The people saying that BH is better than 2003 just watched BH only

2003 is superior
>Feels
>Realisations
>Creativity
>OST


FMAB is good but muh shonen
And even if the 2003 ending isn't all that good and feels rushed, bh doesn't shine that much more with the shonen end

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=uwzAEwzUI8k
youtube.com/watch?v=2vtr8sAuI_I
youtube.com/watch?v=4tEj6gXA_eA
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Brotherhood

2003

...

Brotherhood

2003

(Not talking about the quality but the place)
Dante's theater is more poetic and meaningful

You have a bigger one?

...

The only thing that really fucked up 2003 was Mecha-Archer and the Nazi bullshit. Brotherhood's ending isn't much better, though.

youtube.com/watch?v=uwzAEwzUI8k
youtube.com/watch?v=2vtr8sAuI_I

I think most people will agree the movie is garbage.

Yes it is.
I tell people not to watch it. Shamballa is such a letdown.

brotherhood Kimblee >2k3 Kimblee through

I really enjoyed the atmosphere of 03 climax.

>Mecha-Archer
Was awesome aside from the mouth gun.

Even homonculi are better in 2003
They have a goal of their own : they want to gain humanity. In BH they just follow father like good pups.
And I love their origin way more, Lust's past with scar is good too. A shame mustang kills her so fast in BH.

>follow Father like good pups
Yeah you mean like Greed?
>goal of their own
Gluttony, Pride!Bradley, and arguably shota Wrath didn't have any goals.

And Wrath Bradley is a way better character and more fleshed out than "I want to be human" or "I'm going to kill you to prove I'm me."
Bradley at least tried making sense of his awful fucked up existence. Then again expecting women characters to be well written in shonen is my fault.

Dante was a good antagonist that had too little screentime.

The fact that nobody answers is just proof that the pleb who watched BH didn't bother with 2003 and are just saying that the version they watched is superior. (That and the retards repeating that if it follows the manga then it's good)

>even if the 2003 ending isn't all that good
It was awful, Robo-Archer and the entire concept of a 2nd world was pants-on-head retarded.

This so much

>One ridiculous scene and a last-minute, shitty explanation make it awful

The 2nd world concept is pants-on-head retarded, but it's silly to call the rest of it awful because of that.

I hate to admit it but OP is right

Things that BroHo have over 2003:
>Stronger story focus
>More consistent world logic
>Better world building
Things that 2003 have over BroHo:
>Majority of villains have more depth than BroHo’s
>Character focus is more streamlined
>Better visuals and OST
>The first half is WAAAAAYYYYY better than BroHo’s

I’ve always preferred the way 2003 looks in comparison to BrotherHood.

Add to 03:
>Better soundtrack
>Stronger thematic emphasis
>Better direction
>More detailed and consistent character designs and animation
>Less tone-shattering “humor”

Manga> when it adapts the manga>Brotherhood>03 when it does its own shit

This exactly
The humor and Mai Chang are way too much in BH

Both are fucking fantastic tracks. Love 03's soundtrack, so memorable.

I love the 2003 series, but it had a very rushed final arc and an underwhelming movie sequel to end it, while Brotherhood wrapped everything up well in the episodes it had and ended in a satisfying way.

I'll never understand why people think the concept of a parallel world in 2003 is ridiculous while the manga and Brotherhood having a villain who's essentially an evil genie of the lamp from Ancient Persia who wants to pull God out of the sky and take his place is not ridiculous at all.

Everytime I see her face I hear that song.
youtube.com/watch?v=4tEj6gXA_eA

Same. Arakawa's artstyle looks alright in black and why with thin lines and the energy of line art, but when adapted to an anime everyone just looks fat and blocky.

Patrician taste

I hear this one.

youtube.com/watch?v=2vtr8sAuI_I

Fuck, this song always gave me chills when it played in the anime.

Another example.

You Know I Had to Do It to Em.

I think Brotherhood is overrated shit, but the 2003 anime was utter garbage as soon as it deviated form it's source material. Who ever was writing it tired way too hard to be 2deepforu and edgy. It was honestly hilarious.

Because one is in muh manga and the other is not.

the big difference between brotherhood and 03 for me are supporting characters

In 03, Winry and Mustang do literally nothing for the entire story; Mustang's fight against Bradley is completely nonsensical, given that he knows beforehand that he cannot win thankfully deus ex machina solves everything
Scheriske is a major side character who does nothing along with Winry

In Brotherhood, all of these people are fleshed out, minus bookworm who never appears again.

It's fun to watch both though

I disagree...
2003 has little supporting characters cause they had to create their own ending out of nothing

On BH you have tons of supporting characters that are annoying and not helping the story : the 4 chimeras, kimblee's men etc
Arakawa was too afraid to kill her characters everyone is fine mustang recovers his sight, havic walks again long yao lost greed just like that

Ye sure mustang won in 03 but at least he lost an eye...
Bh is too much of a goofy happy ending

I agree.

Poor Sheska got forgotten, I never understood why.

I saw 2003 first and Brotherhood was better. 2003 was better put together up until it diverged from the manga.

FMAB is the best shonen
FMA 2003 is a good seinen