Gentlemen, are we still in agreement?

Gentlemen, are we still in agreement?

Stopped reading after number one, you can't unironically think this is the eptiome of gaming

>oot above mm
Obvious bait.

The thing with polls like this is that generic games which everyone have played rise to the top and the better games don't simply because the voters haven't played them

>pearl/platinum

what in the FUCK

Will not coment on the ordering, but the games thenselves look solid.

Also this is why reddit is shit

I stopped at #1. I'm not going to subject myself to the torture of reading the rest if that is #1.

And yes, I did like Pokemon Gen 2, and all of the other Pokemon games.

Sorry, pinnacle is probably the proper word to use.

No XCOM on the list so no

>mario kart
>no crash team racing

reddit tier list

Morrowind
Fallout: New Vegas
Deus Ex
S.T.A.L.K.E.R.
System Shock 2
F.E.A.R.
GTA: San Andreas
Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

So are these pretty much the games that are well regarded in Sup Forums, right?

San andreas is objectively shit that appeals to nostalgia fags

>Pokeman

that's faggot shit

no, 90% of that is fedoracore Sup Forums pretends to like to make them look like they have taste

GSC was great and all but man it has zero (non-nostalgia fueled) replayability if you're going back from a newer game.

>no actual goos game before number 73
No we're not in agreement.

remove New Vegas and GTA and I might agree.

I like how Pokémon G/S/C are listed as the best in the series, but #1 game? I think not.

>are we still in agreement?
Since when has anyone on Sup Forums ever agreed on anything?

Fuck reddit.

Yeah we are all edgy like some sort of teenagers who have watched on too many naruto except we are adults who failed to get past that

Also this since when has Sup Forums agreed on anything thing isn't a clever remark when it's pointed out every single time

Probably the best list I've seen posted in awhile. OoT is a bit too high plus MGS4 being on the list at all are some complaints though

I rather ask myself when did it become normal that different opinions are something bad.

When reddit invaded for good

>entire list is mainstream, plebian shit

Fuck off with that shit taste

More proof that Sup Forums was always shit

>objectively shit

You dont know what the word objectively means? English must not be your first language.
It's actually "objectively" a absolutely excellent game. It's far from perfect with may flaws, but overall each design elements positives heavily outweigh the bad.
Gameplay was fair for it's time like a B-, but vehicles handled better than other games like it or other gta games.
Story was good B
Graphics for the time were great A

Music/radio had a large variety and was put together well A

Plus all of the extra crap you could do. Clubbing shopping, getting fat, getting buff, customizing more. How is it objectively shit, to you? Could you not catch the damn train cj?

Just bought it on steam, thanks for reminding me.

Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal is one of those sequels that does it all right and not only improves on the first in every way, but also expands upon it in newer ways.

Is it worthy of being number one? I don't think so, but those are a series of good games in their own regard.

Speaking of vastly superior and/or perfect sequels, where's Devil May Cry 3: Special Edition?

>No Homeworld
>No Total Annihilation or Supreme Commander
>MGS4 on the list
Shit List.

>1. Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal
Dropped instantly.
Yes, this is a Jojo reference. Fuck off.

>gameplay b-

yeah, though by modern standards not even that

>graphics good for the time

nostalgia shit as I said

>story was b

eh, too much to argue without being subjective

>good music

sure

english is my fourth language

Also all the extra sit like eating and exercising is just shallow shit added to make the game seem a bit more fleshed out for the time

nostalgia shit, being able to do exercising mini-games in a game is just boring as fuck

>Monster Girl Quest

an absolutely, not a absolutely

>How is it objectively shit, to you?

you don't seem to know what objectively means as that's an oxymoron

>S.T.A.L.K.E.R.
>Not Metro

Why?

2008

??

Here's what you do:
You call this
>Sup Forums's 100 Good Games List In No Particular Order
and bam, almost all complaints vanish. Except the contrarians, they'll bitch no matter what you put on here.

It says on the image that it's from 2008, 2 years before Metro released.

Ohhh now I see. Apologies for not catching that.

>put in Kingdom Hearts but not Ys, the objectively better ARPG series
Disgusting list

No problem my guy.

Yeah.

Needs to be remade with Undertale at 1 and overwatch at 2

Ys is overrated weeb nonsense with a Gary Stu protagonist

>smash
>not a single street fighter game
>devil may cry 1 instead of 3 or 4
>5 final fantasy games
These lists always succeed in pissing me off

Adol isn't a Gary Stu dumbass.

The list really ought to mention why half of its items are highlighted in red

I was wondering why it was on the list too, and I loved Pearl. Gen 4 isn't widely celebrated so I don't know why it's on the list.

FF games are always decent if not great

Shhh...

What's with all the red

>mario galaxy
>above tetris
r u eben troying

>planescape, the greatest RPG of all time
>nowhere to be found

>red alert 1 instead of 2
yeah no

>pretends to like to make them look like they have taste
but they're perfectly playable games that are legitimately good, what's your problem?

whoops posted the wrong image

>3 million nintnedo games on the list
>2 pokemon games on top 5
>old Sup Forums favorites like New Vegas, VTMB, Thief, Max Payne, Dark Souls and Hitman nowhere to be seen

really get you train a rolling eh

>smash over street fighter
Why is Sup Forums so casual?

>fallout 3 on the list at all

at least it's better and more varied than OP's list.

This. It looks more like a decent list of must plays, but not a top 100.

I hope this list is in "no particular order". If not it's shit.

Also:

>Gold/Silver/Crystal on the list
>Link's Awakening
>Fallout 2
>Megaman 2

>No Paper Mario TTYD
>No Metroid Prime 2 Echoes
>No Undertale
>No Mario Kart Double Dash

it's shit.

>>No Undertale
good bait

>S.T.A.L.K.E.R.

I don't think anybody even argued that it was GOTY/AY material. It's just very well loved.

THIS
DMC on the list but not DMC3:SE?

Also brawl in front of melee? Fuck is that shit?

I did!

>All those Final Fantasies, and even Chrono Cross, but no Suikoden anywhere on the list

Nice try you furry filth

You forgot Pokemon G/S/C HG/SS

Really glad I refused to browse Sup Forums until SF2 HD Remix came out.

There is literally nothing wrong with Final Fantasy

Kudos to you.

I'm pretty sure most people who played S.t.a.l.k.e.r. played it a year or two after it released. Or maybe I'm projecting. I played it in 2009.

It's a cult classic one way or another.

Nothing good about it either.

Get rid of the Final Fantasies, metal Gears, and Pokemon titles, and then I'll agree. You said this was a GAME list, not a movie list.

>half life 2 above half life 1

absolute fucking trash

>no Max Payne
wow just fuck off

>zeldashit on 2nd place
every
fucking
time