Is it good?

Is it good?

Not on Xbox 360

The "amazing fighting system" is a huge meme.
Treat is as Diablo clone, but with TPP camera and it's fun as such.

yes

I bet BotW will be most simmilar to dragons dogma.
the world feels the same, just huge fields with enemies to fight, and a few town hubs as possible.

One of my favorite games. Flawed as hell. Has a special atmosphere.

Fun magic system.

Its really shit. Sup Forums just likes it because its not popular

It's an amazing fucking game my dude. I recommend you to go through the whole game as the Warrior and just generally to not bother with the other vocations. You're gonna have a lot more fun this way.

loved it so much that i wrote a walkthrough for it in excel

it's definitely a flawed game, but it doesn't make the game any less enjoyable until after playing it for a long ass time.

Yes, but far from perfect.
The game would have been a 10/10 if it were more focused on dungeons, instead of having to slog through a boring, empty world for a good portion of it.