Atlus

>Nocturne 2003
>DDS 2004
>Persona 3
>All use the same engine

Now explain to me why they decided for a RNG dungeon in P3 when their previous 2 games had actual dungeons.

Forgot to put 2006 for P3.

Simplification for an entirely different target audience.

That doesn't make any sense when they still could have had a babby dungeons that were actually hand crafted. Even DDS tried to go after the FF audience.

because making 200+ floors by scratch is great

Because Nocturne's dungeons were fucking annoying
>It's another fucking teleport puzzle dungeon where you have no idea how it works except through trial and error

Because nobody plays Persona for the dungeons?
The target audience is waifufags, they don't care about dungeon design as long as they can pretend to have a girlfriend for 80 hours.

Tatarus is shit, P2 dungeons were better.

Because they wanted to do something different with Persona 3. Besides, a modern Japanese city isn't gonna have much in the way of dungeons. Most of P3 is spent in what's basically a normal city. No post-apocalyptic setting.

plot reasons
I prefer P3 with rng dungeons anyways to predictable and simple dungeons of P4

i imagine it had something to do with it being their first time attempting the P3 style ala the social link stuff and they focused on that more. keep in mind they didn't even do everything they actually wanted to do with P3. it's why they released FES and P3P to squeeze out at least some of the other things they really wanted to do.

The dungeons in DDS1 were absolutely boring and dreadful. It was on a whole level of bad compared to SMT3 which had dick tier dungeons, but never felt as bland as SMT DDS1.

DDS2 had cool as dungeons, like the airport. That was memorable. Persona 4's dungeons are worse than Tartarus randomization, someone post the final dungeon in Persona 4. The linearity of it all, lmao.

Do you really think Tartaraus would have been better not-randomly generated

>tartarus is literally worse in every way to p4 dungeons

how the fuck do you count those wait areas and then a straight walk to the boss as a dungeon lmao. delusional p3 fag, p2 dungeons shit on it.

fucking p4 is in a small mountain town and manages to have better dungeons.

Best girl

>Because they wanted to do something different with Persona 3.

That's exactly what happened with DDS and they still made dungeons

who are you quoting?

user, why would the P3 kids infiltrate buildings or go through sewer systems?

Pretty sure it's memory constraints. SLinks take space mang

it's a giant eldrich tower that grows out of the ground every night. you could do anything with it.

Was just saying the "different" is not a valid excuse for struggling to make a single dungeon decent

but DDS takes place in apocalypse setting

being this much of a p3 fag to admit tartarus was terrible

>thinking 256+ floors of the same shit is good
at least they tried to make it seem different in p4 with the themes and complete redesigns. atlus just said fuck it with tartarus and fucked you over with that shit. Fucking P2 had better dungeons.

They gave up after 1 and 2.

>you

Setting doesn't mean shit, seeEach block could have been vastly different

no villain will ever surpass him
why even live

Best P3 girl, but not best purse owner.

don't bother responding to him. i bet you its that same P3fag i was telling Tartarus was shit in another post

Is this what brain damage looks like?

>gets directly quoted
>"who are you quoting"

ayase is the most literally who out of all the P1 cast

>ayase

how does it feel loving a whore?

>whore
We aren't talking about Yukino right now though.

so I thought. I've noticed that's what a lot of people who think these games are important are like.