Is Gothic 2 really better than Gothic 3?

Is Gothic 2 really better than Gothic 3?

from what i've heard, the only ones worth playing are 1 and 2

Gothic 3 is shit so yes

nope
Gothic 2 is for casuals

Gothic 2 may be better but Gothic 3 is enjoyable as well. At least in German

Gothic 1 Is the best game Lorewise, but the controls are fucked up, and the graphics are horribly dated

Gothic 3 gameplay is shit, the story is retarded, and the graphics are horrible

Gothic 2 has a great story, graphics can be improved quite a bit with mods, and the gameplay is fine. Also, Gothic 2 has the best addons

Play 1 and 2, forget 3 ever happend (nobody talks about 4) and start riven, since the riven and gothic universe will be connected in the next game

>gothic 2 is for casuals
>it's harder than 3
So is Gothic 3 just for braindead retards then?

Gothic games are shit, and Risen. All shit. Fuckawful stunlock combat that's pisspoor. Fuck those games.

>Is Gothic 2 really better than Gothic 3?

it's objectively the best

...