Remake Cloud or Advent Children Cloud?

Remake Cloud or Advent Children Cloud?

Neither.

Both are alright

I want the cartoony cloud of the original

I feel like I need to see more than like the minute of remake Cloud they've shown before I decide.

If you're talking designs, I like the AC design more than the original but only without the sleeve.

Are we talking about appearance? There's almost no difference. I only like AC Cloud because he looks not as sickly.

I prefer black haired Coud

Smash Bros. default Cloud

I hope Cloud's as goofy in the remake as he was in the original.

He looks SLIGHTY manlier in what we've seen in the remake.

Absolutely FF AC Cloud, for that amazing costume alone. FF 7 Cloud looks like a pouty fuck boy, hair is shit and the costume is shit when compared to AC's.

This. Once again, a guest character in Smash was given more love and thought into his design than the company who owns him, just like Mega Man and Pac Man.

It's weird, too, because even in other spinoff games like Dissidia, cloud looks closer to his FFVII design than anything "canon" post-AC. When will SE realize nobody likes nuCloud?

Nomura loves AC Cloud and this is all that matters.

>nobody likes nuCloud
Ehm, excuse me, some of us like him.

I love how sickly remake Cloud looks.

That's wrong actually. Remake Cloud is designed to look sickly and pale to foreshadow the plot twist later in the game. Smash Brothers Cloud is just "this design looks like a cool action hero guy".

How bad taste can one person have? The AC costume is so fucking bad. I bet you have a giant half-skirt in your closet.

Which doesn't make any sense since Barrett talks about Cloud looking tough in the first (maybe scond) mission.

man his SSB adaptation was perfect

too bad they included the AC redesign too, which is what everyone uses for some reason. Confident strong mercenary>goth shitter on his way to a rave party

remake Cloud.

looks way less emo.

looks crazy.

i like your opinion.

Barret calls cloud a skiny white ass cracker.

Remake Cloud looks like he has cancer. It's perfect. Really captures how fucked up Cloud is due to the Mako and Jenova Cell treatments he received.

That's probably just a throw away line of dialogue, or maybe even a bad localization because as we all know FFVII had a perfect translation that took no liberties with the script whatsoever.

But now they know what they're supposed to be going for and can make it more thematically accurate. Cloud is not a cool tough guy. He's an abomination of science with unnatural magic freak strength who thinks he's a cool tough guy.

>my opinion is different from yours
Okay, it's still absolutely awesome imo and no, no I do not.

At least remake Cloud looks like a real person instead of a fucking bishie.

AC obviously
Not only does remake cloud have the wrong eye color, but he looks like ass, the hair is flat lack of shadowing and stuff
If they showed us the face of the CGI model for the remake I could make a proper comparison

wrong eye color lol, hes got mako poisoning bb.

his eyes are supposed to be the colour of mako.

No they're supposed to be blue like the sky

anyone else totally okay with Steven Burton doin the voice?

no homo man but my mom used to watch that nigga on General Hospital, always thought he was the shit

then hes Cloud again


FFFFFUUUUUCCCCKKKKK my rage for Sephiroth cannot grow any larger

>Not only does remake cloud have the wrong eye color

Nigger what?

No, I agree with His eyes are supposed to match the lifestream. AC Cloud's eyes look wrong.

maybe they will change into that as he slowly gets over the mako poisoning

>til he falls into the fuckin lifestream

>this

the lifestream. like what mako is taken from

They're supposed to be blue like this, not green
Zack says Mako eyes are blue like the sky
I'd be ok with this

>They're supposed to be blue like this, not green

Remake Cloud's eyes in the OP look bright blue to me, there's just some green ambient lighting.

>Zack says

the fuck are you a medium?

Remastered doesnt look very optimized.

AC Cloud look bright blue, remake Cloud is a weird blue/green cross
In Crisis Core

He looks a drug addict in the remake

i could run Dark Souls 3 at 30 fps

thats enough to enjoy it im sure. though my kid would like a new console in the house too

also fuck you

Why wouldn't he? Guy's been in a test tube for years.

They look green to me. Probably accounting for that he was dunked in mako prior to the story.

This is sarcasm right?

Advent Children Cloud will never not be stupid.

...fuck you too

it wasnt.

He's supposed to looks like this though.

saying this makes me think you look like the guy on the right.

low body fat doesn't mean drug addict. faggot

Didn't he also say Cloud's a skinny lookin dude too.

not 100% sure but its prob before he sees him cleave through enemies and shit and pepper dudes with his materia.

fuckin Braver dude?

they better bring back *%&#$*# Shera

Check this 24

I unironically like his AC design, but yeah VIIR Cloud is so much better. He'll probably turn out as the most faithful to his original design out of all the party characters, which makes sense, but the little changes like his sickly complexion and pseudo-AC hair are cool.

How many of you noticed that the VIIR Buster Sword is actually the Compilation version, but with a metal cover over the hilt to make it look like the original?

In comparison to Barrett himself he calls him skinny. In the beginning he comments on Cloud looking his SOLDIER part. So Cloud didn't look much different/skinnier/sicklier than the SOLDIERs you meet in the game.

The fuck are you on about? He isn't some kind of Frankenstein's Monster. He was a normal dude with a good body build (he was in the shinra army and thus trained and well fed) and he was fed during the time in Hojo's lab as well while getting some alien "enhancements". Literally nobody in the game except Barret in the English localization mentions in any form thst he looks weird or sickly. The only thing mentioned and hinted multiple times is his mental state.

Remake Cloud looks closer to his original design. But I'm guessing that was the intent.

I'll go with remake Cloud. Seems a lot more determined/looks like he just came out of a test tube.

Remake Cloud has no muscles. Litteraly shit tier.

My boy.

Imagine the shit they would've gotten done if Zack survived instead of Cloud.

It'd be perfect if they made a DLC pack giving every character a Smash-esque design.

remake actually has glowing green eyes like he's supposed to

it's not like this game is coming out before 2020 anyway

Remake Cloud is fine for his condition at the beginning of FF7. Just need to give him some muscle. What little he has now is ridiculous.

I don't know, J cells were fucking them both over. Zack would've eventually died of Hojocancer or gone full blackrobbed zombie. He might've taken Aerith out of Midgar, or might've just gotten killed/captured by Turks who've been stalking Aerith all that time.
I sincerely doubt it would've been the VII adventure with Zack as the lead though, since he would have no reason to team it with Barret's AVALANCHE.

>Cloud beefs up as you progress in levels

would be fantastic

Looks like they slapped a Cloud head on top of Promptos body.

This

Can't wait to see bulky tifa !

He looks sickly, but he also looks like a SOLDIER, like an experimented human.

I liked Cloud's spiky hair, doubt it could be pulled off in real life.

This Cloud.

Fuck your Compilation/Remake shit.

With enough hair products it can
Or you can just use a wig

...

Advent Children Cloud.

No, I'm serious. Cloud's hair looks like that in Advent Children because time passed and he got a haircut. I can dig that. I can rectify that in universe.

I can't take that hair style retconning out the classic one during the events of FFVII

Neither.

Final Fantasy VII can go suck a fuck.

>it's popular so I FUCKING HATE IT

The third option

Holy shit, that's horrific.

How about the original Cloud? Or maybe the Smash Bros. default one instead if I can't have that one?
But I have to go with one, then I'd take the one that doesn't look like an anorexic and go with Advent Children Cloud.

>How many of you noticed that the VIIR Buster Sword is actually the Compilation version, but with a metal cover over the hilt to make it look like the original?
I did. That's one of the reasons I think Nomura's gonna do just fine. That was an clever way to integrate the Compilation titles while retaining the classic look.

AC Cloud: 80% female.
Remake Cloud: 65% female.

Uhh no a ton of people say Cloud doesn't look right and everyone notices that something is off about the dude.

You learn this when you talk to people after he leaves the party. They ask about him and say they knew something was off with him. Your fucking party says this on the Highwind as well when you play as Tifa.

Lightning shit begone and stay gone.

Fucking Tifa gave me an armpit fetish

Zack wasn't affected by the Jenova cells. Only weakminded individuals got affected, like Cloud.

We all know why his eyes are more green now

This would make sense for hinting at Geostigma if AC were to be referenced; otherwise I call bullshit

This actually doesn't look like Cloud. His nose has a very defined bridge and his eyebrows are naturally locked in a glare. Plus, he has very distinctive eyes. This Coud looks nothing like that.

I don't remember well but, was Cloud always as emo as he was in advent children and other projects ? ( kingdom hearts, dissidia ) ?


'cause it's really how he is defined now.

>m muh sadness, muh guilt.

>times cloud smiled in AC
>2
>times cloud smiled in other media
>0
Math doesn't lie, bruh. AC Cloud is actually him at his best.

Nope he started off as an amusing arrogant asshole and ended up being a quirky autist

>Let's mosey
Still gets me

Cloud was literally addled passed out in front of the train station in Sector 7 before Tifa found him in the original. That's when the Zack persona happened and he believed he was SOLDIER

That must've really creeped Tifa out. Cloud went from crazy fucker to arrogant SOLDIER in an instant

Man, it's the perfect joke costume.
It must happen.

The whole trip up until finding out clouds real past at Nibelheim creeped her out. She had a lot of moments when shit from the past came up and she would either "..." or act strangely. The first story told at Kalm was especially weird due to her remembering the exact same events but different in important ways.

Cloud was so fucked up I'd be dissapointed if they made him look perfectly healthy and strong.

AC Cloud without the single sleeve>Custom SOLDIER armor Cloud>AC Cloud>Shinra Grunt Cloud>KH Cloud.

AC Hair>CC/Remake/Dissidia hair>OG Hair

Full Fusion Sword>Remake Buster sword>Compilation Buster Sword>First Tsurugi>OG Buster sword>The rest of the fusion swords.

This is objective fact.

I'd fuck the bottom one's mouth and paint his face white. No homo ofc

OG cloud best, only needs higher fidelity hair. Giving his outfit color is good and the Buster Sword shouldn't look so fucking conplicatrd. Just a big fucking slab with holes in it

the PS3 tech demo remake cloud looked the best.

Even if hate Lightning, it would be kinda funny if one option for Cloud's crossdresing segment would be Light's costume and pink wig

>people not realizing remake Cloud that early in the game is supposed to look sickly

>drug fucked retard looks like a drug addict

wow weird