Fixing Sup Forums 2 - Electric Boogaloo

Be constructive, folks. Let's pick up where we left off.

Old polls were kinda shitty so someone'll have to make some new ones.

Other urls found in this thread:

strawpoll.me/11228328
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

first for thread ID's

>Old polls were kinda shitty so someone'll have to make some new ones

IDs are useless because of phone/proxies

1st for stricter Sup Forumsposting moderation

dumb phone poster

You fix it by not posting shit threads that have nothing to do with video games. Faggot.

Sup Forums's fine as it is

1. Get rid of the mods. They're all sjws and care more about their political agendas than they do the rules. I got banned recently for reporting a black nationalist thread on a non-Sup Forums board.

2. Ban all sjw content.

3. KEEP Sup Forums IN Sup Forums REGARDLESS OF POLITICAL ALIGNMENT/POSITION/OPINION.

4. GET RID OF FLAGS AND IDs ON ALL BOARDS.

5. CHANGE /asp/ BACK TO A ALTENATIVE SPORTS BOARD AND MAKE /pro/ FOR WRESTLING.

6. DELETE /wsg/ IT'S A FUCKING WASTE.

7. ALLOW GEN 7 ON /vr/ AND CHANGE THE NAME OF THE BOARD TO /vc/ FOR "CLASSIC GAMING".

8. Ban complaining about "le e-celebs".

AND MOST IMPORTANTLY OF ALL

BRING BACK BOARD CULTURE AND ALLOW ALL DISCUSSION OF GAMERGATE AS LONG AS IT STAYS ON TOPIC ABOUT GAMING JOURNALISM AND DOESN'T BECOME A POLITICAL DISCUSSION.

Thread ID's, ban e-celeb shit, ban people who post blatant non-vidya threads like

>says a filthy frank fan

remove waifus

BAN VERTICAL POSTING
A
N

I
T

Bring back dubs.

>ban people who post blatant non-vidya threads
we should ban OP then.

remove niggers

What destroys Sup Forums is the very fabric of the damn subject. Video games are full of fanboys and brand loyalists. These people shitpost threads to oblivion they don't align with and it creates a ring match between brands and games. The Sonyfag goes into an Xbox thread to talk shit, xboxfag gets mad, does the same to a Sony thread. And the hate goes on and on and on into the shitpost wars. If we just had some ID's we could weed out faggots who seek to just cause strife in a single thread, do you see?

For people who don't understand ID's they change every thread and are completely random. You can't connect posters between different threads even if some are active in both at the same time. This doesn't curb discussion nor does it curb the general banter at all.

In fact it makes everything far better because people actually somewhat think about what they fucking post for a goddamn second. Getting ID's will increase quality this way while also destroying massive shitposting brigades. So basically quantity posts go down and quality goes up.

THIS

ANYONE SUPPORTING THREAD IDs IS LITERALLY A JEW TRYING TO DESTROY ONLINE ANONYMITY

Hiro said these threads are ok until we find the solution

The solution is to fuck off faggot.

But that is never going to happen because everyone is disagreeing with each other. How about Hiro does his fucking JOB!!!

Improved version
1. Get rid of the mods. They're all sjws and care more about their political agendas than they do the rules. I got banned recently for reporting a black nationalist thread on a non-Sup Forums board.
2. Ban all sjw content.

Shut the fuck up.

R E P E A L / G R 1 5 /
E
P
E
A
L
/
G
R
1
5
/

>I don't know what thread ID's are

You're still anonymous, nobody knows your name and your convoluted code disappears every thread and a new one is made for each thread. You're still anonymous it just adds some accountability.

by allowing us to make these threads and discuss how we think Sup Forums should be, he is doing his job.

Ban everyone who unironically defends niggers and muslims

Remove mobileposting.

Man I wish I could find that mother fucker and fuck him up the ass with a knife.

Remove non-virgins, people with social skills and gym-going normies. Make vidya great again!

1. Add poster ID's. Sure this can be easily avoided, but the more hoops shitposters/shills have to go through the better.
2. Ban E-celebrity threads
3. Political discussion is acceptable but only if it is video-game related.

We fix it by bringing to light how the video game market is controlled by kikes.

Ban all SJWs

>gym-going normies
people who go to the gym are the least normie fuckers you'll ever meet

nigger hiroshima has no idea what that means ,he doesn't know what this board is like ; realistically it could be years before anything resembling a consensus is reached

>get rid of the mods
>ban all sjw content
you could have tried harder

He isn't, he is relying on us to do his job. I bet you he said that so you faggots over at /qa/ won't fucking bother him again, it's literally impossible for Sup Forums, hell any board, to agree on one thing, let alone multiple. These threads serve no purpose, and if the mods were smart, they'd delete them.

the only suggestion I have is thread ID's

NO MORE NIGGERS

Is this netflix and chill? Im not america

jesus christ

Ban all leftists. There, I just prevented the board from turning into neofag and we won't need Sup Forums-oneechan to protect us anymore.

More like netflix and kill

That's cool as shit why cant i do wrestling moves irl

PoC are equal to white people, goy :^)

Ban this fucking faggot.

I made a very basic poll about Thread IDs.

strawpoll.me/11228328

For those of you who DON'T KNOW what Thread IDs are, it's a small, unique identifier given to IPs on a per-thread basis. They don't stick with the IP persistently outside of the thread, only within the thread itself. You can see how it works on boards like /soc/ and Sup Forums.

Pros of Thread IDs
- Discourages shitposters from shitposting, as they're easier to weed out.
- Makes it easier in certain types of threads for users to identify one another for temporary purposes. For example, in Sup Forumseekend threads for Smash Bros. or Mario Kart, having a unique ID makes it easier for posters to interact without having to repost friend codes/screen names/ etc.

Cons of Thread IDs
- Goes against true anonymity, which some people really care about.
- Can be easily avoided by dedicated shitposters (the real problem of the board), and even abused by them. A single dedicated shitposter can give off the appearance of numerous people by forcing his Thread ID to be different (i.e. resetting IP, using proxies, etc.) every time he posts.
- Can cause limited discussion problems within threads if posters are not fond of a particular user identified within the thread. Basically, if someone makes a retarded comment early on in the thread, they're fucked for the rest of the discussion, even if they're not nearly as retarded in the future.

I'm personally against Thread IDs on Sup Forums in particular, as I feel that it doesn't address the core problem. But hey, that's why I made the poll.

Can it be fixed without relying on mods?

If you people really want to curb shitposting, console wars, fanboys, brand loyalists, and whatever ID's that change every thread are the way to go. Would help FFXV threads that's for sure, then we could talk without the stupid XV kun witch trials and bullshit.

Goddamn half of these posters right now are betting on ideas that are completely unrealistic and that will never happen.

>HURR BAN Sup Forums

Realize how dumb this sounds and then we can actually decide on something.

Ban all black people. Every 24 hours your IP must post a timestamped picture of your hand to prove skin color.

That all depends on whether or not you can hold back on shitposting and memespouting.

>mfw people actually think hiroshimoot is going to read these threads or suggestions

In a sense, yes. The change has to come from the users, not from mods. To quote myself from the previous thread:

>Report, don't reply, and sage if you need to reply. It's not difficult. It's already been discussed earlier in the thread, truly dedicated shitposters will abuse thread IDs to make it appear as though they are in the majority, when in reality they may either be few or simply alone.

>The problem truly lies not with the shitposters themselves, but with those who take the bait with reckless abandon. Threads don't derail when a shitposter enters, that happens once at least two or three people reply.

>her three year old child was right on the couch the entire time
Fucking despicable.

Enforce the 18+ age limit.

the mods literally aren't here right now
we need some hotpockets that will delete eceleb shit

Bring Ito threads back motherfuckers.

Ban all SJWs, niggers, muslims and neofags.

This applies to "Sup Forums posting" as well, just report it, hide it, filter it, and move on.

>Can be easily avoided by dedicated shitposters (the real problem of the board), and even abused by them. A single dedicated shitposter can give off the appearance of numerous people by forcing his Thread ID to be different (i.e. resetting IP, using proxies, etc.) every time he posts.
>- Can cause limited discussion problems within threads if posters are not fond of a particular user identified within the thread. Basically, if someone makes a retarded comment early on in the thread, they're fucked for the rest of the discussion, even if they're not nearly as retarded in the future.

I disagree with both of these. I actually frequent some boards with the ID's and I can tell you most people don't care to dedicate that much to shitposting. And people don't check the Id over everything, it is there for extreme retard situations. One dumb comment isn't going to kill you for an entire thread, although that isn't even a bad thing. People thinking for a minute about what they post isn't a bad thing.

>falseflagging this hard
Do you retards unironically believe Sup Forums is nothing but racist sexist bigots who want to kill leftists

Who am I kidding Sup Forums is made to troll, Sup Forums is made to shitpost in, Sup Forums is by nature, shitty. There is no fixing it, the only point is to discuss new news and then get yucks off of dumbasses every thread. This place will never get better.

>pls let me post my stuff just ignore it guys haha

If you are watching Hiro,


Instaban:
-Feminism (irrelevant to actual game discussion, a thread can be opened in Sup Forums or /lbgt/ instead for discussion in that matter)
-Racial diversity (if its from a studio, take to its appropriate board, if its in video games, to take it to an extent that does not deter actual discussion from the game such as plot, continuity, etc and not for spreading diversity awareness as a whole in general),
-Gamergating (I do not know what this actually is as I do no participate in it, but from what I have seen, all it brings is irrelevant discussions about people rather than games)
-E-celebs (A hit and miss, I personally want to talk about games, not the people who play them, unless its related to a competition, reviews, or people making them, it should not be allowed)
-Social Media (should not be allowed, not a video game, video game news is fine.)


Side note:
If it a thread that looks like a general but appears once a week, minimum twice a week, it should be allowed.

Ban everyone who unironically uses the word "racist"

You got it, now stop making these shit threads.

go suck more mudslime cocks faggot.

The hard part is making the "kek i'm ironically replying to bait" newfags that think this is hilarious stop and that's impossible, unfortunately.

Ban e-celeb threads
Ban SJW/Gamergate drama
Ban "is there any games where i can _________" with a picture completely unrelated to video games that is just them wanting to make a thread that isn't about video games at all.

There, that's all you need to do. This board has recovered significantly over the last year or so, surprisingly. If you look through the front page right now even it's pretty much all video games.

Yes, that's my exact point. It doesn't matter WHAT the shitposting or bait is. All that matters is that the post is bait, and must be treated equally regardless of its content.

I agree with you in most other contexts. IDs are fine on many boards, where discussions are more contained and civil. I don't believe that Sup Forums is (or ever will be) one of those boards. Sup Forums, being so large, has a niche of extremely dedicated shitposters that have been running rampant for years now. All Thread IDs will do is make what's already brazenly obvious have some color attached to it. We know who Barneyfag is. We know who's posting "What are some games" threads. That simply does not matter. What matters is that these posts are ignored and reported on a user level and dealt with on a moderation level.

remove anime posters besides dbz and jojo
ban moeshitters and loli degenerates

Ban people who don't like anime.
Ban SJW.
But I honestly don't expect anything out of this.

>- Goes against true anonymity, which some people really care about.
and the entire post goes out the fucking window

Accept refugees from Sup Forums

#NOTALLMUSLIMS
#NOTALLPOL

Ban political threads

Ban console war threads

Ban crybabies from Sup Forums that shitpost threads into oblivion eith infographics and webms of black crime because someone called them a faggot.

Ban Tumblr threads

There is literally nothing wrong with loli

Oh, also while we're at it. increase the file-size limit a bit and add sound to webms.

If it does not matter then let us fucking have our IDs then. Your argument is "well I don't think it will improve the situation". I think it will. If you have any solid arguments against ID please let us hear them.

>LET ME QUICKLY TACK ON AN ANTI TUMBLR SENTENCE AT THE END SO PEOPLE DONT FIND ME OUT

no one is sjw on Sup Forums you fat virgin cunt
people just want to talk about video games

ban filename threads

You're not even trying to hide it.

I 100% believe they are. Even racists aren't as cancerous as they are, at least they can stop talking about blacks for 1 fucking thread.

>extremely dedicated shitposters that have been running rampant for years now. All Thread IDs will do is make what's already brazenly obvious have some color attached to it.

And adding ID's would limit these people in shitposting. You can't activate a whole thread with one post. And not everyone knows who these figures are or how to identify them, not everyone is that deep in to the culture here. Which is why thread after thread people take the bait and shitpost wars ensue. Also I think it goes much deeper than just those people, fanboys are everywhere here and they're the worst shitposters.

true, but there's a place for that shit and it's called Sup Forums

It being possible is not the same as it being realistically probable.

The only real solution to these fucking problems is this:

bring back snacks

yeah and who will pay for the new servers?

>LET ME GET OFFENDED BECAUSE user DOESN'T AGREE WITH MY SHITPOSTING!
I can play that game to faggot.

Sup Forums pass users :^)

YOU! The audience!

But who is at fault here? The baiter or the people responding to the bait? Because if the people who responded to the bait didn't respond to it, it wouldn't have derailed the thread and gave the baiter attention.

make the Sup Forums passes $5 instead of $20, you stingy cunt

Dogposter is smartposter.

I'm all of those things and I'm from that place

>it's a ban everything i don't like episode

ban anime

I guess we should live in lawless counties because that's exactly what laws do.

>smug anime girl
>stale Sup Forums memes
>against better moderation

That's 3 strikes.

Ban leftists