New WSJ manga evaluation

BOZEBEATS - Axed shit
Act-Age - Good survivor
Jujutsu Kaisen - Axed shit
Noah's Notes - Good survivor
Ziga - Axed shit

Final Verdict
Act-Age=Noah's Notes>Jujutsu Kaisen>BOZEBEATS=Ziga

Attached: wsj.png (689x669, 960K)

A shame that probably no one wil translate actage, its my favorite new jump manga since a while

Is boze not doing well? That's sad, fucking shit tasted japanese

Last week it was last place in the TOC and the weeks before it was also at the bottom. It's garbage, you need to get some tastes first.

Is Ziga 1 raw/korean scans already out?

Yes

Still surprised nobody picked Act-tage for scanlation

Maybe they're waiting to see how it does in the next weeks. From what I've seen the online reception in Japan has been very positive so it's going to survive. I hope scanlators don't ignore it. I read the first 3 chapters from VIZ on kissmanga but I want more.

All of them are crap. Bring back Numa Shun

Noah's Notes will require the masses to understand the appeal of gyarus.

It's gonna get cancelled

I thought we were living in the age of gyarus user?

My opinion of all of them

>BOZEBEATS
Had best first chapter of these new titles, then suddenly went to shit too fast. It already is giving cancellation vibes in its last chapters. Expect it ending in chapter 14-15

>ACT-TAGE
Started ok and interesting, still less interesting than current Jump lineup. Is going ok for now, but I think it will be axed in spectrum of chapters 35-60

>JUJUTSU KAISEN
Worst title so far for me. I don't see any future for it. Still, my opinion, maybe it survives. For the moment I'll say it will be axed after 2 volumes

>NOAH'S NOTES
Again, too soon to predict anything, but I would see is the most solid so far. Chapter 1 was solid, and chapter 2 was solid again. I think it won't be axed, and I even predict it will enter in Dr.Stone and WNL tier. What I want to see most is if Viz adds it to its lineup (I already saw tweets of Viz saying people saying NN was good to write it in their polls if they want to see NN in Viz)

>ZIGA
Was bland, but better than Jujutsu for me. I think it will be also axed after 2 or even 3 volumes, but at the same time I see it more potential than Jujutsu, Bozebeats or even Act-tage (again, I thought Bozebeats had potential but is going to die soon)

Gyaru manga are doing really well lately though?

I like Act Age the most, definitely going to live.
Noah's notes has potential but chapter 2 feels like it is trying to be the next Dr Stone instead of it's own thing, the MC smug smirk is also kind of annoying.

Ziga chapter one is pretty cliche but I will give it few more chapters to see how things develop.

Noah and Act-age had better first chapters than BOZE

Attached: 1521218733703.jpg (898x1313, 348K)

all axed

>BOZEBEATS
I didn't find it too interesting, and not very memorable.

>Act-age
Seems promising, although the protag doesn't feel very relatable.

>Noah's Notes
Not bad so far, I like that the protag is the spunky gyaru instead, normally she'd be the catalyst of some boring MC's life.

>Jujustu Kaisen
I like the art for this a lot, otherwise the premise is a little meh so far.

>Ziga
Don't know what it's about yet.

I might have to read this now, no pan for the win.

>although the protag doesn't feel very relatable
She isn't meant to be.

I don't know why every protag has to be relatable

So I'm not the only one that likes the art for Jujutsu, it's a shame the story is so lame

This

No, they need to keep something otherwise the magazine is in trouble.

Didn't Jujutsu Kaisen just come out? I have hopes for it being Japanese Ghostbusters.

so what if it did just come out? the story is meh and the art probably isn't enough to save it

So is it garbage because you read it and that's your opinion or due to low ranking because you are retarded Sup Forumstard?

did I say i don't read it, you idiot? the manga is garbage

Wtf cant i just have my nice enjoyable battle shounens?
Aside from Boze and Jujutsu there are no battle shounens. Just give me another Toriko. Cant be so fucking hard.

A good chunk of Toriko felt like an adventure rather than a battle manga.

there are other battle shounens in other magazines, you just need to search them

Noah's Notes in an eyecatcher at least. Ziga has like no character whatsoever.

Needs more gag manga desu

t. Miura

NNT, Fire Fighter, Jagaaaaan...and thats it iirc, at least for the weekly ones. Are there more?

Actage will survive. It can attract both salarymen and young girls.

memesis

>the only gag manga are a dying Gintama and the tomato poodle series
These are dire times we live in

Attached: 1445227433486.jpg (640x480, 56K)

Ah that one too, nice thing with the hero going after woman and the two sidechars being the MCs. Artstyle is dope as well.

Are there no other weekly ones?

Marry Grave and Soukyuu no Ariadne if you are going to mention Sunday.

They are new ones i didnt hear off. Thanks.

Gag manga are shit anyways

Are this two weekly battle shounens?

Yes but they're my kind of shit

Attached: 1488731431942.jpg (1024x748, 201K)

yes, I checked, this is the first time I heard of them

Actage dont get axed aahh

Couldn't have said it better myself. Hopefully they'll replace one of those 3 series with Numa Shun

why did it have to be in wsj?

Fame and money?

if you dont get axed

Tomato poodle is pretty good honestly.

Attached: fug.png (389x244, 104K)

>the protag doesn't feel very relatable.
If you want self-insert, maybe seek isekai trash.

Can s.o please translate Act Age already?

Reading raw and feel excited make my heart ache so much!!!

Attached: imageee.jpg (1315x1920, 641K)

sad this will never get translated

I love history now.

Can't wait to next episode of Noah's Notes

>episode

ziga was disappointing

All axd

C-CUTE

>a fucking meme dog gets more laid than you
fuck

>all these manga with great ideas and art getting canned
>random trash gets lucky and publishes 300+ chapters

i usually see a clear pattern but i literally cannot grasp one here.

it seems totally random how things get popular in japan.

what are the manga with great ideas that got canned and what is the trash that has 300 chapters? im curious

Picked up

I agree with your evaluation. I really hope Act-age starts doing well.

Nisekoi

This is strictly a Jump problem. If these were published in Shounen Sunday they'll have a decent run

Tomatoy is very cute indeed.

Attached: imagee.jpg (1315x1920, 440K)

Execution > Concept

cute prostate

I want to finger the prostate

Fuck that manga.

I'd just eat him up. As a tomato.

>Bozebeats
>Axed
Nah. Jump never axes manga with a cute mc

It's already axed you delusional shotacon.

what is bozebeats about?

dont matter since its axed

Noah's Notes will be axed when people get tired of fapping to Gyaru in 50 chapters or so

can any mangaka make even a slightly original or recognizable art style

Numa Shun.

whats the one that sounded a bit like bakuman
that seemed interesting

lmao dude a wolf kid in a city doing exorcism shit and muh edge

Maybe it might get added to the English weekly jump?

implying people will ever get tire to fapping to such a fine gyaru

Weekly Shounen Hachi? Not entirely sure what you mean, it's not even in WSJ

It's like Kimetsu but Inosuke is the MC and is 100 years in the future.

this one?
shoukan shounen hachi
budding mangaka goes to school for mangakas?

>axed this
>axed that
you guys jump the gun too fast with these new series

Maybe because they're all fucking trash from the first chapter

>Inosuke is the MC
Is that the boar guy? He's cool, but I guess some shit in comparison (setting or plot) are not as good.

why is this generation of jump so shit?
all the big dogs are dying/dead and there's nothing even close to being good enough to replace them

maybe that's just your opinion?

Isn't it agreed that the big dogs are just as bad? Rarely do I see or hear how good they are.

Nope

if you compare them to the new series coming out they're masterpieces

Figures the one I like is the one most likely to get axed.

not when the nips agree and they get axed in 2-3 volumes faggot, if a manga has a shit first chapter then it will get axed, fuck off

>using groupthing to validate your opinions
Japan is not a hivemind, and you are too assblasted about chinese cartoons rankings