Which one was the most powerful?

Which one was the most powerful?

me

Madoka obviously.

>Most powerful
Mami

>Most potential
Sayaka

>Most tough
Kyouko

>Most resourceful
Homura

>All-around mix
Madoka

...

Sayaka

shouldn’t mami and madoka be switched?

Madoka, but because of homura

>Madoka
Manages the Universe

>Homura
Manages the Universe AND Madoka

/thread

>>Most potential
>Sayaka
What?

Someone post the chart.

In a sudden Battle Royale situation, Homura would instakill all of them in an instant (from their perspective), unless Madoka got the Homura time loop buffs.

>>Most potential
>Sayaka
you wish

>>Most potential
>Sayaka
She's literally the weakest of them all. Also endgame Madoka is canonically the most powerful, there's no comparison. Are you on drugs?

Just a meme, sayaka potential is shit and barely at kyoko homura level even going full suicidal.

Not counting Madokami, shouldn't it be Homura?
She can stop time for as long as she wants, create time loops, and has the mahou shoujo equivalent of Gate of Babylon.

ED accurately depicts their power levels (Sayaka < Kyoko < Mami < Homura < Madoka surpassing them all). It's literally been known for 7 years now and people still debate it?

You can tell their potential/karmic weight by how interested Kyubey was in recruiting them.
>Madoka
QB wants to recruit her in all time lines, even the very first one, before Homura artificially boosted her through the time loops. Implies she had good potential from the very beginning.
>Kyoko
Approached by QB at a young age, implying interest from his side. Managed to sruvive on her own despite losing her illusion powers after her family died. Her fight with Sayaka showed her to be physically much stronger.
>Mami
Approached her during a car accident, which seems more like opportunism than genuine interest. Survived for years on her own and managed to munchkin a fairly weak power. Probably the best one in a fight, but that's more due to skill than power.
>Sayaka
Doesn't get recruited in all time lines and used as a disposable tool by QB, implying low interest. Shown to be weaker than Kyoko and explicitely stated to have lower potential than her.
>Homura
Spends the entire first timeline hanging out with Mami and Madoka, but QB doesn't recruit her. Has low physical abilities for a MG and low damage output, forcing her to rely on conventional weapons. Time stopping is a deadly ability, but like Mami she relies more on skill than raw power.

Didn't Mami straight up beat Homura in Rebellion? I thought the idea was that Mami was the most capable Magical Girl outside of Godoka.

She outwitted her with what can only be described as an ass pull. Otherwise, Homura had her dead to rights.

Mami's ability is just all around bullshit. The PSP game notes that she can't guns with more complex mechanism than Muskets, but here we have her remote controlling a perfect clone that could even fool Homura.

To be fair, most Japs don't have a very good grasp of how guns work anyway. The problem is that Mami's ability came out of nowhere, and was at no point alluded to or demonstrated before then, despite there having been plenty of opportunities to do so.

Only acceptable explanation would be that it represents Homura's increasing self doubt, since Mami was one of the only characters in the labrynth to not be wholly connected with an actual MG in the real world.

>Devil Homura
>Godoka
>Episode 12 Madoka
>Episode 12/Wraith Arc Homura
>Regular Homura (if her opponent doesn't know about timestop)
>Mami
>Kyouko
>Regular Madoka
>Sayaka
>Regular Homura (if her opponent knows about timestop)

> She can stop time for as long as she wants
there is a sand clock inside her shield. she turns that up every time she rotates her shield. her timestop lasts until the last drop of sand falls down.
> and has the mahou shoujo equivalent of Gate of Babylon
not really, since unlike Gilgamesh she can't just shoot those weapons outside portals.

Just because you know about timestop, does not mean you can actually prevent it.

>Regular Homura (if her opponent knows about timestop)
Homura kept up with Mami just fine, while fighting in stopped-time. she'd trash Sayaka and most likely put up a good fight against either one of Madoka and Kyouko,

You just made up Sayaka for the obligation of including all of them.

akuma homura is probably even with madokami. They did the same amount of world altering with their magic. theres nothing to say that shes stronger. I dont even think there could be a fight between them anymore, their abilities are too vague and im pretty sure madoka and homura are just laws of the universe at this point, given physical form

>arguing about powerlevels in fucking Madoka
That's the most stupid thing ever.

Homura through out, then Madoka at the end

Their fight circumstances weren't neutral, she got a preemptive strike that took away Homura's trump card. Can't really compare strengths if you beat someone with a handicap.

Baseline Homura's greatest strength is that she already knows what's going to happen because she's gone through that month countless times. Take her out of that month and her overall weakness begins to show. Take away the repititions and Mami has been fighting for longer than Homura,; and even Sayaka, who witched out after only a week or two, still has more combat applications for her magic than Homura does on account of actually having weapons as part of her magic.

She may have kept up with Mami, but she still got outplayed in the end. And not a minute later when she tried to timestop against Sayaka, Sayaka straight shut her down before she could blink. Maybe it's not fair to compare post-LoC Sayaka to base Sayaka, but the fact remains that both times she fought someone who knew about timestop, she could only at best force a stalemate.

I'm a huge Homurafag, but all evidence points to Homura being useless in a fight if you know how her magic works. It's not her fault, it's just the nature of her time magic- It's amazing in the very linear purpose for which it was meant, and completely useless outside of that.

>Sayaka straight shut her down before she could blink
Only to get immediately counter-countered.
>all evidence points to Homura being useless in a fight if you know how her magic works
See

Technically, homura lost none of those fights since they all were just against an avatar of herself in the witch barrier.
She even destroyed her avatar's fake soulgem and didn't die.

There was only a part of homura in that fight and she wouldn't have died if she had been killed.

I think madokami is stronger as at the end of the movie, Homura couldn't do shit if Madoka was to force a re-ascension into godhood and had to rely on guilt and mindrape to calm her down.

>still has more combat applications for her magic than Homura does on account of actually having weapons as part of her magic.
Homura stacked up a whole plethora of weaposn, so it's a null argument