This game's plot is dumb

Why didn't Jason Todd get up on public broadcast to reveal the secret identities of Batman and all of his associates immediately after Batman stopped Scarecrow's plan at Ace Chemicals?

Why did half of Jason's militia not have guns? Aren't they a professional army? I can see why random thugs would be unarmed because they're just scavenging whatever weapons they can find, but having groups of 50+ militiamen without a firearm between them breaks my suspension of disbelief.

Why didn't Jason detonate his giga-bombs as soon as Batman started disarming them throughout the city?

Why did Jason use unmanned tanks in the first place? He must have known that if there were actually people inside those vehicles, Batman's no-kill rule would make neutralizing them much harder since he wouldn't be able to just blow them the fuck up.

Why did the game just forget about the entire Jason Todd plot after the big not-reveal of his identity? There was absolutely no closure on this.

What the fuck was going on in the 100% completion ending? Who was the Nightmare version of Batman? If it was actually Batman being super-Batman, why haven't any of his remaining associates found out about him, since he's obviously using dangerous shit like Fear Toxin?

Why was Deathstroke a tank battle instead of a real fight?

I have many questions.

Other urls found in this thread:

mega.nz/#F!02Zzga7B!xOr0MLqy_5Zss2PXaGnNCw
youtube.com/watch?v=RzejbyLozq8
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Is this game good?

>This game's plot is dumb
whoa shit, you cracked the case boyo

Mechanic wise, yeah, but the plot and their hardon for batmobile sorta ruined it

like says, mechanics-wise, it's the height of the series. However, they construct some pretty contrived scenarios to get the Batmobile in situations where it probably shouldn't be, and the story is phoned in in places.

Batmobile was fun though

Half of it was game design and not related to logic.
Why didn't they all have guns?
A: Batman had to beat them up to carry the dual gameplay idea.
Why didn't the bombs go off right when Batman started fucking with them?
A: so you, the player, would have something to do.
Why weren't they manned thanks?
A: the batmobile had to blow something up and Batman has a no kill flaw so they were unmanned
Etc
Etc

Game design and logic are only mutually exclusive if you're lazy. It is almost always possible to come up with workarounds. For example:

>Why didn't the militia have guns?
>A: Intercept dialogue between Arkham Knight bitching to Scarecrow about how they're too poor to fully supply their men and how Scarecrow isn't delivering the promised funds

>What if the tanks were manned?
>Batman's tank fires rounds deliver EMP shocks that render vehicles DOA while keeping the occupants alive

>Who was the Nightmare version of Batman?
Azrael

It's fun, but isn't that deep to carry the whole gameplay and more than half of the game is dedicated for batmobile.

But what if you picked the "send Azrael to jail" end of his questline? And what would Batman be doing in his "retirement" if not fighting crime on his own or supplying his proteges?

yea

Asylum and City are better tho

>But what if you picked the "send Azrael to jail" end of his questline?
>implying jail works
joker

That's not the point, if you do the bad end of his quest he vows to burn Gotham down, not to become Batman's successor. Also I thought that Robin was supposed to be Batman's successor

IIRC the city was literally consumed by fear gas

could just be some long term effects from overexposure

What about Origins?

It was made by a different studio so the writing isn't all there, if you want more batman it's okay

Rocksteady-produced Batman Beyond game when?

NEVER

Why would anything good ever happen

The only reason I even liked this game was because of the scarecrow plot and the joker closure plot. The whole Jason Todd shit is forgettable because it was done so badly imo. I started skipping this game whenever I go back to replay these and instead just do asylum city and origins. The batmobile stuff was cool at first then th novelty wears off really quick.

I will say the intro always makes me want a first person horror themed Gotham game where you're just a beat cop experiencing Gotham streets by night without being able to do all the cool shit Batman can do. It'd be perfect spiritual successor to condemned.

>he plays Arkham for the story

They managed to fuck up the BB suit between City and Knight. I wouldn't trust them with it.

The TellTale series was a perfect chance to be a detective trying to figure out what/who the fuck this "Bat-man" thing the petty criminals keep going on about.

To be honest Scarecrow should have been KO'd at Ace Chemicals, with the rest of the game being spent trying to take down the AK while battling the fear toxin-induced Joker hallucinations. The big conflict of the game was Todd threatening Batman's family and Batman's shit relationship with them, Scarecrow's continued involvement after being a vehicle to get the Joker in Batman's head was unwarranted.

Didn't give a fuck about none of that stuff. I was too impressed by the graphics and being able to play a pretty looking next gen game on the PS4.

My only main head-scratching thing is if Ivy will be "born again" and be a child in the next game since she sacrificed herself in this one.

Imagine a first-person survival horror game where you have to be a villain's henchman who's job it is to stand guard and protect something important from Batman.

There won't be another game

Or atleast if there is it will be done by WB's internal studio and be a reboot

Does this still run like absolute ass on the pc?

I genuinely thought that's what it was, like a wolf among us type story. I don't know why they did a Batman plot, that shit sucked.

Yeah, you're prolly right. I was just super detached from AK stuff cuz I knew who it was instantly and then once he gets no closure after you do all the shit to trudge that story along I was like fuck this shit, just give me more joker and scarecrow then. I genuinely wish this game had just gone in a different direction altogether.

Kek, it'd be cool but that shit would end at level one when Batman blow your kneecap out

The game's plot is shit because the narrative was concluded as of city, this game is literally "Arkham 3: The Search for More Money"

If you enjoyed the previous Arkham go ahead
I love the double takedown approach

Gordon is best character in Arkham Knight

Can you believe that people on the street are unironically saying that "the Batman" is Bruce Wayne?

>the Batman
It's just some nutter with big ears wearing black.

I personally think that City and Knight are roughly equal, AKA 10/10. What Knight sacrifices in City's perfect story it earns back with fantastic gameplay.

I actually liked the Batmobile until the last Act of the game where it became very clear it was being used as a crutch to avoid designing more interesting encounters.
As for the rest of the game, it's a serious fucking shame that it took the ENTIRE FRANCHISE to finally make most of Batman's takedowns silent. It's one of my favorite games and I would recommend anyone play it.

The writing sucked because they got rid of the original writer. You know, the guy that wrote Batman TAS episodes? The guy that made Arkham Asylum/City feel like long TAS episodes instead of a shit Hollywood-wannabe script?

>Scarecrow is thrown in jail and his master plan foiled
>Batman is talking with Gordon when Arkham Knight comes on screen
>says that he knows who Batman is, but Scarecrow had wanted to save the reveal for some special moment to make Batman afraid or something
>But Scarecrow's no longer in charge
>Arkham Knight reveals his identity as Jason Todd to give his claim legitimacy, and then goes on to reveal the identities of the entire Batfamily, which he claims is the most effective way to make Batman suffer
>declares that all of Gotham's underworld is under his militia's protection, and gives them the command to hunt down Batman, his friends, and all their loved ones while they tear up the city to keep Batman distracted
>rest of the entire game is fighting off the rogues gallery as they try to kill Batman's friends and family, while keeping the city safe
>plus Joker mindfucking
This was how I expected things to go as soon as I stopped Scarecrow only 1/5 of the way in, and I was disappointed

>City's perfect story
Nani???

Picked it up in the sale with the season pass. Anyone who paid full price for any or all of that DLC got ripped off.
Red Hood, Harley Quinn, Catwoman, Nightwing, and Robin packs are all the same; couple of predator rooms and a couple of fights.
Batgirl story was half hour of play time including the shitty collectables.
Mad Hatter, League of Shadows, Mr Freeze, and Killer Croc DLCs were alright but they felt like they were just cut from the main game and should've been in it from day 1.

Writers get no respect in the vidya industry, it's probably for the best for him. Imagine wasting whatever talent you have writing some cool shit and having that shit completely hacked up to be forced to fit some abomination with very specific gameplay mechanics holding back what you can do with the story.

I should stop bitching and just go read a book or some shit.

Paul Dini all the way
Loved the Arkham City story

Hence you never buy a game on day 1
Wait for a year, play something else then grab the full game with DLC and every custom shit bundled together.
I'll do the same for witcher 3 on xmas or next year

>look up on youtube the Catwoman dlc
>"FULL DLC WALKTHROUGH"
>video length: 10 minutes
>DLC price: 5 dollars
I had a feeling that they would do this, but I didn't realize how bad it was

Get bent, Batman
I'm totally better then you, that's why I'm throwing shitty looks at you

Arkham City is among the top 3 Batman stories ever written, in any medium. Prove me wrong.

The whole Scarecrow threatening to blow up the poison bomb is so stupid. He gave everyone time to evacuate so the only casualties were his own men and a few cops.

Um, what?

Does letting R'as al Ghul die in Arkham Knight break Batman's character?

Deathstroke's fight was fucking shit. One of the only people who can stand toe-to-toe with Batman and they put him in a fucking tank!!

All of these are valid questions except the gun one. Almost every militia dude in the game has a gun, mainly at checkpoints. It's just that Batman has gadgets that disable them at this point of the game so they're near useless.

Yeah they're well shit. I played through the base game on release so this time I did all the Arkham Episodes first this time.
The only reason the Catwoman one takes so long is the last fight is a bit of a bitch with the fighting area getting tiny and her having no multiple ground takedown.

The bomb was so big that evacuating the city wouldn't have saved anyone, the fear gas gloud would have covered the whole eastern seaboard. He gave the warning to induce panic (which was his gimmick) and to give the AK's militia the space to move in, since their job was to provide enough military hardware/manpower to actually kill Batman.

Also, what state is Gotham supposed to be located in?

There's huge fights with militiaguys on the airships where none of them have guns

>beat his shitty tank and he leaps out
>finally a decent boss figh-
>Batman's putting him into the Batmobile and that's that
Every single boss fight in this game is Dropping the Ball 101.

It was based on New York but I don't think there's a set location

I was preparing for the Origins rematch...

Take him away boys.

its really fucking gay that the game doesn't begin until you complete it and start New Game + as an actually effective, properly equipped version of Batman

One of my favourite parts of NG+ is when Riddler hides in the basement acting all smug and shit so you just hit the button and bring him back immediately.

Riddler questline was one of the best parts of Arkham Knight. Great banter between everyone involved

>however, they construct some pretty contrived scenarios to get the Batmobile in situations where it probably shouldn't be

Including a spare one appearing right after the last one gets destroyed despite Fox saying that it's a one of a kind.

Wait does NG+ actually change anything in Knight? I assumed it was just like the others where it made the game hard mode but you got to keep your upgrades.

What ended up happening to Harley Quinn in the Arkhamverse? Her only mention in AK is a prequel, they don't ever give her ultimate fate like they did for the rest of the villains.

>Get spoiled on the identity of the Arkham Knight here on release week.
>"Talia Al-ghoul is The Arkham Knight"
>"She wanted to get revenge for her father."
> Pissed that some faggot spoiled that.
> Play it months later.
> Game hints that it's todd and couldn't help but be proud for RS to go such length to trick me.
> It actually was Todd all along.
>mfw I got a double plot twist.

>I'm not buying your game, Todd

>Hush sidequest painfully set up in City
>Bruce Wayne gets exposed to the whole world as Batman in the end of Knight
>doesn't use Hush as scapegoat and instead his whole sidequest gets concluded in a few minutes and has absolutely no relevance to the plot

I bought it for the harley ass

>FIGHT ME BATMAN
>IM GONNA KILL YOU BATMAN
>LETS END THIS NOW OLD MAN
>FIGHT ME COWARD

Bruce Wayne would probably just plead guilty anyways.
>Hush goes to jail for being Batman
>Batman is still out there, doing things while Hush is in prison
>"hmm maybe we got the wrong Bruce Wayne the first time around"

I knew it during Arkham City when you find out who is the identity theft killer

Werks on my machine. The patch probably fixed a lot of things.

>Robin marries Barbara at the end of the game
Can she still feel sex, despite the paralysis?

mega.nz/#F!02Zzga7B!xOr0MLqy_5Zss2PXaGnNCw

nah batman would just go, look guys the bruce wayne batman is this plastic surgeon i'm the real batman

As far as I remember it's the same as the others. Tougher enemies earlier on. Keep all your upgrades. Enemies do more damage. No counter icons.

But in Knight once you beat the Riddler's challenges he escapes into the basement of the orphanage and only comes up when you've collected all 243 trophies/riddles/breakables. On NG+ you keep your progress on that so if you've already collected them all you can initiate the fight immediately which makes Riddler look a tit.

it hav jok man it best stori I like jok manm

Oh sweet, doing all those Riddler challenges again would've been a fucking joke. I wish they hadn't completely abandoned the Asylum/City style riddles because those were actually kinda fun to figure out sometimes. Driving a car real fast through a sewer isn't really an intellectually challenging task.

What went wrong?

I can answer the first question.
It's because Jason still loved the bat family and the only one he was pissed at was Bruce. He didn't reveal his identity because he wanted to break him and then kill him

But threatening his family is literally the only way to break Batman, and the only practical way to do that is to reveal their identities

youtube.com/watch?v=RzejbyLozq8

>cut the Jason Todd bullshit, maybe keep the build up as a red herring
>take out all of the Joker scenes
>Batman confronts AK at the end
>boss fight happens
>Batman beats AK
>unmasks him
>"Did you miss me, Bats?"
>it's fucking Joker
>not really though
>there was never an arkham knight, just bruce fighting his fears since the very beginning
>fears of getting old
>being obsolete
>fear that killing is the right thing to do
>that killing joker was the right thing to do
>bruce still doesn't realize he's fake, is still reeling
>there is a crash from overhead
>the more arkham knights drop from the ceiling
>the perspective switches
>it's actually Robin, Nightwing, and Catwoman
>bruce can't tell it's them
>he takes a fighting stance
>final boss:Batman
>objective:survive

Red Hood bump

That sounds way cheesier than how the actual game handled Joker

More importantly, why was Robin a skinhead and Nightwing an emo kid?

It's capeshit, of course it's dumb. AA and AC also have dumb fucking stories too.

Wow, this explains so much. No wonder I found the story in Knight to be awful as fuck. Then again, I didn't much like the ending to City.

Batman carried out the wrong person

Talia was a bitch and a rapist

She was sacrificed so we wouldn't have to deal with Damian

>not wanting a tsundere waifu who spikes your drink in order to have a love child with you

In what way? I think if done correctly it would poke fun at the fact that joker has stolen the show in every game while also not actually having joker steal the show, in game it just felt like they needed an excuse to put him in for the Jason todd/Arkham city points

Can we talk about this? Verrrrrry Intredasting
youtube.com/watch?v=RzejbyLozq8

>fight me coward, I'll win because I know all your tricks
>hides behind mooks
What a load of shit

This whole series would've been over in a few minutes if Charlie had been there

That still doesn't explain why he didn't reveal Bruce's identity

You haven't read much Batman then or only watched the cartoons.
>Giving a shit about Talia.

Because that was Scarecrow's plan

AC was fun but it was basically a hodgepodge of like 3 or 4 better stories, sort of like The Dark Knight Rises (AC is way better than TDKR tho)

>wanting to have your life ruined
>volunteering to be JUSTed

>its nighttime the entire game
>forced bat-tank missions throughout
fucking thing sucks, Arkham City is true kino compared to this

Scarecrows plan was to nuke everything with fear gas

...

It's nighttime in all the arkham games.

If Batman only comes out at night, why don't the villains all launch their attacks during the day?

test