Would you sacrifice your favorite developer to bring back 90s ID software?

Would you sacrifice your favorite developer to bring back 90s ID software?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Id,_ego_and_super-ego#Id
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

Modern ID is better

No.

Quake was pretty good, but I didn't care for Commander Keen and Doom was my least favourite of the 2.5D shooters.

90's ID IS my favourite developer, what now?

so kill the current Id software to bring back the 90s Id.

also
>ID
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Id,_ego_and_super-ego#Id

I don't have a favourite developer, just kill one at random. If it happens to be Konami, even better.

No? They make better games than they ever did. Besides, I don't think id really knew what they were doing... when they got it right they just got lucky. Reading all the stuff about the making of Doom, it really should have been a failure considering the mess of a development it went through, but it just worked. A lot of its genius isn't really from careful design, but pure accident.

>kill Atlus
I love old id but I can't

So let me get this straight, id got rid of the Carmack cancer but you want to bring it back? Maybe your little gold fish brains will one day understand that muh Carmack muh id Tech is not quite the same as designing a good game, and the successful design of Doom didn't necessarily come from the brain of Carmack.

Konami is already dead
Second is Vanillaware and no I would not have them killed

Everyone knows this. Carmack just made really good tools for designers to work with. He is only good for engines, and is not an artist/designer.

So give Carmack talented designers, and you get some very good vidya.

name a bad Id game

hovertank, catacombs, dangerous dave, commander keen, quake 2, quake 3, doom 3

No TTimo means its shit, and its owned by Zenimax which is even worse.

Not him, but Quake 4. What a piece of shit.

Newest doom is better than any old iD game fag

Why do Romero looks like if he had down syndrome?
Aldo mirin them carmack's forearm.

Nah. OG Doom is vastly more important and Quake 3 is actually more fun to play.

DOOM is pretty good though. Better than I had hopes for.

why are you capitalising it like that?

nope

I'm not a fan of FPS games. I remember playing Q1, Q3A and that's really it

but... 90s ID is my favourite developer

JC is only good at creating a good engine,
JR is a somewhat good designer (When policed)

Tom Hall, Sandy Peterson and American Mcgee are the real MVPs

>name a bad id game
>posts Quake 4
You do know who made Quake 4 right?

Yeah let's sacrifice what years of practice has given us and go back to the dinosaur age of video games in exchange for the modernization
Fucking nostalgiafags

probably the kind of person who says "DooM"

tom hall's doom bible is crackpot stuff. if you want a hall game go play rise of the triad. it's fun for like 15 minutes and then you're sick of it.

More important doesn't mean better

John stealing some code Carmack
John and one dead cat Carmack
John apple 2 stealing Carmack
John no sympathy Carmack
John consoles are better than PC Carmack

Whatever your personal opinion may be, in 20 years you'll have to find an old machine and pull out an old copy of Windows and hope that it doesn't get auto-updated and break compatibility.

Quake (and the other classic Id games) on the other hand will still run on any machine because the code was opened and will therefore remain playable as long as people with coding skill want to play it.
In fact, its been updated to use the Vulkan graphics API.

Zenimax destroyed the coolest thing about Id, and for that I'll never forgive them.

Derp, I forgot Raven did it. It's still a shit game.

Can't sacrifice what's already dead.

kill yourself

This.