Which sprite is best?

Which sprite is best?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=5lea-Dx6b5Y
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Not 3

Why not

CD

Looking at them like this, oddly 1 seems the best. He looks better without the shiny spot on his head and I like the colors and subtle contrast. I'd probably go
1>M>3>2

sonic pinball

Sanic 3.

Full of determination and confidence. Arms ready to tackle any fight that comes his way. Eyes that resemble a fierce and unyielding fire.

Sonic 1/2 looks like he can't be bothered. Mania loses because he's the wrong shade of blue AND he can't be boethered/

when the fuck is mania coming out?

never?

please i need it ;-;

SM > S1 = S2 > S3

2.
3 always looked too shiny and his eyes always looked weird.

3 takes this easily, in a walk, no contest, not even close, by a country mile, hands-down, without a shadow of a doubt.

The small pupils just make him look mental to me.

Sonic 3

Mania, obviously. It has the highest detail and frames out of all of them.
If you say otherwise you're blind as shit or just a contrarian.

Spring, as is Spectre of Torment.

2

Definitely 3.

Mania

t. not blinded by nostalgic bias

I miss sprites. I also miss the shitty N64 polygon models for like, Bomberman, Mario, Wario and all them.

2

3 was my favorite when I was a kid, but now I think it looks kinda derpy because of the small pupils. All of the others, including CD, are the same fucking sprite.

sonic mania or sonic 3

in sonic 1 or 2 his head looks too big for his body

2, for now.
Mania looks pretty damn nice though, might be the new best. We'll see once the game is out.

All of them.

shit, they changed the bubble shield so it pinballs you in the angle of the platform you hit?

I'm not sure I like that.

Not him, but 3 tried too hard to make everything look "3d" and a lot of shit ended up looking weird and lifeless as a result.

The Bubble Shield looks actually fun now.

3 > 1 > M > 2

Is sonic a good video game

>25 year-old franchise

I don't know, you tell me.

Also
>Sonic 3 the Hedgehog

4 Resident Evil

You really can't go wrong with any mainstream title before Shadow the Hedgehog. They're all playable, some being downright great.

Adventures is fucking terrible too.

I think Sonic Adventures 2 is fun. I think Sonic Adventures 1 is not as fun but it isn't terrible.

The collective Sup Forums borg hates the Adventure series, though, so my opinions are unwelcome.

And Aventure 2 is so bad and cringey it's an ironic treasure

The gameplay in 2 is something I've always enjoyed but fuck me that music and story. It's definitely the edgy teenager of the Sonic series, after it stopped being a happy-go-lucky kid and before it became a joyless adult trying to reinvent himself every 2 years.

The original by far.

Go home Arin. You're the dumbass for not reading that you had to hook froggie by tugging on the joystick, just like how you have to hook real fish.

YOU FUCKING RETARD


IT SAYS

>Sonic 3: Sonic The Hedgehog

FUCKING SJW SHITLORD

Sonic Mania's is best in motion but I like Sonic 3's standing sprite the most.
The arms in 1 and 2 look really weird where I think the extra shading in Mania helps fix that.

Here's my predictions.
>the game has 12 zones
>7 classic zones, 5 new ones
>there will be a classic zone from an unexpected game (not 1-3K or CD)
>studiopolis act 2 will have the lights turn off
>one of the new zones is a castle
>the plot will not feature time travel
>surprisingly, super tails and super knuckles appear
>the special zone is like NiGHTS into dreams
>there is online multiplayer to a capacity greater than just leaderboards
>the final zone is not the death egg

Adventure 2 Battle has great gameplay and a godlike Chao Garden

Any of them except Sonic 3.

>CD
>Just the same sprite as Sonic 1, but with a fucked up walk cycle

youtube.com/watch?v=5lea-Dx6b5Y

iirc sonic 3's art got shit on back then too

theeeeen don't use bubble shield?

One and two.

Yeah, three makes him look like he has a shit eating grin. Only time that ever worked was the ocver art for Sonic Adventure.

Goddamn it.

why are they all crying

>liking sonic adventure 2 when 1/3 of it is action stages
>hating shadow when all of it is action stages

SHIGGY DIGGY DOO

>hating sprite art for creating depth
Depth is what makes good sprite art, faggot

>it made it look lifeless
Kill yourself

Adventure 1 is pretty good outside of Big's (mercifully brief) section
I agree 2 is not very good

For the robotized friends they have to kill over and over through out the stages.

Not him but I liked the Knuckles stages fine

Also Tails/Robotnik levels could still be described as "action" stages

This triggers me badly

Why does he have those white pixels under his eyes in the 1 and 2 sprites?

3 > M > 1 > 2

3 looks like he'll fuck your shit up (and does).
Mania may have the wrong shade of blue, but has plenty of detail to make up for it.
1 is just nostalgia.
2 was always meh to me compared to the others.

2 right now, but I do like Mania.

thingken of animals

Who the fuck is Arin

sonic mania looks like silver sonic from 2

>Sideburns

Obviously 3.

1 and 2 have extremely poor spritework in comparison, with a lot of poor shading. Look at those out of place black pixels on his shoes, hands and neck, for example. His arms look weird too, too long with tiny hands. The mania sprite is better than them but still based on them and shares a lot of their problems.

There's also the annoying inconsistency with the design of his quills, where it looks like he only has three of them, whereas the Sonic 3 one correctly conveys the shape of his head, with the quills set in rows of two.

Better to keep the mouth closed and be thought a fool...

I'm pardial to Sonic 3. S1 and 2 are good too. Will have to play Mania before I have an opinion on it.

CD fans can just fuck off.

2D sprite: Sonic Mania
3D model: Unleashed

Anyone have the chart?

Color from 2
Eyes from 3
Everything else from Mania.

the one with blue arms

It always worked like that.

I don't get why that's so controversial. As a non-fan, blue arms are much more consistent.

>Adventures

The 3 sprite looks better by virtue of not having those hugeass black voids for pupils. I don't give a shit about title-screen sonic.

Sonic 2.

I like 2 but, 3's shoes, posture and hands look better to me. It's just a shame about that definition on the mouth.

I'd go with 3.

1>2>4>3

One has the best colors, 4 is too fuzzy and 3 looks like shit.

It's not. One mega autist got his panties in a twist over it, and then it became a meme.

>there are retards who like 3's clown shoes, boxing gloves, tiny pupils, and floppy dull looking spines

you are so autistic that you actually pay intense detail to the sprite of an anthropmorphized blue hedgehog from a video game made over 20 years ago

3 looks fucking retarded and his feet are in a gay pose.

What else are we going to compare the sprites on?

isn't that the point of this thread though?

better than having stupid pizza shoes

shit I forgot about how his belly and shoes look like they're oiled up

you're a stupid pikachu

The Mania sprite just looks like they coloured over the Sonic 2 sprite and gave it slightly bigger gloves and extra shading. I thought this was supposed to be "Sonic on the Saturn", not "Another Genesis Sonic game".There's no way that Sega would have kept the sprites that similar between console generations if they made a 2D sonic game for the Saturn.

Missin a few.
So am I.

Mania > 2 > 1 > 3

3 looks goddamn retarded.

Mania > 1 = 2 > 3

...

Tan arms are easier to make out from a sidescrolling perspective.

Mania's looks like inconsistent garbage. It looks like he has a 3D head ontop of a flat body. Even Sonic Spinball's is better.

>It looks like he has a 3D head
That's your eyes being shit, you mole virgin.

>Even Sonic Spinball's is better.
Fucking kill yourself.

Here are some sprites, although Tails has no tails in the standing sprite this guy ripped

I can see why you might not like Mania's head, but
>Even Sonic Spinball's is better.
wew

He's not wrong.

Thats aosth sonic

...