Is this guy the reason people don't want a Melee HD...

Is this guy the reason people don't want a Melee HD? Why do people think maining a video game character makes you autistic?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=vXgpGBbh5r8
youtube.com/watch?v=qCyrgyjgH38
pvplive.net/c/mango-curse-smash-bros-ama
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

Maining fox or falco is pretty autistic

No one cares about fox. Everyone hates ICs and Puff.

They could just, you know, rebalance the game. Since its a broken piece of shit

>Caring about "balance"
More autistic than maining fox or falco

Damn what's the matter with him

t. fox waveyiffer

Fox isn't even good though.

because an HD melee would ruin whatever BALANCE the game had

i say shit that the CPU can't preform, IE everything you autists NEED TO HAVE to play at high levels, should be banned and have your fingers sliced off for trying.

what is waveyiffing?

I honestly think if Nintendo made a Melee HD they would kill the competitiveness by removing a lot of the tech skill and exploits that make the game fun.

>everything you autists NEED TO HAVE to play at high levels
git gud shitterboy

I get rebalancing can lead to more issues, but I just wish more developers focused on buffs over nerfs. I just want good low tiers and more Ness mains not nerfed Fox.

that cheat u use with fox

nice ad hom

If they made Melee HD I would exclusively play for fun and nostalgia.

no, fuck you
i don't play your shit game to "git gud", i play it for fun

even the person who made the fucking game said its not a fighter. he says it in the last smash direct, go fuck yourself, calls your shit game series a "action platformer" not a fighter

just stop thinking your game is special
best part is, eventually, smash melee won't be played anymore since your "gods" are all old men now and no new blood is being pumped in like in the 00's

i win in the end and your game will become nothing while everything else like SF will be played forever and ever

faggot smash babby

also, you have autism because you play your shit meele at high levels, go fuck off.

FFFFIIIIIIRRRRREEEEE
TORRYAAAAHHHH
MISHON COMPREE

Why does everyone think Fox is saying "Fire!" when he does his Up-B?

If you listen closely he's clearly saying "HIYAH!!"

You must be tough guy irl user

Buffs to other characters are preferable, but the slight nerfs to Fox in PAL over NTSC don't really effect his playstyle, while still making him ever-so-slightly less dominant.

SF has players well into their 30s still playing, so I'm not even sure what you're saying.

Also jesus fuck, the way you type is literally hurting my eyes. Please get off of this website and go back to middle school.

Why in the fuck would anyone want Melee HD?

The people that play Melee are the types of people that refuse to move on. They're the types of people that bitch about every little change, no matter how insignificant.

There's no reason to make an HD version of a broken game that no one would play anyway.

I'd play it if they buffed the low tiers and had online play. There's only so much Fox, Marth, Falco, and Sheik I can take.

haha calm down nerd it's just a game
that you're really bad at XD lmap

>this level of FGCuck autism

Unprecedented.

At that point it's better to just move on. Melee's roster is terrible, and they would have to take considerable steps to make characters like Pichu, Zelda, and Bowser as powerful as Fox, Marth, Sheik, and Falco.

I already did. But I'd be lying if I said I'd never want to go back if an upgrade arrived.

>Sm4sh is falling in popularity
>Melee will never go away
>Platform fighters besides Melee almost never catch on

You can tell who is a shitter at this game based on their posts. So far I have seen nothing but pussy ass shitters in this thread. Melee is more fun when played casually than any other smash, only at the highest possible level of play is the game unbalanced.

I will cum in your mouths after I shit on your faces with Pichu.

I play SD Remix when I want a more fun "balanced" game.

Only at the highest level of play is the game unbalanced. I love how the homosexuals on this site just parrot shit they've heard.

I personally have seen smash 4 babbies get absolutely raped with characters like Ganondorf and Pichu.

>only at the highest possible level of play is the game unbalanced
lol

>I'm bad at Melee so smash should just slow down for me.

You modern nintendo fans are worse than having aids and cancer at the same time.

I play Smash Bros is a half-assed competitive level. So It sorta does matter to me. I like faster PK Flash and faster PK Fire. :^)

Neck yourself asap.

You know Melee has a strong following, right?

just nerf usmash and give jab1 a lower angle

also maybe PAL upb. boom, fox is balanced

mfw
>i win in the end

>I win in the end

wew go easy on us user!

Just finish roy and g&w and thatll be enough. I guess make it PAL also

>people don't want a Melee HD

Who?

Im on mobile, so do you want me to explain why youre wrong?

It has hyper support among a few thousand autists obsessed with EVO. I guarantee you the general video game population would prefer to play Smash 4.

Why would I want Melee HD? Smash 4 has cleaner programming and is more balanced. Tanaka should be looking forward to improving the series, not staying with a release Gamecube game.

That doesn't mean Smash 4 is a better game, and more to the point that doesn't mean we shouldn't have a re-release of the classic. A lot of people play COD but that does not mean Counter-Strike shouldn't exist.

Well, yeah. It's the newer game and it has more characters and is shilled everywhere. It's guaranteed support.

But even when I was a casual, I found myself shying away from brawl in favor of playing 64 and melee with my cousins back in 08 as soon as a month or two after I got brawl, so quality wise I'm not so sure.

That said, I can guarantee that if a new smash game came out and played like melee, the general audience wouldn't likely even notice because they're not there for the gameplay in the first place. Typically they're just there to play something to pass the time with friends. It makes me wonder why nintendo doesn't just make a smash game that plays like melee since the formula for a perfect competitive smash game is already there and it's not like it would hurt anything casually speaking, as proven by every game in the series.

Yes, it does mean it's a better game. It's valid to have the opinion that Melee is more fun, but even there I disagree with you.

>the general video game population would prefer to play

You can insert any amount of shitty casualbait garbage at the end of this sentence. I'm not sure if you're trying to make this a positive or what.

>it does mean it's a better game
>game quality has nothing to do with the game, just the amount of people who will play it

This isn't even Neo/v/, this is some sort of Ad/v/anced shitposting.

Because melee is the better game which offers universally greater freedom of movement through jump momentum, a unique combo system that changes based on the moment to moment interactions of player vs player, and the kind of high speed gameplay a lively party game should have.

By that logic Transformers 2 is one of the best movies because it's one of the highest grossing movies.

just rerelease it with online capabilities desu

Ad populum is a poor method of baiting, user.

Blah, blah, blah. I'm a faggot who thinks anyone else cares this much about technical game mechanics. People play smash to let Pikachu Thunderbolt Link, not for that nerd shit you are spouting.

No. I said Smash 4 is better because it has better game design and programming. You guys only love Melee because nostalgia.

>says smash 4 is better/more fun because more people are familiar with it
>an user says melee is technically superior
>"b-but game mechanics don't matter"

>nostalgia
Not even close to true. People have gotten into Melee's technical play even after Brawl came out. Smash 4's ground movement sucks.

>I said Smash 4 is better because it has better game design and programming

No you didn't, you said
>Yes, it does mean it's a better game.
in response to
>That doesn't mean Smash 4 is a better game
in response to
>I guarantee you the general video game population would prefer to play Smash 4.

But Smash 4 has better mechanics. You faggots simply think Melee's mechanics are a gift from Jesus due to your love of the game, even though they are broken and unrefined.

This post triggers me more than it should.

youtube.com/watch?v=vXgpGBbh5r8

One guy says Melee sucks, and the whole comment section turns into autists screeching in defense of their sacred cow. This is why everyone laughs at Melee players.

Okay, you need Ridalin to play Melee. What's your point?

Explain how it has better game design please.

From what I can tell, it severely gimps on-stage movement with the lack of ability to move back and forth without an agonizingly long turnaround animation, air mobility is inferior to any given mario game due to the lack of jump momentum, ledge play is nonexistent due to the new mechanics, which leaves an entire and rather in-depth segment of smash's offensive/defensive play completely out, knockback is extreme, hitstun is too little, and together this disallows proper followups aside the same down throw uptilt combo for most of the cast, directional influence is notably nerfed, thereby mitigating the extent to which a player can affect the direction they're sent when hit by a move (something that worked far better to keep both players engaged with one another when coupled with the notably minor degree of knockback and greater hitstun of melee and 64 to some degree).

Footstooling is a quirky idea that brawl added and smash 4 kept, but it's far too prone to causing jab locks which provide the defending player with zero performable actions for its duration and is no better than the wobbling Ice Climber exclusive issue in melee, except way more prevalent.

Also, rage is a poorly thought out mechanic that causes more problems than it solves, but I digress.

If you think the singleplayer content is superior, I suppose that's fair. But in terms of gameplay, I cannot agree.

What? I just listened to the isolated clips, and he's obviously saying "Fiyah". Falco does it too.
I mean, the move is literally called fucking "Fire Fox."

The gameplay is less restricted than that of the sequels on a fundamental level.

People don't want Melee HD because Meleefags would bitch about it not being >MUH MELEE even if everything but the resolution was exactly the same.

youtube.com/watch?v=qCyrgyjgH38

nice ad hom and alternative facts, faggot

This is 100% accurate. You are still going to get butthurt replies from Meleefags though.

>competitive video games in general

Better go tell daddy you want to exclusively play a video game fox named "Fox" in a children's party game from 15 years ago for a living.

Do you honestly expect anyone to read your rambling mess of nerd jargon?

Honestly, if the mobility of all the low tiers was heightened, G&W's l-cancel issue was fixed, and if they improved the offensive power of roy specifically, they'd all be fairly viable aside maybe Pichu who would be the joke character he was always destined to be.

Virtually every character has the tools they need to perform their archetypal roles well, it's just a matter of giving them the mobility to create openings to do so, or I guess as an addendum for a couple characters: M2, DK, Bowser, and G&W could do with some better shields.

I think Melee is the best of the series and that is true with some people, including Mango:
pvplive.net/c/mango-curse-smash-bros-ama

Is there something wrong with making a decent living doing something enjoyable?

Hey, if it pays the bills and doesn't break any laws, it's a good living.

Ok, so its an action platformer. Its still one of the best and most engrossing multiplayer engines of all time.

This.

because it does

>mfw this post is responded to with zero arguments

Why are you even in the thread if you don't know about a game's mechanics?

I don't think anyone wants to take the 20 minutes it would take to process and critically respond to his list of game mechanics.

Different guy, but why are you people so intense and elitist about game mechanics? It's just a fucking video game.

1. No. Melee HD would be a godsend if they didn't change the top 8 characters at all and improved the rest.
2. What

If you don't have a competitive mindset, you just won't understand. It's better to leave it at that. It would be like trying to explain the value of romantic poetry to a chink engineering major.

Oh, that's because mechanics determine how a game plays and people want to play the game they think plays the best and additionally would like to see that style of play supported by the developer for the foreseeable future if possible.

Bruh you don't get to be all pissy if the argument was "smash 4 has better game design" and that other guy gave a rebuttal with actual examples. That's literally what the conversation was about.

Hypothetically, if they released an HD remake for the Switch do you think they would butcher it and remove wavedashing or the fast frenetic pace that the hardcore fans loved about it?

If you don't critique what you love, then what you love won't improve.

you fuck most chars can wavedash

I think if they did it like their virtual console titles they'd just port it straight over without changing anything. But if they did an HD remaster they'd definitely change stuff

I have a competitive mindset, but it's more a question of diverting your interests. I would rather use my time/energy to get good at baseball and woodworking and a variety of other things. It seems a bit obsessed to focus upon one skill.

All characters in Melee can wavedash. It's inherent to how the air dodge system works.

You won't get good at a single skill if you spread your focus out over multiple hobbies

>competitive game where people play against one another
>hurr balance is meaningless

Aight, so if Kirby had an attack that would instantly kill every character on screen and win the match with the press of a single button, and no one else had that ability, you'd still be perfectly fine with the game? No? Then fuck off.

Such decisions would completely miss the point of remastering SSBM. We're dealing with Nintendo, so it's pretty likely that they'd do it.

You have to be fairly obsessed to be notably good at anything.

But these Meleefags ignore the character imbalance and exploitable nature of Melee. They don't critique, they merely defend their baby.

Melee HD is a twitch meme.

those are some hot blanket statements senpai

You can get good at multiple things, but simply not world champion good. It doesn't seem healthy to spend all your time in one skill. You should become a more well rounded person.

Melee isn't well balanced but it's still a better game.