Can we get a roster thread going?

can we get a roster thread going?
I really enjoy these threads, seeing who people want to see in Smash and who they dont want.

please no shit posting, thankyou

...

Why would a side character get in before the mascot?

cause his design is dumb

why couldn't they just be alternate costumes, but we chose Ribbon Girl because it adds diversity to the roster also shes a qt

>slippy

what the fuck would he do besides being a shitty fox/falco clone

>3 marios

bait?

you're right, I should have added Metal Mario and Baby Mario as well.

>ribbon girl
>not spring man

...

Honestly, Smash 4 gave me everything I wanted. I got Mewtwo back. I got Shulk, Megaman, and Little Mac. Unfortunately I don't find Megaman nor Mac fun to play, but I got the representation I wanted anyway. I got a spellsword in Robin, even if he's not very good and I'd have preferred someone a bit quicker. I got a spear user in Corrin.

Smash 4 added pretty much everything I wanted except for a dedicated bow user.

Jesus Christ you can't just include every character
Do you want this game out in 2030?

its just for fun dooder, no reason to have an aneurysm.

You are a gentleman and a scholar.

I'd put Peppy in over Slippy and include the Ice Climbers, but your roster is overall good.

but since you want a smaller roster, here is my restricted version.

This is fucking garbage

>Isaac
>prince of sable
>keeping corrin

you're alright, op

Because I'm too lazy to make a pic.

>Start with Smash 4 roster
>Change
Dr. Mario
Dark Pit
Lucina
Make them skins with some changed moves.
Mii
Give a more custom moveset.

>Cut
Robin
Corrin
Roy
Lucario
Greninja
Cloud

>Return
Ice Climbers
Snake

>Add
Paper Mario
Kirby Rep
New Pokemon Rep
New FE Rep
Toon Ganon that uses swords
Ridley
Inkling
Spring Man
Bomber Man
K. Rool
Chorus Kids

>DLC
Ray Man
Banjo Kazooie
Fawful
Eggman
Proto Man
M. Bison
Jack Frost
Shantae

Also, if I didn't put a character that you wanted on here, it's not because I don't like them, it's more because the roster is fucking floated as it is.

All I ever wanted.

It was never going to happen, but if it did...

WHERES LUCINA YOU FUCKING NIGGER?????????????????

why?

>4 FE shitheads
>4/5 pokemon characters are generic humanoid fighters
>One of the pokemon is a cancerous waifumon trash that plagues modern Pokemon
>literally who anime characters in the last two slots
>Bigley
>Porky, a villian that nobody remembers, over Lucas
>Ribbon Girl instead of Springaling

>smash roster thread
>no shitposting

good luck, I've never seen it

also shantae of course and this badass

>Geno
>No Jigglypuff

...and into the trash it goes.

ONLY THING I WANT IS RIDLEY.

use gadgets

if you arent going to post a generator or something then i'm not gonna bother

...

does he do that in the starfox games?
and I mean the real ones

>literally who anime characters in the last two slots

Sophie from Style Savvy a series that has 3.5 games and better sales than Zelda.

And if you don't know who Saki is you need to get fuckin' gud.

I didnt use a generator

well they can invent a moveset for him, in the games he is the tech guy

>i-it has better sales than zelda

And yet I don't know anyone who ever talks about it.

Fuck off, weab.

>Style Savvy

How the fuck would that work?
At least characters like Wii Fit Trainer, Villager, and Dunk Hunt had enough material to go off of. How the fuck do you make a character from a dress up game viable for Smash?

>I have no imagination

No more literally who's
no more blue haired swordsmen
no more WHITE haired literally who's
no characters that are too big
no spl2oon

and what the fuck are you talking about, everyone was saying how ridiculous using WFT, Villager and Duck Hunt were for characters.

>crossing out rayman

wrong choice faggot

He would have a shit moveset and you know it cunt

>Samurai Goroh
My nigga

...

Alright then, Mr "I have more imagination than you", give me a viable move-set.
And yet Sakurai obvious had enough stuff to pull from.
I'm not gonna say it's IMPOSSIBLE, but until I see something that proves me otherwise it sounds pretty damn unlikely.
>No more literally who's
>Keeps Geno, Captain Syrup, Green FE Girl, that one Kid that can turn into a Snake and a Frog

>Porky, a villian that nobody remembers, over Lucas
I preffer lucas but seriously? Porky is quite iconic among the games.

>Mario
>Luigi
>Yoshi
>Donkey Kong
>Link
>Samus
>Kirby
>Pikachu
>Fox
>Pit
>Marth
>Villager
>Olimar
>Sonic
>Megaman
>Pac-Man

Behold, the only good roster list

>Wanting no Inklings

Why?

Yeah I missed those fucks and would have crossed them out too.

>cutting that many characters, including various staples like ness and falcon
Are you baiting?

>Cutting characters that aren't Dark Pit, Lucina, Dr. Mario, and outdated Pokemon and FE reps
Die.

You get one rep if you are iconic and/or profitable

>Mario
obvious
>Luigi
technically his own series, also obvious
>Yoshi
iconic, profitable
>Donkey Kong
iconic, profitable
>Link
iconic, profitable
>Samus
iconic
>Kirby
iconic, profitable
>Pikachu
iconic, profitable
>Fox
iconic
>Pit
profitable
>Marth
profitable
>Villager
profitable
>Olimar
profitable
>Sonic
iconic
>Megaman
iconic
>Pac-Man
iconic, profitable

Meanwhile
>Ness
neither, hasn't had a game in nearly two decades
>Falcon
neither, hasn't had a game in a stupid long amount of time
>Dark Pit
one rep
>Lucina
one rep
>Dr. Mario
one fucking rep
>Pokemon, FE, other autism
one, one, one rep

just give me dixie kong pls

any list without Waluigi is dropped

>never again

>Losing the entire point of Smash Bros

Yes but Falcon is an Iconic part of Smash brothers, he doesn't need his series, if he was ever cut, people would get extremely butthurt. And also disown smash until he was placed back in.

The point of Smash Bros is advertising

Jamming Ridley or Waluigi or some character nobody cares about is missing the point

>Falcon is an Iconic part of Smash brothers

Being your autistic main is not "iconic"

>The point of Smash Bros is advertising

Nigger, he gets his own cinematic shots from the dev team.
Cry more, he will never not be in smash.

>profitable
>profitable
>profitable
>we need more money than we need fun

Sup Forums was right.

>Smash Bros is about advertising
>So instead of advertising franchises that actually fucking need recognition, let's just advertise shit that's already being advertised to all hell

If any of that shit were true we would have not gotten Pit at all, because that shit was not profitable or iconic until Uprising.

...

>advertising series that don't have games to buy

You can whine all you want, there is a reason there are fifty Pokemon and Fire Emblem reps and its not because the series is extremely popular

Smash Bros exists for advertising

>still crossing out rayman

WRONG CHOICE AGAIN FAGGOT

Explain Pit then.

Nintendo is not about fucking advertising you retard. It's about Nintendo's history. We would have a giant amount of Smash trophies filled with literal who's if that was the case.

NEVER
EVER

>Explain Pit then.

Brawl = had a game coming out to buy
4 = had a game coming out to buy

>People putting Crash on the roster
As much as I love Crash, along with Cloud he is way more of a Sony rep than any one else.

>Brawl
>Had a same coming out to buy

I'm throwing a wildcard out there and confirming Isaac for the next smash. I'll be screencapping this post and you'll all have egg on your face in 2 years

All three mother games can currently be official bought via wii u virtual shop.

Guess ness returns then.

Smash is about advertising, but fuck off if you think that is the absolute only aspect of it.

>Brawl = had a game coming out to buy

Sure, Smash Bros. Brawl was advertising a game that wouldn't come out for six years!

....

WAIT WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU RETARD

REMOVE
Tsubasa
Takamaru
Ashley
Porky
Toad
Ridley
Chibi Robo
Pheromosa
Dillon
Choir Boy
Saki
Style Savvy

No one with taste like GS, issac has no chance. We already got the better gba jrpg psychic protagonist.

>You are a gentleman and a scholar.
Jesus Christ it's like I'm really on 9gag.

Add
>Solid Snake
>Wolf
>Ice Climbers
>Lyn
>Inkling
>[ARMS character]
>[Pokemon Sun/Moon mon]
>Bomberman

Remove
>Dr. Mario
>Dark Pit
>Lucina
>Roy
>Miis

And refresh the gameplay mechanics/cast from there. Rework the fundamentally flawed or boring (Little Mac, Palutena, Zelda, Ganondorf, Lucario, Olimar, etc.)

>Marshall
Your roster is total fucking garbage in every other category, but any sort of Rhythm Heaven character will get you an A+ in my book

...

Was just about to say this.

And then Uprising came out Two years BEFORE Sm4sh, so it wasn't even a "upcoming game" at that point.

Hell Sakurai even said that he wasn't going to make Sm4sh until Uprising was done.

yeah but maybe I could master Isaac's recovery within 20 years of playing

>being so shit you can't do pkt2 properly

>stuffing Smash with more characters
>when a huge volume of the current roster is either boring, terrible to fight against, a retread on another character, or outright unplayed

hoping smash 5 fixes whats there instead of adding new shit willy nilly

i personally think a handful of cuts from some non-clones would make the game feel different and lend space to potentially better characters (Jiggs, Wii Fit Trainer, Falco, Corrin) but cutting anything pisses people off apparently. Every other fighter does it, not EVERYTHING sticks

>People adding Lyn
Why?

I mean, I'd rather just have Ike and Marth period, but at least Robin and Corrin had some somewhat interesting gimmicks to stand out.
What the fuck does she even have that would make her more than just Marth (Not Lucina Editon)?

Let's change the subject.

Who do you want to CUT from smash?

Cloud
Bayonetta. Fuck Europe.

Make it happen Koei Tecmo!

I voted for Protoman in the Smash ballot.

I think I'm the only person in the world who did.

>cutting characters just because you don't like them

I fucking hate Ness and Link players but I'm not gonna be a retard and say they need to be removed.

Waifufags.
Characters like Hector, Ephraim, or literally any magic user would be ten times better, but they have dicks, so not a whole ton of people care about them

that's what I said yes. Never been able to

Ness and Link don't make up the entirety of most doubles tournaments.

Not him, but I'd just cut shitty clones like Dr. Mario, Lucina, and Dark Pit. Cloud too because he just doesn't fit Smash.

Bayonetta would depend if we're getting a 3rd game or not. And if it's exclusive.

mine probably not digested too well

>Corrin
>Dark Pit
>Dr. Mario (full Mario alt)
>Falco
>Jigglypuff
>Lucina
>Miis
>Roy
>Ryu
>Wii Fit Trainer

there's better Pokemon, FE and Street Fighter characters to pick from

if Falcos gonna continue to be a hodge podge shitpile instead of his fun Melee incarnation than he can stop wasting space

i dont really have an excuse for WFT. if she was a speedy fast-faller instead id probably want to keep her

>cutting Ness

gross

>cutting Falcon

unacceptable

I've always felt like Dark Pit was wasted potential.

Why doesn't he have Pit's old moveset? That'd be a huge differentiation and pretty easy to do.

>Cutting Jigglypuff when she's part of the Classic group

I don't even like Jiggly but that's just stupid.

>Corrin
Agreed

>Dark Pit
Agreed

>Dr. Mario Alt
Agreed

>Falco
The Meleefags would crucify you.

>Jigglypuff
Original 12. Never gonna happen.

>Lucina
Agreed

>Miis
Agreed

>Roy
Agreed

>Ryu.
I'm on the fence with him.

>Wii Fit Trainer
Original Moveset, Original Character, Original game. I disagree.

Alright Sup Forums, since we're obvious not going to get what we want, might as well post the character that you would like that would NEVER EVER happen. There are no limits. They just need to be from Sup Forums.

I wish Sony Smash was good.

I hear people say she could have a bow, but I call bullshit because both Links are a thing

What's worse is how some add her then cut Robin or Corrin

I see where he's coming from, and this is from a huge Jigglypuff fag. Jigglypuff is pretty boring, especially when comparing her to the 801 other Pokemon in existence. It's not like her kit is anything incredible or unique either.

However, it's who he wants to see cut, not who will be cut. I doubt she'll ever be cut, just because of OG 12 and all that.

Sony Smash needed a fucking stun bar or something to make it feel less like mashing action figures together