Daily Reminder

> P3 > P4 > P2 > P1 >P5 = trash

P1 > P2 > P4 = P5 > stinky poo poo > P3

i like all of them

P5> P1 > P2 > P4 > P3

t. reddit faggot cuck

5 really was horrible, wasn't it? It had a really good start but fell flat on its ass and the plot was a complete mess. How do you mess it up so badly having so much time to work on it?

I'm okay with this

Persona 3's social links sucked balls

IS>3>EP>4>5>1

2 > 5 > 4 > 3 > 1

But also this.

P3 > P5 > P4

>not liking just one
delete your post right this second

4 and 5 look cool but the rest look sissy gay boys.

I've never played the series though.

>first two
>anything but outdated literal trash that only degenerate hipsters pretend to like/play

5>3>4>1
Waiting on EPPSP and playing other megatens since the group said a 2017 release is possible.

P5 is trash but so are 1 and 2.

Still though, can't join a school club in 5? WHY?

>games
>outdated
You forgot your fedora

3 was good too. 1 and 2 are overrated garbage people on Sup Forums try to push to look like they didn't start the series at p4g.

P5 = P3P > P4
Havent got around to play the first two yet

>Still though, can't join a school club in 5? WHY?
Helping Sojiro are more fun then joining school club.

Also P5>P1>P4>P3>P2

P3>P1>P5=P4=P2, couldn't suffer 4 through the end.

Who the fuck would have a criminal student in their club.

The only bad game in the series is SMT If...

>epic elitist that pretends to play and enjoy early atari era ping pong games
That fedora was actually yours, my friend

>Still though, can't join a school club in 5? WHY?
Because Joker isn't a faggot.

>you can come to the school but you can't join a club

sound logic. You're excuse is overdone as shit anyways. The whole logic that they left out a feature on purpose doesn't change the fact they left out a feature.

This. Literally no sane human being can place P1 on top.

If you put 3 over 5 you are actually retarded.

More like your bait is overdone as shit as always.
It's the same feature as doing after school activities, which already overdone from P3 and P4.

P1 > P2 > dogshit > e-celebs > nu-Sup Forums > P4 > P3 > millenials > gamergate > P5

but the gameplay in p1 is more interesting than 4 and 5's. i like the setting better too, it still is an average game, if they were to remake it with the QoL implements of today it'd be an 8/10 game.

Not really. P1 has an edge over P2 on the video game side because it's actually balanced, and the rest is down to whether you enjoy spending 100 hours talking to high schoolers about their problems or whether you enjoy video games. It's just a personal thing.

>It's the same feature as doing after school activities, which already overdone from P3 and P4.
>everything that upsets me is b8


Worst excuse I've heard so far

underage b&

P5 > P3 >>> P4
No one cares about 1 and 2 lmao

Let's not do that.

I think 5 is the best for the moment but it's not heads and shoulders above the others, that could change with a re-release that fixes some of its flaws though, which I expect it will get. I should really play 1 and 2 one of these days, but I still have some other MegaTen games I'm a bit more interested in to play.

>can't join a school club in 5? WHY?
>hanging around with balls obssesed jocks and daddy issues drama queens
lol no

>hating P5

What sort of fresh meme is this? Have I missed something?

>Still though, can't join a school club in 5? WHY?
Who cares? They were only ever places for S. Links and not even great S. Links at that.

EP > IS > 5 > 3 > 1 > 4

>actual logical reason that upsets me is overdone even though it's true

Best crying post I've seen so far

extreme contrarianism

>yu is the only one with a masculine jaw

Chad confirmed

They're upset that their P3 thread aren't popular.

Day of the rope for P3fags when? I'm tired of them trying to stir shit anytime they feel public opinion is against them

Nostalgiafags for 3 combined with the meme cycle where the new game is considered the worst soley due to the fact there isn't nostalgia clouding their opinion of the game.

Where's my P1+2 HD Remake featuring updated gameplay and a story restructured around a school year?

You'll get it after I get my SMT1 HD remake.

Why do P3fags say Shido is a bad villain as a reason 5 is bad when all Persona 3 had was revolver jesus and weird counsellor who dies half way through immediately after being revealed as evil?

>SJ got a remake and 1/2 didn't.
SJ is just fine, 1 and 2 could use some modern age TLC.

Maybe after ANOTHER ONE of P4 spins off while waiting for P5 first spins off.

Patrician taste. Really, 3 is trash

Sup Forums being contrarian as normal. Nothing to see here.

5>4>3>2>1

SJ is just getting some touchups akin to III's Maniax edition. 1 and 2 would probably need to be completely remade from the ground up.

Swap 3 with 4 and this is basically my ranking

I only played 5 and it is one of the best game of all time, awesome and fun game

Unless P3-5's formula is adapted into P1's isekai demonic city settings well, no.

I know people are giving DSJ a lot of flak, and deservedly so, but I do have to say that ATLUS's re-releases are often pretty good in my opinion. Maniax and Golden, despite having Marie, were both pretty big steps up form their vanilla games and I've heard nothing but good things about the Radinat Historia re-release. DSJ looks like it's going to be a miss, but I'm glad that ATLUS are at least putting some effort into milking every game they've ever made seeing as they're clearly intent on doing it no matter what.

I am currently at Shidos castle and can't be assed to pick it up again. Should I bother finishing it?

Yeah cuz highschool shenanigans will fit right in with SQQ and EP

2 For story
5 For gameplay
3 for music
4 for Chad Simulator
1 for Gambling Addiction and dancing

This is a great game series.

Probably, since you've come this far.

Patrician taste

Why is people pretending that the first persona game was good?

In general :
P5>P3>P2>P4>P1

In terms of story :
P2>P1>=P3>P5>P4

P1 > Gameplay P5 > P2 > shit > P3 > P5 > P4

Disliking =/= hating
The game just isn't as good as the others.

Objectively gamewise P5 is better than all of the predecessor though. Saying it as being isn't as good as the others just makes you look like you never like the franchise in the first place.

>it's another "REE IT'S THE NEW POPULAR ONE SO IT'S THE WORST GAME IN THE SERIES" episode

P2 > P1 > P3 > P5 > P4

P2 < P1 < P3 < P5 < P4
Fix that for you.

>nothing but good things about the Radinat Historia re-release
haven't played it but fuck the new artstyle is atrocious by comparison

>those awful pastel colors compared to the original fantastic use of shadows and lighting

Now this is some good taste.

I play these games for the plot and cast and I didn't like any of it. Even gameplay wise it's one of the easiest games in the series next to Innocent Sin.

IS> EP> P5> P1> P3 >P4>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>P4G

Catherine>P5>P4=P3>P2=P1

Story: P3

Gameplay: P5

Waifus: P4

Music: P5

Overall best: P5

Persona 3 has a better story cause of it's darker tone, but it has the worst gameplay out of the 3 Personas I've played. Persona 4 is in the middle with having better gameplay, but a worse overall story, though I find the girls to be excellent. Persona 5 is the best overall experience because dungeon crawling isn't as much of a chore and the wonderfully crafted OST blends nicely. Persona 5's story is okay, better than Persona 4's, but not as good as Persona 3. Persona 5 is my overall favorite because it's not severely lacking in any department, so it gives off the best experience.
I haven't played P1 or P2 due to the dated gameplay, and I'm just not a fan of dungeon crawlers in general. I like Persona cause it's casual and has those visual novel elements that attract people who wouldn't go near JRPGs.

The worst taste, the shitty waifu game happened to have the worst waifus and out bland Minato.

why doesn't Potter-kun's nose ave a shadow
is this a deep metaphor for Igor being dead

>Catherine first

I... I agree with you user

Honestly I agree.

>2 For story
I hope you mean characters because it's pretty embarrassing otherwise

It's ironic because P5 is basically a glorified visual novel moreso than it's prequels.

how many levels of contrarianism are we on right now where you refuse to admit that as a game persona 5 is the best.
>but my dark game with basically no story until the end is better
>but my slice of life anime story is more comfy
jesus Sup Forums

Well I play these games for demon management, battle system, visuals, and story character.
I mean if I only care about the plot and cast I rather watch youtube so I can skip the worst part of the game, which is the game itself.

Fortunately this only for P2, since P1 P3-P5 had some fun battle and demon management. Which I really baffled why people put P2 as their higher rank.

I agree with everything besides P5 having the best music, P3's is so much better for me, which one has the best characters though?

This.
I played P2 though, and I rank it berween P4 and P3, but only because I really loved the story(which is better than P3's).

The light from the front, he's in custody remember?

And?

The only correct choice

How so?

3 is absolute trash compared to 4 and especially 5

You are actually retarded to think 5 isn't the best in the series.

someone with taste at last

I wont get the same experience watching a YouTube video over playing the actual game. It's not that I dislike the combat/dungeons, it's just something I never cared about.

Uh, it is the same experience actually in fact it works more in your favor since you don't cared about combat/dungeons.

Yes, let me experience the social links, time management, dialogue choices, player progression and maybe some other things I'm missing though a youtube video.

P1 > P3 > P5 = P2 > P4

nice bait