Why did you kill her? She was only trying to protect you

Why did you kill her? She was only trying to protect you.

Other urls found in this thread:

rule34.xxx/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1985875
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

BECAUSE SHE DIDNT SUCK ON MY BIG FAT JUICY PENIS AND FUCK IT! LOLOLOL XD
HAH JK GET TROLLED

_ ____ __ ____ ____ ____.

She attacked first, not my fault the bitch wouldn't let me leave

this

Women always find a way to get killed, can't really blame me.

I'm sorry that I didn't eat the pie and let Stockholm syndrome take over me like you did.

a

>everything tries to kill you
>want to go back home
>she attack you too
>LMAO WHY DID YOU KILL HER xD

I didn't kill her because every sperg and their granny spoiled me the fight while recommending me this game
The fucking fanbase ruined this game for me.

She was asking for it.

Because she wouldn't fucking move. Like god damn bitch, you want to FIGHT ME instead of letting me past a simple door?

POST
THE
THICCCC

Because the game tells you you can beat monsters to make them submit and then forces a critical hit to kill her. Sparing her has no immediate effect unless you spam it and Frisk outight notes that talking doesn't seem to have an effect.

I'd rather fuck the other two goats, honestly.

This. Although it's more that they didn't spoil the story so much as the "correct" way to play it.

"NO DUDE NO NEVER KILL ANYTHING!!"

You're supposed to fuck around your first time through to understand the game world, and then learn about the resets and the save/load mechanics. Stop telling people to do the optimal route right off an spoil the goddamn journey.

This
The fight was designed for you to kill her the first time around.
Then you get instructed to repeat-spare, and THEN you don't kill her.
It's a retarded shit because it forces you to play 2 times.

wasted opportunities: the game

It would have been so easy to implement many more variations and endings, good idea, lazy execution.
lol so randum humor also makes it not replayable

Because she was creeping me out, has all these references to being your mom and taking care of you and shit. Unfortunately most Undertale players didnt recieve parental attention so instead of seeing how weird she was being as sus they were like "i want a goat mom!!!! Oh no i kill her ;__;"

I gladly killed that creepy bitch and would do so again

>no option to live with Toriel forever

Fuck going back to the surface, I want to live with a thick goat mom who bakes me pies

Case in point

Telling you to go pacifist the first time is the same as spoiling it since you miss a lot of cool stuff you would only see in neutral.

now we're talking

I wanted to see what would happen

>no option to live with Toriel forever
false.
when Toriel asks you to go back to your room you are free to do so, and do nothing but bum around her house and the earlier parts of the cave for as long as you want, hundreds of hours even.

FUUUUUUUUUUUUCK

>No explanation of how frisk leaves the underground in the neutral ending

Nice plothole

Don't you end up living with her in the good ending though?

Because I thought it was like poke'mon, and if I got her health low then spared everything would be fine.

>It would have been so easy to implement many more variations and endings, good idea, lazy execution.
Ya kidding me?

I think the execution was okay story wise, except the retarded ending where you are expected to care about some goat you just met for the first time. The real part that was wasted potential is the gameplay, since the whole shmup/rpg hybrid thing could have been really fun, but in the end we got two good fights and both locked in an otherwise complete shit route.

>play it blind
>accidently kill her
>reload the save to try and save her
>mfw Flowey

I didn't even know about the pacifism meme in this game.
I tried "mercy" a couple times and she kept refusing, so I decided to fight her normally. Fuck you I'm not living my life underground with spiders and a furry goat.

...

I want to play this game?

I like to think she was packing an ass that nice under those robes

>hurrr Im going to destroy this passage

The door is already locked you dumb goat all you had to do was bury the key somewhere and the kid could have never left, why are you so stupid

More thic toriel butt

Honestly, I don't get how 90% of the fanbase memes around killing goatmom without meaning to. I didn't get spoiled a single time (only knew about the game having Genocide and Pacifist routes) before playing the game yet I fucking knew there was a way around killing her.

This is why you play every game blind. If you had played it after being exposed to the memespouting fanbase you would probably be one of the people saying something along the lines of
>Wow that part with flowey was really predictable it wasnt even original because some obscure VN referenced saving/loading too lmao

death to all nonhumans tbqhfam

Only if you're perceptive you'll really keep trying anyways.

The number of periods in her ellipsis increases by one each of the first few times instead of it just being exactly the same. But yeah, being told out outright that it doesn't seem to have an effect is a little counter-productive.

Everything in the underground must die.

I want to fuck that 'girl'.

>Sparing her has no immediate effect
Other than the fact that she gets an extra period each time? Any change is an incentive to keep going.

Remember the first 3 threads about this game on this board?
They were amazing
If you werent there I feel sorry for you

>spare like 6 times
>flee
>search house looking for anything i missed
>go to sleep
>game tells me to notgive up blah blah
>go back to fight her
>spare like ten times
>hit her
>try to spare, nothing happens
>flee
>check out house again
>backtrack as much as i can trying to find any clue to wathever i have to do
>go back to fighting her
>hit
>spare
>hit
>spare
>fuck it
>kill her
>stupid flower makes fun of me
>i was suppossed to choose mercy an autistic amount of times
bravo toby fox bravo

>undertale thread

YAAAAAAH TRICK YAAAAAAAAAAAH

more

She gives you different dialogue after 4 spares but nice try.

...

>Game tells you that you can spare monsters by getting their HP low enough
>tells you that trying to solve things peacefully has no effect, pushing you to attack her more
>throws in a random critical hit that instantly kills her

The game fucking wanted her to die, that's why. You can't kill her "on purpose" unless you know about the super critical hit beforehand, which isn't even part of the mechanics of the game, it's specific to her fight and you have no way of knowing about it unless somebody who has played the game before tells you about it. It's pretty cheap really.

...

>it's specific to her fight
It happens in most boss fights. If you hit them too close to the end of their lifebar they die.

yeah the dialogue changes to sparing wont work or something like that
i also tried to spare undyne like 50 times before she killed me, the dialoge changed to undyne looks around to see if this is a joke

The game tricks you into killing her accidentally so that you will reload and find out about how reloading is a part of the plot.

rule34.xxx/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1985875

Yeah its honestly bad game design.

more of that ass

The only important character I killed was Undyne, and I did that on purpose because she's a total bitch. The game is piss easy and Toriel cannot kill you, it's easy to try every option a couple of times.

>let seven kids die
>didn't stop alphys from doing her bullshit
>when the going got tough the goat got going
>bitch never answers my calls after leaving the ruins

Fuck Toriel.

But user, that's just semantics. It's exactly the same as the Kill Paarthunax quest in Skyrim. You can ""decide"" not to kill him, but you cannot remove the quest from your journal, which means that the game expects you to kill him if you want to feel any sense of closure.

Really? Well shit. I can't really remember. The only ones I remember are Undyne taking forever to kill because of her not-giving-up thing, and I think Muffet only dies if you hit her again after she spares you.

Oh. I didn't reload, I just kept on because I at least knew that the characters who die or are spared will affect the rest of the game somehow.

A Grizzly Bear faces all the monsters of the underground.

Who wins?

If you reload after killing her there is text indicating that Frisk remembers killing her and Flowey points it out.

I wish I could have gone back and slapped her after seeing her berate ASGORE for the very problems she created and exacerbated for years on end.

more

>using rule34 and not e621

The first several hundred threads about this game were amazing. It was basically a single thread being remade 24/7 for two weeks. Do you have any idea how much restraint it takes Sup Forumsirgins to collectively make sure there's only one thread at a time, and then actually talk about videogames on top of that? It was a miracle.

And then a bunch of faggots had to fuck everything up by forcing it off to /vg/ after two weeks. MGSV threads were flooding the board all the time, yet because the single Undertale thread was a "general" it's the one that ends up being shoved out. Undertale discussion was dying off naturally, but pushing it to /vg/ predictably led to months upon months of Undertale trolling threads because people learned it could trigger people just as hard as ponies. Undertale is now forever part of Sup Forums board culture thanks to that critical mass of stupid, so I suppose I shouldn't be too salty.

>literally could have noogied Asgore back to his senses after the tragedy and prevented the call for war on humanity
>advocates Asgore just going out and reaping souls after fusing with one
>Asgore's plan, however cowardly and passive, turned out to be the absolute best possible plan
>hates him anyways

should've given us an option to live with Asgore tbqh

>and Toriel cannot kill you
she actually can but you have to intentionally try to make it happen, by running into the bullets before your hp is low enough she stops trying

she even has a shocked/horrified expression sprite for when she kills you

How do monsters breed if they are all female? It's not like you can say they do it human men considering they were locked up all the way underground.

Also FemNapstablook is the only thing I fapped to in this.

In her defense, the annoying dog stole her phone (even if you don't wait for him to steal her phone in the pillar room).

No stopping the ass train, skelington

>you can choose who dies!

>cant choose to kill the weeb lizard the second you meet her

Fucking why

fpbp

I see you weren't here for the threads after the kickstarter but before the game came out, when a mega autist would be summoned any time toriel fanart was posted to complain about how its against the rules to post her since she's a furry

it happened in every single thread, it was really pathetic

She gives you different dialogue every single time.

>1 line of dots
>2 lines of dots
>3 lines of dots

>didnt fap to toriel in that

faggot

Wouldn't have been able to fight Mettaton in either form in that case. Wouldn't know about his switch in his invincible box form, wouldn't have the yellow Soul power to shoot his heart in EX form.

>Take in a child
>Treat them like your own
>They beat up your son, steal your husband's crown, poison your husband, then get your only son killed
>Get asshurt at your husband for banning all humans and having a "kill on sight" policy, go live in the ruins
Why is Toriel a fucking retard?

>THICCfags

People, look at her sprite; the woman is basically built like a cow.

Monsters seem to breed asexually even in the base game.

>Not liking Alphys

She is literally the most fleshed out character.

I'm not a furry m8. I'll admit I'm a straight up vanilla monster girl fag.

Yeah, that part creeped me out. Especially since I usually savescum notoriously much if the game allows me to.

Who cares, give me choices, I thought that was the deal, the selling point.
So you made an insufferable character ok fine but why cant I kill it? Why do I have to suffer?
Its literally "that part" of undertale

>Monsters seem to breed asexually even in the base game.
Since when? I'm pretty sure Asriel is a result of Asgore and Toriel.

I killed her after trying to spare her like 5 times. I didn't feel bad about it because I had a hunch she was evil, not only that but she was encroaching on my freedom. Turns out I was partially right. She may not be 'evil' but shes certainly a cunt.

Thought he was referring to the first few threads after the game came out. Pre-game threads were completely different.

>yfw humans are an analogy for niggers and the monsters are whites

who cares about the in game sprite, in my art she can be as thick as I want her to be

>the woman is basically built like a cow

keep going

more lewd goat ass!

fucking casual

Not him, but they -are- Boss Monsters, so they're kinda different. Then it again, it would also be kinda weird if monsters produced asexually into two different genders or have a gender dichotomy at all. Might be something they picked up from the humans since they used to live together.

In the library, you find a book that details reproduction as the combination of parts of two souls into a new being. Such is why only monsters that are parents can age so long as the child is still alive.

>She is literally the most fleshed out character.
Having the most flesh doesn't make them fleshed out user

REFUGEES WELCOME
NOT ALL HUMANS

...

More!

I don't kill people
I slaughter their souls