Godtier:
Animegataris
Great tier:
Chuuni Taisen
Good tier:
Shokugeki no Soma
Osake wa Fuufu ni Natte Kara
Net-juu no Susume
Imouto sae Ireba Ii
Just because
Meh tier:
UQ Holder!
Umaru
Blend-S
Shit tier:
Boku no Kanojo (manga is great, anime is shit)
Everything not listed is watched 1st ep and dropped.
Other urls found in this thread:
Seasons theme:
youtu.be
Meh:
Girls Last Tour
Shit:
Juuni Taisen
Love Live S2
Just Because
Ancient Magus Bride
I think that's all I'm watching
>Meh tier:
>UQ Holder!
I'd have agreed from the first episode, but I really enjoyed the second.
Godtier:
GARO: Vanishing Line
Just Because!
Great tier:
Houseki No Kuni
Net-juu no Susume
Inuyashiki
Good tier:
Juuni Taisen
SideM
Kino No Tabi
Shoujo Shuumatsu
Meh tier:
Urahara
Shit tier:
Ousama Game
Not inclusive of 2nd Seasons
Anything unlisted probably didnt catch my eye and hence wasnt watched
The quality of the anime is ok, but its manga that is meh. Only thing to look forward is cross dressing oppai.
God tier:
Shoujou Shuumatsu
Great TIer
Kino
Okay Tier
2 car
Not even watching anything else, season is pretty terrible.
>gatari
which girl is rararagi focused on this season now?
>Great
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Houseki no Kuni
Mahoutsukai no Yome
>Good
Kino no Tabi
Garo: Vanishing Line
Konohana Kitan
>Okay
Just Because
Two-Car
Chuuni Taisen
>Dropped
Urahara
Ousama Game
Nishio Ishion show of the season is Juni Taisen. Animegatari is Haruhi S3.
>this list
Is watching anime your work? Otherwise i cant see how anyone can force himself to sit through all of those as your picks are the blandest and slowest pace stuff this season, aside Chuuni Taisen
God-tier:
Blend-S
Cute Tier:
Konohana
Anime Gataris
Imouto sae Ireba li
Netojuu
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Osake wa Fuufi ni Natte Kara
Reddit Tier:
Kino no Tabe
Mahoutsukai no Yome
Kujira no Kora
UQ Holder
Boring Tier:
Just Because (but somehow I like it anyway)
2car
Can't tell yet:
Dies Irae
Shit Tier:
Ousama Game
Black Clover
Sengoku Night Blood
Urahara (unfortunately, the concept had potential but it should've been short form)
Infini-T
That's all I've tried.
How do you know that the season is terrible if you're only watching three shows?
Great tier: Net-juu no Susume, Umaru R
Good tier: Juuni Taisen, Black Clover
Shit tier: Dies Irae
Bunny outfits are much better with bare legs. Fight me.
Its not bunny outfit, its Casino outfit.
Can't rate i enjoy them all the same.i'm watching 20 this season
You have to watch everything in order to make a tier list. This is barely even half of what's airing.
What's all this about Juuni Taisen, no one told me it was good
>God Tier
Girls' last tour
>Great Tier
Animegataris
Neet Cake
Blend-S
>Good tier
Drunk wife
Osomatsu
Sunshine
Kino
UMR
Konohana
>Meh
Souma
imouto sae
JUST
>dropped
Die Israel, but that was a show I went blind and it's not its fault I'm way off from the target audience.
Still need to watch boku no kanojo, inuyashiki and 3gatsu but I bet all those are good.
They might be slow but they certainly aren't bland.
>great tier
Osomatsu
Gintama
Shoujo shuumatsu
>good tier
Osake
Kino
Hoozuki
I can't tell if Animegataris is a Samurai Flamenco or not
>cant even read
>Great Tier
Osomatsu-San
>Good Tier
Kino
Shokugeki No Soma
Kekkai Sensen & Beyond
Kujira no Kora wa Sajou ni Utau
Cinderella Girls Gekijou 2nd Season
>Meh tier
Umaru-Chan R
Love Live Sunshine S2
>Shit tier
Inuyashiki
Godtier:
Kujira no Kora wa Sajou ni Utau
Mahou Tsukai no Yome
Great tier:
Juuni Taisen
Konohana Kitan
Good tier:
Love Live Sunshine S2
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Blend S
Netojuu no Susume
Meh tier:
UQ Holder
Just Because!
Black Clover
Shit tier:
Ousama Game
Dies Irae
Watched like 4 shows this season
Great Tier
Garo
Inuyashiki
Okay Tier
Black Clover
Shit Tier
Ousama Game
Can't watch Gintama cause I haven't even finished the second season never watched Soma but heard good things about it. I was gonna watch Die Iraes but got put off by the critical reception
>Umaru better than sad old man anime
Absolutely garbage taste.
We'll know by episode 7.
>everyone is a edgelord for the sake of "realism"
>god-awful CG in every scene
It's shit, mate.
Although it's just a reference episode 2 revealed that humanity has created a space elevator.
I'll probably watch:
Umaru S2
Imouto sae ireba ii
Love Live Sunshine S2
Kino no Tabi
Inuyashiki
Watching but might drop:
Net-juu no Susume
Dies Irae
Not really interested in the rest of what airs this season, which seems kinda shitty overall.
The show is no more about sad old man but about grampinator vs cyber sasuka
What do you think about Urahara? Second episode was even more boring and terrible than first
What happened that you waited this time until everything airs first episode?
Haven't had time to watch everything, just 14 new series. The number to the left of the name is its rating out of 10 in terms of enjoyability to me.
Watching
-Anime Gataris
-Juuni Taisen
-Net-juu no Susume
-Konohana Kitan
-Ousama Game
-Just Because
-Boku no Kanojo Bitch
-Kino no Tabi
-Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
-Inuyashiki
-Garo: Vanishing Line
-Kujira no Kora wa Sajou ni Utau
-Dies Irae
-Blend S
-Imouto sae Ireba Li
Dropped
-Code Realize
-Black Clover
-Robomasters
-Old Mage's bride
-Two Cars
-UQ Holder
Not judging quality by now. Might drop more in the future.
Also dropped Urahara
I have the list ordered from least to most likely to be dropped.
Mahoujin Guru Guru
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Net-juu no Susume
Houseki no Kuni
Himouto! Umaru-chan R
Blend S
Mahoutsukai no Yome
Garo: Vanishing Line
Animegataris
Kino no Tabi
Just Because!
Konohana Kitan
Kujira no Kora wa Sajou ni Utau
Urahara
It's a show with creativity and imagination as a theme that's repeating itself on episode 2.
You know what always puzzles me in these threads? When it was extremely early in the season, you had a lot of sequels, now, not so much. And no, its not that people are caring more about the new shows now, that wouldn't explain why many sequels vanished from these posts as we got deeper in the season.
I take more active users have participated in these threads earlier and are already tired of repeating their opinions, but is the average watcher here really this much of a newfag to not have watched shit that aired between 2012-2015? Its even more jarring by contrast when its people who watch basically the entire season.
>Kino no Tabi
>only 5 from the bottom
It can't just be good, it needs to be as good as the original. I doubt I will drop it but it has a lot to live up to.
The original was not that good.
Is there anything worth watching? Last time I actually checked Fall season was months ago, and I already declared it to be the worst season yet.
The only things I'm watching is
>Blend S
>Umaru S2
>LL S2
>YuYuYu S2 at ep07
Blend S is currently the best since anything with a narrative needs more time to setup where it is going.
Top Spot:
Blend S
Good shit:
American Garo
HnK
Kek eyes
Mahoutsuaki
Pure Kino
Osomatsu 2-san
Netojuu
Okay shit:
Dies Irae
Imouto
Juuni
Konohana
Kujira
Shuumatsu
UQ
Washio Sumi no Recap for half the season
God tier:
>Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Great tier:
>Kino no Tabi
>Umaru
Good tier:
>Net-juu no Susume
Meh tier:
>Blend S
>Houseki no Kuni
>Shit tier:
Imouto sae Ireba Ii
>ctrl+f
>hoozuki
>only one result
I didn't know Sup Forums's taste had gotten this bad. What the fuck, guys?
Explan yourselves.
Also dropped that gem girls anime
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou was way better than I was expecting, I would give that a watch.
I am only watching animegataris so far.
Is there even anything else worth watching?
Watchable:
Mahoutsukai no Yome
Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
I can read and I'm saying it doesn't work.
If you don't mind CG, gem people. Konohana is nice, but might be too slow for your taste. I take you don't like Osomatsu or Hoozuki already. Kino is not as good as the 2000s series, but is not bad either. Also, drop walmart madoka.
I doubt most of the people here were around in early 2014
Good tier
Net-juu no Susume
Kino
Hoozuki no Reitetsu
Inuyashiki
Ok tier
Konohana
Love Live
Drop tier
Umaru
Food the animation
Godtier:
Shoujo Shuumatsu.
Kekkai Sensen.
Hoozuki no Reitetsu.
Great tier:
Chunni Taisen.
Blend S.
Inuyashiki.
3 Gatsu S2.
Good tier.
Food Wars.
Osomatsu.
Mahou no Yome.
Kino.
Konohana Kitan.
JUST because.
Imouto Sae Ireba li.
Meh tier:
Net Juu.
Boku no Kanojo.
Umaru.
IM@S Side M.
Yuuki Yuuna.
Shit tier:
Ousama Game.
LL S2.
Urahara.
My ears tier:
Black Clover.
Even Horriblesubs hate it. They don't even bother to proof-read their shit encodes. Half the subs are in the middle of the fucking screen.
Also, what the fuck is with the subs of a lot of series this season? I'm seeing way too many TL notes and hardsubbed signs in various anime. Didn't we move past this in like 2012?
>>My ears tier:
I don't get it.
The main character screams all of his lines.
>God tier
None
>Great Tier
Inuyashiki
Mahoutsukai no Yome
>Good Tier
Juuni Taisen
Anime-Gataris
Net-juu no Susume
>Meh Tier
Imouto sae Ireba Ii
Blend S
>Shit Tier
Ousama Game
Boku no Kanojo ga Majime Sugiru Shojo Bitch na Ken
Black Clover
Dies Irae
OP here, i watch Ballroom no Yokoso, but generally dont list sequels since the thread is mostly for seasonal shows.
This. If you rewatch the old series, the episodes were basically equivalent to the new one. You'd get a relatively short introduction, followed by relatively short world-building, and relatively short climax, with the resolution taking up a good 25% of the time toward the end, which is how the new one is being written.
I feel like most of the charm of the old series was atmospheric, though, which the new Kino no Tabi doesn't do as well. Ironically, Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryouko does the post-apocalyptic atmosphere way better, although the writing is a lot closer to Yuyushiki than it is to Kino no Tabi.
>AOTS Candidates
Kujira
Houseki
MahoYome
>Great, can become AOTS down the line
Kekkai Sensen Beyond
3Gatsu S2
Imouto Sae
Girl's Last Tour
Kino
>Good fun
Osomatsu
Inuyashiki
Juuni Taisen
Osake wa Fuufu
Blend S
Umaru R
>Meh
Just Because
Dies Irae
YuYuYu
>Dropped
Ousama Game
Konohana Kitan
Black Clover
Bitch
UQ Holder
Oh, right.
I like the gem sluts and Blend S.
I don't think you're using the word "even" correctly. Clearly HS have terrible taste. That doesn't mean that other people who aren't watching it have actually tried to watch it, though.
Blend S is more like Bland S. Like majority of MTK stuff just unfunny.
Gem sluts is too 3DCG for me, also looks ok.
God tier :
Shoujo shuumatsu
Great tier :
Konohana kitan
Yuuki yuuna s2
Fun tier :
Umaru
Souma
UQ holder
Shit tier :
Bland S
Just because
Shobitch (I like the manga, but the anime is meh)
Imouto bla bla bla
Not cute enough. Too much sausage, not enough moe.
>Shobitch (I like the manga, but the anime is meh)
Litterally worse adaptation thatn Jitsu wa Watashi wa, at least Jitsu Wa maintained the humor and main gimmics of original. Meanwhile Shobitch failed to deliver every single joke and set accents right - its not fun, its not erotic, it tries to me Mysterious Girlfriend X instead of Aho Girl
Are you even watching it?
>it tries to be Mysterious Girlfriend X
I just watched the first episode and this is the exact reaction I got, a dumbed down Nazo no Kanojo. But if you say the manga is more like aho girl (???) then I'm just going to keep watching the anime.
>zzz Kitan great
>Walmart Madoka great
Yurifags are too predictable
>it tries to me Mysterious Girlfriend X
I'm not even invested into the show or manga, but that is a low blow. This isn't anywhere close to being as bad as Nazo no Kanojo X. At least the MC in this show isn't a massive pussy and the girlfriend actually wants to put out for him.
>Rate This Season so far
Pretty gud, I'd say? There are a lot of varieties to satisfy a wide range of people. You can't ask for more for this sorts of hobby.
so literally the only animu you turds kind of agree on is Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou. I guess I'm watching that one and ignoring everything else.
The whole point of manga is idiots delivering misunderstood erotic punchlines. There is no drama or story per se, its just gags and generally setup in format better suited for anime shorts.
The heroine is also not a misunderstood innocent girl, but genuine slut interested in sex because is raised like and gets all her knowledge from even bigger slut - her mother.
>all these retards shitting on an adaptation of a kamige
I know there someone says that every season but there is honestly much less shows I'm enjoying this season compared to last ones. Only show I'm enjoying is Imouto Sae Ireba Li and I usually watch at least 4 shows each season. Honestly a pretty boring fall season.
Don't listen to them, Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou is just the new Coppelion
>GARO: Vanishing Line
>Just Because!
Lol. Enjoy your production disasters.
I'm taking it slower this season, will watch other things and work on my backlog, while I wait for more episodes to air before starting with most of the shows. But for now:
Great:
>Konohana Kitan
>Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
>Mahoujin GuruGuru.
Any VN adaptation, no exceptions is by default shit. But Dies Irae is double shit.
Many of the continuations are also very good (Kekkai Sensen, Shokugeki no Souma, Hoozuki no Reitetsu, Fate Apocrypha), and there is potential for a few of the other new anime to get better as they go on (lots of people really like Mahoutsukai no Yome), but Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryoukou is the only new anime with broad appeal to western audiences which it's obvious, right now, that we will still be praising in 10 or 20 years.
Only because there's nothing to hate yet.
Nothing happened so far, there was nothing to even animate and it was easy to watch.
Pretty sure it will get boring fast and not even the post apocalyptic setting will make it interesting.
Enthusiastic for:
robodad
magic nazis
zodiac killers
Entertaining enough:
elite neet
ln authors
gems
maid cafe
drunk wife
Considering dropping:
gimmick countries
cheap chinese garbage
misunderstandings royale
Dropped:
2car
girl's last drool
lesbocats
dogmage
how2slut
anime club
AAAAAAAAAA
just
With the holdovers from last season (guru and badfate) I'm satisfied overall.
Absolutely not. With Coppelion, it was obvious from the start that it would be shit. You can't have a good post-apocalyptic atmospheric anime when your characters are LITERALLY ordinary high school girls wearing their school uniforms and who have no originality to their character writing - they were all just standard JK tropes.
>praising in 10 or 20 years.
I am sorry, but it is the type that will be forgotten in 1.5 weeks.
What are these two anyway? I don't remember them in first season
Coppelion, unlike this, actually had a story which wasnt half bad and was very fit to be what people expected from it - true to spirit STALKER anime.
It bombed, but it wasnt a horrible show.
I don't know man, I was very pleased with the source material, unless the adaptation fucks up badly, I'm up for this ride until the end.
>it's obvious, right now, that we will still be praising in 10 or 20 years.
Truly the psycho pass of our generation.
Not really. Mahou Tsukai no Yome and Kekkles Sensen have much more Western appeal than SSR. It will probably get the same treatment as Sora No Woto, that is, shows that only Sup Forums remember.
>Nothing happened so far, there was nothing to even animate and it was easy to watch.
>
>Pretty sure it will get boring fast and not even the post apocalyptic setting will make it interesting.
Nothing will happen. This will be the Yuyushiki of kino.
You seriously think SSR has original character writing? Both girls are stereotypical moeblobs that look like they're taken straight out of CGDCT shows. Come on now, either you're a real idiot or a reverse troll. Stop messing around and leave the comfy thread alone.
>SSR
>Western appeal
I fucking love it but I don't think there's much going for it that way, user.
But the west loves potatos way more than rice.
AOTS contestants:
Kekkai Sensen & Beyond
Garo: Vanishing Line
Osomatsu-san
Shuumatsu Ryoko
Mahoutsukai no Yome
Good fun, might be AOTS contestants:
Juuni Taisen
Houseki no Kuni
Souma
Sorry bud, these are non-newtonian potatoes. The western world only love potatoes with adherence to classical physics.
>they ate irradiated fish
>they ded
Didn't know it's a two-episodes OVA.