Agree or you don't know shit

Agree or you don't know shit

>Shitty opinions: the list

Why is Yellow bad when it's the same fucking game as Red and Blue, just with Pikachu and anime references?

>Black and white two that high up
desu desu desu.

why is this thread posted outside of /vp/ ?

why are b&w 2 in god but the originals in bad?
Aren't they basically the same games?

bw2 is god tier while bw is bad?

Fixed.

>diamond and pearl that high
>emerald that fucking low aswell as B/W
this is such an obvious bait image jesus christ.

I'm not a faggot manchild who played pokemon past 9 years old, so Gold and Blue are god tier and everything else is all irrelevant.

>B2/W2
>god tier
Nope.

The list is bait. You can tell because Diamond and Pearl are far too high, and Emerald is in shit tier.

Swap the gen 6 games with the games in Shit tier and it's perfecto

How could yellow possibly be worse than Red/Blue?

>Platinum god tier
>emerald shit tier
Nigga are you fucking retarded?

How can platinum be so much higher than D/P?

B2/W2 are better than B/W but the gap shouldn't be that far apart. They're still very similar.

Every game in shit tier is put thier for a very good reason, user.

Not him, but just handing out starters kind of devalues them, Pikachu is probably the shittiest starter in the series and the artwork is just a shit version of the anime art. At least R/B have their own thing going on art wise, even if it's really fucking weird.

Why do people hate Pearl/Diamond? I thought they were pretty good. Granted they were my first Pokemon games.

>God
B/W
>Top
B2/W2, Emerald, HG/SS
>Good
R/S, G/S/C
>Mediocre
R/B/Y, FR/LG
>Bad
OR/AS
>Shit
X/Y

>Not him, but just handing out starters kind of devalues them
I thought you had to earn them through side questions throughout the game?

About as good a list as I could've expected. Not bad at all.

K I D
I
D

Forgot: PT in Good, D/P in mediocre

>FireRed LeafGreen ever below the originals
>The games that introduced online play in shit tier
What a boob

is there any reason to play black/white over black 2 or while 2?

I'm 18

If fixed almost everything D/P did wrong, it's a pretty dramatic improvement in most ways.

Slow as fuck, shit type distribution, shitty post game, too many event legendaries, region isn't that fun to navigate, honey is a shitty mechanic, and it introduces a ton of new evolutions to old mons that you can't actually catch until post-E4.

D/P run at like 10fps, and no battle frontier

>all one and the same game
>6 tiers

God Tier: All of them
Shit Tier: Any opinion that says otherwise
Go be grumpy somewhere else

>Platinum in God Tier and Emerald in Shit Tier even though Emerald did what Platinum did but better
>Diamond and Pearl in Top Tier
>Original Gen 3 games in Shit Tier

This has to be a troll post. There is no way someone can have tastes this shitty.

Reverse the tiers

The side quests in question were easy as fuck. Charmander and Squirtle just gets handed to you for free, Bulbasaur just requires your Pikachu not hate you.

FR/LG is everything bad about the originals without the charm bugs or nostalgia jank that makes the originals fun to play. The few things they add don't make up for how lackluster the overall package is, and they're the only remakes to not allow you to evolve Pokemon from the generation that recieved later evolutions, which is shitty.
If you want Kanto, play Gen I. If you want Gen III, play Emerald.

Shut your mouth you fucking child

What are the chances of my main nigga Totodile being in Sun/Moon?

I turned 18 eight days ago man, I'm not underage anymore.

Better than OP's, but just swap Emerald with Platinum and it will be solid.

>they're the only remakes to not allow you to evolve Pokemon from the generation that recieved later evolutions

what the fuck are you trying to say you mongoloid? Learn English before you post.

hot opinions incoming

Fixed.

just grab one from /vp/ when the game comes out

-0%

There is not a single Pokemon game that should be below decent/mediocre tier.

agree on a lot of it. Particularly putting pearl and diamond so low. Anyone who excuses how slow they are is a tool. Even with animations off.

OP here. i can agree wit hthat one too.

...

I love Pokemon but they're all the same, man.
The highest tier one would be whichever one has online play, so the newest one is always the best.

These lists are pretty debatable, but I think that we all can agree that ORAS is without a doubt, the WORST pokemon game ever

I most likely will, but I'd like the gen 2 starters to get some recognition. Well, Totodile, at the very least.

I mean, I like Emerald, but it still suffers from the whole "it's a gen III game"
The Physical Special split alone makes a big difference.

They're the only remakes to not allow you to evolve Pokemon from the generation (that is being remade) that recieved later evolutions (from later games)
The wording was a little awkward, but honestly anyone who actually plays Pokemon should be able to figure it out.

Eh, drop Gold/Silver. They were fun, but they had their share of problems. Same goes for Ruby/Sapphire.

>Anyone who excuses how slow they are is a tool.
RPGs aren't the genre for you.

Nigga, played em all. There's no excuse. Fixed in platinum so there's zero reason to play the shitty originals.

>ORAS
The endgame is pretty bad. Nothing interesting to do

pretty spot on. I never played platinum because of how terrible daimond and pearl were though and didnt play b&w2 because I didn't think it would be different enough from the originals

how about you fucking kill yourself????

I'd argue XY is worse, ORAS atleast has Delta.

>Eh, drop Gold/Silver. They were fun, but they had their share of problems.

Could be said of every single Pokemon game in the whole series tbqh. Doesn't mean a thing.

You first, come back and give me a sick bj after.

And Platinum still suffers from the whole "it's a Gen 4/Sinnoh game."

>slow
>terrible region design.
>Emerald did the Battle Frontier better
>Emerald did Gym Leader rematches better
>Emerald did legendary Pokemon better.

The Physical/Special split is fairly trivial and doesn't make up for all of these combined imo.

there is literally no reason to play a pokemon game, let alone post a thread here kys yourself all of you

Nope, D/P are still worse.

>4th and 5th gen top

>6th gen higher then bottom tier

>Counting remakes

This might be the most objectively wrong list I've ever seen

Yes, but Gold/Silver have pretty big issues that their later remakes (Crystal, HG/SS) fixed. There's no reason to put them in the same tier as those games, when they are objectively better games.

>it's an underage b& trashes RBY episode

God Tier
>Emerald
>HG/SS
>Platinum

Great Tier
>B2/W2
>Crystal
>Gold/Silver
>Ruby/Sapphire

Good Tier
>Black and White
>X/Y
>Diamond/Pearl

OK Tier
>R/B
>Yellow

Meh Tier
>FR/LG
>OR/AS

Containment tier

I agree with you mostly but
>Emerald Shit Tier
>ORAS below XY when they are near objectively better from a gameplay POV.

not OP but I'm playing through yellow right now after not touching gen 1 since like 1999 and man this game is janky as all fuck.

I enjoy it but the way it handles pokemon boxes and item management is such a goddamn pain. Nevermind problems that go deeper like how absolutely busted psychic is.

I still wouldn't call them the worst or even bad though. Just things that really don't hold up compared to later titles.

>Diamond and Pearl in Top Tier instead of Emerald
>ORAS not in shitter than shit tier

I'm 18 too kid, and my first game was Crystal
smdh

You have your own board for a reason.

How mad were you to drag 'n drop every single image to the bottom?

A little mad

FR/LG below the originals?

-0 and 0 are the same number.

any reasons they shouldn't be, faggot? they're the closest things to "definitive" pokemon games that have ever been released

>God tier
Black/White 2
Platinum
HG/SS

>Great tier
Emerald
Fire Red/Leaf Green

>Good tier
Crystal
Black/White

>Meh tier
Diamond/Pearl
Red/Blue
Ruby/Sapphire

>Shit tier
ORAS
XY


Discuss

>the game with the global trade network, the longest post game for catching more pokemon, and has some of the most creative evolution requirements out of any pokemon game i have ever played
>good tier

I have played all the pokemon games, it's pretty obvious you haven't

>anything gen 4 above bottom tier
Hello Sinnohfoetus child

t. Genwunner

>all of these salty fuckers who don't own 3ds's

tell me why any of the stupid fuck features are better then the features in X/Y listed in my post here

Because it took trading, searching, training and breeding pokemon to levels not seen in the rest of the series


WHAT THE FUCK I AM SO MAD

Platinum god tier is accurate.

I couldn't get into gen 5 though. How different is b&w2 from 1? I know black for me was boring as all fuck.

>diamond and pearl in top tier

How can people think 3rd gen is above 4th gen

3rd was the weakest one of the entire series. Even weaker than 1.

slightly larger map, more pokemon available, larger post game, and some say a better story, but I still prefer one in the first but
>opinions

BW2 has more content, bigger dex, new areas, etc. If you weren't really into BW you probably wouldn't like it though.

>Gen 6 in shit tier
shit taste

DP are not that high. They're in good tier.
X/Y are not that high, knock them to bad tier.
Bump B/W up to good tier
Oh shit emerald is last.
This is bait.

>DP that high
>BW that low
>Emerald that low
>ORAS and XY that high

>Physical/Special split is trivial.

You are a fucking retard.

...

>HG/SS good
I want this meme to end. It's a slog to play through, but post-game is top-notch.

It should always be one below Plat and BW2.

>DP better than XY

never actually played a pokemon but gonna get in

is it okay to play the 3rd/sequel version instead of the original pair? Do I really miss out on anything by doing that?

Am I the only one who liked yellow? I think it was cool cause you had your pikachu following behind you. Maybe it's nostalgia I don't know but it's still one of my top pokemon games.

I meant to type mediocre. That was a mistake.
But even DP is better than Breeding Simulator XY.

I found the people in the too poor to afford a 3ds and get there pokemon opnions from memes tier

>god-tier
Emerald, Platinum, B2W2
>top-tier
BW, HGSS, Crystal
>good-tier
FRLG, GSC, RS
>meh-tier
GS, ORAS
>bad-tier
XY, DP
>shit-tier
RBY

>tfw I know that X and Y were really lackluster in content
>tfw I still cant say anything bad about them just because I like the new 3D models so much
I also really liked the petting.

Where where they lackluster in content?

Because I don't think they are