I'm trying to do a list of (near) perfect games or 10/10 games.
This is the list so far:
9 Hours 9 Persons 9 Doors Age of Empires II Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn Bayonetta Bayonetta 2 Bloodborne Castlevania: Symphony of the Night Cave Story Chrono Trigger Civilization IV Dark Souls Deus Ex Devil May Cry 3 Diablo II Donkey Kong Country 2 Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze Doom (1993) Earthbound Final Fantasy VI F-Zero GX Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective Half-Life Heroes III of Might and Magic Journey Katamari Damacy Kid Icarus Uprising Kirby Super Star Ultra Last Window: The Secret of Cape West Metroid Prime Mother 3 Ninja Gaiden Black Pac-Man Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver Quake Rayman Origins Red Dead Redemption Resident Evil 4 Resident Evil Remake Shadow of the Colossus SMT Nocturne Silent Hill Silent Hill 2 Skies of Arcadia StarCraft Street Fighter II Suikoden 2 Super Mario 64 Super Mario Bros 3 Super Mario Galaxy Super Mario World Super Metroid System Shock 2 Terranigma Tetris The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time The Witcher 3 TimeSplitters 2 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Ultima Online Unreal Tournament 2004 Warcraft III Xenoblade Chronicles
Am I missing something? Am I overrating something?
David James
You forgot Final fantasy tactics
Andrew Turner
Hitman: Blood Money
Landon Hill
Portal 2
Jacob Young
Civilization V with DLC is also 10/10
Luis Gutierrez
It's 'Heroes of Might and Magic III' not this new Heroes n of Might and Magic crap get it fucking right next time.
Liam Allen
Freespace 2
Andrew Harris
Stop your autism
Owen James
Good list but you forgot
Goldeneye Chrono Cross Spyro the Dragon 2
Austin Rogers
The Wonderful 101
Daniel Rogers
Godhand
Logan Harris
Is Inside considered a 10/10 game here?
Benjamin King
I was gonna say Cave Story, but it looks like you already agree :)
Adam Cox
I don't know how that would be possible since Limbo was better in every way
Isaac Wright
Splatoon
Brayden Taylor
Portal
Juan Morales
Limbo was shit though
Owen Kelly
Add VSav, Garou, GGXXAC+r, KOF 2002 UM
Levi Cooper
Etrian Odyssey V
Just fucking incredible. Never been happier to speak moonrunes.
Justin Cox
I didn't say otherwise
Chase Adams
Wario Land 4 Pikmin 1 or 2 (take your pick) Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker Paper Mario: the Thousand Years Door Metal Gear Solid 2/3 (take your pick) Ace Attorney: Trials and Tribulations
Cooper Rivera
Thief 2
Jacob Ortiz
mass effect 2
Brayden Morris
DeSu overclocked and I'm not even memeing. Best sRPG I've played in a decade. Great story. Great soundtrack. Great endings.
Can't think of a single flaw.
Christian Sanders
I would get rid of the following:
>9 Hours >Bayonetta 1 and 2 >Devil May Cry >Earthbound >Final Fantasy >Kid icarus >Pokemon >Xenoblade
This is supposed to be a GAME list. Why are there movies on here?
Leo Clark
>Ninja Gaiden Black OP, you're alllllllllllllllright
Kayden Scott
I know right?
Also OP forgot The Walking Dead Season 2 and Heavy Rain
Jackson Brown
Quake FEAR Dwarf Fortress Descent 2 Crash Bandicoot Zeus: Master of Olympus Medieval 2: Total War Total Annihilation Factorio Mount & Blade: Warband Nitronic Rush Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Theme Park World Team Fortress 2 before hats Teeworlds Worms Armageddon Tomb Raider Anniversary Thief Gold
Samuel Rogers
Who said Portal 2 and Mgs(3) was right. The others mentioned good titles but not 10-10. Only pandered to their tastes.
Jaxon Lopez
Replace TimeSplitters 2 with TimeSplitters: Future Perfect or add TimeSplitters: FP on there too.
Mason Sullivan
Ebic
Jayden Jackson
>the witcher 3
nice bait m8
Elijah Bennett
Disagree. TS2 is better than TSFP
Nathan Johnson
Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky
Levi Bell
Yeah you're missing Myth 2. That game is maximum comfy.
Christopher James
shovel knight
David Nelson
>9 Hours 9 Persons 9 Doors The conversion of art to sprites is abysmal. Almost to the point that it would've been better to remove them and just be a sound novel with illustrations occasionally.
Luis King
The first Fable should be on there.
Jason Ramirez
>Dark Souls
How can this be anywhere near perfect when shit like Lost Izalith exists? List is shit in general.
Cameron Sanchez
I'd put Castlevania or Castlevania III/Akumajou Densetsu on there as well as complement to Symphony of the Night.
But the reality is that there are tons of games worth playing, and while it's nice to compile a list for your own edification/enjoyment of course you're going to end up excluding things. So yes, you're missing plenty. This board won't be all that helpful unless you're just looking to stir shit up.
Nathan Thomas
Tactics Ogre: Knight of Lodis
Gavin Cook
There needs to be a GTA title in the list. Which one is not my place to decide.
Also, a Total War title. My vote goes to Rome, but that's down to personal taste. You could pick Medieval or Medieval II just as easily.
Finally, where the fuck is Max Payne? It is quite literally a 10/10 in every conceivable way.
Jeremiah Fisher
Muh nugga >my personal 10/10
James Bennett
>I'm trying to do a list of my favourite games
William Phillips
That's a good list. Time consuming but good. You should add persona 4 to it though.
Logan Brooks
These niggas know what they are talking about.
Carter Bennett
Vice City or San Andreas
Alexander Rogers
Soul Reaver FFIV, FFVII-IX Dragon Quest V, VIII
>Xenoblade Chronicles Xenogears is incomparably better, but even it can't be called 10/10 for an obvious reason.
Zachary Campbell
...
Brody Butler
So far I agree with: Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn Bloodborne Castlevania: SotN Chrono Trigger Civilization IV Deus Ex Final Fantasy VI Heroes of Might and Magic III Ninja Gaiden Black Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver Red Dead Redemption Resident Evil 4 Silent Hill 2 StarCraft (but make it StarCraft: Brood War) Suikoden 2 Tetris TLoZ: ALttP TLoZ: MM TLoZ: OoT Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory
I would add: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Dwarf Fortress Final Fantasy Tactics: The War of the Lions Final Fantasy IX Flower Freespace 2 Hitman: Blood Money Inside Mass Effect 2 Metroid: Zero Mission Mount & Blade: Warband Ori and the Blind Forest Planescape: Torment Portal Portal 2 Rise of the Tomb Raider Rollercoaster Tycoon 2 Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri SimCity 3000 Spelunky Super Smash Bros. Melee The Witness Thief II: The Metal Age
Ethan Stewart
2/2
Now fuck off OP
Nathaniel Watson
>999 >not VLR Good. Fuck VLR.
Jackson Roberts
Nah I love the game but its nowhere near perfect
Isaac Hughes
Spyro 1-3 Wario Land 4 Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow, Order of Ecclesia Grandia Quake 3: Arena Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together Spelunky Cave Story
Elijah Long
>Soul Reaver I for one think the original Blood Omen is a much better game.
Wyatt Nguyen
Guitar Hero 3.
Chase Sanchez
Ocarina of Time, yo
Luke Ramirez
Nice list user I would personnaly add by alphabetical order :
-Baten Kaitos 1 / Origins -Day of the Tentacle -Demon Souls -Dishonored 2 (I know it can be controversial because of technical issues but this game is insane beyond that) -Fallout 2 -Freelancer -GTA San Andreas -Jet Set Radio / Future -Riven (Myst II) -any Smash Bros. game (melee or 4 as you see fit) -Towerfall Ascension -Perfect Dark 64 ? But don't know if it aged well -XCOM
Benjamin White
I think we can compromise, just add both games.
Isaac Bennett
>Dwarf Fortress Fantastic game but you're fucking wrong if you think its a 10/10 Haven't played half of the others but TF2 was at most an 8/10
Kevin King
God no, these are nowhere near being worthy of 10/10 rating.
Nathaniel Clark
>Earthbound This game has a ton of problems and most of them were fixed in the sequel. More like a 7/10 game
Evan Brooks
>Tomb Raider >Crash Bandicoot >Team Fortress 2 U absolutely what m80
Joshua Campbell
shit opinion
Luis Sanchez
Where the fuck is Okami you bunch of shit taste casuals
None are bad games, but I can't see how they could possibly be 10/10
Anthony Green
>no For Honor kys
Mason Gonzalez
Okami and Viewtiful Joe deserve to be on that list
Jackson Hill
Fuck off with that picture. You can't make "official Sup Forums poll" without it being stickied for at least a week and I don't even remember seing this one.
Nicholas Wood
Tried to include it but fell asleep 10 minutes in senpai
Mason Miller
>9 Hours 9 Persons 9 Doors
I like the series, but it's a solid 7 or 8 out of 10.
The puzzles aren't exactly neuron flaring and the writing is nice but flawed. VLR is honestly a minor step above as far as plot goes.
Anthony Allen
Fuck off nufag plebbit
Anthony Wood
Mega Man X?
Christian King
Looks like a ton of meme games. Your list doesn't have much personality, it's just a reflection of what idiots on here like.
Blake White
Then post some good games.
Bentley Brooks
Id get rid of Dark souls Maybe bayonetta 2 because personally didnt hold my interest much
Otherwise that seems like a nice list Id add TF2 God Hand
and if you dont mind visual novels Steins;Gate
Gavin Foster
>VLR is honestly a minor step above as far as plot goes >throwing lots of plot twists at your face is honestly a minor step above as far as plot goes
Jack Allen
>V
V has flaws. If you want perfection in design, the answer is DQ1.
Logan Cook
no ico love?
Jacob Murphy
This list is outdated,they made a new one last year
Carter Cook
This desu. Where is max payne? Either 1 or 2 has to be one the list for being one of the best Tps
Dylan Edwards
DeSu 2 record breaker was better in pretty much every way in my opinion. It had better story, voice acting, and characters.
Hudson Thompson
>9 Hours 9 Persons 9 Doors stopped reading there fuck off retard
Grayson Bailey
>21. Bayonetta 2 >67. Bayonetta STOP THIS FUCKING SHIT! It's a good fucking game, but it's not LEAGUES better than 1! Goddammit, you guys.
Hunter Taylor
Well, some:
Renegade Streets of Rage 2 Alien Soldier Halo: Combat Evolved Halo 2 Gears of War King of Fighters XIV Far Cry Far Cry 2 Planescape Torment Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri X-COM: UFO Defense Jet Set Radio The Last Express The Secret of Monkey Island The Secret of Monkey Island 2 Tenchu: Stealth Assassins Ninja Gaiden
I'd take these games off the OP list:
Bayonetta Bayonetta 2 Castlevania: Symphony of the Night Cave Story Devil May Cry 3 Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze Doom (1993) Earthbound Final Fantasy VI Journey Mother 3 Ninja Gaiden Black Pac-Man Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver Quake Rayman Origins Super Mario 64 Super Mario Bros 3 Super Mario Galaxy System Shock 2 Tetris The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time The Witcher 3 TimeSplitters 2 Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory Unreal Tournament 2004 Warcraft III Xenoblade Chronicles
Leo Rodriguez
Team Fortress 2
Hudson Clark
WHERE THE FUCK IS THIS GAME!?
Oliver Nelson
>Dark Souls >Bloodborne
I disagree. Severe flaws in both games.
Dominic Nelson
>tetris the only truly perfect game lots of good games on your list but few I would give a 10/10
Luke Sanders
Define "Perfect".
Because different ways people might label something as "perfect" can create different criteria. Are you looking for a game which does everything it tried to do expertly, with everything it didn't irrelevant? Are you looking for a game which was an expert representation of the system it put into place? Are you looking for one which is just better than others you would compare it with? Are you looking for one which most people would (reasonably) not find and major faults in?
>Am I missing something? Am I overrating something? Probably, and probably.
Noah Brown
>no dishonored
Shit taste desu.
Benjamin Butler
It has about as many as 999 does.
Robert Cox
>adds halo and GoW >removes quake and ut2004 this is bait
Alexander Watson
>SMT Nocturne
nice
James Johnson
I don't find any twitch shooter a 10/10.
Gabriel King
999's are more evenly paced than VLR's.
Ethan Williams
>Dark Souls >Bloodborne trashman.jpg
Luis Martin
Super Mario 64 is one of the only games that actually belongs on the list.