/night fags
Matthew Roberts
Fixed Shinji was a weak crybaby until last ep. Rei was a dumb hoe. Asuka was a crazy bitch. The only redeeming characters are Gendo and Kaworu. Gendo saved this animu from being shit
Brandon Torres
>k-on, claddad I think you mean Kyoanifags.
Charles Baker
I mostly agree. Madoka is more polished overall; Eva is like watching Ano have a slow motion breakdown.
Sebastian Price
>moe being better than anything AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA
>Each had a better build up and pay off than the trio None of them were real characters. You're a fucking retard if your only interpretation of Shinji is 'same redundant character'.
Hudson Butler
basically yea and fate/night/fags
Isaiah Fisher
I also like gundam
Daniel Baker
I thought gundam was about peace through the power of song and friendship.
Easton Taylor
I thought Eva was a show about learning to grow up and how to make friends and real connections with others.
Kevin Miller
No, not really. It's about how abominations will start to make your life miserable if you move in with one or more girls.
Adam Brown
...
Tyler Rivera
And I know there is already a thread going but >the real patrician's choice.
Lucas Wood
Why'd I drop madoka three times because of trash direction/boring pointless scenes? Because it's overrated as fuck
Edgy Brazilians who jerk off to Fate/Zero are the primary fanbase
Jacob Diaz
Why is the directing trash?
Ian Nelson
Madoka is alright. I've seen the show once, as it aired whenever that was. Never watched the movies. I've watched Eva several times, along with the movies. I just find it more compelling.