Edge Magazine gives BOTW 10/10

>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [10]
>Horizon Zero Dawn [9]
>Nioh [9]
>Sniper Elite 4 [7]
>Torment: Tides of Numenera [8]
>Aaero [7] / PC
>Dexed [6] / PSVR
>Dandy Dungeon [9] / iOS
neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1347513

What does Sup Forums think of this?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=RtNvDfjEbQw
nintendoeverything.com/zelda-breath-of-the-wild-gets-first-review-in-edge/
youtube.com/watch?v=IJuvLndCMfc
gamingbolt.com/will-the-legend-of-zelda-breath-of-the-wilds-release-affect-horizon-zero-dawns-sales
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

they also gave skyward sword a 10

Everything probably should go down 1 number.

>Horizon and Nioh, a fucking 9

How have they completed the game already?

Any reviews that come out on the embargo are going to be from players still in the honeymoon phase who haven't experienced all that the game has to offer.

>NioH
>9

do we hate nioh now???

get over it piss baby.

youtube.com/watch?v=RtNvDfjEbQw

>implying this isnt GOTY

>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [10]
>Horizon Zero Dawn [9]
IT WAS HER TURN

that cover is misleading. there are no underwater exploration in BOTW, just like WW it only has 2D water.

Why did the N64 pull off 3D explorable underwater, but these "new" games cant? Thats pathetic.

okay that looks FUN

Someone post the webm where Link is following the frog in the water and you can clearly see the chest sunk at the bottom of the pond.

Yes. They pretty much spoil the game in the review.

I would like to see this. Im not trolling, I legitimately thought BOTW had WW-tier "water".

>>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [10]
>>Horizon Zero Dawn [9]
>>Nioh [9]


Horizon should be like a 7.5-8. Nioh is good there tho.

Its just mediocre

I'll see if I can find it for you, dude. I actually wanna find it so I can save it.

>thats stasis move at the end

>EDGE magazine
>fun game but boobs are too big, so 6/10

>>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [10]
>>Horizon Zero Dawn [9]


Wow, at least we know they're retarded.

That's what I wonder too. If the game really has so much to offer, how could they complete it, explore pretty much everything, and write a review in only a few days? I doubt they played most of the game. It's why a 10/10 often feels more symbolic than anything, they want to make a statement about how this game is a masterpiece.

>The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild [10]
>Horizon Zero Dawn [9]

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA IT'S NOT FAIR

IT WAS SONY'S TURN

user don't you know that publications are only right/wrong when they agree/disagree with me?

I mean the fact that they gave Skyward Sword a 10 (like every other outlet at that time) pretty much confirms that they are susceptible to the Zelda bias so I'm not going to trust this review. Skyward Sword is an 8 at best, anything higher is objectively wrong.

Stop lying viral marketer.

Dragon's crown starts amazingly but it gets dull pretty quickly imo

>Having just completed it, we couldn’t help but think of Horizon Zero Dawn while playing Breath Of The Wild, and how simplistic it now seems compared to Zelda

I don't want to destroy your dreams but I seem to remember someone using the magnet thing to take the chest out of the water.
Still doesn't mean there is no explorable underwater though

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

nintendoeverything.com/zelda-breath-of-the-wild-gets-first-review-in-edge/

>The result, for all the longevity of its series and the familiarity of the open world genre, is a game that evokes feelings we haven’t felt for 20 years. Not since Ocarina of Time have we set foot in a world that feels so mind-bogglingly vast and unerringly magical, that proves so relentlessly intriguing. Plenty of games promise to let us go anywhere and do anything. Few, if any, ever deliver so irresistibly. 19 years on Ocarina is still held up as the high water mark of gamings best loved and greatest series. Now it may have to settle for second place

Yeah i'm having trouble finding the frog webm maybe somebody will post it soon in another thread but there's at least images showing you can see underwater and you can collect fishes and shit. Even if you can only magnesis the chests that's still better than just 2d wind waker water but i'm hoping you can dive and stuff.

Nioh deserves a [0]

Oh yeah, I remember that too.

So you can't even swim underwater.

That's fucking embarrassing.

>normie reviewers even suggesting that Ocarina of Time is no longer the best Zelda

wew lad, this really is it, isn't it?

>no underwater exploration means no water temple
Best Zelda confirmed

nah horizon should stay 9 and nioh should be 7-8

>Skyward sword is better than horizon
Hahahahahahaha

contrarians on Sup Forums were wrong again
is anyone actually surprised?

or reviews are just inconsistent and big IPs are susceptible to overhype

>>Dandy Dungeon [9] / iOS

This shit a 9 ???? Wtf ???

NINTENDO BACK ON TOP BABY

youtube.com/watch?v=IJuvLndCMfc

Im scary about zelda beat horizon.

So?

NO, IT WAS OUR TURN

No odds are Skyward Sword is better than Horizon. It's certainly no 10 but it's better than the 6/10 Horizon is.

THEY CAN'T KEEP GETTING AWAIT WITH IT

This. Underwater sections are shit in everything that isn't Ecco.

NO
NO
IT WAS SONY'S TURN
IT WAS OUR TURNNNNN

WHAT THE F*CK HOW COULD THIS HAPPEN, WE WERE THE CHOSEN ONES DAMMIT

>>Torment: Tides of Numenera [8]

Cannot wait for the game. Hopefully console version will be good, otherwise I am pirating it on PC.

DELETE THIS RIGHT FUCKING NOW

New Ecco when?

Right after the new Phantasy Star, Virtua Fighter, Panzer Dragoon, and Vectorman.

BTFO

>nah horizon should stay 9


lolno.

Paid review

Nintendomination, boys.

Everyone is already comparing it to Super Mario 64 and Ocarina of Time.


It's happening. It really is.

>Sniper Elite 4 [7]

fuck that. its the best sniper elite yet. 8.

>IT D DOESN'T COUNT!

How does Nintendo do it?
How do they come back with such force?

>>>>>>>>>>>Dandy Dungeon [9] / iOS
what

Twilight Princess Redux

Considering Zelda always gets a couple points added to its score by default because muh zelda, I think it's going to be average as fuck. Literally a 10/10 it's ok, just like SS and TP.

>$360 for a game
>when you can get a game that's almost as good for free on your phone
Really makes you think

Or it's possible that Nintendo is paying them to say that.

None of the console Zeldas have been average. Wind Waker is the weakest one and its still a good game.

Why would I care about reviews? I know that I will enjoy Torment more than any of these other games no matter what some "journalist" says about it.
There are way too many example of games that were praised to high heavens but turned out to be mediocre at best (Shadows of Mordor, MGS V,...) and too many niche games that get ignored almost completely.

nope the best are 1 and 2, 3 is utter trash and 4 is mediocre

>skyward sword was given a 10 by the same magazine

that says all you need to know

I remember hearing this when the wiiU came out

but have fun with your delusion

>evokes feelings we haven’t felt for 20 years
SS was 20 years ago...

This. They're susceptible to Zelda bias. That's also why they gave a 10 to Majora's Mask, and Wind Waker, and Twilight Princess, and Phantom Hourglass, and Spirit Tracks, and... oh wait, they didn't do any of that.

I'll give it a month before people realize there's very little actual substance to it. open world games always have this effect.

people put in 500 hours then realize they didn't actually have much fun and there was very little they even remember.

How the fuck could they beat the game, and play enough of its content, and write a review, in only a few days of playing it? Fucking bullshit

gamingbolt.com/will-the-legend-of-zelda-breath-of-the-wilds-release-affect-horizon-zero-dawns-sales
>
Take a look at what Gamespot’s Peter Brown, who just last week awarded Horizon a glowing 9/10, had to say. “…I really liked it [referring to Horizon Zero Dawn]. But playing Zelda is really making me question- jeez. Horizon is a great game, it’s a fantastic game. But next to this, it’s like, shoot! If I was to make a list about what I like about both these games, the Zelda one would be as twice as long, I think.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

This video makes the game look so tacky LOL people are going to buy this? Look at that world map it's in, jesus. ahaha

What a load of bullshit. I've played several open world games and the ones that weren't enjoyable got little of my time. Any of the ones I spent many hours with were enjoyable throughout. Anyone who puts significant time into a game and doesn't enjoying is a fucking retard. If people end up putting a lot of time into Zelda then it means they enjoyed it enough to continue. If it ends up being shit it'll get dropped like everything else.

I love all the verticality and diversity this game has. If you've played the game you can look at a screenshot and know exactly where it was taken.

Horizon doesn't have lewd cuties.

DELETE THIS

Bonus Horizon comparison

They got the game several days ago, and have several more before reviews can be posted. They'll have a good two weeks or so to beat it. If they're playing many hours a day it's plenty of time to finish it.

fucking based

what's went wrong bros?

Sony got btfo yet again

YIKES!

Do reviewers give big name Nintendo games automatic high ratings just because it's Nintendo? Do they do it on their own or are they bought?

>can still play bloodborne

>can play this on a pc emulator

feels good man

Some things never changes. the world is a Harem for link

DELETE DIISSSSSSSSS REEEEEEEEEE

Source?

Delete these, friends.

HOW DO WE STOP NINTENDO FROM WINNING?

why are people posting about horizon as if it's supposed to be some amazing ps4 exclusive

nioh is better

as well as this.

Stop buying shit games and people won't make shit games.

Nintendo has been producing (making and publishing) the best software it ever did on the WiiU.
It was completely expected that it could only get better with Zelda too. And this has nothing to do with the Switch release.

>No SSX in years
>Nintendo gave us one in BOTW
WTF I love Zelda now

GAMES ARENT SUPPOSED TO BE FUN!!!!
THEY'RE JUST SUPPOSED TO LOOK LIKE REAL LIFE!!!!!!!

But that would absolutely decimate sony and make sure Nintendo wins forever!?

That's not the solution!

>"The question, then, is, can this percolate down to the commercial market, too? Is there a possibility that the release of Zelda (and the Nintendo Switch) puts a bump in Horizon‘s sales? Realistically, the answer is- no. While I am currently going to make no judgements or statements about which of the two games is better, the fact of the matter remains that currently, they are going after two very different audiences. PlayStation 4 has achieved full mass market penetration, and is owned even by extended, ‘casual’ gamers, so to speak- these are people who may have bought a PS4 to play some FIFA or Call of Duty with their friends, but will absolutely look into a high profile release for the console that they find interesting. These people are likely to purchase Horizon, especially after Sony’s relentlessly aggressive marketing for it over the past month."
kek