ITT: games that got scores way too high

ITT: games that got scores way too high

...

>mario kart 8 deserving the same score as P5

Zelda. Take your pick.

No matter how bad MK8D is, it's still a game unlike Persona 5
This, BotW and Twilight Princess are the worst offenders of this

...

>samething 8th time scores 94/100

nothing about this game is a 96

>JRPGs are not games

How about games that got scores too Low

I've learned to accept the fact that anything Nintendo rehashes will always get high marks across the board. Nintendo more than likely doesn't pay for any reviews at all, since reviewers will bend ass-backwards for them out of brand loyalty alone.

BOTW wasn't even that revolutionary or amazing, it lacked a lot of personal touches that would make it a 10/10. I fail to see how the latest rendition of MK8 gets near-perfect scores when the latest Forza or DiRT games usually have quite a bit of variability in their scores because people actually review them instead of looking at the pretty Nintendo characters like a bunch of mindless sapes.

MGS4

PMD is a pretty meh roguelike desu.
It wasn't until Super that the gameplay was up to snuff.

GTA IV, that shit got 98 and it's not that good.

These two and pic related

>Persona 5
>game

>ITT: games that got scores way too high

This year? Breath of the Wild, easily. But that's to be expected since it's a Zelda game.

If anything Persona should be higher

I never liked Wind Waker or Botw

This, IV has terrible driving physics. How anyone can think that game is 9.8/10 is mindblowing.

...

...

The ones that stood out from last gen were MGS4 and GTA IV.

but which one is the true masterpiece?

hint:it's both

I still don't get all the hype for The Last of Us.

Botw is amazing and the last of us is an amazing movie.

i don't get all the hype for breath of the wild either.

these games are pretty underwhelming. 4.9 is harsh but it deserves at most a 7

fun fact: last of us has less cutscenes than xenoblade chronicles.

i don't get all the hype for any game

Botw beats tlou on gameplay but loses in story. I guess it depends on what aspects the gamer cares for the most.

didnt play it myself but I liked what I saw from tech demos

having a health bar that doesnt regenerate by itself and scarce ammo/items where you have to take count of every bullet you have

those were very big deal when the game came out. Almost all the games had near unlimited ammo and health regen when it came out

I mean for the time the technical side of it was really impressive. Uncharted 4 deservingly got a lower score despite being a better game.

...

Having played it, it's just a good 7/10 zombie cover shooter.

i prefer gameplay over story but i can still appreciate story driven movie-games like persona 5, nier: automata and MGS4.

>Twilight Princess
It improves in almost every single way over WW. It's definitely not a 96, but it's leagues better.

Salty bitch spotted
The fact that the user and reviewer scores are identical shows the game is ELITE

It's barely a shooter, though. On harder difficulties you have to sneak around, avoiding enemies if possible but still scavenging for items.
I agree with 7/10. Like Uncharted, Naughty Dog doesn't know how to make interesting gameplay enough to carry a 10 hour long game.

>reviewer scores
Who cares about 10 vs 0 : shitpost warfare

>I mean for the time the technical side of it was really impressive
This is the real reason honestly, it was top-tier in terms of the technology powering it for a console game released in 2009.

The most impressive part to me was how reactive and intelligent the enemies seemed to be, and how you could use the enviorment in kills that made the fighting dynamic and a struggle. It looked so good people thought it was scripted. But then they had other people come in to play the tech demo after the reveal and it blew everyone's fucking minds that it wasn't scripted.

The combat always looked great and interacted with the enviorment, but the AI seemed just as interesting. (The guy pleading for mercy in the gameplay reveal trailer was a highlight, as well as the bandits legit worried when you take their friend hostage.) Unfortunately, the AI seemed to get a downgrade in the final release.

at least that bad game got outscored

P5 is better. MK8 sucks.

>That anal devastation

He's not wrong though

It's also a much shorter game

>Not having regenerating health is revolutionary

Jesus...

So are any of you fucks ever gonna explain what the hell is wrong with MK8D or something?

Star Fox Zero and Mario Tennis?

These two are exceptions which prove the rule alongside a few more like amiibo festival for example

here comes the BotW drones

Don't even have to look at the score to tell you that ARMS got scored too high

Sup Forums is shit at it since the double items now make it harder for them to stay in first place

...

...

You are like little baby.
Watch this!

bump

It will never not be funny

>MK8D
>best kart racer ever made

>persona 5
>debatably not even the best in its own sub series

difference being when you play xenoblade, you play it. When you "play" TloU half of it is walking around not doing shit like moving ladders around, settlement NPCs vomiting exposition, moving dumpsters, or leading Elly through water bits

This. MK8 doesn't deserve shit especially since it's just a remake to boot. It is only riding on Nintendo high score pass, like all the zelda and mario games.
Only Nintendo can create an utterly mediocre game and receive high scores, that would be considered sub $15 shovelware trash if it was released by anybody else, with 60 metascore.

You're right. There's no way New Vegas deserved 8.4. More like 4.8.

yeah every fucking thread botw fags get destroyed

88 for that game is just right. It's a good game, but not 90+ good. Still enjoyed it more than botw though. I also think botw is overrated.

What lead you into writing this post? Sheer anger?

Because it's pretty much worthless, you're repeating what the guy said.

I've literally never seen one argument that somehow dismantles the premise that BotW has absolutely amazing main dungeons, an extremely diverse world with lots of secrets, amazing polishing, towns, quests, humor, music, art style, physics, love for detail.

So no, you just look like braindead, jealous retards every single time.

Getting rocked by universal critical acclaim, good sales and a benchmark for future open world games

...

Hltb says Xenoblade is 68 hours long whereas TLoU is 15. Xenoblade having more cutscenes is not surprising.

those main dungeons are anything but absolutely amazing, they are all complete lackluster. one of my major complaints about the game.
you may only think this if this is your first zelda game or something, and have no idea how good dungeons look like

I would agree with persona 5's score being too high if it weren't for the fact that it's 1 point higher than persona 4's, and 5 is better than 4

>If I say the opposite of the truth maybe someday it'll become real to me!

Stay forever BTFO. 97. Greatest game of all time objectively.

Maybe we played different games then, because while these did exist, it wasn't even close to half of the game.

I mean, it definitely has better dungeons than MM and WW. TP had the best looking dungeons, but I think the ones in BotW were more fun. Maybe better than SS, but I barely remember that game. I've been playing Zelda since right before MM came out.

I exaggerate, but it's way too prevalent to be ignorable. I played through it once on grounded when I got the bundle on black friday a few years back and If I replayed it, it would be even worse

D-D-D-DELETE T-T-THIS!!!!

This

>wind tunnels water skinned
>move gear in circles!!!
REVOLUTIONARY
>BotW has absolutely amazing main dungeons, an extremely diverse world with lots of secrets, amazing polishing, towns, quests, humor, music, art style, physics, love for detail.
reads just like a paid review.
>fish gets out
>animation plays
WOOOW 10/10!
>universal critical acclaim, good sales and a benchmark for future open world games
so every recent activision, ubisoft and EA should get this 10/10 then

you see ninten.drones? every-god damn time it's the same thing, you can't keep doing this for free.

>b-b-b-b-but sony
every time

I hope you are aware that you don't make one single argument.

And I've finished every single Zelda a few times. TP dungeons are said to be the best 3D dungeons and they are absolutely horrible compared to the four beasts. Time-wasting, slow trash.

Are you a nigger? I can't decipher your babble or what points you're trying to make.

>tfw I think the exact opposite
I liked the series until the 3ds entries. I played Super but it was a slog

>getting triggered by it and proving you are a Sony fag
Like clockwork.

...

Zelda games are flagship for Nintendo, nobody gives a shit about Horizon
It's pathetic that you have to compare the best Nintendo has to offer with a low-mediocre offering from Sony. Compare MGSV wildlife ai, or even MGS3 wildlife ai to BotW and you'll realize how Nintendo just candy-coats old worn out mechanics to inexperienced children to make a quick buck

they tried to shit on other games and failed so they had to go back to horizon

this salt can't be real

but jim sterling said that horizon was going to be the best game ever stop making fun of it

PMD games are some of the most boring games Ive played, I really dont see the appeal of them

its a good game don't know why you guys want to hate it so bad

You just don't like roguelikes

hey

hey guess what

jim sterling's review knocked BOTW out of the top 10 highest-rated games on metacritic ;)

>nintendo bonus for a shitty port
incredible

this

thanks, jim :)

Explain how it's a shitty port.

not an argument

wasn't trying to be, just saying thanks :D

3 should be lower but NV score is right if you don't count all the mods you used to save it

it was also a buggy mess on release

someone really isn't happy with their exclusive shitty Dark Souls like game