Why do critics overrate Nintendo games?

This game is barely a 7/10

It's a solid 9 at least

why the fuck do any of us care about metacritic. i discard that shit entirely. same with the opinions of others. even when the official score justifies my opinions i dont bring it up

why? journalists dont know shit. they just dont. breath of the wild being good or bad depends on the individual. like any game. one person might not even see a flaw you couldnt ignore. or they might see it as good.

STOP

POSTING

METACRITIC

Nintendo bonus is real

The way professional reviewers work is they try to judge the material as objectively as possible so they look at Nintendo and reason that it's appeal is of a younger demographic and they skew their perception accordingly.

an impressionable 12 year old will like this game much more than a jaded 30 year old who has seen it all.

Fuck no
>Ubisoft tier shrines
>Only 4 dungeons
>empty world
>mediocre combat with breakable weapons
>braindead puzzles

Because they are paid for it.
Like any place else where someone pays you off to say good on their behalf, you will just say it because they are paying for it.

You're whining isn't gonna change the score

I'd say it was a solid 10/10.
Sorry it didn't give you whatever you where looking for.

>an impressionable 12 year old will like this game much more than a jaded 30 year old who has seen it all.
But those 12 year old kids are playing COD and GTA 5
Those 30 year olds are the main ones playing botw.....

>I am always right

>>Ubisoft tier shrines
Wow. 1 post in and you already fucked up.

>Listing obvious flaws is whining
NintendoGAF is real

We get it, BOTW is shit because it's not another OOT rehash. We already had a thread about this yesterday

It's the same shit nintenbro

sure thing bud, never any nintendo hate on here. Nope!

And the day before and the day before yadda yadda

It’s an 8.
It has clear and obvious flaws that other games have so it shouldn’t get a free pass.
Honestly I think a lot of reviewers just gave it a 10 just so they didn’t have to deal with creating a shitstorm.

Uh huh. DO go on.

>ITT: Opinions parading as facts
No, YOU think it's only a 7/10. I'd call it a nine. My main gripe was lack of enemy variety that really pushed you. Lynels, Guardians and I guess Hinoxs and Taloses are the only ones to push you or make you think about how to best fight it at that moment.

Bokoblins are stupid and weak, Moblins are stupid and Slow, and Lizalfos are mainly just weak once you get good weapons.

Because fanboyism.
I mean we have people on this very board that thinks that Nintendo is gods gift to man. I'm not even joking.

These fuckers were more annoying than anything

No BOTW is just a mediocre open world game over hyped by critics and nostalgia ridden fans.
Nintendo's version of Skyrim basically

>It's a solid 9 at least


user WOULD YOU STILL RATE IT A 9 IF IT WAS A NEW IP OR DIFFERENT FRANCHISE?

That's like your opinion bud

>not enough enemy variety
>enemies weak and stupid

And that's a 9?

why not?

And I felt it was better than every open world game before it. Though my opinion is based mostly on the major Bethesda and Ubisoft releases.

Nintendo bonus!!!!!!

BoTW. AKA 'Sunset The Game'. Seriously, why does the entire game take place on a sunset? Everything has this yellow tint to it, and it looks bad.

It's not a major deterrent for him, or me.

>>not enough enemy variety
>>enemies weak and stupid
>And that's a 9?

Its their love for Nintendo or Zelda. If you take the same game but put completely new original characters in, they say the gameplay was ass

>Though my opinion is based mostly on the major Bethesda and Ubisoft releases
>It's better than literal dog shit
Not that hard

There may have been something wrong with your copy buddy

True, but I enjoyed it enough to give it a 10/10.
And I hope the next game is even better. I'd love to see more traditional dungeons in the same overall style.

...

$$$

People are still buttblasted by this?

Every day sense the first review.

>same Zelda!
>shallow open world!
>s-shrines!
>weapons aren't infinite!
>looks!
>same game!
>boring open world!
>it's not even a Zelda game!
>it's just another Zelda game!
>it's only good because Zelda in the title!

Agreed, BOTW is shallow and pedantic.

That's what I've always disliked about nintenbros.
There willing to overlook mediocre gameplay because muh bing bing wahoo

When did game difficulty become a huge component about whether a game is good or not?
This is in general, btw, and I get that challenges sometimes are fun and gives you temporary excitement when you get over it,
but I still want to know when and why is it a big deal

If it wasn't Nintendo it would be getting praised constantly here.

You stay salty and samefagging. BoTW was a massive success and there is nothing you can do about it

it encourages adoption rate in younger ages

>Nintendo fans spent months crying about the score Jim Sterling gave it

Irony.

That's what I've always disliked about nintendo haters.
There willing to overlook good games because muh nintendo

>People don't think BOTW is a revolutionary 10/10 so there just jelly XD
It's a barely above average

Ummmm, no sweetie, Fart of the Wind was forgotten just like a fart in the wind. PUBG outsold it and will win GOTY and is already influencing games. Will neokikeshitrashillarytendronydooddleroonyboobergooberscoompferinos ever deal with this?

The game is an unbelievable work of art. If you genuinely can't enjoy this game, then you must have a brain defect or want to appear cool by not liking things. Is it perfect? No. Do the positives outweigh the negatives by a magnitude of a hundred? Yes, absolutely.
BOTW was for adult me what OoT was for teenager me: a revelation in game design. A magnificent statement by Nintendo that Open-world games don't HAVE to be shit by default.

Jim Sterling everybody! So nice of him to join us here on Sup Forums

OH WOW A ZELDA GAME. 6/10

SAGE

>He says this while PCbros overlook gameplay for graphics
>While Xbots care more about store menus than making games
>while Sony cares more about story than games.
Give me one (1) fanbase that actually cares about gameplay.

I'm not a fanboy and I don't care about scores aside from the hilarious fact that it triggers the fuck out of people here

Wind Waker was better.

But user, I need to use Metacritic to laugh at other people!

Pokebarnyfag pls

All that success and it didn't even make it into the top 10. LOL!

Are u ok

Just like how niggas got triggered by the Uncharted score IGN gave

>Mediocre crap is successful.
Really makes ya think

The ranking works with age right? That's why GTA is there despite having lower user score. Seems unfair

>that top 10
top fucking kek

>SSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Nindumpies are so pathetic.

There is literally NOTHING on this board I hate more than Wind Waker fags. I can smell them from behind my monitor, they stink of pretentiousness, of faggotry. You just know that they think they're doing their due diligence as epic Sup Forumscore "Gaymurs" by picking the weakest Zelda title on their least popular system to boost their fragile Nintendobabby egos.

>Twilight Princess? Too much like Ocarina of Time!
>Skyward Sword? It's on the Wii, it's casual!
It's embarrassing the mental gymnastics that these retards go through to justify their edgy opinions, Wind Waker is simply the worst 3D Zelda.

>B-b-b-ut muh cel-chaded aesthetic, muh comfy!
"No". It looks like a badly animated cartoon for children, the ocean setting is boring, the sailing is slow. The dungeon design? Simply abhorrent, easy and creatively bankrupt. The Triforce hunt is a tedious fetch quest that has little bearing on the main quest. The main quest itself, either too easy or too boring.

>B-b-b-ut muh music
Dragon Roost is for fedora wearing retards and the tropical shit is trite. Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask are far better in regards to music and if you suggest otherwise, you are being willfully ignorant or are completely aesthetically challenged.

>Whatever man, just like lay off and let me have my opinion

You FUCKING FAGGOTS have gone on too long without being challenged on your like for this piece of shit game. You revel in this title's mediocrity like a badge of honour.

You're all pathetic let's be honest here

I shat on Xbots and Pc along with Sony. What the fuck is the matter with you?

>mediocre crap
Still butthurt?

He's just pointing out a fact that happens to be a Sony game. Why are you so defensive

What is better than a 10/10?

We were just laughing at people who got triggered by low scores what are you crying about?

11/10

>SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Just LOL. How come nindiddlers are still mad that their bullies had PlayStations?

See

Victim complex. Alternatively he's a shitposting warrior

not this pasta again ffs

Bought it, played it, beat it. 7/10 seems fair.

Are you okay? user calm down
Sony

there's no objective numerical rating for a piece of media you fucking austist, grow up

Another 10/10 with features I like even more.

Because unlike PS4, which constantly milks uninspired, shitty shooter games, Nintendo actually makes original content.

This. I'll never consider Zelda to be GOTY material no matter how many people argue otherwise, and no matter how many idiot journalists praise it. To me it'll always be that game that did a lot of cool stuff, but was held back by retarded limitations, like 30 FPS, the stupid cutscenes littering the map, the disgusting sex fanservice, the degenerate crossdressing, the abominable season pass which is vastly overpriced for content that should be in the game for free, and overall the obnoxious, toxic fanbase doesn't make it any better.

Too many other good games came out this year for Zelda to even stand a chance.

>muh number ratings
>muh number ratings
>muh number ratings

Please take a serious look at yourselves. Go cure your autism.

>Nintendo makes original content
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

(breathes)

AHHAAHAHHAHA

(inhales)

ahah.. ahah..... *sniff* HHHHHHHHHAHA


HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHHHAAHAHAHAHAHHAH!!!!!!!!


*WHEEEEEEEEEEEZE* HHHHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA

AAAHHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA

AHHAHAAH


MWAHAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHHAH!!!!!!!111!11!!111!11!!11!!11!!11!!11!!!!1!!!sniff* HHHHHHHAHAAHAHAHAHA

(breathes in)

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

ahah... *sniff* HHHAAHAHAHAHAHAH

(inhales)

HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HAHAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAA *BRAAAAAAAAAA


(breathes in)

AAAHAHAHAHAHAA *BRAP* HAHAHAAHAHAAAHAHAHAAAAA

(breathes)

AHHASHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAA

(breathes in)

HAHAHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHHHAHAHAHAH

MWAHAHAH

(inhales)

*WHEEEEEEEEZE* HHHHHHHHHHHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

AHHASHAHAHAHAHHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!!!!!!!

(breathes)

HAHHHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHAHA

*WHEEEEEEZE* HHHHHHHHHAHAHAAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!

HAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAHHAHAA

ahah.. ahah..... *sniff* HHHBBBBWAHAAHAHAH!!!!!!1!!!*sniff* HAHAH!!!!!!!!!!11!!11!11!!11!!1!!!!!!!11!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!!!!11!!11!11!11!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

MWAHAHAAAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHAHAH!!!!

HAHAAHAHAAHAHAHAHAH

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA OH NO UH UHAH UHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

MWAHAHAHHHAHAH

*WHEEEZE* HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAHHAAH

(breathes)

AAAHHAHAHA


HAHAHAHHAHAHA OH NO NO NO NO NO UHAHAHHAHAHAHAAAAAAAAAAPPPP* HAHAAHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHHAAHAHHAHAAHAAA

(inhales)

*WHEEEEEEZE* HHHHHHHHAAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!11!!!!11!!!!111!!11!!111!!!!!!!

Why are you here ACfag. Why do you post in threads about games you don't like because of the most asinine reasons. The season pass isn't even totally out yet

>B-BUT SONY!
Feels good living in your head rent free :)

>IIITTTTSSSSS NNNOOOOOTTTTTT GGAAAAMMMEEE OOOFFF TTTHHHEEE YYYYYEEEEEAAAAARRRRR RRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>Nintendocucks will never get a real 10/10 game

THIS POST AGAIN

>both acfag and pokebarneyfag are here
WE HAVE A PARTY BOYS

>that image
ok what other switch game do you want to talk about, tetris, arms, splatoon again, indie games other platforms already played and had threads when they were relevant or lego city?

ITS JUST A VIDEO GAME

6/10

NINTENDIES BTFO

Actually it's 0/10 because no GNU/Linux client

PUBG will win. Sorry neokikeshitrashillarytendronies :(

>after rom
>10/10

kek

>OH NO A DIFFERENT OPINION!

>shitpost about botw high scores
>not in top 10
>lmao scores don't matter

Says who? You? Reminder BOTW already won one while PUBG has 0. So far BOTW wins, irregardless of what you speculate becuase of your bias

Good for them. I literally don't fucking care. You do.