Is this the greatest game of all time?

is this the greatest game of all time?

Yes

Maybe, it is one of the best of this generation though

Lmao not even close

It's up there

no.

Yes. Best rpg as well

Not even the best game on its console

top 20, maybe

It's not even the best Atlus/SEGA release this year.

>this is what weebs actually believe

This

No.

I think so

It's not even the best persona but ok

it's definitely the best persona

Its better than p3 and p4 but worse than 1 & 2

You say that but P4 exists

I hate Yousuke, Yukiko, and Teddie though

I actually hate them

P4 is the worst persona. Grow some taste

bruh i am a big p4 fan but p5 shatted all over this.

>Those games that only get the story right and everything else except for some songs is awful

3, 4 and 5 are glorified slice of life sims with piss easy combat and mediocre story telling. IS and EP have mind numbing combat but great presentation.
Persona 1 is just bad.

>3, 4 and 5 are glorified slice of life sims
literally nothing wrong with this

Honest question what IS this game?
I've never played a Persona game, and from what i have seen it looks like a shitty weeb highschool simulator with some PS2 tier dungeon crawling and turn based combat thrown in.

How is it the best game of all time?

>I've never played a Persona game, and from what i have seen it looks like a shitty weeb highschool simulator with some PS2 tier dungeon crawling and turn based combat thrown in.
You've got it figured out. If you're expecting substance from this glorified visual novel then prepare to be disappointed.

This is pretty much what it is, with pants-on-head retarded writing, at that. Even Andromeda was better than this in every way.

>in every way
In every way?

Gameplay, story, characters, environments, graphics, pretty much everything, yeah.

>characters, environments, graphics
no

Not really, its a pretty mediocre game carried by being the most stylish game since DMC 3 but style alone dosent equal good.

Not even close

Shame the gameplay is so shit. Its a polished VN for lonely neckbeards from Sup Forums.

>he prefers ps3 anime style bullshit
>he prefers one-note archetypal characters
>he prefers cliche, linear environments

ok then.

>style over substance: the game
not even the best this year

P4 > P5 > P3

P4's town and characters make it the best, even if the battle system of P5 and the demon recruitment make the gameplay of P5 better. Also P5 seemed to lack challenge. The only hard boss was the burger guy.

Indeed

t. echo chamber

If it is, then video game must be irredeemably shit

>P4's town and characters
Are some of the most painfully anime things that have ever existed. The whole game is pretty much a physical embodiment of the conversion to SOL that led to one of the worst pop culture trends in human history.

But all of those were better in P5 by miles compared to Andromeda. Even Witcher 3 looks better than Andromeda and it came out almost two years ago.

I'm not saying Andromeda was a beautiful game or that they were the deepest characters ever written, but compared to P5 it's a masterpiece.

That's pretty much it. If you're a teenager or very early 20 something you might be able to enjoy the story but otherwise it's pretty lame.

And the gameplay is garbage, game literally plays itself. You don't even have to pay attention really, every skill you should use is highlighted to make sure you don't miss it, every turn swap is the same with the game telling you exactly what to do, and you're supplied with the specific skills you need to take every boss just as you encounter it, with no other strategies necessary. It's barely even a game.

Persons 5 literally looks like a 2008 era PS3 game. There is nothing visually impressive about it at all.

He wasn't talking about graphics either.

Why is shitposting about this game always so low effort?

>>he prefers cliche, linear environments
??

>best rythm game
>best sport game
>best shooter
>best RTS
>best pc game
how other games can even compete?
Game is legit garbo VN kys if you think is even great

You are a serious fucking fanboy if you seriously think this is even game of the year.
The game is seriously mediocre all around. It has some nice ideas, but not enough for a game that is at leas 80 hours long.

It's not even the best game in it's franchise.

*YES*

persona 5 isn't an SMT game

Yeah, it's a Megaten game.

no it's a persona game

Persona is a part of Megaten.

they intentionally dropped the megaten name from the titles

Consider dying in a fire, please.

Bloodborne exists