I'm trying to play as faithfully to the character as possible, but the decision involving Gaetan's fate has me torn

I'm trying to play as faithfully to the character as possible, but the decision involving Gaetan's fate has me torn.
What would book Geralt do?

Let him live. Geraldo doesn't kill other Witchers.

why do you even consider killing a witcher who was fucked over by some filhy backstabbing peasants?

Let him live. Fuckers deserved to get massacred and it's none of Geralt's business.

Even if it's the one that killed another witcher that was lambert's friend?

>What would book Geralt do?

Waste months of his life doing pointless shit for literal nobodies instead of doing what he needs to do.

The Witcher 3 is fucking terrible.

He did his job and the greedy fuck didn't want to pay him. Should have just killed his attackers and left going a bit overboard killing everyone but it was still on them.

This
I wish the game was just the main story, so like 1/30 of the content currently in the game. Then it would be great.

>a town deserves to die because one person in it is an asshole
t. Stalin

>I wish the game was just the worst part of the game
Witcher III would be decent if there would be no bullshit with mary sue ciri and white cold
why does every rpg need huge ""epic"" worldsaving story

Are you kidding? The main story is the worst part of Witcher 3. Its fucking awful. The expansions,e specially Heart of Stone is kino though.

In the latest book, Geralt meets some Cat School Witcher and says that they are banished from visiting other Witcher Schools and that he doesn't want to see him again or will kill him on the spot.

I was ready to spare him until I asked him why he saved the girl.

>"She kinda reminded me of my sister so i didn't kill her."

This fucker was ready to kill a little girl over 1 fuck scamming him.

Because of a precise personal reason, nothing like that quest.

The latest book is shit and not worth mentioning.

it's implied he's flipped out and done shit like this before and will very likely do it again.

the objectively right thing to do is put him down.

>They don't call me the Butcher of Blavikin for nothing

Or some shit - certainly got me

dude killed women and children.

fuck him and fuck you.

witchers are not knights, idiot. fuck your morals

Witchers aren't murderous vagabonds either.

take that edge and slit your throat.

That line literally made no sense since Geralt is wrongly named that after people misinterpreted events.

Gaetan literally went crazy and killed innocents. the events aren't related at all.

they are mercs who live on their own
take your cuckoldry and play gone home

Let him live. If you do, Geralt talks about how the same thing happened to him twice. One of those times was how he earned the nickname "butcher of Blaviken".

Well, in his defense, they were going to kill him to avoid payment.

the witchers' reputiation isn't really clean to begin with. Its in their best interest to stay in business and not slaughter/drive away their customers with their tantrums/history.

the same did not happen. Geralt killed bandits not innocent villagers.

they are not innocent, they wanted to kill him as a fucking dog

Let him go, Geralt generally did not try to get involved in the affairs of strangers.
It got him killed before.

that was the mayor and his couple guards in the barn. Gaetan then went crazy and killed every innocent in the village unarmed women and children.

So how did geralt act in the books? I heard someone say he never turned down money

why would he?
Is "getting payed for your job" evil?

Well yeah, but that's mostly due to witcher work paying like fucking shit, rather than him being a greedy cunt.

He's generally more of a grumpy butthole in the books.

It's what he says in the game, man. Just repeating it. Did not read the books.

Kill him.

Pussy school psychopaths who massacre entire villages are bad for business.

>Witchers are not knights, so they should behave in the exact opposite way and just slaughter people wantonly
You are 12.

He was right in killing the guys who tried to kill him.

He was wrong for killing everyone else in the village for their sins, arn't Cat School fags known for being mentally unstable, it wouldn't be long before this guy pulled shit like this again. Hell the only thing that spared that little girl from his austimo rage was that she reminded him of someone, what if she hadn't? He gonna kill her because of what some faggot did?

So what? That just makes my dick even harder

He slaughtered an entire town, he's done it before and he'll likely do it again. Being fucked over by a peasant is no excuse to start mass-killing. Geralt wouldn't allow him to live knowing he would continue to butcher innocents, and further besmirch the Witchers' reputation.

Let him live of course. In fact, I would have helped him do it.

Kill the fucker. You get the best line in the game if you do.

>Kill Berengar
>Kill all of de Aldersberg's pseudowitcher mutants
>Kill nameless assassin
>Import save to W2
>Kill Auckes and help kill Serrit
>Kill Letho
>Import save to W3
>Kill what's left of Kiyan
>Kill Gaetan
>Kill Jad Karadin
>Let Keira die because I don't want Lambert to be happy
>Possibly cause Vesemir's death by turning down Nilfgaardian assistance with the siege
>Don't be supportive of Ciri so she dies and Geralt maybe commits suicide
fuck witchers lol