How accurate is this list?

How accurate is this list?

I just got Darklands on sale actually. How is it?

>gothic 2 in high tier
>not in god
>all that shovelware in god tier
>all that hyperbole in shit tier
It's pretty awful list.

there is some pretty thick nostalgia glasses but it's overall a ok list

Move Fallout 4 to top tier please

>high tier
>Witcher 2
Lmao

If I have NEVER played a CRG in my life, whats the best one to start with?

I dont want it to feel archaic though. Are any of the newer ones good?

>gothic no in god tier

REEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>Daggerfall mid while Morrowind god
5 bucks I can guess which game you started with.

why isn't d3 in god tier?

99% of 2017's Sup Forums won't have played even all of the games in a single tier; ergo, that cannot be an official Sup Forums list, regardless of your (and my) personal experience

also M&M3 beside 6+7 irks me. 3 was pretty shitty m8.
you're also stretching the WRPG breadth pretty far to include things like EYE/VTM/AlphaProt/etc but not include their classical predecessors.

Put skyrim in shit tier

just try one of the new ones, you can't play an old one without it feeling a bit archaic no matter how you slice it or equip nostalgia/oldfag goggles to ignore the clearly aged graphics.

if you really want to play an old one, try the remastered baldur's gate or planescape torment (dunno if that one's out yet? i think it was coming out)

I'd move Expeditions: Conquistador to Mid Tier. I liked the game, don't get me wrong, but there was definitely a lack of polish and some ideas that just didn't work as executed. I understand that the game barely got made in the first place, and they didn't have the resources to do much fine tuning. But be that as it may, the game is still only Mid Tier.

>skyrim isn't at the bottom
other than that yeah

>Witcher 3 not at the top as Elder God tier

Bloodborne fans are STILL this mad, huh?

>EYE in mid tier
>only one tier above invisible war
Criminally retarded

>gothic 2
>high
nice meme list

Dragon Age Origins for PC is a pretty good introduction. And really play it on PC the console version is gimped to hell.

Thread template.

>Diablo 2 and Morrowind on god tier
This really upsets me but otherwise I'm mostly fine with the meme tier list.

it is badly in need of an update tho

It's pretty factible that in a genre the better games were produced in a certain time-frame and that's just how it is with crpgs.

Goldbox games are too rudimentary to be put in such a high tier. Their combat is far more basic than FFT, their story is generic D&D fare and their decision making is visual novel tier.
Don't get me wrong, I like them, but they haven't aged well at all and their value is mostly historical. They were jus early scouts into crpg territory.

>there is no gothic on god list
>dungeon siege is on da low list

>Wizardrys are low
At least bump them up to mid.

>gothic 1&2 only in High tier
That list is shit user. Anything that puts morrorwind before gothic is pure shit.

Needs updating. Let's decide where the following go on it:

>Fallout 4
>Mass Effect Andromeda
>Wasteland 2
>Pillars of Eternity
>Torment: Tides of Numenera
>Divinity: Original Sin
>UnderRail
>Siege of DragonSpear
>Shadowun Returns
>Shadowrun Dragonfall
>Shadownrun Hong Kong

It's not, there a lot of shit tier game in both the god tier and high tier

Pretty sure it was just one autistic faggot that spammed this a while back.

Such as?

That's some pretty shit taste

Morrowind
New Vegas

Not even gonna bother list more than one from each because all the autistic retard are going to chimp out with just these two

I agree with you though. Both are at best mid tier games. List some more?

its pretty outdated senpai

wasteland 2 belongs in mid tier

>Skyrim low tier

Made by some sexually frustrated virgin

>Divinity II is as good as New Vegas

bullshit

That's a pretty contrarian looking list there, filled with late 90's/early 2000's borderline shovelware and gimmicky crap. Many of the games in God Tier belong a lot lower and games in Lower Tier a lot higher.
Actually to be honest it just reeks "teen looking for e-cred parroted RPGCodex".

Why do people call every western action rpg a wrpg but when it comes to Japanese action rpgs like Souls, Nier, Monster Hunter or Nioh they insist that they aren't jrpg's just simply action rpgs?

shit
shit
mid
mid
good
mid
good
good
shit
low
god
mid

Divinity 2 is great, basically the gaming equivalent of locking yourself up alone with 15l of ice cream and 80 hours of porn.

No, don't get me wrong, I fucking adore Divinity II - it's the assertion that it's as good as New Vegas (one of the greatest RPGs of all time) which comes off as ridiculous

What games in god tier don't belong? Ultima?

I tried playing Ultima 7 and I found it to be barely playable. PC games pre-1996 really aged badly in terms of everything, you'd need some serious patience to play them. System Shock is probably the only one I could get play (didn't finish), not counting Doom with source ports

Not accurate at all because it was made by people who haven't played most of these games but only namedropped them for street-cred. What makes Ultima VII a better RPG than Knights of the Old Republic II? Why would Diablo 2 be a better RPG than Baldur's Gate? What makes Star Trail better than Alpha Protocol? The list makes little sense.
Also it should be considered: RPGs are a multidimensional genre which cannot be ordered linearly while doing its various aspects justice.
The games listed here all worth playing, but they are too diverse to consider one better than the other.

is diablo a RPG now? lol

sharing your opinions is for fags btw

>spot EYE
>mid tier

This is a terrible list

Wizardry 1-3 in low tier says it all.

MM3 was great kill yourself.

It was always an RPG and was responsible along with Baldur's Gate for a resurgence in them during the late '90s. Not that you were even alive when it came out.

Sharing a tier with Daggerfall, Risen, Divine Divinity, Fable or Grimrock is not that bad. That's pretty good company.

Not him but again, very rudimentary games with only historical value.

How about no. I don't want to discuss ranking Pillars in any thread, ever. That can only end in disaster.

i don't consider it an rpg in the same sense that baldurs gate is an rpg. it's more hack and slash, no??

i am not implying diablo 2 is a bad game.

>gothic 2 not in god tier
shit list

You can at least guanratee that god tier and high tier has fantastic games.

Have the none bait version

Not as accurate as this list.

This one's even worse

Why do you faggots care so much about what 14 year old neets on a Hungarian basket weaving forum like?

I don't get why everyone sucks VTMB's dick so much. It has a good setting a a handful of good characters but everything else sucks.

They forgot FO4 in Top Tier