Is the 3ds version really THAT bad?

is the 3ds version really THAT bad?

too bright and cartoony. the removed the soul and atmosphere from the game

I IIkeda it a lot.

It's the definitive version.

It's good up until the Twinmold fight. Ignore shit like .

No, but the good changes it makes are cancelled out by the bad ones, so it's not really better or worse so much as a sidegrade

Fuck off, I'm a giant 2deep5u MMfanboy and it preserved the atmosphere fine.

For every good design change there's a bad design change alongside it
If you haven't played the original, then go for it. But if you're a fan of the original, there's going to be some 50/50 shit

Aside from gimped Zora swimming, shitty Odalwa boss battle and gimped Ice Arrows, it's improved in basically everything.

Good:
>Much better models and textures, and improved lighting/particles that with 1 exception (great bay temple) preserve the atmosphere and for the most part still feels creepy
>Gyorg fight is better
>Doesn't make you rewatch the business scrub cutscene
>Better framerate
>Song of double time allowing you to choose specific times to fast foward to.
>Gyro arrow controls
>Fishing
>if you have a n3ds/xl, you have camera rotation/control via c nub

Neutral:
>The bombers notebook is a little less obtuse and more organic to use, but it's also a little too helpful.
>Likewise, the save system is less obtuse, but allowing you to save without it being attached to going back in timee also removes some of the stress the game is meant to invoke, but you can impose thee limit artificially anyways.
>Twinmold fight is different but not better or worse. Some people like the change, some don't.
>Bank placement is moved

Bad
>Odolwa fight was made very easy, especially with the deku mask.
>Ice arrows can't be used just anywhere anymore.
>Zora swimming less fun, which outweighs the benefit of easier control in tight spaces.
>Bombers notebook pops up automatically and takes a while to do so, is annoying
>You have to get out of rolling as goron to hit Goht, but this isn't nearrly as bad as Odolwa's change
>It's harder to use the Deku spin to go faster (super minor thing to count against it, but it's there)
>Great bay temple's atmosphere is a bit changed due to less gritty textures and brighter lighting

I wonder if it would be posible to just make a hack of the original game with new textures and models.

Are n64 hacks at that level of editablility yet?

I wouldn't say its bad, but its not better than the N64 version.

Confirmed never having played it. The real flaws are
>slower swimming controls
>boss battles changed for no reason and made less fun
>ice arrows not properly programmed to work on any water

Visually the game looks great, way better than the n64 graphics which are only "better" to retards wearing nostalgia goggles

It would be a lot easier to just make a ROM hack of Majora's Mask 3D and fix everything wrong with it.

>Gyorg fight is better
That should go to neutral because the second phase, RNG can screw you over
>Much better models and textures
This can be for the player's preference. I didn't like how exaggerated some animations were

I was won over by the opening scene in the woods, it's fucking beautiful.

Only change I don't like so far is taking out the colors in the astral observatory. Why??

>tfw this is so damn organized
>tfw cant just have this be a thread closer
>tfw if every thread about arguing a games pros and cons had this type of comment and would be closed half of Sup Forums would be in a lost on what to talk about

I think it's really good, has some good changes and some bad ones that have already been mentioned.

One thing I really don't like is the reward for collecting all the stray fairies in the first and second dungeons were switched.

it's literally better than the n64 version

no and yes

I actually liked the Odalwa fight, it made more since to have a fight that used the Deku form, instead of just a generic sword fight.

I played it one time for 30 minutes and haven't touched it since. It's probably fine, maybe I'm burnt out on MM or something.

But on the downside, its slower to kill him than on the original
You forgot to say 10/10

This. Well worth it to have MM on a portable and it has many improvements.

no

Changes to Zora swimming triggered me extremely hard.

It's not dark and edgy enough :((((( ;_;

what? no it's awesome, literally my only complaint was them fucking with that moon child dungeon and the zora form dashing shit, and the fishing is pointless, but all the quality of life improvements are huge and make the game a lot less tedious without taking away the old charm in any way