Out of these three, which one is game of the generation?

Out of these three, which one is game of the generation?

I haven't played Witcher but I'd say Zelda.

Bloodborne, it actually has level design.

You missed one, OP. Storyfags need not apply.

bloodborne is the worst out of the three

Witcher in terms of story

Bloodborne in terms of gameplay

BotW in terms of memes

nier automata

Definitely the Witcher.
We don't see giant adventures like it anymore.

Fucking around in V isn't as fun as in 4.

Bloodborne.

I love witcher don't get me wrong but it was still infested with mini map cancer and fetch quests.

I regretted buying The Witcher.
Bloodbourne isnt my kind of game.
Not interested in the Switch.

>Witcher in terms of story
Seriously? Of all the serie it has the most generic story.

Witcher and it's not even close.
It's not the game of the generation if it's only one one platform.

This

Witcher for story
Bloodborne for gameplay
Zelda for the world

As someone who has played them all I'd pick Bloodborn without a doubt, and I'm not even into the Soulfaggotry-genre (which really should be named after Severance: Blade of Darkness).

...

Bloodborne is the best by far imo. There are more groundbreaking games, but Bloodborne is fucking masterfully crafted.

Witcher 3 is crazy ambitious and has tons of high points, but also a lot of flaws and annoying set backs.
BotW is a gamechanger and will change the landscape of the industry; but personally I found the game lacking in terms of meaningful content. It's a great proof of concept, a spectacular tech demo with an amazing map, but the content om the map was lacking.

Persona 5

Witcher 3

TW3 is the only game this gen that made me say "next gen is here" out loud.

did you clap?

Now, I was surprised at how good the game looks despite all the crying about downgrade.

Look, the obvious answer is Zelda. I understand we have a weird need to compare games, and thus tend to think they are "closer" in quality than they really are. But it's BotW. The other games don't even come close. No other open world game has such advanced physics or movement that feels so good, plus such an interesting world that you can manipulate.

We all know it's true, the other games, while having somewhat decent qualities on their own, do not even come close. BotW is the first open world game made with the "gameplay and physics come first" ethos. It is honestly embarrassing how irrelevant it renders most other (if not all other) open world games. In particular, if you play the Witcher 3 after this, it is almost unplayable, as it is impossible not to notice how limited the movement is; you will desperately find yourself wanting to climb on most surfaces or interact with the world like in BotW, but you cannot. The world has no real sense of weight, it's more like a movie than a game.

The Witcher 3 definitely. I mean BotW definitely has more acclaim but when The Witcher 3 came out, everybody was fucking talking about it for years.

That said, Bloodborne is definitely THE exclusive of this gen though

Zelda.

Bloodborne added nothing but Souls with guns gameplay.
TW3 added nothing but the story which you can read from the book.
Zelda added the best open world interactivity to date, the Chemistry Engine, and a true open world freedom not barred by story.

bloodborne because it was actually a challenging game and not a bloom rollercoaster.

>falling for the open world meme

Reddit

Zelda > Bloodborne >>> Witcher3

first dark souls

w3 is best out of those 3

just because w3 doesnt have the physics of zelda doesnt mean it doesnt have satisfying movement on its own. i honestly enjoyed walking through the overworld

witcher 3 ofc

Played the Witcher, watched playthroughs of BB and Zelda.

The Witcher is great, not a masterpiece, but it's fantastic, needed like 6 more months of work and tweaking.

Zelda needed even more work than The Witcher, they probably rushed for the switch.

BB in my opinion is the best of all three, in terms of lore and story, gameplay and "wow" factor.

The Witcher 3 wins though cuz it's not a fucking exclusive, and fuck buying 300$ consoles to play a single game 30 fps.

Bloodborne > BOTW >>>>>>>>>> Witcher 3.

Bloodborne and BOTW are both 10/10 experiences to me personally. I thought TW3 was boring as fuck with shitty combat.

Skyrim isn't even this gen and still is king of open world games, so how can people like you claim that BotW is game of the gen based on it being open world, while it struggles on the same point.

Open worlds are so overdone and boring now. Thanks Ubisoft.

Witcher 3 with all of its expansions, obviously

Witcher definitely.
A generation of storydriven cuks that despise gameplay.

not only was it generic it was outright bad
I haven't seen this level of hackery since Mass Effect 3

BotW is a pretendious game of generation
Witcher is a game of generation accepter by masses
Bloodborne is the game of generation

witcher is the best video game ever made
bb is an okay souls game
botw is just rehashed 20 year old franchise fodder

>adventures
Like clicker-combat? Or fetch quests?
Or that generic tale of a story?

Two of those are Gen 8.
One is Gen 9.

TW3 sucks so that's out. Bloodborne while it's GOAT didn't do anything new. BotW reinvented the open world genre and added many new things never seen before. My vote goes to Zelda for this reason.

None of the above.

>No other open world game has such advanced physics or movement that feels so good, plus such an interesting world that you can manipulate.
Movement feels like ass in BotW, yes you can climb, swim and glide but in general the movement feels slow and clunky. You're constantly limited by stamina until end game where it isn't a worry, or until you unlock Revali's gale trivializing the entire limited stamina climbing they were going for. There is no reason to have limited stamina outside of combat when running but yet they do it for no reason. You could argue it incentives you to use horses to travel around, but not only are they unresponsive, they can only be summoned from stables making them effectively useless.
If you want a game with movement that feels good, play Nier Automata, or any Platinum game really. They know how to make movement feel good without wasting your time on stamina management.

Botw created something diferent for the franchise and created so much hype and fun in videogame comunity

Withcer 3 is generic as fuck compared to the other ones, witcher 2 is better

And cmon, worst souls game, only good because its praised by the exclusive fags

I will say BOTW, it is fun to play and refreshed the videogames

>Fetch quests
>Clunky controls
>Can't take a step without triggering a cut scene
>Batman senses
>Boring combat
>Shallow main character
>Open world meme

WHY do people praise Witcher 3?

And cmon, best souls game, only bad because its shat on by pc cucks

>still is king of open world games
HZD, TW3, BOTW surpassed Skyrim already.

Woah, OP? I think you forgot something there...

Morrowind "surpassed" Skyrim and it came before.

because it is the best video game ever made? just a tought

ah yes, New Vegas. Much better than all three in OP

They're all good games in their own right, but it would be
>Witcher III if you enjoy good dialogue and world building
>Bloodborne if you're into good gameplay and atmosphere
>Zelda if you're below 12

Unironically Persona 5

I think people praise it for
>good graphics
>well done interactive cutscenes
>CDPR has a reputation of a "good hearted underdog studio", that alone gets it a lot of praise and free shills

>Fetch quests
Done right compared to other games.
>Clunky controls
True
>Can't take a step without triggering a cut scene
Lie
>Batman senses
Lie
>Boring combat
True
>Shallow main character
You just don't understand, nigga
>Open world meme
Your opinion is a meme.

>muh stamina meme
It's like the stamina meter was created for you to slow down and enjoy exploration, something not needed in Plat games user.

Game design 101, If Link was not given a stamina meter then you chucklefucks would just zoom from point A to point B without stopping every which while to appreciate the world.

>>Fetch quests
>Done right compared to other games.

DUDE FETCH MY PAN LMAO

the atmosphere is amazing

>shadowy forests with trees bending in the wind with ominous storm clouds above
>towns visible in the distance and are often a vast world of their own
>never know what you may come across as you explore and follow unusual noises or sights

Bloodborne isn't even the best Souls game. It was great, sure. But there's no way it's GOTG.

I'm not sure what it was about Witcher that I didn't enjoy, but it didn't really click with me. Could have been partly due to the bad taste Witcher 2 left in my mouth.

BOTW is probably my pick of these three, only because I had a better experience with it over Bloodborne (which I did enjoy). But it still isn't GOTG. I like the idea of revisiting it one day, but the world was just so damn lifeless.

I enjoyed all three equally

That's what my eyes are for you dingus, I'm capable of seeing things in the world and running them to them without the game forcing me to stop every 10 seconds. If I see a few islands in the distance, how does lack of stamina help me there? It just takes me longer to get there. While running there, I might find a shrine, I'm capable of seeing that shrine without stopping because I'm incapable of seeing shit without walking at the speed of a snail.

I haven't played Zelda and Bloodborne but I'd say Zelda.

that's not how it works, choose one and hate the others

BotW

alternatively the old hunters

you're as bad as the nintenbros and pcbros

You disgust me

I like bloodborne but the NPC hunters are awful

>WHY do people praise Witcher 3?

Because, unilke you, they've over the age of 12.

>witcher in terms of story

no, I'd give it to bloodborne on the worldbuilding alone. W3 fucked the world W1/2 established

if you think W3's atmosphere is amazing play W1, shits all over W3

BOTW > Bloodborne >>>>>> Witcher

>seeing is exploring
Guess you've explored the Bahamas even if you've never been there because you've seen it through a monitor. Guess you've been to Mt Everest because you flew by its peak.

Witcher 3 no contest!

Still hell more intresting than just "Get me 3 herbs and come back"

So much this. Tw3 definitely did good world building for an open world game but it is hard to forget that most of it just involves uneventful walking.

Are you purposely being obtuse or what? You go to it when you see it, jfc.
> I'm capable of seeing things in the world and running them to them
Reading comprehension is hard.

You mean they are old cuks that hate actual gameplay?

Yes.

i really didn't. Xenoblade X had better worldbuilding and came out the same year, it didn't even focus on story. They really fucked up W3 by not including stuff like scoe'tal, radovid's wife, Geralt being a rider, etc. Don't even get me started on Ciri's bullshit. The game starts out good, peaks at the start of skellige, but shits itself when Ciri reunites with geralt

No random bandit attacks or monster attacks out of blue made the world traveling bit shit and bland.

you're obviously a delusional nin-toddler/ pc-cuck

I'm not being obtuse, I'm saying that having a stamina wheel was the limit to stop and take in the surroundings.

Skyrim, TW3 were never known for that despite having graphically superior worlds. HZD too even though it had Photo Mode to make everything look better than it is.

...

Why do you bring platform wars here?
Witcher is all over the consoles and PC and it's pretty much immersive walking simulator with a shitty combat system that looks kino. Literally no fun allowed game.

I feel that CDPR could have done soooo much more in terms of enemy variety and giving them territories to roam. It would have been great if I had to remember the enemy types in a particular area and move accordingly just like a real adventure. The exploration in TW3 is definitely on the lacking side but if they did something like this then the flaws would have been overlooked.

Didn't play bloodborne but it sure isn't tw3

so it's either botw or bloodborne.

To take in what surroundings exactly? All the exploration elements are extremely visible from a long distance, they made sure you'd be able to spot most shrines from a mile away, mini bosses are huge and can be spotted from far away, as can all stables and such. Not everyone wants to look at grassy plains and think about how beautiful it looks, you can do that with unlimited stamina if you wanted to. I know I did a few times while playing BotW, TW3 and Nier, two of which have no limited stamina system.
The only series that got limited stamina movement down right are the Soulsborne games, the world is small so you it doesn't take much stamina to run around, and there's always enemies to engage, or something around every turn to find literally everywhere. That is what good exploration entails, you won't find an amazing unique weapon in BotW exploring, whereas you can find countless items in the Soulsborne games. To each their own I suppose.

>shitty combat system that looks kino

If you were talking about Witcher 1 and 2, id believe you. On 3? Not that much.

But why? Game of the generation does not mean it's good. It means the game is popular. Wild Hunt is ahit of a game but look at all the cuks above that absolutely adore it.

BB left the biggest impression on me, but if you go by what everyone else will say its BotW, it has the most universal appeal and more people have played it and come away liking it as oppose to the other 2. There are few games called "best game ever made" and people arent being ironic about it, you cant even argue with people at this point because its already decided that BotW is the defining game of the medium and anyone that is a nay sayer is considered a contrarian and shitposter.

I think what nintendo did right with the open world in zelda is how unrestricted the player is to completing the storyline in a linear sense. Given there are tasks to do in order but to go about exploring the world really was a fresh take at open worlds compared to ubishit that marks your map for every single thing to do

pressed post too soon.

I literally went though the map locations to make travel more enjoyable. Then used fast travel a lot. Trekking back with nothing to do is bad.

BB

Depends on what the criteria is, it could mean the game has to be good, which tw3 isn't

Being a console exclusive + souls-like game adversely affected Bloodborne.