The great debate

The great debate

P5 > Berseria > literal shit >>>>>>>>>> FFXV

Not much of a debate.

Berseria and FFXV are shit

They're all garbage

P5 > FFXV > Berseria

P5 is the only good game there

P5 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Berseria / FF15

P5, easy.
The rest disappointed while P5 exceeded expectations.

I would play the shit out of P5 if it didn't have dating sim.

P5 >>> FFXV > Berseria.

and I fucking loved Berseria. Are JRPGs back guys?

>i would play the shit out of persona if it didn't have the thing people come to expect in a persona game
??????????

Kill yourselves. P5 is literally a VN with turn based combat in a corridor, the tutorial is also literally 10 hours long, fuck man there is more invisible walls in P5 than XV has despite you being in very small areas to walk in in P5.
P5 has the worse soundtrack and it sounds like fucking generic filler trash, XV has fantastic fucking themes for battles, bosses, characters and story moments that P5 doesn't even fucking come close to reaching.

P5 all takes place in a single city while XV takes place in a whole world and has music reflective of you going to differnet places, Letallum has havana flavor, Altissia has italian flavor, walking on the overworld has wanderlust which has a wild west feel to it which completely fits Leide and the general overworld, as does sunset waltz which reflects a sense of adventure and romance of adventure. The songs in XV actually evoke emotion, nothing in P5 evokes any emotion.

Does P5 have more than 1 city? Does P5 have a mining dungeon? A sewer dungeon? An ancient medieval ruins dungeon? An ice cave dungeon? A genius platforming dungeon? Characters with actual personality? An MC with a character arc? Graphics that don't look PS2 tier? No, it doesn't. Fuck off you lying cunts

>Kill yourselves. P5 is literally a VN with turn based combat in a corridor
t. person who hasn't actually played the game.

P5 for the gameplay.
Berseria for the story.
FFXV for the graphic.

/thread

I adore alot of the things P5 did but I'm also really frustrated at how shit the writing is. Objectively it would go P5>Berse>FF but Berseria would have easily pulled ahead if it had the atlus budget. I also feel more likely to replay Berseria NG+ than do P5 NG+ and suffer through the story/characters again.

I can agree with this, even though I think Beseria has a better story and characters than P5. I can't help but these threads are magnets for Personafags though, and possibly Sony loyalists as well.

it's not even a debate. P5 is consistently excellent, Berseria has good gameplay but a lot of issues, and FFXV is trash

A better story maybe but characters? You're joking

Absolutely not. Opinions but I do think Beseria has a stronger cast. Hell, P5's side cast is arguably better than it's main cast.

Berseria is trash i will forever be pissed of at you cunts for tricking me into buying it

>P5 is consistently excellent
Except for the shitty writing and story that it spends most of its time on.

the charactes in Berseria are so fucking awkward and cliched and mary sue, with a lot of awful voice acting

What? Berseria is generic as all hell.

Dont kid yourself, the P5 cast is awful. The plot only requires like three of the party members while the rest float around, just to exist so the player feels like he has friends.

Berseria even being an option in this debate is insulting to P5 and FFXV

>Persona 5
>characters
Tell me how the characters in P5 are better than Berseria.

Don't get me wrong, I love P5.
But it's characters are as bland as you can get and forgettable.

And the P5 cast isn't then? By JRPG standards the Beseria cast is pretty non-standard. And before you say anything, that doesn't mean it's original.

FFXV is insulting to itself

Its just waifufags, we all know Berseria is garbage.

>waifufags
>in Berseria instead of P5
what?

P5 is the dating sim though

Disagree, I would have to really really do some digging to find Berseria tier party members in the genre. The character arcs are all smartly woven into the story and there are good buildups to really emotional moments. P5 plays it safe to a fault, the new writer was not very good.

Yeah but the difference is P5 is actually a good game

I disagree, both Berseria and P5 are pretty bad.

But at least I knew I was getting into when I played Berseria, P5 was just overall boring as fuck.

P5 was the one made with waifufags in mind though.

Yeah, I think that's why I feel that many of the side characters feel more interesting. Compared to the main girls the cakes have better social links, for example.

>what is magilou

Came here to post this.
FPBP.

>wall of text
Check

>replying to a shitton of posts
Check

>defending FF15 to the death while shitting on superior competiton
Check

Hello XV-kun, long time no see you inbred cumslurping cockmuncher.

Anything other than this is just contrarianism.

Berseria has a much better script than both, P5 has the better gameplay and is overall the better "game", FFXV is a mistake

Between Berseria and P5 it depends on what you values most in a jrpg

>contrarianism

IGN peoples choice GOTY Final Fantasy XV

IGN best OST of the year Final Fantasy XV

Gamefaqs GOTY Final Fantasy XV

Gamefaqs best PS4 GOTY Final Fantasy XV

RPGfan GOTY Final Fantasy XV

RPGsite GOTY Final Fantasy XV

Gemtatsu best PS4 GOTY Final Fantasy XV

Gematsu best XB1 GOTY Final Fantasy XV

Gematsu best character of the year Noctis from Final Fantasy XV

Gematsu best OST of the year Final Fantasy XV

Gameinformer best cast of the year Final Fantasy XV

Gameinformer best sidekick of the year Ignis from Final Fantasy XV

US Gamer best OST of the year Final Fantasy XV

Dualshockers GOTY Final Fantasy XV

PLaystation lifestyle best RPG GOTY Final Fantasy XV

Drago d'Oro GOTY Final Fantasy XV

CG Magazine GOTY Final Fantasy XV
etc

Stay BTFO.

Overall Persona 5 is the better game.
It's plot and characters are dog shit though.

>REEEE EVIL ADULTS
>All the party members are basically reharsh of P3/P4 characters

So i just bought Berseria and im 4 hours into it but im not really impressed. The overworld feels lifeless, the dungeons are just bland hallways and the story so far just seems like really standard edgy anime shit. I dont hate japanese stuff before anyone mentions it but this game just feels mediocre. Does it get any better?
>inb4 oh it gets good 30 hours in bro

XV-kun, you missed your meds again.

Persona has better combat, music and style. Beseria has better characters and story.

It really depends on which you enjoy more.

Berseria main cast are way better than P5 or any recent JRPG for that matter

Beseria's main flaw are the "dungeons". They are, for the most part, palette swapped hallways.

The characters are far more entertaining than the ones in P5.

Try to stick with it. You get your entire party early in the game unlike P5, you can probably decide for yourself once you pick up Eleanor if its worth continuing.

Persona 5 is saved by it's visual style, and music really. The combat itself, isn't really anything new aside with a tweak or two.

>only 10 actual GOTY,
>ff7 has at least 13
lol

>FFXV even being an option in this debate is insulting to P5 and Berseria

fixed

Truth.

Tales games are my comfy games.

Always pretty much the same characters, combat and storyline with slightly different flavors. Relaxing to play, especially with a good player 2.

fpbp

>The great debate

There isn't any debate. Final Fantasy XV is shit, Berseria is at least a decent JRPG, and P5 is literally GOTY contender.

Artorias is the best Antagonist.

Artorias was okay, why do people worship that guy?

P5 sucks and if you unironically think otherwise you're actually retarded.

It isn't even contender for JRPG of the year let alone better than Zelda and Yakuza. Fuck off waifufag

>Rehash

To an extent but not exactly. They do use the same tropes but kinda mixed like how ryuji is basically a combination of yosuke and kanji and ann is a notasshole yukari.

The cast is definetely more bland than previous persona entries though. I don't think they will ever top p3's or p2's cast. Despite p4 having mostly bland characters, seeing their shadows made everyone except yosuke also interesting.

To be honest, I agree, p5 characters are kinda boring, they are still able to make the games story enjoyable though, they just feel very bland compared to past games.

I'd put Yakuza over Zelda. Zelda is the same thing but for husbandofags/fujos and has practically killed the franchise.

fpbp

>Nothing in P5 evokes any emotion.
I wouldn't say that when you're trying to defend XV user.

They're all trash.

Play a different Shin megami game? They're all pretty fun

Which debate, worst PS4 JRPG?

didn't play berseria but P5 is miles better than ffxv.

Play another SMT

I recommend either Soul Hackers, SMT4 or Nocturne.

>Which debate, worst PS4 JRPG?

if that was the case, XV would win hands down. It's more disappointing than pic related

Just because you can resort to ad hominem doesn't compensate for your lack of an argument. XV is the best out of the three.

>Big Nep's game disappoiting

kys.
for real, just kys.

it was okay

>V-II
>disappointing
I think it's time to stop posting.

fpbp

>Zelda RPG
>Yakuza RPG

>I can't read

P5 is a visual novel but a good one.
FFXV is an unfinished game.
I did not play Berseria yet, waiting for a sale.

You can get it for like 30$ on keys websites.